by
palashbiswas
@ 2007-11-04 - 19:57:09
Love is Not Allowed
Palash Biswas
Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
Another Rizwanur-Priyanka in the making
Sougata Mukhopadhyay / CNN-IBN
Kolkata: In a slight similarity with the Rizwanur-Priyanka case, another one appears to be in the making, yet again in West Bengal, where a couple in Howrah allege they are being hounded by police on trumped-up charges filed by the girl's parents.
In March this year, 20-year-old Sweety Tater married Rakesh Shaw against her parents' wishes. Forced to elope, Sweety is now under arrest after her father, an influential Thane businessman filed a case against her. Her crime: stealing cash and ornaments.
Sub-Inspector Sofi Sheikh at the Mira Road police station, Maharashtra, said, "The girl's father has alleged that she has stolen a few bangles and Rs 8000 in cash."
Sweet and Rakesh fell in love with each other when she was visiting relatives in Howrah.
Rakesh, who earns a modest lliving working at a diagnostic centre, alleges that Sweety's family dragged her away when they came to know about the marriage.
He says that he has been receiving serious threats from his wealthy in-laws ever since.
"Her parents forcibly took her to Mumbai, tortured her and tried to marry her off," says Rakesh. "They threatened us over the phone and also abused us in person."
Such was Sweety's distress when she was arrested on a case filed by her father that she fainted when a Maharashtra police team took her into custody, in Howrah.
Although she has been granted interim bail, Sweety has been asked to appear before a Maharashtra court by the November 17.
Rizwan case: Discrepancies found in eyewitness account
The CBI has found discrepancies in the statement of a person, who had claimed to have seen computer graphics teacher Rizwan-ur Rahman being kidnapped from a crossing by four people hours before he was found dead. The person was allowed to go by the investigating agency after a marathon grilling since last night. Zeenews reports.
"We have examined his statement and allowed him to go," Joint Director Arun Kumar said in Delhi.
CBI sources confirmed that there is a lot of discrepancies in the statement of Indranil Ghosh, who claimed to have seen Rizwanur being abducted.
"We are not taking his statement seriously," sources said.
When asked whether the investigating agency is going to arrest the person for misleading the CBI in their probe, Kumar said, "there are many people who are trying to mislead the CBI. How many of them will we arrest?"
Ghosh, a resident of Ajoynagar in the northern fringes of the city, earlier claimed in an interview to a TV channel that he had seen four persons pushing a person (resembling Rizwanur) into a green ambassador at Khanna crossing which sped towards Ultadanga.
"I was standing at the crossing when I saw four people along with Rizwan alighting from a taxi and then pushing the man into a green car. The vehicle then drove off towards Ultadanga," Ghosh told the channel.
Just after the interview, Ghosh was summoned by the CBI officials to their make-shift office at Nizam Palace here and was interrogated whole night.
The eyewitness claim comes close on the heels of a letter sent to CBI by an unknown person on Wednesday claiming that he has seen Rizwan being kidnapped.
The agency is yet to confirm any relation between Ghosh and the person who had written the letter.
The body of Rizwan, who had married a Hindu girl from an influential business family, was found on the railway tracks near Dum Dum on September 21. Although the government initially ordered a CID enquiry, it later handed over the case to CBI following a high court order.
Eyewitness claims Rizwan was abducted
A 29-year-old man has claimed he had seen some people abducting Rizwanur Rehman from somewhere in north Kolkata on September 21, the day his body was found with his head smashed.
''I saw two Ambassador cars abducting Rizwanur on that day as he got out of a cab. It was before the Khanna cinema hall, at the bus stop, and the time was around 10 am,'' said Indranil Ghosh at the studio of Bengali TV channel Tara Newz on Saturday.
Ghosh also went to the spot and described what he saw.
The disclosure came amid the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the case and the debate on whether the youth was killed or committed suicide.
''I was living under moral dilemma till then. I saw two men gagging Rizwanur. I could also recognize one of the abductors,'' said Ghosh.
The channel informed Kolkata Police Commissioner Gautam Mohan Chakraborty about the claims of Ghosh and the police commissioner in turn assured to ensure police security to him and escort him to the CBI officials investigating the case.
''I could not decide whether to come out and tell the truth because my wife is pregnant. She is expecting anytime but I finally decided to come out,'' he said in the live programme at Tara Newz.
Newspersons thronged the studio of Tara Newz as the channel started telecasting the programme.
Rizwanur Rehman, a 30-year-old graphic designer, was found dead around 10.30 am (IST) with his head smashed on September 21 near railway tracks, barely a month after his marriage with Priyanka Todi, daughter of industrialist Ashok Todi.
Before his death, he had mentioned the names of IPS officers Gyanwant Singh and Ajoy Kumar as the ones who had intimidated him to get out of the marriage.
Todi allegedly threatened his son-in-law with dire consequences and put pressure on him through the police to annul the marriage.
Rizwan: Cops may be charged
Statesman News Service
KOLKATA, Nov. 3: Police officers who had allegedly interfered in the marriage of Rizwanur Rehman and Ms Priyanka Todi may be charged with abuse of power by invoking Section 13 (1) (D) of Prevention of Corruption Act 1988, said a senior official of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), which is probing the mysterious death of the computer graphics teacher.
“Charges of abusing power can be levelled against the policemen irrespective of the outcome of the probe. Apart from abuse of power, these policemen can be charged with abetting the young man’s suicide if it is established that Rizwanur had indeed taken his own life. If the probe establishes that the youth had been murdered, the police officers can be charged with conspiring to murder as well as abuse of power,” the CBI official said. Interestingly, in June this year, the Supreme Court had ruled that a person cannot be convicted of abetting the suicide of another merely on the basis of an allegation that the accused person had subjected the victim to harassment. “In cases of alleged abetment to suicide, there must be proof of direct or indirect acts of incitement to the commission of suicide,” a Bench had ruled.
The CBI official said that a person found guilty under Section 13 (1) (D) of Prevention of Corruption Act 1988 could be sentenced to imprisonment for up to three years. It was also learnt that the CBI may take four persons, whose names figure in the Rizwanur death case, to Delhi after Diwali along with Mr Rukbanur Rehman for a polygraph test. Officials didn't disclose the identities of these four persons.
Mr Rehman today said that the CBI was tightening its noose around two senior IPS officers. "CBI officials told me that they had been examining the role of two senior IPS officers, Mr Gyanwant Singh and Mr Ajoy Kumar, who had threatened my brother with harm if he didn't allow his wife to accompany her father to her parental home. The sleuths asked me to narrate what
(Continued from page 1)
exactly the two IPS officers had done to separate Priyanka from Rizwanur. They told me they were nearly done and promised justice for my family," Mr Rehman said.
Mr Sujato Bhadra, secretariat member of Association for Protection of Democratic Rights (APDR), who was questioned by CBI officials today as well, said: “CBI officials enquired about two phone calls that I had made to Rizwanur's mobile phone on 21 September. The first call was made at 10.11 a.m. and the second at 3.09 p.m. A GRP officer took the second call. They also asked me how could I be so sure that Rizwanur had been murdered. I listed some reasons which can't be disclosed to the media." Even Mr Bhadra thinks that the CBI will soon wrap up the probe and submit a report to the HC.
Eyewitness
KOLKATA. Nov. 3: Mr Indranil Ghosh, a south Kolkata resident, told a Bengali news channel today that he had been witness to Rizwanur Rehman’s abduction near Khanna cinema hall around 10 a.m. on 21 September. He was waiting at a bus stop when he saw a taxi pull up with Rizwanur in it. A green Ambassador drew up near the taxi, two youths got off it and forced Rizwanur into the Ambassador before speeding towards Ultadanga. When contacted, city police chief Mr Gautam Mohan Chakraborty, said: "We are ready to provide security to Mr Ghosh if need be." At 12.40 a.m. on Sunday, Mr Ghosh was escorted by officers of Bidhannagar East PS to the CBI office at Nizam Palace to be questioned by sleuths there. SNS
A gift for India's inter-caste couples
Prakash Hatvalne / For The Times
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-marry4nov04,1,1335263.story?track=rss
BARRIERS: Daduram Balai and his higher-caste wife, Jyoti Prajapati, at home in Madhya Pradesh state. “We’ve never allowed caste to come between us,” he said. Even after they married, Prajapati’s parents tried to get her to dump him.
In an effort to dissolve the ancient social system, the government is giving cash to anyone who marries 'down.'
By Henry Chu, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
November 4, 2007
BAIRAGHAR, India — Plenty of women may feel they deserve an award for marrying their husbands, but Madhavi Arwar is actually getting one -- from the Indian government, no less.
Not that her husband, Chandrashekhar, is a bad sort. In fact, he's a good-looking guy, holds a steady job at an insurance company and dotes on their apple-cheeked son.
But he is also a Dalit, or an "untouchable," the lowest of the low under India's ancient caste system. Madhavi is not a Dalit, and for marrying "down" the social ladder, she is entitled to $250 in cash, plus a certificate of appreciation.
"I was a bit amazed that even for a thing like marriage, they were giving money," Madhavi, 33, said as she sat in her living room here in central India.
The windfall is part of the government's campaign to chop away at the barriers of caste, the complex hierarchy wherein a person's place in society is determined purely by birth.
As India struggles to modernize and transform itself into an important world player economically, officials know they need to erase these age-old divisions and expand opportunities for social mobility for all the country's 1.1 billion people, including the majority who have historically been considered low-caste and oppressed.
Mandatory quotas in education and public-sector jobs have been in place for years. Now private companies, the engine of India's rapid economic growth, are also looking to train and hire more employees from lower-caste backgrounds.
The integration efforts have enjoyed some success, especially in booming cities such as New Delhi and Mumbai, where caste distinctions are somewhat blurred. High-caste Brahmins sit next to Dalits on packed public buses. Upper-caste Indians, who in the countryside might refuse to draw water from the same well as lower castes and "untouchables" for fear of "spiritual contamination," are served by low-caste waiters in chic new restaurants. Dalits occupy some of the highest positions in the Indian government.
Last holdout
But one institution has proved stubbornly resistant to change: marriage.
Scan the matrimonial ads in any Sunday newspaper, and the importance of caste quickly becomes apparent. In a country where the vast majority of marriages are arranged, parents seeking spouses for their children tout their eligible "Agarwal," "Khatri," "Gupta," "Gujjar" or "Jat" sons and daughters, all names of castes or of communities whose caste affiliation is immediately understood.
In a survey last year by the New Delhi-based Center for the Study of Developing Societies, 74% of Indians said inter-caste marriages were unacceptable, despite a law passed 52 years ago that expressly affirmed an individual's right to wed whomever he or she chooses.
"It's very difficult," Meira Kumar, India's minister of social justice and empowerment, acknowledged in an interview. "You can't legislate the mind-set. You can't order an attitude."
The caste system traces back thousands of years in India, although its exact origin and how it evolved to its present form is the subject of debate.
People were generally divided among four groups: the Brahmins, or priestly caste; a kingly and warrior caste; a merchant caste; and a caste of agricultural, service and manual laborers. Those labeled "untouchable" were considered so unclean that they did not even technically belong to a caste and were outside the system, assigned the most degrading jobs, some of which persist today, such as cleaning out communal toilets with little more than their bare hands.
Modern India began with a vision of a society based on dignity for all, and caste discrimination was outlawed after independence in 1947. But notions of caste, which is inherited from the paternal line, continue to exert a heavy influence on politics and society and, despite being identified with Hinduism, cut across religious lines to affect Muslims and Christians as well.
Nowhere is this truer than with regard to marriage, a stronghold of caste and the means by which group segregation has been maintained and reinforced over the centuries.
Although no official data exist on the number of inter-caste couples, experts doubt that such alliances make up more than a tiny fraction of the total. Most probably are elopements or "love marriages," rather than arranged matches.
A dangerous step
The consequences of breaking with tradition, particularly by marrying an "untouchable," can be severe.
Adieu, with Rizwan vow
KINSUK BASU
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1071104/asp/nation/story_8509863.asp
Calcutta, Nov. 3: The CBI has assured Rukbanur Rahman that his family would certainly get justice in the mysterious death of his brother Rizwanur.
“Aap ko zaroor insaaf milega. Aap hum par vishwas rakhiye,” an agency officer told Rukbanur before “wrapping up” the case yesterday in time for a Diwali break.
Rukbanur today told The Telegraph the assurance had come after he broke down during an interaction with the officials.
“I suddenly got very emotional and broke down, saying my brother had been terribly wronged and that he should at least get justice. After a brief pause, one of the senior officers held my hand and assured me personally that we would surely get justice and asked me to trust him,” he said.
Rukbanur’s mother Kishwar Jahan said she was keeping her fingers crossed. “What else can we do but have faith in them? Hum aur kisse insaaf maangey?”
Most senior CBI officials today left for New Delhi in keeping with the claim of an officer that the agency had cracked the case. Sources said the few that remained would leave on Tuesday after tying up “a few loose ends”.
The statements of some remaining persons will be recorded by then, the sources added. The team would then meet after Diwali to scan the statements and the post-mortem findings and take a call on whether Rizwanur’s body needed to be exhumed.
“We had split into several teams to work at a fast pace and the progress we have made in less than a fortnight is tremendous. We will return after Diwali to consolidate our findings,” a CBI officer said.
‘Abduction witness’
A garment dealer today claimed to have seen a man resembling Rizwanur being bundled into a car at Khanna in north Calcutta by three persons on the day the computer graphics teacher died.
Indranil Ghosh, who lives in Santoshpur, told a television channel that another car followed the vehicle into which the man was forcibly taken.
After Ghosh made the claim, he was taken to Nizam Palace where a CBI officer questioned him late into the night. Ghosh apparently approached the channel first because he didn’t trust police.