Search blog.co.uk

Posts archive for: July, 2007
  • Another Marichjhanpi under Creation as Polavaram Evicts Dandakaranya Refugees

    Another Marichjhanpi under Creation as Polavaram Evicts Dandakaranya Refugees

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Millions hit by South Asia floods! and the fact remains that the greatest cause of these floods is nothing but the Gignatic Dams, the buring grounds for SC, ST and refugees!
    But the Ruling Comradors of zionist hindu post modern US galaxy order die to serve the interests of MNcs, promoters and builders as they opt for Big dams evicting SC ST underprevileged marginal people and the benifit goes to the affluents!
    Andhra Govt strated the construction works without having the clearance of Polavaram dam. The clearnce was given by the Ventre without the consent of Orisssa and Chhattish Gargh. And these two states did not care to inform at least those people who have to face the destined environmental disater.
    Left is leading a movement in Khammam and all over Andhra demanding land to poor. Whereas they annihilate the peasantry in Left Ruled Bengal. East Godavari, where the reservoir is being constructed in Polavaram and Khammam districts are epicentres of antiPolavaram Dam agitation. One or two tribes have to be wiped out for ever in these areas. More over eviction drive is already on. The Left has not taken up the issue.
    Why?
    Left is not worried at all that being evicted the Dandakaranya refugees would come to Bengal once again. Would there be another Marichjhanpi?
    Worsening floods affecting eastern India, Bangladesh and Nepal have led to millions of people fleeing their homes. About four million people have been affected in the Indian states of Bihar, West Bengal and Assam where at least 30 people are known to have died.
    In Nepal more than 70 people have died in floods over the past two weeks.
    Thousands of Bangladeshis are also affected, particularly in central areas near Dhaka where water in the Ganges and Brahmaputra rivers is rising.
    MILLIONS of people have been forced to flee their homes in north-east India as the death toll rose from raging floods triggered by heavy monsoon rains.
    "The situation has turned devastating overnight, drowning five more people in separate incidents and displacing another 3 million in 15 districts," said Bhumidhar Barman, the relief and rehabilitation minister of Assam state.
    The floods have stranded more than 4 million people and claimed 20 lives in the past week.
    The Brahmaputra River is usually in flood in the northern summer from monsoon rains and melting glaciers.
    Soldiers used rubber boats and rafts in many places to evacuate people, as communication and transport links were badly disrupted.
    A Central Water Commission bulletin said all major rivers and their tributaries in Assam were flowing well above the danger mark.
    The worst hit was the eastern Dhemaji district where an estimated 250,000 people had taken refuge in makeshift shelters on raised embankments, in government schools and offices.
    A team of doctors and paramedics was sent to the flood-hit areas by boat and raft to treat people with water-borne diseases.
    "We have also sent veterinarians along with adequate cattle and poultry feed in several areas," Barman said.
    The Regional Meteorological Centre warned of more rain in the next 24 hours.

    Floods, drought show no let-up
    By Xin Dingding, Liu Weifeng and Li Fangchao (China Daily)
    Updated: 2007-07-30 06:43

    Floods and drought continued to play havoc last week, raising the death toll across the country, with experts blaming the freaky weather conditions on global warming.
    More than 700 people have been killed in floods, landslides, mudslides and storms across 24 provinces and 82.05 million have been affected.
    The water level in Huaihe River has started receding but incessant showers continue in the upper and middle reaches of the Yangtze River.
    The Huaihe River Flood Control and Drought Relief Headquarters said yesterday that the water level at Wangjiaba, a key hydrological station in the middle reaches of the Huaihe, dropped slightly below the danger level of 27.5 m on Saturday night. That was the lowest in 26 days.
    http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2007-07/30/content_5445512.htm
    Experts demand inquiry into "man-made" floods
    Gargi Parsai
    "Mismanagement of large reservoirs created this monsoon's disasters"
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Central Water Commission, National Disaster Management Authority criticised for failing to prevent floods
    Probe into high pre-monsoon storages, downstream releases demanded
    Surat floods resulted from sheer mismanagement by Ukai dam authorities
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    NEW DELHI: At a meeting on flash floods and dams organised by Intercultural Resources in collaboration with South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) on Tuesday, water experts have demanded an independent inquiry into whether the flash floods that ravaged parts of northern and western India were "man-made" and could have been avoided with optimal operation of large dams.
    They urged the setting up of a National Commission on Drainage, as the primary issue from the agriculture point of view was of drainage and not floods.
    Criticising the "failure" of the Central Water Commission and the National Disaster Management Authority in pre-empting and preventing floods that caused large-scale loss of lives, livestock and property, the participants demanded an independent inquiry on the issue of flash floods, particularly those due to sudden downstream releases from dams. They also demanded investigation into high pre-monsoon storages and the downstream releases, apart from a review of the dam operation rules. As recommended by the National Flood Commission (1980), States must review dam operations and revision of flood cushion provisions in a transparent manner, they said here.
    The meeting alleged that mismanagement and negligent operations of the large reservoirs on Tapi, Narmada, Krishna, Godavari, Mahi and Sabarmati rivers created man-made disasters in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh this monsoon.
    http://www.hindu.com/2006/09/08/stories/2006090824780300.htm

    PM expresses regret at Andhra police firing
    Hindustan Times - 39 minutes ago
    Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Monday expressed his regret at the police firing that killed eight people in Khammam district of Andhra Pradesh before leaving for the state to review investment and agriculture projects.
    Khammam firing: PM meets YSR, reviews situation Zee News
    PM 'regrets' Andhra police firing, to review law and order India eNews.com
    Bharath to me
    show details 10:36 pm (45 minutes ago)
    Dear All

    What is the role of Irrigation departments investigation wings, maintenance workshops and so on when the contractors decide design of dams and irrigation projects?

    The state of affairs in Irrigation department of Andhra Pradesh speak for itself. A report in today's The Hindu explains the situation.
    Many questions are raised about the new method 'EPC', evolved by nava bhageerathas under YSR government, that 'justifies' awards of projects to contractors without clearances from any regulating body and knowledge of people
    FYI

    bharath bhushan
    .................................................................

    The Hindu Monday, Jul 30, 2007
    A workshop without any work
    Swathi.V

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    After introduction of engineering, procurement and construction regime, work here has declined
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    HYDERABAD: Dilapidated structures, crumbling doors, peeling walls and indiscernible remnants of sofa sets mark the office of the Regional Workshop and Machinery Division in Khairatabad, which easily surpasses any other Government office in haunted looks.
    The decibels created by the siren at lunch break seem ridiculously disproportionate to the amount of work done there. For, a break would seem logical only when there is work and there is hardly any here.
    It is one of the six mechanical divisions in the State under the Department of Irrigation, and till a decade ago the only recourse in the city for thousands of Government vehicles needing repairs and replacements. "Even repairs to the irrigation dams were carried out from here," confirms an employee.
    The division was also the storehouse for cranes and earth moving machinery used by various departments.
    "After the introduction of EPC (Engineering, Procurement and Construction) regime, the work here has gradually declined. All departments are procuring vehicles on contract," said an official. Now, the vehicles that come for repairs -- reduced to a trickle -- have to be accompanied by departmental sanction and the relevant cheque.
    Recruitment of staff stopped 10-15 years ago, informed an official. Every year 20-30 employees retire, resulting in further erosion in the already stagnant strength.
    "Even the existing employees do not have any work," he says.
    Similar workshops near the Secretariat and in Vijayawada are functioning well with double the number of employees.
    Auctions
    Official sources said that the idle machinery was auctioned last year to realise Rs. 21 lakh. Of the previous six or seven, only a crane or two remain now.
    Interestingly, only this division has the crane that can carry Khairatabad Ganesh idol to its waters.
    The original six-acre spread of the workshop has been reduced by chunks to accommodate buildings of Central Designs Organisation, Hydrology Department and Polavaram Guesthouse.
    A proposal to transfer all the technical staff to the Dummugudem Project in Khammam was recently sent to the ministry, says the Chief Engineer and Commissioner of Godavari Basin P. Prabhakar Reddy. Had it materialised, he says, the mechanical staff could have been transferred to the workshop near Secretariat. But it didn't.
    With the demand for the implementation of GO 610 gaining strength, now the fate of the proposal remains uncertain.
    The division falls under Zone-6 while Dummugudem is in Zone-5, making it impossible to effect inter-zonal transfers.
    Retirement
    "A few highly skilled hands here are about to retire. Due to lack of work, even the existing workers are losing on their skills. Private contractors will take care of construction, but will they be available for repairs? What will the authorities do when the projects develop technical snags in due course of time?" the employees of the workshop question.
    (end)
    .............................................
    support the struggle against polavaram dam
    save koya tribe and eastern ghats
    http://telanganautsav.wordpress.com/2007/03/28/polavaram_question_mark_over_future/#more-115
    INTERLINKING RIVERS
    http://72.14.235.104/search?q=cache:qMEwArJLn3oJ:www.indiatogether.org/environment/interlink.htm+River+link+plan+in+India&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=16&gl=in
    Krishna Godavari River Link
    http://nwda.gov.in/writereaddata/sublink2images/76.pdf
    1
    Chapter - 3
    Interstate Aspects
    3.1 General
    The Godavari (Polavaram) – Krishna (Vijayawada) link canal is one of the
    components of the Mahanadi – Godavari – Krishna – Pennar – Cauvery – Vaigai link
    system for inter-basin transfer of water in Peninsular India. All the major river
    basins involved in the interlinking are interstate in nature. The inter-basin water
    transfer links are, therefore, to be governed by interstate agreements. The States
    involved in this major interlinking are Orissa, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra,
    Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamilnadu and the Union Territory of
    Pondicherry. In respect of Godavari and Krishna river basins, the question of sharing
    of waters between the basin-states has already been adjudicated by the respective
    water dispute tribunals. In respect of Cauvery basin, the water sharing is currently
    under adjudication by the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal.
    In so far as the Polavaram – Vijayawada link is concerned, the proposal is to transfer
    surplus waters of Godavari to Krishna. Even earlier to NWDA’s studies, such a
    proposal had been mooted by Andhra Pradesh for transfer of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) of
    Godavari waters to Krishna. An agreement had also been reached between the party
    States for sharing of this quantum of water which was endorsed by the Godavari
    Water Disputes Tribunal (GWDT) in its award given in the year 1979.
    The present NWDA’s proposal is to transfer an additional quantity of 1236 Mm3 to
    Krishna through the same Polavaram – Vijayawada link canal over and above the
    2265 Mm3 of water transfer proposed by Andhra Pradesh.
    The details of the award of GWDT and the effect of water transfer from Godavari to
    Krishna on the Krishna basin States are briefly presented in this Chapter.
    3.2 States Traversed by the Godavari River
    The river Godavari is an interstate river. Its catchment area spreads over five States
    viz., Maharashtra, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa while
    the main river flows through only three States i.e., Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and
    Madhya Pradesh.
    The total length of Godavari is 1465 km. Originating in Maharashtra, it flows for
    about 694 km in that State and forms the border between Maharashtra and Andhra
    Pradesh for about 16 km. After flowing for about 281 km in Andhra Pradesh, it again
    forms the boundary between Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh for about 48 km. It
    also forms the boundary between Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh for about 24
    km. Finally it flows for about 402 km in Andhra Pradesh before it joins the Bay of
    Bengal. The State-wise catchment area of the basin is given in Table 2.1.
    2
    3.3 Interstate Agreements on Sharing of Godavari Waters and the GWDT
    Award
    The competitive claims of the riparian states for the utilisation of the waters of the
    Godavari basin have given rise to disputes between them for sharing of the waters.
    Eventually in April 1969, the Central Government constituted the Godavari Water
    Disputes Tribunal and referred various disputes for adjudication. While the disputes
    were before the Tribunal, the party States themselves, after negotiations entered
    into agreements from time to time on the utilisation of the waters of the Godavari
    and its tributaries. The Tribunal incorporated these agreements in their final
    adjudication and ordered that the agreements should be observed and carried out by
    all concerned.
    As per the award of the Tribunal, waters available in different sub-basins from the
    catchments intercepted by major/medium projects proposed on various tributaries
    by the States have been generally allocated among the respective States. In
    addition, for minor irrigation schemes, industrial and domestic uses, etc., certain
    specific quantities have been allowed to be utilised by various States. The remaining
    yield from the free catchment available in different sub-basins, as will be flowing into
    the river Godavari, is left for utilisation by Andhra Pradesh.
    3.4 The Polavaram Project and the Transfer of Water from Godavari to
    Krishna
    The Polavaram project was originally proposed by Government of Andhra Pradesh as
    an entirely State project for extending irrigation facilities to the upland areas in East
    Godavari, Visakhapatnam, West Godavari and Krishna districts and for other benefits
    like making water available for industrial purposes at Visakhapatnam and generation
    of hydropower.
    The States of Maharashtra and Karnataka had been agitating for the utilisation of
    more water of the Krishna river on account of diversion of Godavari water into the
    Krishna. On 4th August 1978, an agreement was entered into between the States of
    Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh stipulating the diversion of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC), at
    75% dependability, of Godavari waters from Polavaram Project into Krishna river
    above Prakasam Barrage at Vijayawada, thereby displacing the discharges from
    Nagarjunasagar project for Krishna delta, and thus enabling the use of the above
    quantity for projects upstream of Nagarjunasagar. The States also agreed that the
    quantity of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) thus made available will be shared in the
    proportion of Andhra Pradesh 1274 Mm3 (45 TMC); Karnataka and Maharashtra
    together 991 Mm3 (35 TMC).
    Dispute arose between the party States regarding the FRL/MWL of Polavaram
    Project, which will submerge areas in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh
    and Orissa. This dispute has also been resolved by the Tribunal. It was directed by
    the Tribunal that the Polavaram Project should be cleared by the Central Water
    Commission as expeditiously as possible for FRL/MWL of 45.72 m (150 ft.). It was
    further directed that the CWC should also decide the matter of design and operation
    schedule for the project keeping in view the agreements between the States in this
    regard as far as practicable.
    3
    3.5 Interstate Aspects under the Proposed Link Project
    The Godavari (Polavaram) – Krishna (Vijayawada) link is one of the several link
    proposals under the Peninsular Rivers Development component of the National
    Perspective Plan for large scale transfer of water from the surplus to the deficit river
    basins. It may not be possible to cover these large scale transfers under the present
    interstate agreements of the GWDT award. After a consensus is reached by the
    States concerned on the various link proposals, a separate agreement for sharing the
    surplus waters may have to be entered into by the States involved. The studies of
    NWDA and the provisions stipulated in the award of GWDT are not to be mixed up as
    the two have entirely different objectives and different locus standi.
    In this context, it is pertinent to note that while the Polavaram Project as proposed
    by Andhra Pradesh envisages the diversion of only 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) from
    Godavari to Krishna, the hydrological studies carried out by NWDA indicate the
    possibility of diverting a further quantity of 1236 Mm3 of water from Godavari to
    Krishna through the Polavaram – Vijayawada link canal. The agreement of 4th
    August 1978 between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka which has also been endorsed
    by the GWDT, stipulates that if the diversion at 75% dependability exceeds 2265
    Mm3 (80 TMC) due to diversion of Godavari waters from the proposed Polavaram
    Project into Krishna river, further diminishing the releases from Nagarjunasagar
    Project, such excess quantity should also be shared in the same proportion as agreed
    to (refer section 3.4 above).
    It is also pertinent to note that the issue of sharing of additional waters that may
    become available to Krishna from other river basins, particularly Godavari has also
    been gone into by the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal. After careful consideration
    of the issue, the Tribunal has directed that in the event of augmentation of the
    Krishna waters by the diversion of the waters of any other river, no co-basin State of
    Krishna shall be debarred from claiming that it is entitled to greater share in the
    Krishna Waters on account of such augmentation when the award of the Tribunal
    comes up for review after 31st May 2000.
    Eleventh Plan (2007-2012)
    The UPA government unveiled an approach paper to the 11th Five-Year plan titled,"Towards faster and more inclusive growth".According to the approach paper the monitorable targets of 11th five-year plan are:-
    GDP growth rate to be increased to 10% by the end of the plan;
    Farm sector growth to be increased to 4%;
    Creation of 7 crore job opportunities;
    Reduce educated unemployed youth to below 5 percent
    Infant mortality rates to be reduced to 28 per 1000 births;
    Maternal mortality rates to be reduced to 1 per 1000 births;
    Clean drinking water to all by 2009;
    Improve sex ratio to 935 by 2011-12 and to 950 by 2016-17;
    Ensure electricity connection to all villages and BPL households by 2009
    Roads to all villages that have a population of 1000 and above by 2009;
    Increase forest and tree cover by 5%;
    Achieve the World Health Organisation standard air quality in major cities by 2011-12;
    Treat all urban waste water by 2011-12 to clean river waters;
    Increase energy efficiency by 20 percentage points by 2016-17;

    Despite the fact that various industrial projects are facing stiff opposition from the people facing displacement, the list of corporate houses showing concern for the State's development appears to be getting longer by the day. One company even goes to claim that it is `committed' to giving everyone in Orissa a reason to smile.In fact, these companies have been operating in the State since a long time. But till recently,they had hardly expressed their eagerness to become a part of the development of the State that has been infamous for child sell, backbreaking poverty and hunger deaths.Interestingly, many of these corporate houses would unofficially agree that they have not been able to do much when it comes to their corporate social responsibility to make things better for the communities in the areas of their operation.
    Although those manning the operations of the these companies officially claim that they are doing a lot for the people living in the periphery of their factories and plants in different parts of the State, frequent protests and agitations by those affected

    by the `developmental projects' portray tell a different story.
    People’s Union for Democratic Rights, Delhi, PUDR
    invites you to a public meeting
    State Repression
    TODAY
    a civil rights perspective
    Sunday, 5 August 2007
    Gandhi Peace Foundation, DDU Marg, Near ITO, New Delhi
    10 a.m.
    Session I: Attacks on Civil Rights Organisations
    Speakers: PUDR (Delhi), PUCL (Chhattisgarh) ,
    APCLC (Andhra Pradesh)
    12 noon
    Session II: Reports from States
    Speakers: PUCL( Jharkhand), AFDR (Punjab),
    MASS (Assam), PUCL (Nagpur),
    COHR (Manipur), PUCL (Rajasthan),
    PMHR (Naga areas), PCHR (Jammu & Kashmir), APDR (West
    Bengal), LHS (Mumbai), HRF (Andhra Pradesh)

    RPL bags Sasan mega power project
    Economic Times - 4 hours ago
    30 Jul, 2007, 1430 hrs IST, PTI NEW DELHI: The government on Monday awarded the 4000 MW Sasan ultra mega power project to Anil Ambani's Reliance Energy as the company submitted the lowest bid of Rs 1.19616 per kilo watt hour.
    Reliance Energy wins Sasan project on 2nd attempt CNN-IBN
    Rel Energy wins bid for Sasan UMPP Moneycontrol.com
    Times Now.tv
    Food, Drinking Water Scarce In Flood-ravaged Bihar
    NEWSPost India - 3 hours ago
    Monday 30th of July 2007 Large parts of Bihar were faced with food and drinking water scarcity in one of the worst floods in 30 years that has cut off several towns, destroyed hundreds of houses and killed at least 20 people.
    Bihar floods:3 districts cut off from Patna Times of India
    Bihar flood situation grim, 14 dead NDTV.com
    Dear friends,
    A four nation Fact Finding Mission (FFM) composed of medical doctors and
    social activists was organised recently to look into the impacts of an
    industrial aqua farm in Tamil Nadu (India) and the human rights violations
    against Dalit villagers protesting against it.
    The team, convened by Tamil Nadu Women's Forum and Malaysia-based Pesticide
    Action Network Asia Pacific, visited Kolathur (population: 4000) and nearby
    areas including the Chinna Aqua Farm, and held extensive discussions with
    villagers, particularly women.
    Based on its findings, the Dalit community called for immediate closure of
    the illegal shrimp pond, and urged the District Administration to withdraw
    the nuisance cases filed against villagers, investigate the complaints of
    police atrocities and compensate villagers for livelihoods lost due to
    pollution.
    Please support the struggle of the Dalit community by signing on to the
    online petition letter http://www.foodsov.org/html/petition04.php
    The petition letter will automatically send the petition letter to different
    government officials and institutions in India and encourage them look into
    the case.
    If you wish to download the documentation of the fact-finding mission,
    please follow this link: http://www.foodsov.org/resources/againstallodds.pdf
    Kindly pass on this letter to your friends and networks.
    In solidarity,
    PCFS Secretariat
    ===============================
    People's Coalition on Food Sovereignty
    P.O. Box 1170, Penang 10850, Malaysia
    Tel: 604-6570271 or 604-6560381
    Fax: 604-6583960
    Website: http://foodsov.org
    E-mail: secretariat@foodsov.org
    Jalayagnam: liability period may be enhanced

    User Rating: / 0 Saturday, 30 June 2007

    Poor Best

    Hyderabad, June 30: The ‘liability period’ of contractors building irrigation projects under Jalayagnam holding them liable for any damage to the structure due to poor quality is likely to be increased from the existing two years to 10-15 years.
    The Government is contemplating this measure in view Basavadoddi, a part of Gururaghavendra Project in Kurnool district, developed “piping” (holes) during the recent heavy rains, forcing the authorities to empty the reservoir to save nearby habitations. Contractors will have to pay compensation for any structural damage or defect found during the liability period.
    Addressing at a press conference here on Friday, Major Irrigation Minister P. Lakshamiah said unlike in the past, the irrigation projects, now being implemented through the EPC mode, were being covered by insurance with the contractors themselves paying the premium.
    Also, the quality of the material and finished structure was being checked up by third parties consisting of engineering professionals and reputed organisations. This was in addition to the verification made at site laboratories set up by the contractors under the agreements and the joint inspections by Government officials and the third party, the Minister said.
    The quality control system during the TDP regime was so poor that parts of Owk, Veligodu, Kandaleru, Maddileru, Penn Ahobilam Balancing Rservoir, Cheyyeru, Yogi Vemana and Koulasnala projects got washed away or developed defects.
    K. C Canal was modernised by availing a huge loan but it developed breaches during the recent rains.
    “Will the Telugu Desam own responsibility for this ?”, he asked. He said the irrigation projects were handed over to contractors in 206 packages for execution and their quality was monitored through 38 third party cells. Denying the TDP’s charge that the construction was sub-standard, he said major projects like Polavaram and Pulichintala were designed based on the reckoning of the Maximum Probable Flood discharge for a long period running into tens of decades.

    After firing, Chandrababu, Left gun for YSR
    Express News ServicePosted online: Monday, July 30, 2007 at 0000 hrs Print EmailKhammam Deaths: Govt announces Rs 6 lakh ex gratia after relatives protest with bodies outside district collectorate
    HYDERABAD/KHAMMAM, JULY 29: The embers left by Saturday’s police firing which killed six Left activists agitating for land are unlikely to die soon. With the CPI(M), an important ally of the Congress at the Centre, baying for blood, the road ahead may not be smooth for Chief Minister Y S Rajasekhara Reddy.
    Even as Opposition leaders and top Left leaders made a beeline for Mudigonda, the Chief Minister, Home Minister K Jana Reddy and DGP M A Basit chose not to visit the spot. Police officials are understood to have advised them against going to Khammam citing security concerns as the situation in the town continued to be tense. The state Government has meanwhile announced ex gratia of Rs 6 lakh to the families of the victims.
    It was a heart rending scene outside the district collectorate in Khammam where draped in one TDP and five CPI(M) flags, the bodies were lined up as the relatives waited for the Government to do justice. It was only at around 4.30 pm, after Collector Sashibushan Kumar reached the site and announced Rs 6 lakh ex gratia to the kin of the deceased, that they allowed the bodies to be taken for post-mortem. Two acres of land, employment and a house to the bereaved families and Rs 50,000 to all those who suffered serious injuries and Rs 10,000 for minor injuries were also announced. He also said that the CI and the SI would be suspended.
    Speaking to reporters in Hyderabad, the CM said a judicial inquiry has been ordered to ascertain the circumstances that led to the police firing besides initiating departmental action against the policemen responsible. “Let us try to find a solution to the problem instead of aggravating it. I appeal to all political parties to help restore normalcy,” he said.
    Earlier in the day, accompanied by CPI(M) MLA T Veerabhadram and several party leaders, TDP President N Chandrababu Naidu visited Mudigonda. After consoling the locals, the TDP chief addressed them from a jeep and his message was clear: YSR has no right to continue as Chief Minister any longer.
    Later, he arrived at the collectorate and consoled the relatives of the deceased. Launching a scathing attack on the Chief Minister, he announced Rs 1 lakh to the bereaved families on behalf of the TDP and Rs 25,000 each to severely injured and Rs 10,000 to those who suffered minor injuries.
    Between the two Left parties which have been jointly waging the land struggle over the past two months, the CPI(M) was more belligerent in the aftermath of the Khammam incident. Politburo member Sitaram Yechuri wanted the Congress high command to realise that there was a visible anti-Rajasekhara Reddy mood in the state and it would be detrimental to the state Government if the same situation continued. CPI(M) state secretary B V Raghavulu minced no words and demanded Reddy’s resignation.
    But, CPI state secretary K Narayana felt it was not wise to target one individual though the Government was responsible for the police firing. Moreover, this demand would relegate the main issue of the land struggle to the background, he said.
    Not only in Dhaka, but also in Chittagong, Mymensingh, Sylhet, Jessore, Khulna, Dinajpur, Pabna and Kushtia as well as in scores of villages, Yahya Khan’s West Pakistani army committed such atrocities on hundreds and thousands of Bangali women. Even old women and literally kids of twelve years were not spared. All foreign correspondents have testified to this horrible rape of Bangali womanhood.
    Another leading U. S. Journal made the comments: “Three is no doubt that the word massacre applies to the situation. It’s a veritable blood bath. The troops have been utterly merciless. It was like Genghis Khan, said a shocked Western official.” (Time, April12).
    Here is another report on the carnage in Dacca by victor Chen, who had been visiting Dacca as a tourist (Newsweek April 19,1971).
    “The houses were burned down, and some were still smoldering....... literally dozens of dead bodies were strewn all over the place , many of them small kids, all of them riddled by bullets.”
    Here are other reports on “ Reign of Terror” let loose in Chittagong.
    “The Americans evacuated from Chittagong told Newsweek's Tony Clifton that the bitter fighting there had reduced East Pakistan’s largest port to a ghost town.” (NewsWeek, April 19,1971).
    “In a civil war already marked by brutality, the lightning attacks were notable for their savagery. In the port city of Chittagong, Pakistani troops forced Bengali prisoners to ride on the front of a truck, shouting ‘victory for Bengal’ an Independence slogan. When other Bengalis emerged from their hiding places, the Pakistanis opened fire with machineguns.” (Newsweek, April 26,1971). The same issue of Newsweek further reported: “In the cities of Sylhet and Comilla along the eastern border, West Pakistani firepower routed the followers of Mujibur Rahman and left the bodies of scores of dead peasants to the wild dogs.” Martin Woollacott, Guardian’s correspondent, reported from near Jessore, a vital road and rail centre:
    “West Pakistani troops have sent patrols out from their cantonments in Jessore to mortar and burn villages close to the town.”
    “ Fires were springing up in all direction...... Some 500 yards beyond flames were visible as the thatched roofs of houses in the next village caught fire”.
    “In the fields lay farm implements that peasants had abandoned earlier when a Pakistani aircraft appeared overhead”.(Guardian, April 4,1971).
    Locked In Arena Of Authorized Slaughter:
    The Pakistani Nazis wanted to hide the ugly truth from the world. So they bundled out all foreign journalists of the country and took away all reports, films etc. from them. Here is how Loren Jenkins of Newsweek (April12) describes that episode:
    “Two ho

  • Brahminical Rule Remains Intact, Intllegentsia Bengal Ensures that!

    Thank You, Monideepa!
    Brahminical Rule Remains Intact, Intllegentsia Bengal Ensures that!
    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Thank You, Monideepa!I have been writing and talking continuously on Dandkaranya Refugees along with all the ousted Dalit Bengalies from Bangla Geopolitics ,scattered all over India, facing deportation drive and deprived of human and civilrights, mother tongue and reservation. Now the Brahminical system strips them off citizenship with the new citizenship act denying their status as partition victim refugees.
    Kolkata Intelligetsia fights a brave fight on issues like Singur and nandigram, whichis nothing but a Dalit Muslim Insurrection. TASHAM has objections against Chemical Hubs. Mahashweta Devi writes daily column. Joy Goswami wrote mind blowing poems. Artists have walked on streets and many of the intellectuals have snapped relations with Ruling Left.
    But the scenerio remains the same as CPIM continuous to rule and implemet its disastrous Capitalist Development and sustains itself with well armed Gestapo grassroot network as well as scientific rigging machinery. The Ruling Brahmincal Class has made amockery of Ideology. They are up against US imperialism but welcomes the US Mancs including DOW to rule Bengal as well as India. They speak against INdo US Nuclear deal and also plan a Nuclear Power Plant in Haripur which is only possible when the agreement goes operational as Nuclear reactor has to be imported.
    They Boast of Panchayati Raj, rural development and land reforms, but they don`t hesitate to evict Rural Bengal for indiscriminate industrialisation and urbanisation!
    They agitate against SEZ countrywide put commits Nandigram Genocide and the rain of state sponsored terror seems to be infinite.
    They led the refugees. They Invited Dandakaranya Refugees and massacred them in Marichjhanpi!
    They are most vocal to implement OBC quota but they have not identified the OBC castes in Bengal till this date. More over, they deny any sapce to Dalit Movement in Bengal and deny every opportunity to SC, ST, OBC and minorites. Reserved posts are translated into general quota very smoothly or the posts remains vacant until caste hindu candidates accomodated.
    It is a WWF show, Ruling Class v`s Ruling class! Budha V/s Mamata Bannerjee. The most of the mediapersons and members of Kolkata Intelligentsia happen to be Brahmins. While they use the underprevileged masses for personal milage, political powergame and individual supremacy and bargaining, they maintain complete silence over Dalit and minority issues. It is complete blackout.
    Nandigram and Singur issues suit them and they have not to get bullet injuries or suffer any personal loss, they pose standing United. It does not change the social equation. Brahminical Rule remains intact. But reservation, quota, Sacchar Committee report and dalit or minority movement threaten their dominance! Whatever movement is allowed or publicised , that is under the leadership and sponsorship of the Ruling Class. As the folk is in vogue and demand . It is made a sophisticated marketable commodity. The banded and branded Folk is very saleable. But the Ruling classes never entartain the people and society where from the folk is originated.
    Thus, our appeals to the Politicians and Intelligentsia goes abegging. They won`t respond. They wont react. They won`t publish or broadcast anything related to the SC ST and dalit refugee issues.
    Mahasheta Devi does not respond. Mamta Bannerjee is never known to stand by refugees and Dalits.
    I have been writing continuously on these issues. Not even a single dispatch is responded or published in Bengal. But we have echoes elsewhere rather worldwide!
    I send these writeups to individual orgs, icons, parties and media persons without getting any response. Sanhati Udyog or Tasham has not to respond on dandkarany. But, as tribal pepole are involved and one or two tribes may be wiped out , I expected Mahashweta devi to write.
    Despite all its Absolute Power, I expect the Ruling Left won`t like another Marichjhanpi at all! If the Dandakaranya Refugees are evicted to accomplish the Polavaram Dam plus Godavari -Krishna Riverlink, you won`t help to stop the repeatation of Marichjhapi Incident. Thus, I hoped that the party and the government should have tyaken notice. No. It did not happen.
    But this afternoon I got a surprise call from Monideepa Bannerjee from NDTV. She discussed Dandkaranya Refugee problems at length and assured me that NDTV is going to take up the matter. She informed me that she intends to go to Marichjhanpi.
    Thanks Monideepa!
    I know the Brakha Dutta team is capable to inform the Nation which RTI denies!
    Why is all this happening now? Going by the words of the observers of Orissa's so called mineral-based industrial development and the growing opposition to displacement by industries in the recent years, the companies dealing in minerals became conscious about their social responsibility only after the police firing in Kalinga Nagar Industrial Complex in Jajpur in which 13 tribal men and women and one policeman were killed on January 2 last year.
    In post-Kalinga Nagar situation, almost every company started making attempts to show that they were actually not exploiting the mineral resources of the State for their own gain, but were `genuinely' concerned for the wellbeing of the people of Orissa, particularly the tribals and poor people living in the interior regions.

    The long wait for Posco’s $12-billion Orissa project is over. After two years, the South Korean steel giant is all set to begin construction work ...
    Mittal to set-up steel plants in Orissa, Jharkhand IndiaPost.com
    Orissa expects project worth Rs 2,00000 cr to start in 10 yrs Hindu
    At long last, corporate houses that are mostly into exploitation of the rich mineral resources of Orissa have started expressing their 'concern' for the State's development. The numerous hoardings dotting the skyline in Bhubaneswar, particularly the VIP routes, give enough indication in this regard.
    Going by the catchphrases on these hoardings, if one company wants just to see Orissa smile,
    the other wants to become a partner in the State's progress. Yet another company says that their greatest joy is in serving the villages of Orissa.
    Dandkaranya Dalit Bengalies don`t know the destined fate. They experienced Partion Holocaust and Marichjhapi Massacre! Would they survive this time?
    It is my concern. I am thankful to everyone who is interested in this rescue operation!
    Pl ring me!
    Once again, Thank You, Monideepa!
    Meanwhile Nepal protests Big Dams in India bordering Nepal and wants them decommissioned!
    Here is a Nepal Rising write Up!
    Certain agreements signed between two governments are really shocking. Right now a big part of our plains, the Terai, is under water. Dozens of people have been killed, thousands rendered homeless, and their crops destroyed by the waters blocked by the dams built close to the Nepalese border by India. Flooding due to the dams has become an annual phenomenon during the rainy season.
    Parliamentarians want the government to officially make a request to demolish those dams situated along the border.
    Ties With Neighbours: Asset Or Liability? [ 2007-7-30 ]
    The Rising Nepalhttp://www.gorkhapatra.org.np/content.php?nid=24024___##0##___ The Tamil Nadu government had also written to the Chief Ministers of peninsular States, including Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Kerala, Maharashtra and Puducherry, for a meeting on interlinking of rivers in the peninsular region, which could be hosted by Tamil Nadu.
    Responding to Tamil Nadu at the meeting, Mr. Premachandran said water was a State subject and the State legislature, “expressing the unanimous will of the people”, had passed a resolution on September 6, 2003, against the link. “The Kerala Government has already communicated our strong reservations on the link to the NWDA in September, 2003 itself.”
    Reviewing the progress of the NWDA, Mr. Soz said the Detailed Project Report of the Ken-Betwa link between Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh was expected to be completed in 2008.
    Draft MoUs sent
    Draft MoUs had been sent to Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan on the Parbati-Kalisindh-Chambal link; to Gujarat and Maharashtra for the Narmada-Par-Tapi link; and to Gujarat and Maharashtra for the Damanganga-Pinjal link.
    According to the Minister, a meeting of the Consensus Group for discussing the technical details of the Godavari (Polavaram)-Krishna (Vijaywada) link had been held between Orissa, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Chhattisgarh. The views of the Andhra Pradesh Government were awaited.

    Normal life was affected in Nandigram today due to a 12-hour bandh called by the anti-land acquistion committee, BUPC, against yesterday's firing and police lathicharge in which one person was killed and five others injured. Superintendent of Police, East Midnapore, G Srinivas, said 400 policemen had been stationed at Nandigram as a precautionary measure and the stituation was peaceful. Shops and establismnents were closed and vehicles were off the roads. The Block Development Office (BDO) and the local panchayat office also remained closed, police said.
    The situation remained tense as supporters of both the CPI(M) and the Trinamool Congress led Bhoomi Ucched Pratirodh Committee had gathered in strength at Bhangabera, Tekhali Bazar, Jananir-it-bhata, Shatengabari, Paharganj bordering Nandigram and Khejuri, police said.
    Fifteen injured in yesterday's incident have been been admitted to Nandigram primary hospital. About 500 BUPC supporters were camping outside the hospital claiming that the injured were their supporters, police said.

    AMARTYA SEN FAVORS LAND ACQUISITION FOR INDUSTRIALIZATION
    From: PCFS secretariat Date: Jul 2, 2007 7:48 AM
    Subject: [Foodsov_advocates] Please Support Dalits' Call Against Aquaculture
    To: foodsov_advocates@peoplesfoodsovereignty.org
    Manmohan speaks to Andhra CM over police firing
    New Delhi: With the Left training its guns at the Congress Government in Andhra Pradesh on the police firing incident in Khammam, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh today spoke to Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y S Rajashekhara Reddy and expressed regret at the "unfortunate incident."
    "The Prime Minister reiterated the government's commitment to redistribute surplus land and fulfil its stated commitments to the rural poor, especially the landless," PM's Media Adviser Sanjaya Baru said in a statement.
    The Chief Minister informed the Prime Minister of the steps taken and of instituting a judicial inquiry into the incident, he said.
    The Prime Minister expressed his regret at the unfortunate incident, Baru said.
    Singh conveyed his heartfelt sympathy for the next of the kin of those who died in the firing and enquired about the welfare of those injured.
    Six activists of Left parties were killed in the police firing at Mudigonda during a land distribution agitation on Saturday.
    Despite West Bengal's decision to scrap a planned Special Economic Zone in Nandigram, clashes continue to mar the peace in the area.
    On Sunday one was killed and over 35 people were injured as Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) and a Trinamool Congress-backed group, Bhumi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee (BUPC) supporters clashed at the local bus stand. The ruckus ended after the police used force to disband the mob.
    However, soon after the incident, the Opposition - Trinamool Congress, which is supporting the agitating farmers, went on the offensive. Party supremo Mamata Banerjee blamed Congress President Sonia Gandhi of supporting the CPM. Mamata demanded that the Centre dismiss the Buddhadeb Bhattacharya government.
    "The Central government can take action against the Andhra Pradesh government and Andhra government can ask for judicial enquiry and compensation. But, instead of giving a drop of water to Nandigram, this government is attacking everyday,” said Mamata.
    Mamata also criticised the CPM of double standards.
    "You see the attitude of the CPM and the double standard of the government. If it happens in Andhra Pradesh, they condemn it. But when it happens in their state, they indulge in state sponsored terrorism that kills people,” said Mamata.
    The Opposition Trinamool Congress today accused the CPI(M) of adopting "double standards" in demanding the resignation of the Andhra Pradesh chief minister in the wake of police firing in Khammam while the Left Front government in West Bengal did "nothing" for the victims of the police firing at Nandigram.
    "The CPI(M) is demanding the resignation of Chief Minister Y S Rajasekhar Reddy, but its leaders in West Bengal did nothing for the Nandigram victims," party chief Mamata Banerjee told reporters after meeting Governor G K Gandhi. The CPI(M), she said "follows a policy of double standards. It has a different stand when it comes to party-ruled states."
    "After six people were killed in police firing in Andhra Pradesh, the state government there took punitive action against policemen and also ordered a judicial enquiry and compensation for the families of victims. But the Buddhadeb Bhattacherjee government did not take any such action in Nandigram," she said.
    Demanding that the West Bengal Chief Minister be sacked for the police firing in Nandigram on March 14 when 14 people were killed, she said that she had requested the governor to intervene at Nandigram where firing was continuing from adjacent CPI(M) controlled Khejuri.
    She claimed that the firing and hurling of bombs from Khejuri was responsible for the fresh spurt of violence in Nandigram.
    Prakash Karat under attack from Comrades

    Virendra Kapoor | Monday, July 30, 2007 12:33:40 IST
    http://www.cybernoon.com/DisplayArticle.asp?section=fromthepress&subsection=editorials&xfile=July2007_insidestory_standard216&child=insidestory
    Hindi as passport to New York
    Usually the Hindi Sammelans held in foreign climes at the peak of the Indian summer end up as all-paid junkets for the invitees who invariably take along their spouses and, in a few cases, even sons and daughters for furlough. How the cause of Hindi, still the national language at least officially, is advanced remains unclear.
    However this year?s Hindi Sammelan, held mid-July in New York, takes the cake. Not only was the selection process of delegates most haphazard, but even the number of eminent Hindi litterateurs who spurned the invitations was unusually high. From the award-winning Mahashweta Devi to Ashok Vajpaeyi, Namdhari Singh and Kedar Nath Singh quite a few eminent invitees chose to skip the meet. Others like Indira Goswami made the trip to New York, though how she as a celebrated writer in Assamese would advance the cause of Hindi was not clear. A former journalist close to the HRD Minister Arjun Singh hand-picked five of his colleagues from his own organsiation for the trip.
    Nearly half of the delegation was connected with the media, especially because all the state and central legislators had dropped out in view of the presidential election. A large number took their spouses along. The organizers helpfully provided double rooms to all delegates at the up-market UN Plaza Hotel in Manhattan so that spouses could be accommodated. A delegate from Haryana took along his 80-plus father, explaining that the old man had a life-long ambition to `see America?. Another brought his son along from another western country and had him listed as a delegate.
    Some were tempted by the thought of getting the US visas stamped on their passports on the strength of the official MEA letter, though quite a few did settle for the official passports issued for the duration of the trip. With the local media pointedly refusing to take note of the conference, and scarcely a report in the national media back home, it is a mystery why taxpayers? rupees are being spent on what has become an all-paid junket in the name of our `national language?.
    Most curiously, former CBI Chief and now a member of the National Human Rights Commission, P. C. Sharma, responding to the general circular from the organisers, ended up as a speaker at the Hindi Sammelan in New York, though his tab was picked by the Commission and not the MEA. All in the cause of Hindi, of course.

    Truth of Nandigram and Singur
    Justice on Trial submits report to President
    Truth of Nandigram and Singur
    A high level committee comprising retired judges and top police officials recently visited Nandigram and Singur to find the truth of the farmers’ agitation. It found that there was no rule of law in Nandigram and Singur area. “Media reports indicate that the situation is not much different even today. The committee met different NGOs and organisations, which lent support to the information,” the committee said in its report. The committee under the banner of Justice On Trial, an Ahmedabad based NGO, presented the report to President Dr A.P.J. Abdul Kalam on July 5 in New Delhi to promote, protect, defend human rights and freedom, establish supremacy of law and to implement vigorously the concept of justice to all.
    “The committee strongly feels that the government should take immediate necessary action for implementation of rule of law, safety and security of the citizens of that area, take legal action against the CPI(M) cadre who have committed serious crimes, provide adequate compensation and initiate immediate action to search for the missing persons. The committee also recommends that request of the citizens to acquire land of inferior quality as suggested by them be looked into seriously. The committee is surprised to know that it is for the first time in the history of land acquisition that such a procedure (actually no laid down legal procedure) was adopted by the government itself,” said Justice S.M. Soni, former Judge of Gujarat High court while talking to media persons in New Delhi on July 6.
    In response to the media reports on the law and order situation in and around Nandigram and Singur, Justice On Trial had constituted this committee under the chairmanship of Justice M. Ramkrishna, former Chief Justice of Jammu & Kashmir and Assam, with Justice S.M. Soni, member, former Judge of High Court of Gujarat and former Lokayukta of Gujarat (member), Shri G. S. Gill, additional Advocate General of Rajasthan (member) Shri P.C. Dogra, former Director General of Police, Punjab (member), Smt. Nafisa Hussein, former member of National Commission for Women (member), Smt. Dr Suvarna Raval, social worker for Nomedic Tribes (member) and Shri Ramkishor Pasari, social activist (member secretary).
    According to Justice Soni, the committee visited the site of Nandigram and Singur blocks to personally inquire from the affected persons whether there was any breach or defiance of human rights/any other rights and if so how to remedy the same.
    “The committee visited areas between Nandigram and Khejuri and met residents and affected persons. It found that almost all the residents had emphasised that they belonged to the CPI(M). They also said that this has been a CPI(M) dominated area. It was their grievance that though they belong to the CPI(M) and it is CPI(M), which has helped them to become owners of the land, yet the government now wants them to become landless under the pretext of promoting industry. Our land is very fertile and number of families is maintained through the income from this land. Though we had offered our less fertile land for setting up industry, it is surprising that they are still bent upon acquiring this fertile land only. It is equally surprising for the citizens of this area, how this communist government which we have installed through our votes, wants to put us on the roads against their normal pro-labour and anti-industrialisation philosophy,” the report submitted to the President said.
    http://www.organiser.org/dynamic/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=195&page=12
    AEZ a failed concept: J. Ramesh
    Rediff, India - 7 hours ago
    He urged the eastern states like West Bengal, Orissa, Jharkhand and Bihar to prepare a detailed project report on agri exports, to identify anchor products ...
    Government mulls committee to reopen Bengal tea gardens NewKerala.com
    Tea garden worker's woes continue NewKerala.com
    Jairam: Sell closed tea gardens or face takeover Kolkata Newsline
    INTERLINKING RIVERS
    http://72.14.235.104/search?q=cache:qMEwArJLn3oJ:www.indiatogether.org/environment/interlink.htm+River+link+plan+in+India&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=16&gl=in
    PERSUADING THE PRESIDENT
    President Kalam, please listen
    Six leading advocates of decentralisation and people centred planning met the President of India on 20 April to impress upon him that the Interlinking of Rivers project is a step in the wrong direction. They have since written a letter to Dr.Kalam addressing his questions.
    Interlinking rivers | Water
    May 2005
    RAJYA SABHA INTERVENTION
    'Not the litmus test for patriotism'
    The entire weight of technical opinion has been to proceed with caution on the Interlinking of Rivers. An extract of Jairam Ramesh's speech in the Rajya Sabha debate on the working of Ministry of Water Resources on 20 April 2005.
    Interlinking rivers | Water
    May 2005
    FEASIBILITY
    A breach in the interlinking plans
    Forced by the Supreme Court to make its research public, the agency that claimed to have conducted feasibility studies on interlinking rivers puts out an incomplete document. Sudhirendar Sharma notes, however, that the politics of this mega-project will keep it alive, despite such incompetence and disregard for regulations.
    February 2005
    Cart before the horse
    With little agreement among the States both on the desirability and feasibility on the proposed river links, separate negotiations for each link reeks of unrealistic ambition. But ultimately, the paradox of this project is that its proponents are taking a bottom up approach to the execution of a top down decision, says Videh Upadhyay.
    May 2004
    Unseen waters
    Water beneath rivers and streams flows so fast that only a portion of it is tapped by wells. Subsurface dams would obstruct this, and allow more to be extracted. Additionally, they can force flows to the surface, making substantially more water available downstream without major ecological and human costs, says Jagadiswara Rao.
    May 2004
    The doubtful science of interlinking
    Why exactly do we need to link our rivers? Are we short of arable land, or are crop yields too low? Are we short of rainfall, or do we manage the available water poorly? Can arithmetic hydrology adequately substitute ecology? Jayanta Bandyopadhyay and Shama Perveen of IIM Kolkata present a sweeping analysis.
    February 2004
    Interlinking the Chief Ministers
    How can a state that only a few weeks ago expressed concerns over river diversions, so quickly change its assessment? Sudhirendar Sharma notes the reversal of positions on the interlinking mega-project is tied to political changes rather than environmental or social assessments.
    February 2004
    Linking lives, not rivers
    Utthan's water management schemes in Gujarat show that empowered local communities can tackle water problems, and have little need for New Delhi's grand designs. More importantly, the spin-off social and economic benefits, deliberately woven into these local efforts, are significant, too.
    Gujarat
    October 2003
    Interlinking? No, thanks
    The Kerala Assembly has decided that the state has nothing to gain - and plenty of already scarce water to lose - from the massive plan. The Assembly resolution has come at the right time in reviving a long-lost ecological consciousness.
    Kerala
    October 2003
    River links and judicial chinks
    Why did the Supreme Court take up interlinking rivers? When only one state filed its view in court, why did the court presume a 'consensus'? With two options at every turn, the Court has consistently picked the unconvincing one, and this has hindered the necessary discussions, says Videh Upadhyay.
    Opinions | Videh Upadhyay
    The river linkages payoff
    Against all the evidence, a conspiracy appears to have been hatched at the top echelons of the government to somehow bring this massive river linking project on the national agenda. The lure of gigantism today is the prospect of large and easy kickbacks, says Prashant Bhushan.
    June 2003
    Interlinking : Epitaph for the displaced
    Mr. Suresh Prabhu, when asked for estimates on the numbers of people to be displaced and about the cost of rehabilitation: "This is to be worked out but the benefits outweigh the costs." If it is yet to be assessed, how can anyone be sure that the benefits outweigh the costs, asks S G Vombatkere.
    March 2003
    The need for public debate
    Proponents of interlinking rivers must consider that an explicit definition of "public interest" or "public good" needs be used to identify the primary stakeholders and their stake in such a massive 'development' project.
    February 2003
    Arguments and Alternatives
    There may be an overall shortage of water, but the gravity of the problem is primarily due to improper distribution, vast differential in consumption and wastages. S G Vombatkere presents alternatives to and arguments against interlinking.
    January 2003
    Salvation or folly?
    Mass transfer of water across river basins is a gigantic project entailing construction of dams and canals and other connected hydraulic engineering works. Several questions need to be asked and answered first.
    January 2003
    Interlinking Mirages
    Anyone who knows what river systems and river-basin projects are will know that whatever water the plan to connect the nation's rivers holds is but a mirage.
    December 2002

    Krishna Godavari River Link
    http://nwda.gov.in/writereaddata/sublink2images/76.pdf
    1
    Chapter - 3
    Interstate Aspects
    3.1 General
    The Godavari (Polavaram) – Krishna (Vijayawada) link canal is one of the
    components of the Mahanadi – Godavari – Krishna – Pennar – Cauvery – Vaigai link
    system for inter-basin transfer of water in Peninsular India. All the major river
    basins involved in the interlinking are interstate in nature. The inter-basin water
    transfer links are, therefore, to be governed by interstate agreements. The States
    involved in this major interlinking are Orissa, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra,
    Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamilnadu and the Union Territory of
    Pondicherry. In respect of Godavari and Krishna river basins, the question of sharing
    of waters between the basin-states has already been adjudicated by the respective
    water dispute tribunals. In respect of Cauvery basin, the water sharing is currently
    under adjudication by the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal.
    In so far as the Polavaram – Vijayawada link is concerned, the proposal is to transfer
    surplus waters of Godavari to Krishna. Even earlier to NWDA’s studies, such a
    proposal had been mooted by Andhra Pradesh for transfer of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) of
    Godavari waters to Krishna. An agreement had also been reached between the party
    States for sharing of this quantum of water which was endorsed by the Godavari
    Water Disputes Tribunal (GWDT) in its award given in the year 1979.
    The present NWDA’s proposal is to transfer an additional quantity of 1236 Mm3 to
    Krishna through the same Polavaram – Vijayawada link canal over and above the
    2265 Mm3 of water transfer proposed by Andhra Pradesh.
    The details of the award of GWDT and the effect of water transfer from Godavari to
    Krishna on the Krishna basin States are briefly presented in this Chapter.
    3.2 States Traversed by the Godavari River
    The river Godavari is an interstate river. Its catchment area spreads over five States
    viz., Maharashtra, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa while
    the main river flows through only three States i.e., Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and
    Madhya Pradesh.
    The total length of Godavari is 1465 km. Originating in Maharashtra, it flows for
    about 694 km in that State and forms the border between Maharashtra and Andhra
    Pradesh for about 16 km. After flowing for about 281 km in Andhra Pradesh, it again
    forms the boundary between Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh for about 48 km. It
    also forms the boundary between Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh for about 24
    km. Finally it flows for about 402 km in Andhra Pradesh before it joins the Bay of
    Bengal. The State-wise catchment area of the basin is given in Table 2.1.
    2
    3.3 Interstate Agreements on Sharing of Godavari Waters and the GWDT
    Award
    The competitive claims of the riparian states for the utilisation of the waters of the
    Godavari basin have given rise to disputes between them for sharing of the waters.
    Eventually in April 1969, the Central Government constituted the Godavari Water
    Disputes Tribunal and referred various disputes for adjudication. While the disputes
    were before the Tribunal, the party States themselves, after negotiations entered
    into agreements from time to time on the utilisation of the waters of the Godavari
    and its tributaries. The Tribunal incorporated these agreements in their final
    adjudication and ordered that the agreements should be observed and carried out by
    all concerned.
    As per the award of the Tribunal, waters available in different sub-basins from the
    catchments intercepted by major/medium projects proposed on various tributaries
    by the States have been generally allocated among the respective States. In
    addition, for minor irrigation schemes, industrial and domestic uses, etc., certain
    specific quantities have been allowed to be utilised by various States. The remaining
    yield from the free catchment available in different sub-basins, as will be flowing into
    the river Godavari, is left for utilisation by Andhra Pradesh.
    3.4 The Polavaram Project and the Transfer of Water from Godavari to
    Krishna
    The Polavaram project was originally proposed by Government of Andhra Pradesh as
    an entirely State project for extending irrigation facilities to the upland areas in East
    Godavari, Visakhapatnam, West Godavari and Krishna districts and for other benefits
    like making water available for industrial purposes at Visakhapatnam and generation
    of hydropower.
    The States of Maharashtra and Karnataka had been agitating for the utilisation of
    more water of the Krishna river on account of diversion of Godavari water into the
    Krishna. On 4th August 1978, an agreement was entered into between the States of
    Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh stipulating the diversion of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC), at
    75% dependability, of Godavari waters from Polavaram Project into Krishna river
    above Prakasam Barrage at Vijayawada, thereby displacing the discharges from
    Nagarjunasagar project for Krishna delta, and thus enabling the use of the above
    quantity for projects upstream of Nagarjunasagar. The States also agreed that the
    quantity of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) thus made available will be shared in the
    proportion of Andhra Pradesh 1274 Mm3 (45 TMC); Karnataka and Maharashtra
    together 991 Mm3 (35 TMC).
    Dispute arose between the party States regarding the FRL/MWL of Polavaram
    Project, which will submerge areas in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh
    and Orissa. This dispute has also been resolved by the Tribunal. It was directed by
    the Tribunal that the Polavaram Project should be cleared by the Central Water
    Commission as expeditiously as possible for FRL/MWL of 45.72 m (150 ft.). It was
    further directed that the CWC should also decide the matter of design and operation
    schedule for the project keeping in view the agreements between the States in this
    regard as far as practicable.
    3
    3.5 Interstate Aspects under the Proposed Link Project
    The Godavari (Polavaram) – Krishna (Vijayawada) link is one of the several link
    proposals under the Peninsular Rivers Development component of the National
    Perspective Plan for large scale transfer of water from the surplus to the deficit river
    basins. It may not be possible to cover these large scale transfers under the present
    interstate agreements of the GWDT award. After a consensus is reached by the
    States concerned on the various link proposals, a separate agreement for sharing the
    surplus waters may have to be entered into by the States involved. The studies of
    NWDA and the provisions stipulated in the award of GWDT are not to be mixed up as
    the two have entirely different objectives and different locus standi.
    In this context, it is pertinent to note that while the Polavaram Project as proposed
    by Andhra Pradesh envisages the diversion of only 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) from
    God

  • title-2728101

    Thank You, Monideepa!
    Brahminical Rule Remains Intact, Intllegentsia Bengal Ensures that!
    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Thank You, Monideepa!I have been writing and talking continuously on Dandkaranya Refugees along with all the ousted Dalit Bengalies from Bangla Geopolitics ,scattered all over India, facing deportation drive and deprived of human and civilrights, mother tongue and reservation. Now the Brahminical system strips them off citizenship with the new citizenship act denying their status as partition victim refugees.
    Kolkata Intelligetsia fights a brave fight on issues like Singur and nandigram, whichis nothing but a Dalit Muslim Insurrection. TASHAM has objections against Chemical Hubs. Mahashweta Devi writes daily column. Joy Goswami wrote mind blowing poems. Artists have walked on streets and many of the intellectuals have snapped relations with Ruling Left.
    But the scenerio remains the same as CPIM continuous to rule and implemet its disastrous Capitalist Development and sustains itself with well armed Gestapo grassroot network as well as scientific rigging machinery. The Ruling Brahmincal Class has made amockery of Ideology. They are up against US imperialism but welcomes the US Mancs including DOW to rule Bengal as well as India. They speak against INdo US Nuclear deal and also plan a Nuclear Power Plant in Haripur which is only possible when the agreement goes operational as Nuclear reactor has to be imported.
    They Boast of Panchayati Raj, rural development and land reforms, but they don`t hesitate to evict Rural Bengal for indiscriminate industrialisation and urbanisation!
    They agitate against SEZ countrywide put commits Nandigram Genocide and the rain of state sponsored terror seems to be infinite.
    They led the refugees. They Invited Dandakaranya Refugees and massacred them in Marichjhanpi!
    They are most vocal to implement OBC quota but they have not identified the OBC castes in Bengal till this date. More over, they deny any sapce to Dalit Movement in Bengal and deny every opportunity to SC, ST, OBC and minorites. Reserved posts are translated into general quota very smoothly or the posts remains vacant until caste hindu candidates accomodated.
    It is a WWF show, Ruling Class v`s Ruling class! Budha V/s Mamata Bannerjee. The most of the mediapersons and members of Kolkata Intelligentsia happen to be Brahmins. While they use the underprevileged masses for personal milage, political powergame and individual supremacy and bargaining, they maintain complete silence over Dalit and minority issues. It is complete blackout.
    Nandigram and Singur issues suit them and they have not to get bullet injuries or suffer any personal loss, they pose standing United. It does not change the social equation. Brahminical Rule remains intact. But reservation, quota, Sacchar Committee report and dalit or minority movement threaten their dominance! Whatever movement is allowed or publicised , that is under the leadership and sponsorship of the Ruling Class. As the folk is in vogue and demand . It is made a sophisticated marketable commodity. The banded and branded Folk is very saleable. But the Ruling classes never entartain the people and society where from the folk is originated.
    Thus, our appeals to the Politicians and Intelligentsia goes abegging. They won`t respond. They wont react. They won`t publish or broadcast anything related to the SC ST and dalit refugee issues.
    Mahasheta Devi does not respond. Mamta Bannerjee is never known to stand by refugees and Dalits.
    I have been writing continuously on these issues. Not even a single dispatch is responded or published in Bengal. But we have echoes elsewhere rather worldwide!
    I send these writeups to individual orgs, icons, parties and media persons without getting any response. Sanhati Udyog or Tasham has not to respond on dandkarany. But, as tribal pepole are involved and one or two tribes may be wiped out , I expected Mahashweta devi to write.
    Despite all its Absolute Power, I expect the Ruling Left won`t like another Marichjhanpi at all! If the Dandakaranya Refugees are evicted to accomplish the Polavaram Dam plus Godavari -Krishna Riverlink, you won`t help to stop the repeatation of Marichjhapi Incident. Thus, I hoped that the party and the government should have tyaken notice. No. It did not happen.
    But this afternoon I got a surprise call from Monideepa Bannerjee from NDTV. She discussed Dandkaranya Refugee problems at length and assured me that NDTV is going to take up the matter. She informed me that she intends to go to Marichjhanpi.
    Thanks Monideepa!
    I know the Brakha Dutta team is capable to inform the Nation which RTI denies!
    Why is all this happening now? Going by the words of the observers of Orissa's so called mineral-based industrial development and the growing opposition to displacement by industries in the recent years, the companies dealing in minerals became conscious about their social responsibility only after the police firing in Kalinga Nagar Industrial Complex in Jajpur in which 13 tribal men and women and one policeman were killed on January 2 last year.
    In post-Kalinga Nagar situation, almost every company started making attempts to show that they were actually not exploiting the mineral resources of the State for their own gain, but were `genuinely' concerned for the wellbeing of the people of Orissa, particularly the tribals and poor people living in the interior regions.

    The long wait for Posco?s $12-billion Orissa project is over. After two years, the South Korean steel giant is all set to begin construction work ...
    Mittal to set-up steel plants in Orissa, Jharkhand IndiaPost.com
    Orissa expects project worth Rs 2,00000 cr to start in 10 yrs Hindu
    At long last, corporate houses that are mostly into exploitation of the rich mineral resources of Orissa have started expressing their 'concern' for the State's development. The numerous hoardings dotting the skyline in Bhubaneswar, particularly the VIP routes, give enough indication in this regard.
    Going by the catchphrases on these hoardings, if one company wants just to see Orissa smile,
    the other wants to become a partner in the State's progress. Yet another company says that their greatest joy is in serving the villages of Orissa.
    Dandkaranya Dalit Bengalies don`t know the destined fate. They experienced Partion Holocaust and Marichjhapi Massacre! Would they survive this time?
    It is my concern. I am thankful to everyone who is interested in this rescue operation!
    Pl ring me!
    Once again, Thank You, Monideepa!
    Meanwhile Nepal protests Big Dams in India bordering Nepal and wants them decommissioned!
    Here is a Nepal Rising write Up!
    Certain agreements signed between two governments are really shocking. Right now a big part of our plains, the Terai, is under water. Dozens of people have been killed, thousands rendered homeless, and their crops destroyed by the waters blocked by the dams built close to the Nepalese border by India. Flooding due to the dams has become an annual phenomenon during the rainy season.
    Parliamentarians want the government to officially make a request to demolish those dams situated along the border.
    Ties With Neighbours: Asset Or Liability? [ 2007-7-30 ]
    The Rising Nepalhttp://www.gorkhapatra.org.np/content.php?nid=24024___##0##___ The Tamil Nadu government had also written to the Chief Ministers of peninsular States, including Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Kerala, Maharashtra and Puducherry, for a meeting on interlinking of rivers in the peninsular region, which could be hosted by Tamil Nadu.
    Responding to Tamil Nadu at the meeting, Mr. Premachandran said water was a State subject and the State legislature, ?expressing the unanimous will of the people?, had passed a resolution on September 6, 2003, against the link. ?The Kerala Government has already communicated our strong reservations on the link to the NWDA in September, 2003 itself.?
    Reviewing the progress of the NWDA, Mr. Soz said the Detailed Project Report of the Ken-Betwa link between Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh was expected to be completed in 2008.
    Draft MoUs sent
    Draft MoUs had been sent to Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan on the Parbati-Kalisindh-Chambal link; to Gujarat and Maharashtra for the Narmada-Par-Tapi link; and to Gujarat and Maharashtra for the Damanganga-Pinjal link.
    According to the Minister, a meeting of the Consensus Group for discussing the technical details of the Godavari (Polavaram)-Krishna (Vijaywada) link had been held between Orissa, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Chhattisgarh. The views of the Andhra Pradesh Government were awaited.

    Normal life was affected in Nandigram today due to a 12-hour bandh called by the anti-land acquistion committee, BUPC, against yesterday's firing and police lathicharge in which one person was killed and five others injured. Superintendent of Police, East Midnapore, G Srinivas, said 400 policemen had been stationed at Nandigram as a precautionary measure and the stituation was peaceful. Shops and establismnents were closed and vehicles were off the roads. The Block Development Office (BDO) and the local panchayat office also remained closed, police said.
    The situation remained tense as supporters of both the CPI(M) and the Trinamool Congress led Bhoomi Ucched Pratirodh Committee had gathered in strength at Bhangabera, Tekhali Bazar, Jananir-it-bhata, Shatengabari, Paharganj bordering Nandigram and Khejuri, police said.
    Fifteen injured in yesterday's incident have been been admitted to Nandigram primary hospital. About 500 BUPC supporters were camping outside the hospital claiming that the injured were their supporters, police said.

    AMARTYA SEN FAVORS LAND ACQUISITION FOR INDUSTRIALIZATION
    From: PCFS secretariat Date: Jul 2, 2007 7:48 AM
    Subject: [Foodsov_advocates] Please Support Dalits' Call Against Aquaculture
    To: foodsov_advocates@peoplesfoodsovereignty.org
    Manmohan speaks to Andhra CM over police firing
    New Delhi: With the Left training its guns at the Congress Government in Andhra Pradesh on the police firing incident in Khammam, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh today spoke to Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y S Rajashekhara Reddy and expressed regret at the "unfortunate incident."
    "The Prime Minister reiterated the government's commitment to redistribute surplus land and fulfil its stated commitments to the rural poor, especially the landless," PM's Media Adviser Sanjaya Baru said in a statement.
    The Chief Minister informed the Prime Minister of the steps taken and of instituting a judicial inquiry into the incident, he said.
    The Prime Minister expressed his regret at the unfortunate incident, Baru said.
    Singh conveyed his heartfelt sympathy for the next of the kin of those who died in the firing and enquired about the welfare of those injured.
    Six activists of Left parties were killed in the police firing at Mudigonda during a land distribution agitation on Saturday.
    Despite West Bengal's decision to scrap a planned Special Economic Zone in Nandigram, clashes continue to mar the peace in the area.
    On Sunday one was killed and over 35 people were injured as Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) and a Trinamool Congress-backed group, Bhumi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee (BUPC) supporters clashed at the local bus stand. The ruckus ended after the police used force to disband the mob.
    However, soon after the incident, the Opposition - Trinamool Congress, which is supporting the agitating farmers, went on the offensive. Party supremo Mamata Banerjee blamed Congress President Sonia Gandhi of supporting the CPM. Mamata demanded that the Centre dismiss the Buddhadeb Bhattacharya government.
    "The Central government can take action against the Andhra Pradesh government and Andhra government can ask for judicial enquiry and compensation. But, instead of giving a drop of water to Nandigram, this government is attacking everyday,? said Mamata.
    Mamata also criticised the CPM of double standards.
    "You see the attitude of the CPM and the double standard of the government. If it happens in Andhra Pradesh, they condemn it. But when it happens in their state, they indulge in state sponsored terrorism that kills people,? said Mamata.
    The Opposition Trinamool Congress today accused the CPI(M) of adopting "double standards" in demanding the resignation of the Andhra Pradesh chief minister in the wake of police firing in Khammam while the Left Front government in West Bengal did "nothing" for the victims of the police firing at Nandigram.
    "The CPI(M) is demanding the resignation of Chief Minister Y S Rajasekhar Reddy, but its leaders in West Bengal did nothing for the Nandigram victims," party chief Mamata Banerjee told reporters after meeting Governor G K Gandhi. The CPI(M), she said "follows a policy of double standards. It has a different stand when it comes to party-ruled states."
    "After six people were killed in police firing in Andhra Pradesh, the state government there took punitive action against policemen and also ordered a judicial enquiry and compensation for the families of victims. But the Buddhadeb Bhattacherjee government did not take any such action in Nandigram," she said.
    Demanding that the West Bengal Chief Minister be sacked for the police firing in Nandigram on March 14 when 14 people were killed, she said that she had requested the governor to intervene at Nandigram where firing was continuing from adjacent CPI(M) controlled Khejuri.
    She claimed that the firing and hurling of bombs from Khejuri was responsible for the fresh spurt of violence in Nandigram.
    Prakash Karat under attack from Comrades

    Virendra Kapoor | Monday, July 30, 2007 12:33:40 IST
    http://www.cybernoon.com/DisplayArticle.asp?section=fromthepress&subsection=editorials&xfile=July2007_insidestory_standard216&child=insidestory
    Hindi as passport to New York
    Usually the Hindi Sammelans held in foreign climes at the peak of the Indian summer end up as all-paid junkets for the invitees who invariably take along their spouses and, in a few cases, even sons and daughters for furlough. How the cause of Hindi, still the national language at least officially, is advanced remains unclear.
    However this year?s Hindi Sammelan, held mid-July in New York, takes the cake. Not only was the selection process of delegates most haphazard, but even the number of eminent Hindi litterateurs who spurned the invitations was unusually high. From the award-winning Mahashweta Devi to Ashok Vajpaeyi, Namdhari Singh and Kedar Nath Singh quite a few eminent invitees chose to skip the meet. Others like Indira Goswami made the trip to New York, though how she as a celebrated writer in Assamese would advance the cause of Hindi was not clear. A former journalist close to the HRD Minister Arjun Singh hand-picked five of his colleagues from his own organsiation for the trip.
    Nearly half of the delegation was connected with the media, especially because all the state and central legislators had dropped out in view of the presidential election. A large number took their spouses along. The organizers helpfully provided double rooms to all delegates at the up-market UN Plaza Hotel in Manhattan so that spouses could be accommodated. A delegate from Haryana took along his 80-plus father, explaining that the old man had a life-long ambition to `see America?. Another brought his son along from another western country and had him listed as a delegate.
    Some were tempted by the thought of getting the US visas stamped on their passports on the strength of the official MEA letter, though quite a few did settle for the official passports issued for the duration of the trip. With the local media pointedly refusing to take note of the conference, and scarcely a report in the national media back home, it is a mystery why taxpayers? rupees are being spent on what has become an all-paid junket in the name of our `national language?.
    Most curiously, former CBI Chief and now a member of the National Human Rights Commission, P. C. Sharma, responding to the general circular from the organisers, ended up as a speaker at the Hindi Sammelan in New York, though his tab was picked by the Commission and not the MEA. All in the cause of Hindi, of course.

    Truth of Nandigram and Singur
    Justice on Trial submits report to President
    Truth of Nandigram and Singur
    A high level committee comprising retired judges and top police officials recently visited Nandigram and Singur to find the truth of the farmers? agitation. It found that there was no rule of law in Nandigram and Singur area. ?Media reports indicate that the situation is not much different even today. The committee met different NGOs and organisations, which lent support to the information,? the committee said in its report. The committee under the banner of Justice On Trial, an Ahmedabad based NGO, presented the report to President Dr A.P.J. Abdul Kalam on July 5 in New Delhi to promote, protect, defend human rights and freedom, establish supremacy of law and to implement vigorously the concept of justice to all.
    ?The committee strongly feels that the government should take immediate necessary action for implementation of rule of law, safety and security of the citizens of that area, take legal action against the CPI(M) cadre who have committed serious crimes, provide adequate compensation and initiate immediate action to search for the missing persons. The committee also recommends that request of the citizens to acquire land of inferior quality as suggested by them be looked into seriously. The committee is surprised to know that it is for the first time in the history of land acquisition that such a procedure (actually no laid down legal procedure) was adopted by the government itself,? said Justice S.M. Soni, former Judge of Gujarat High court while talking to media persons in New Delhi on July 6.
    In response to the media reports on the law and order situation in and around Nandigram and Singur, Justice On Trial had constituted this committee under the chairmanship of Justice M. Ramkrishna, former Chief Justice of Jammu & Kashmir and Assam, with Justice S.M. Soni, member, former Judge of High Court of Gujarat and former Lokayukta of Gujarat (member), Shri G. S. Gill, additional Advocate General of Rajasthan (member) Shri P.C. Dogra, former Director General of Police, Punjab (member), Smt. Nafisa Hussein, former member of National Commission for Women (member), Smt. Dr Suvarna Raval, social worker for Nomedic Tribes (member) and Shri Ramkishor Pasari, social activist (member secretary).
    According to Justice Soni, the committee visited the site of Nandigram and Singur blocks to personally inquire from the affected persons whether there was any breach or defiance of human rights/any other rights and if so how to remedy the same.
    ?The committee visited areas between Nandigram and Khejuri and met residents and affected persons. It found that almost all the residents had emphasised that they belonged to the CPI(M). They also said that this has been a CPI(M) dominated area. It was their grievance that though they belong to the CPI(M) and it is CPI(M), which has helped them to become owners of the land, yet the government now wants them to become landless under the pretext of promoting industry. Our land is very fertile and number of families is maintained through the income from this land. Though we had offered our less fertile land for setting up industry, it is surprising that they are still bent upon acquiring this fertile land only. It is equally surprising for the citizens of this area, how this communist government which we have installed through our votes, wants to put us on the roads against their normal pro-labour and anti-industrialisation philosophy,? the report submitted to the President said.
    http://www.organiser.org/dynamic/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=195&page=12
    AEZ a failed concept: J. Ramesh
    Rediff, India - 7 hours ago
    He urged the eastern states like West Bengal, Orissa, Jharkhand and Bihar to prepare a detailed project report on agri exports, to identify anchor products ...
    Government mulls committee to reopen Bengal tea gardens NewKerala.com
    Tea garden worker's woes continue NewKerala.com
    Jairam: Sell closed tea gardens or face takeover Kolkata Newsline
    INTERLINKING RIVERS
    http://72.14.235.104/search?q=cache:qMEwArJLn3oJ:www.indiatogether.org/environment/interlink.htm+River+link+plan+in+India&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=16&gl=in
    PERSUADING THE PRESIDENT
    President Kalam, please listen
    Six leading advocates of decentralisation and people centred planning met the President of India on 20 April to impress upon him that the Interlinking of Rivers project is a step in the wrong direction. They have since written a letter to Dr.Kalam addressing his questions.
    Interlinking rivers | Water
    May 2005
    RAJYA SABHA INTERVENTION
    'Not the litmus test for patriotism'
    The entire weight of technical opinion has been to proceed with caution on the Interlinking of Rivers. An extract of Jairam Ramesh's speech in the Rajya Sabha debate on the working of Ministry of Water Resources on 20 April 2005.
    Interlinking rivers | Water
    May 2005
    FEASIBILITY
    A breach in the interlinking plans
    Forced by the Supreme Court to make its research public, the agency that claimed to have conducted feasibility studies on interlinking rivers puts out an incomplete document. Sudhirendar Sharma notes, however, that the politics of this mega-project will keep it alive, despite such incompetence and disregard for regulations.
    February 2005
    Cart before the horse
    With little agreement among the States both on the desirability and feasibility on the proposed river links, separate negotiations for each link reeks of unrealistic ambition. But ultimately, the paradox of this project is that its proponents are taking a bottom up approach to the execution of a top down decision, says Videh Upadhyay.
    May 2004
    Unseen waters
    Water beneath rivers and streams flows so fast that only a portion of it is tapped by wells. Subsurface dams would obstruct this, and allow more to be extracted. Additionally, they can force flows to the surface, making substantially more water available downstream without major ecological and human costs, says Jagadiswara Rao.
    May 2004
    The doubtful science of interlinking
    Why exactly do we need to link our rivers? Are we short of arable land, or are crop yields too low? Are we short of rainfall, or do we manage the available water poorly? Can arithmetic hydrology adequately substitute ecology? Jayanta Bandyopadhyay and Shama Perveen of IIM Kolkata present a sweeping analysis.
    February 2004
    Interlinking the Chief Ministers
    How can a state that only a few weeks ago expressed concerns over river diversions, so quickly change its assessment? Sudhirendar Sharma notes the reversal of positions on the interlinking mega-project is tied to political changes rather than environmental or social assessments.
    February 2004
    Linking lives, not rivers
    Utthan's water management schemes in Gujarat show that empowered local communities can tackle water problems, and have little need for New Delhi's grand designs. More importantly, the spin-off social and economic benefits, deliberately woven into these local efforts, are significant, too.
    Gujarat
    October 2003
    Interlinking? No, thanks
    The Kerala Assembly has decided that the state has nothing to gain - and plenty of already scarce water to lose - from the massive plan. The Assembly resolution has come at the right time in reviving a long-lost ecological consciousness.
    Kerala
    October 2003
    River links and judicial chinks
    Why did the Supreme Court take up interlinking rivers? When only one state filed its view in court, why did the court presume a 'consensus'? With two options at every turn, the Court has consistently picked the unconvincing one, and this has hindered the necessary discussions, says Videh Upadhyay.
    Opinions | Videh Upadhyay
    The river linkages payoff
    Against all the evidence, a conspiracy appears to have been hatched at the top echelons of the government to somehow bring this massive river linking project on the national agenda. The lure of gigantism today is the prospect of large and easy kickbacks, says Prashant Bhushan.
    June 2003
    Interlinking : Epitaph for the displaced
    Mr. Suresh Prabhu, when asked for estimates on the numbers of people to be displaced and about the cost of rehabilitation: "This is to be worked out but the benefits outweigh the costs." If it is yet to be assessed, how can anyone be sure that the benefits outweigh the costs, asks S G Vombatkere.
    March 2003
    The need for public debate
    Proponents of interlinking rivers must consider that an explicit definition of "public interest" or "public good" needs be used to identify the primary stakeholders and their stake in such a massive 'development' project.
    February 2003
    Arguments and Alternatives
    There may be an overall shortage of water, but the gravity of the problem is primarily due to improper distribution, vast differential in consumption and wastages. S G Vombatkere presents alternatives to and arguments against interlinking.
    January 2003
    Salvation or folly?
    Mass transfer of water across river basins is a gigantic project entailing construction of dams and canals and other connected hydraulic engineering works. Several questions need to be asked and answered first.
    January 2003
    Interlinking Mirages
    Anyone who knows what river systems and river-basin projects are will know that whatever water the plan to connect the nation's rivers holds is but a mirage.
    December 2002

    Krishna Godavari River Link
    http://nwda.gov.in/writereaddata/sublink2images/76.pdf
    1
    Chapter - 3
    Interstate Aspects
    3.1 General
    The Godavari (Polavaram) ? Krishna (Vijayawada) link canal is one of the
    components of the Mahanadi ? Godavari ? Krishna ? Pennar ? Cauvery ? Vaigai link
    system for inter-basin transfer of water in Peninsular India. All the major river
    basins involved in the interlinking are interstate in nature. The inter-basin water
    transfer links are, therefore, to be governed by interstate agreements. The States
    involved in this major interlinking are Orissa, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra,
    Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamilnadu and the Union Territory of
    Pondicherry. In respect of Godavari and Krishna river basins, the question of sharing
    of waters between the basin-states has already been adjudicated by the respective
    water dispute tribunals. In respect of Cauvery basin, the water sharing is currently
    under adjudication by the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal.
    In so far as the Polavaram ? Vijayawada link is concerned, the proposal is to transfer
    surplus waters of Godavari to Krishna. Even earlier to NWDA?s studies, such a
    proposal had been mooted by Andhra Pradesh for transfer of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) of
    Godavari waters to Krishna. An agreement had also been reached between the party
    States for sharing of this quantum of water which was endorsed by the Godavari
    Water Disputes Tribunal (GWDT) in its award given in the year 1979.
    The present NWDA?s proposal is to transfer an additional quantity of 1236 Mm3 to
    Krishna through the same Polavaram ? Vijayawada link canal over and above the
    2265 Mm3 of water transfer proposed by Andhra Pradesh.
    The details of the award of GWDT and the effect of water transfer from Godavari to
    Krishna on the Krishna basin States are briefly presented in this Chapter.
    3.2 States Traversed by the Godavari River
    The river Godavari is an interstate river. Its catchment area spreads over five States
    viz., Maharashtra, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa while
    the main river flows through only three States i.e., Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and
    Madhya Pradesh.
    The total length of Godavari is 1465 km. Originating in Maharashtra, it flows for
    about 694 km in that State and forms the border between Maharashtra and Andhra
    Pradesh for about 16 km. After flowing for about 281 km in Andhra Pradesh, it again
    forms the boundary between Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh for about 48 km. It
    also forms the boundary between Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh for about 24
    km. Finally it flows for about 402 km in Andhra Pradesh before it joins the Bay of
    Bengal. The State-wise catchment area of the basin is given in Table 2.1.
    2
    3.3 Interstate Agreements on Sharing of Godavari Waters and the GWDT
    Award
    The competitive claims of the riparian states for the utilisation of the waters of the
    Godavari basin have given rise to disputes between them for sharing of the waters.
    Eventually in April 1969, the Central Government constituted the Godavari Water
    Disputes Tribunal and referred various disputes for adjudication. While the disputes
    were before the Tribunal, the party States themselves, after negotiations entered
    into agreements from time to time on the utilisation of the waters of the Godavari
    and its tributaries. The Tribunal incorporated these agreements in their final
    adjudication and ordered that the agreements should be observed and carried out by
    all concerned.
    As per the award of the Tribunal, waters available in different sub-basins from the
    catchments intercepted by major/medium projects proposed on various tributaries
    by the States have been generally allocated among the respective States. In
    addition, for minor irrigation schemes, industrial and domestic uses, etc., certain
    specific quantities have been allowed to be utilised by various States. The remaining
    yield from the free catchment available in different sub-basins, as will be flowing into
    the river Godavari, is left for utilisation by Andhra Pradesh.
    3.4 The Polavaram Project and the Transfer of Water from Godavari to
    Krishna
    The Polavaram project was originally proposed by Government of Andhra Pradesh as
    an entirely State project for extending irrigation facilities to the upland areas in East
    Godavari, Visakhapatnam, West Godavari and Krishna districts and for other benefits
    like making water available for industrial purposes at Visakhapatnam and generation
    of hydropower.
    The States of Maharashtra and Karnataka had been agitating for the utilisation of
    more water of the Krishna river on account of diversion of Godavari water into the
    Krishna. On 4th August 1978, an agreement was entered into between the States of
    Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh stipulating the diversion of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC), at
    75% dependability, of Godavari waters from Polavaram Project into Krishna river
    above Prakasam Barrage at Vijayawada, thereby displacing the discharges from
    Nagarjunasagar project for Krishna delta, and thus enabling the use of the above
    quantity for projects upstream of Nagarjunasagar. The States also agreed that the
    quantity of 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) thus made available will be shared in the
    proportion of Andhra Pradesh 1274 Mm3 (45 TMC); Karnataka and Maharashtra
    together 991 Mm3 (35 TMC).
    Dispute arose between the party States regarding the FRL/MWL of Polavaram
    Project, which will submerge areas in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh
    and Orissa. This dispute has also been resolved by the Tribunal. It was directed by
    the Tribunal that the Polavaram Project should be cleared by the Central Water
    Commission as expeditiously as possible for FRL/MWL of 45.72 m (150 ft.). It was
    further directed that the CWC should also decide the matter of design and operation
    schedule for the project keeping in view the agreements between the States in this
    regard as far as practicable.
    3
    3.5 Interstate Aspects under the Proposed Link Project
    The Godavari (Polavaram) ? Krishna (Vijayawada) link is one of the several link
    proposals under the Peninsular Rivers Development component of the National
    Perspective Plan for large scale transfer of water from the surplus to the deficit river
    basins. It may not be possible to cover these large scale transfers under the present
    interstate agreements of the GWDT award. After a consensus is reached by the
    States concerned on the various link proposals, a separate agreement for sharing the
    surplus waters may have to be entered into by the States involved. The studies of
    NWDA and the provisions stipulated in the award of GWDT are not to be mixed up as
    the two have entirely different objectives and different locus standi.
    In this context, it is pertinent to note that while the Polavaram Project as proposed
    by Andhra Pradesh envisages the diversion of only 2265 Mm3 (80 TMC) from
    God

  • Hilsa Politics as Bangla Brahminical Communalism takes on Dalit Muslim Insurrection!

    Hilsa Politics as Bangla Brahminical Communalism takes on Dalit Muslim Insurrection!
    Fresh violence broke out in troubled Nandigram

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Nandigram flares up yet again! Fresh violence broke out in troubled Nandigram in West Bengal Sunday as Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) supporters and a Trinamool Congress-backed group clashed while taking out separate processions.Police used batons to disperse the clashing mobs, East Midnapore Superintendent of Police G. Srinivas told IANS. Both the CPI-M and the Bhumi Uchched Pratirodh Committee (BUPC), which opposes government takeover of farmland for industry, had taken out processions when the fighting occurred. The CPI-M supporters were celebrating the party's win in the Haldia municipal elections while BUPC wanted to surround the Nandigram police station.
    CPIM is cashing Bangla Brhminical Communal nationality on the same line as the Bangladeshi Muslim Nationality has taken over Bangla nationality in Dhaka. Facing stiff resistance of United Dalit MMuslim Insurrection against Buddh Brand Capitalist development, indiscriminate land acquisition for Urbanisation and Industrialisation the Post Modern Marxists, comradors of US Hindu Zionist Post Modern Galaxy order plays Bangla Nationality Card so well to keep the Vote Bank Intact! Thus, Hilsa and Moitri Express have taken over every other issues. Buddha declared that there won`t be no SEZ in Nandigram, but just after romping home in Laxman Seth Tamalika Seth stronghold Haldia, Nandigram has to feel the heat and fire of the state sponsored violence!
    Meanwhile, Scientists and teachers today predicted disastrous effects for the proposed chemical hub in Haldia and urged the state government to provide a detailed report of the proposal to the public.
    In a letter written to the chief minister, the Teachers and Scientists Against Maldevelopment (TASAM) warned that “the proposed hub will effectively become an instrument for providing cheap labour and dumping ground for the toxic material due to the relaxed environmental laws of our country”.
    The state government should have consulted the experts before proceeding with the proposal. “The decision taken by the government was solely an administrative one. It should have discussed the matter with researchers and scientists of this field”, said Prof. Partha Sarathi Ray, chemical technology professor at Calcutta University.
    Prof. Rabindra Nath Majumdar, another professor at Calcutta University, said that the government’s decision of selecting Haldia to set up the chemical hub was wrong because it is dangerous to set up such a hub in any fertile land or even coastal area. Though the government has publicly announced that the hub would be “environment friendly” and “less polluting”, it has not provided any substantial data to support it.
    After political parties, the chemical hub proposed by the Left Front government has come into the bad books of a section of teachers and scientists.

    The members said it was wrong of the government to acquire land at Nandigram without putting to rest problems pertaining to pollution, waste management, disposal of effluents, etc. They demanded to know the details about the design, the investors and other players in the setting up of the proposed hub.
    “Chemical pollution is as detrimental to the environment as nuclear pollution. Moreover, such an activity cannot be allowed in a densely populated state like West Bengal,” said Manindra Narayan Majumdar, former Professor of chemistry and Dean Faculty of Science, Kalyani University. Citing various disasters in chemical factories, he added that accidents are highly possible in such plants.
    Abhee Dutt Majumdar from Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics said they have conveyed their concerns to the chief minister several times but to no avail.
    “Our state is rich in biodegradable and renewable resources like plant biomass. The government should try to utilise these resources instead of setting up petro-chemical hubs,” he added.
    The project in Nandigram has become a flashpoint between the state's long-ruling communists and farmers who say their prime agriculture land is being taken away.West Bengal has witnessed regular protests over acquisition of agriculture land for industry this year, with violence in Singur, near Kolkata, where Tata Motors is building a small car factory.The project, billed as key to the rejuvenation of West Bengal and a test case for the communists, has been mired in trouble with some farmers saying the government took their land against their will.The government says it has compensated most of the affected farmers and is unwilling to halt the project.

    Trinamool chief Mamata Banerjee appealed to the central government to take action against the West Bengal government.She said that if the Centre can take action against the Andhra government then action should be taken against the Bengal government.
    In the wake of the Bangladesh government’s six-month ban on export of hilsa, the state fisheries department, keen to boost the sale of the fish from Bangladesh in local market, has taken up the matter with the central government. While at least 25 people have been injured in a clash between ruling CPI (M) and opposition Trinamool Congress supporters that took place in Nandigram on Sunday.According to reports, trouble started after a victory procession of the Trinamool Congress that won seven of the 26 seats in the recently concluded Haldia civic polls turned violent. here are reports of bomb explosion in the area and a CPI (M) party office was also attacked.
    Trinamool along with Bhumi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee (BUPC), which is opposing the land acquisition for a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) in Nandigram, has called for a shutdown on Monday.
    Meanwhile, Trinamool chief Mamata Banerjee demanded dismissal of the State government and asked the Centre to intervene.Banerjee held the state government responsible for the murder of Tapasi Malik at Singur, site of the Tata Motors'
    small car project, and threatened to continue its agitation
    till the forcibly-acquired land was returned to the owners.
    Condemning the police firing that killed seven farmers
    in Khammam district in Andra Pradesh, Banerjee said, "We
    don't support what happened in Andhra Pradesh and this is our
    stand for any such incident anywhere in the country, unlike
    the Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee government in West Bengal".
    Appreciating the Andhra Pradesh government's steps
    ordering a judicial probe into the police firing that killed
    farmers, announcement of compensation for the families of the
    deceased and the injured and anouncement of punishment for the
    officials responsible for the incident, Banerjee regretted
    that the Left Front government was yet to take any such step
    here on the killing of 14 persons in police firing on March 14
    at Nandigram.
    "If the Centre can ask for report from the Andhra
    Pradesh government on the incident, it should also ask for
    reports on Nandigram and Singur from the West Bengal
    Government on the same ground," she said.
    Banerjee said that despite an assurance to look into
    their demands during 26-day-long hunger strike, he did not
    keep his word.
    "No system worked properly in the state and the police
    was not allowed to work independently," she regretted alleging
    that after the L F win in the Haldia Municipality, the local
    authority issued notification for acquisition of land in all
    those wards where opposition candidates had won creating
    tension among farmers.
    Reports from Nandigram said 26 people who were injured were admitted to hospital. Srinivas, however, said only five people had sustained injuries and one bomb was hurled. He said there were no reports of firing.
    "The situation is now under control," Srinivas said as tension gripped the area.
    BUPC leader Abdus Samad said the CPI-M procession had ended peacefully. But when BUPC began marching, CPI-M workers hurled bombs at them.
    CPI-M leader Ashok Guria, however, alleged that BUPC men attacked their party office, triggering the clash.
    The BUPC has now called a 12-hour Nandigram shutdown Monday to protest against the latest violence. It said CPI-M men fired from Khejuri, a stronghold of the party and where most CPI-M supporters of Nandigram are now sheltered in camps.
    "We will surround the Nandigram police station on Aug 1 to protest the firing," said Samad.
    "The latest violence is because of comments made by Haldia MP Laxman Seth who dubbed the verdict in Haldia as a mandate for industrialisation and hinted at eyeing Nandigram again for an industrial complex," a BUPC supporter said.
    Haldia is an industrial town close to Nandigram where the communists are planning to relocate the chemical hub that was originally planned in Nandigram triggering the saga of violence and killings.
    The Left Front won the civic body elections held this month under the shadow of the violence in Nandigram.
    Meanwhile, CPI-M patriarch Jyoti Basu said he was concerned over the latest reports of violence. "Nandigram is still violent and the peace process has to make headway," he said.
    At least 22 people have been killed, hundreds injured and several raped in Nandigram in protests since January against the special economic zone (SEZ) and a chemical hub planned there in collaboration with Indonesia's Salim Group.
    Following the violence, the SEZ plan was scrapped but thousands of people belonging to both the CPI-M and the BUPC have been living in camps.
    The all-party talks to start a peace process in Nandigram and facilitate the return of terror-stricken villagers to their homes have not yielded much success.

    Mr Kiranmay Nanda, minister-in-charge, today said that he has written to two Union ministers ~ Mr Jairam Ramesh and Mr Pranab Mukherjee ~ asking them to discuss the matter with Dhaka. “I have also requested the chief minister to discuss the matter with the Centre”.
    To stop the sale of local hilsa weighing around two kilos, the state government has decided to impose complete ban on the use of nets used by fishermen in south Bengal, Mr Nanda said.
    “We issued a circular in June on the specification of nets to be used. But fishermen had already procured their nets for this season. So we are going to issue an order on the density of the knitting. This will ensure that only the bigger fish gets caught in the net”, Mr Nanda said after discussion on his department’s budget.
    India, Bangladesh to resume train service after 36 yrs

    India and Bangladesh are all set to resume cross-border passenger train services after 36 years. Two trains will start to ply between Kolkata and Dhaka in September. Meet 10-year-old Sridhar Das, he is going back home to Bangladesh after one of his frequent visits to India where his father Nirmalendu Das works. For this father and son, and thousands of others like them, this journey is an arduous one. To get to Dhaka, they must alight at the Gede Railway Station in India, and walk three kilometers to catch a connecting train from the Darshana railway station in Bangladesh.
    Little wonder then that the resumption of direct trains from Kolkata to Dhaka is eagerly awaited.
    Nirmalendu Das says, “No doubt we will be benefited from this bus service. It’s going to help us.”
    Basu demands inquiry into AP police firing
    Veteran CPI(M) leader Jyoti Basu today said there should be an impartial inquiry into the police firing in Andhra Pradesh to find whether the firing was unprovoked.
    "I hope there will be an inquiry to find out whether the firing was unprovoked or absolutely necessary. I hope that our party's Andhra unit will raise demand for an inquiry into the incident," Basu told reporters here.
    Referring to report of attack on CPI(M) zonal office in Nandigram today, the veteran Marxist said "This is unfortunate. It seems Nandigram is not within West Bengal."
    "However, despite all such provocations we won the Haldia Municipal polls recently. It (the Haldia civic poll result) is a matter of pride for Left Front that people are with us."
    Basu came to state party headquarters to attend the state committee meeting.
    Six persons were killed and eight others injured when police opened fire yesterday to quell violence in Khammam district during a state-wide shutdown called by Left parties in AP to demand the distribution of land to the poor.
    Board set to clear more SEZ proposals
    New Delh): The board of approval for special economic zones will meet on August 8 to consider eight cases, including two from Infosys, as the process gathers momentum after a change in norms and less political resistance.
    “After the August 8 meeting, we will have a large chunk of SEZ proposals — that had piled up before the assembly polls because of political opposition in various parts of the country — cleared,” a government official said.
    With the empowered group of ministers changing the rules and putting a cap of 5,000 hectares on multi-product zones in April, the stage was set for faster clearances.
    As of now, the board had approved 547 zones, of which 132 had been notified. The board has given formal clearances to 362 and in-principle clearance to 177 zones. Nearly 200 cases had been considered in five meetings since May 9.
    Listed for in-principle approval at the August 8 meeting are Adarsh Prime Project’s 468-hectare IT SEZ in Karnataka, Enfield Infrastructure’s 16-hectare IT Zone in Bengal and the 10-hectare Genpact project in Rajasthan.
    Other proposals include two from Infosys Technologies for IT Zones in Andhra Pradesh and a biotech SEZ by Veritas Infrastructure Development Ltd.

    Singur: Govt should have issued single notification, not 13

    Express News Service

    Kolkata: The former secretary of the land and land revenue department of the state had filed a writ petition in the form of a public interest litigation (PIL) in Calcutta High Court challenging the acquisition of land at Singur for the Tata Motors’ small car project. The matter is being heard by a Division Bench of Chief Justice S S Nijjar and Justice Pinaki Chandra Ghosh. The counsel of the former land and land revenue secretary Soumendra Chandra Bose today contended that the notifications for land acquisition at Singur were virtually illegal.

    The counsel added that Hooghly collector Binod Kumar who was in charge of land acquisition did not have the power to issue a notification for acquiring land at Singur on behalf of the Governor of the state. According to an existing order issued by the state government, only a person holding the rank of secretary or joint secretary was authorised to issue the notification. Further, there was no record to suggest that the Governor of the state had delegated this power to Kumar.
    The state government had issued 13 notifications for acquiring 997.11 acres of land spread over five mouzas at Singur. But instead of doing so, the counsel argued, that the government should have issued only a single notice. All that the 13 notifications did was to create confusion among Singur residents. He added that the state government should produce all records related to land acquisition before the division bench so that malpractice during the acquisition process could be detected.
    CPM seeks regulatory frame work for corporates
    Madurai: Maintaining stiff opposition to Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in retail the CPI(M) today sought a regulatory framework for domestic corporate houses entering the sector.
    ''Parliament should enact a model legislation to be followed suit by all the states, '' CPI(M) polit bureau member Sitaram Yechury said addressing the members of the Tamil Nadu Chamber of Commerce and Industry (TNCCI) here last night.
    Mr Yechury, the second polit bureau member to address the TNCCI after a gap of 26 years after veteran Jyoti Basu, said the party was for a system of licensing to allow big business houses to venture into the sector, in order to prevent monopoly.
    Domestic corporate houses, which initially supported the party’s stand on opposing FDI in retail have now become apologists, offering a fallacious rationale, he observed, expressing surprise. This was because they have resigned to the fate of being collaborators for the backdoor entry of foreign monopoly into this vital sector, he explained.
    In this context, he welcomed the initiative of Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi to study the legal options adopted by other states to prevent the entry of corporate giants in this field.
    Justifications by the Centre and ruling classes for FDI, including quality, competitive price and helping farmers, were all myths which, Mr Yechury said were exposed much earlier.
    Police firing: Andhra govt announces compensation
    A bandh to protest the death of six persons in police firing disrupted life here today even as the Left parties and main opposition TDP stepped up their attack on Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y S Rajasekhar Reddy, demanding his resignation for the incident. Tension gripped the town as hundreds of CPI(M) and CPI activists organised a sit-in at the district collectorate here with the bodies of those killed in the firing yesterday. The bodies, wrapped in red flags, were kept on a platform as the relatives of the victims sat wailing nearby.
    The activists ended their protest after the chief minister announced compensation of Rs five lakh for the kin of the dead and said they would be given a government job, a house and three acres of land. The protestors then allowed the bodies to be taken for an autopsy.

    There is tension in Khammam in Andhra Pradesh a day after six people were killed in police firing when a protest by CPM activists for land reform turned violent.Victims' families are refusing to cremate the bodies of those killed till action is taken against the concerned police officials.
    The state government has announced Rs 5 lakh as compensation for the families of those who died. The government has also announced Rs 50,000 as compensation for the injured.
    Land agitation
    On Saturday, a three-month-old land agitation turned violent after a mob attacked the jeep of an Additional Superintendent of Police.
    Security officials say there was a significant presence of Naxalites in the area last afternoon, which led to escalation of violence.
    Khammam is a stronghold of Left parties, including CPI and the CPI(M).
    CPI(M) leader Sitaram Yechury and opposition leader Chandrababu Naidu are expected to visit Khammam on Sunday.
    Chief Minister YSR Reddy has ordered a judicial inquiry into the incident.
    On Saturday, Congress President Sonia Gandhi had asked the Andhra chief minister to submit a report on the firing incident.
    The firing at a mob of Left activists at Mudigonda village yesterday during a state-wide bandh to press for the distribution of land among the poor triggered a political storm, with the entire opposition condemning the incident.
    TDP President and former Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu and CPI(M) Polit Bureau member Sitaram Yechuri said the chief minister should immediately step down, owning moral responsibility for the "killing of innocent protestors".
    Senior CPI leader Gurudas Dasgupta, who visited Khammam with Yechuri, termed the deaths as a "case of ghastly murder" and said it would have "far-reaching repercussions at the national level". Naidu and Telangana Rashtra Samiti chief K Chandrashekhar Rao too visited Mudigonda and Khammam.
    The state government has ordered a judicial probe into the firing, transferred Khammam's Superintendent of Police R K Meena and suspended Additional SP Ramesh Babu and two other officers.
    Chief Minister Reddy appealed to the Left parties to call off their three-month-old protest for the distribution of land to the poor as his government was already implementing a programme for this.
    Left activists who staged the sit-in for over 20 hours in Khammam, however, demanded that a case should be filed against police personnel responsible for the firing.
    Emotions ran high as the protestors shouted slogans against the government. Opposition leaders including Naidu and TRS chief Chandrasekhar Rao, who visited the site of the protest, expressed solidarity with the demonstrators.
    Naidu said the TDP would give Rs 1 lakh to the family of the victims and provide free education to their children.
    In Hyderabad, the Left parties and TDP organised a rally to protest the firing. Leaders who addressed the rally demanded the chief minister's resignation.
    Yechuri said the chief minister "is trying to suppress a peaceful movement for land reforms". The Left parties would continue their land struggle, he said.
    The CPI's Dasgupta said: "We will raise the issue in the coming session of Parliament. The Congress government here cannot get away with a fascist approach towards a peaceful movement for land reforms."
    Yesterday's violence-marred bandh came a day after talks between the government and representatives of Left parties failed to break the impasse over the distribution of land to the poor. The Left parties have been insisting on the setting up of an autonomous commission to monitor the land distribution.

    Development policy flawed, says Patkar
    While blasting the state for its industrialist-friendly policies, social activist Medha Patkar dared the government with another ‘freedom struggle’. Patkar, who on Monday led a protest against the displacement of the poor due to misplaced ‘development’ policies like the formation of Special Economic Zones in Maharashtra, alleged that while the government’s was favouring big names in the industrial sector, it was least bothered about the displacement it was causing.
    Patkar was forced to hold the meeting at the starting point of the rally — Sandhurst Road near Dongri — when the protestors, including hundreds of displaced hawkers, peasants, labourers, Project Affected Persons (PAPs) and civil liberty groups from various parts of the state, were stopped by the city police in their steps.
    Speaking at Azad Maidan,Mumbai, Patkar pointed out that development and displacement are the two sides of the same coin. “To displace people from their livelihood by evicting the urban poor from their homes, taking away fertile lands of farmers and tribals, depriving fishermen from fishing are some of the grave issues of misplaced development plaguing the country,” Patkar said.
    Upping the ante against the ill-planned development, Patkar demanded a true and just development of all people. “Our leaders should stop uprooting and displacing poor and working class people from their livelihoods in the name of development,” she said.
    Simpreet Singh, an activist, said “We oppose the Maharashtra government’s decision to repeal the Urban Land and Ceiling Act, as it will further help the interests of the builder lobby and a few elite people.”
    “On the contrary, the state government should implement ULCA to buy or seize surplus lands and re-distribute the same among displaced people after asking them to form societies,” she added.
    The protestors also decided to submit a memorandum to CM Vilasrao Deshmukh and Deputy CM R R Patil, demanding immediate revoking of the SEZ Act, cessation to demolition of slums and illegal encroachment of land by builders.

    Jairam pep talk on Singur
    KOLKATA: “Singur will be the catalyst of industrial revival in eastern India,” Mr Jairam Ramesh, Union minister of state for commerce said today. The restriction on foreign direct investment from Bangladesh would be lifted on a case by case basis this year, he earlier told reporters during the day after the AGM of the Indian Tea Association.
    “I know this is a controversial statement, but I am known to stir up controversies,” he said. SNS
    DLF launches its first IT SEZ in Gujarat

    DLF Ltd has launched its first IT SEZ at Gandhinagar. This is its first commercial venture in Gujarat. This will be followed by projects in other cities in Gujarat. The SEZ will have state of the art, world-class facilities.
    Speaking about DLF’s entry in Gujarat, its spokesperson said that after successfully launching our first IT SEZ complex in Gujarat, we propose to launch IT SEZ in Ahmedabad with 3.5 million sq.ft in next 3-4 months. We are aspiring to set up townships in all the major cities of Gujarat including Ahmedabad, Baroda and Surat.
    We are also planning to participate in development of International Convention Centre in Ahmedabad, development of modern state-of-the-art Bus Stand in various cities. Beside this, DLF would also like to get involved in the development of Japanese’s City and Sabarmati River Front Development”.
    The IT space is spread over 25 acres and offers 2.5 million sq ft of developed workspace, is all set to revolutionize IT workspace in Gujarat. It is a ready-built IT workspace to offer unmatched scalable advantages.
    This SEZ project at an estimated cost of Rs.850 crores will be developed over two phases. The first phase is expected to be operational in next 15 months and being an IT SEZ, it would cater to all the international and national IT/ ITES companies. The project can generate jobs for 30,000 direct and indirectly.
    Tin-pot riot squad brings tears to top cops’ eyes
    Rajib Chatterjee
    KOLKATA, July 27: The recent agitation in Singur, which saw farmers retaliating even after teargas shells and rubber bullets were fired upon them, may not only be because of their undaunted spirit. Senior police officers have found out the reason, that a large number of police personnel do not have the required skill to use these non-lethal weapons and disperse mob.
    The state has in the past year, witnessed many agitations, at times violent ones, particularly in Nandigram and Singur. Investigating the reasons behind the failure of police to disperse the mob, officers found out that a large number of police personnel, some aged above 45, don't know the "right technique" to use non-lethal weapons such as teargas shells and rubber bullets, often used to quell mob and restore normality. Some of the policemen have not held such a weapon in the past three years.
    "Most policemen don't know the number of teargas shells needs to be fired to restore normality in an area. They are also unaware of the distance between the policemen and mob that needs to be maintained while firing teargas shells," Mr RK Majumdar, director general and inspector general of state armed police, said. Now, it has been decided that such police personnel would be sent for retraining. Senior police officers have been asked to prepare a list of policemen who require training regarding effective use of non-lethal weapons.
    "Policemen have started receiving training on effective use of teargas shells at the Barrackpore armed police brigade.
    “Instruction has been issued to district police authorities to prepare a list of those willing to enlist for the training," Mr Majumdar said. The state home department has also sent a team to the Mob Dispersal Training Academy of the Central Industrial Security Force at Coimbatore recently. Now, they will in turn impart training to their colleagues on effective use of teargas shells and rubber bullets. It has been decided that a separate mob disposal squad will be set up in each district in future.
    Three batches of police personnel from North and South 24-Parganas have been trained in Barrackpore.
    http://www.thestatesman.net/page.news.php?clid=6&theme=&usrsess=1&id=164298
    Tata Steel TN project faces opposition

    CHENNAI: Tata Steel's move to set up a titanium dioxide plant in Tamil Nadu faces criticism from opposition parties barely a month after the company entered into an agreement with the state government for the second time.
    On Sunday, AIADMK leader J. Jayalalitha threatened to demonstrate against the project.
    Last month, the Tatas had announced that they would set up the plant to make titanium dioxide - used as a base for paints - from ilmenite, mined from the beach sands of Tuticorin and Tirunelveli districts in southern Tamil Nadu.
    Former MP and actor R. Sarath Kumar, who is planning to launch a political outfit soon, has set up a "fact-finding team" to investigate the sale of land to the Tatas in 50 villages in Sathankulam, Radhapuram and Tiruchendur areas of the district.
    PMK chief S. Ramadoss said, "Ilmenite should not be a private property and the government should itself set up the plant instead of giving it to a private party like the Tatas.
    "When the government is finding it tough to set up desalination plants in Tamil Nadu, the Tatas' talk of desalination plant, reclamation of land and agro-based employment is simply unbelievable," Ramadoss said.
    The plant, entailing an investment of Rs.25 billion, will have a capacity to mine 500,000 tonnes of ilmenite and make 100,000 tonnes of titanium dioxide a year.
    India imports about 70,000 tonnes of titanium dioxide every year.
    Political outfits are alarmed that huge chunks of Tamil Nadu's southern beaches will go to private hands as the project needs a huge area of land - for every 100 tonnes of sand mined for ilmenite, 90 tonnes of sand will go waste.
    Tata Steel had first signed a memorandum of understanding with the Jayalalitha government in 2002, but the project failed to take off.
    The AIADMK now alleges that the ruling DMK is acquiring land from farmers in Santhankulam taluk at very low prices and the Tata project "would affect the livelihood of around 20,000 families".
    "Moreover, Karunanidhi has created an impression among farmers that as many as 1,000 people would get direct employment and indirect employment for 3,000 in the proposed plant," she said.
    "The AIADMK party condemns the DMK government's initiative in acquiring land indiscriminately from poor farmers to hand it over to entrepreneurs."
    Ramadoss said, "It is simply shocking to learn that the government would acquire 10,600 acres of land for the Tatas".
    He warned Tata's Tamil Nadu plans would soon turn into another Singur - the town near Kolkata where a project of another Tata firm, Tata Motors, has been facing violent protests.

    Mainstream, VOL XLV, No 32
    Culpable Derelection of Duty by Police Officers
    by D. Bandyopadhyay
    Sunday 29 July 2007
    http://www.mainstreamweekly.net/article250.html

    constituencies of Chitrakut district. In addition Dadua’s brother contested from a constituency of Pratapgarh district on the SP ticket. The mother of Thokia dacoit Piyariya Devi contested on the Rashtriya Lok Dal ticket from Naraini (Banda). All this poses a serious danger to the basic tenets of democracy. How can we expect the true voice of people to emerge when voters are pressurised increasingly by the threats of dacoits and how can we expect corruption to be curbed when the utilisation of development funds in a panchayat starts with paying a share to the dacoit gang? Clearly the dacoit menance has to be brought to the centre-stage of protecting democracy in areas like Chitrakut. In the legends of the Ramayana, it is Lord Rama who provided protection to villagers threatened by monsters. In modern times, helpless people are still waiting for a protector. n
    It is quite heartening that after some initial delay the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is proceeding with the investigation of the Tapasi Malik rape-and-murder case with expedition and dexterity. They are showing their professionalism for which they have made a name for themselves.
    Delay undoubtedly hampered the quality and speed of investigation because many of the important clues and vital evidence must have been lost or deliberately suppressed or concealed due to both the efflux of time and interference by interested persons and groups.
    It was the duty of the State Police to do what the CBI is doing now. They were on the spot immediately after the event when much of the evidence now lost or not easily retrievable could have been easily gathered and the culprits could have been arrested pending further investigation.
    It is now clear that this rape and murder was not a crime of passion. It was a deliberate act of the party in power and its local leaders to send a clear message to the agitating farmers and their family members to desist from such “anti-party” activities.
    The day before she was murdered, Tapasi appeared on the rostrum at Kolkata’s Chowringhee where Ms Mamata Banerjee was on an indefinite hunger-strike. As Tapasi was a leading figure of the anti-land acquisition movement at Singur she was publicly lauded for her courage and leadership. Hence she was made the ta

  • title-2721712

    Betrayal By Orissa Government and Destined Environmental disaster Immediate task should be surveys to point out the submergence are a village to village in Dantewara and Malkangiri Palash Biswas Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551 Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com Changing Currents was Earth Report's countdown to the 3rd World Water Forum (Kyoto, Japan, 16-23 March 2003). Dam Dam Dam Big dams. Love them or hate them, we have to live with them. Environmental campaigners contend that vast schemes such as the Three Gorges in China or the Narmada in India, are social and environmental catastrophes in the making. But their backers have a different view. Big dams can provide non-polluting energy and control flooding. In the run up to the World Water Forum, Earth Report presents the case for and against big dams. We travel to China and India to examine two of the most contentious dams presently being built, and we visit Norway where the economy is almost entirely based on hydropower. http://www.tve.org/cc/doc.cfm?aid=932 Floods are the most destructive, most frequent and most costly natural disasters on Earth. And they're getting worse. Large parts of central and western England are underwater in the worst flooding in 60 years. Insurers estimate the damage could reach $6 billion -- on top of the $3 billion in flood losses suffered in northern England in June. Over the past two months, the monsoon season in Bangladesh, China, India and Pakistan has, conservatively, claimed hundreds of lives. Texas has suffered major flood damage, as have Nebraska, Oklahoma, Kansas, Missouri and North Carolina. Although California's primary water worry right now is drought, increasingly serious floods lie in store for us, too. Flood damages have soared around the world in recent decades for a variety of reasons. Global warming is worsening storms; we've deforested and paved over watersheds; and more people are living and working on floodplains (there are few better examples of this than the fast-sprawling cities of California's Central Valley). But a key factor behind the spiraling flood damages is the very flood-control measures supposed to protect us. Flood damages soar when engineering projects reduce the capacity of river channels, block natural drainage, increase the speed of floodwaters and cause the subsidence of deltas and coastal erosion. In addition, "hard path" flood control based on dams and levees can ruin the ecological health of rivers and estuaries. http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2007/07/29/EDG3IQ8JRI1.DTL Dear Bharat Ji and friends! I have talked you to shift the agitation epicentre in Malkangiri and dantewara on telephone. I have talked to Orissa and bengal leaders. Since the people in Orissa and Chhatishgargh are quite unaware of the danger ahead and despite official objection the state governments do not help them anyway. The state machinery is avoiding to workout the survey and hearings to measure the impact, direct or indirect, it is nothing but betrayal to the people of the respective states.You may not involve the people or mobilising them unless you clarify the facts. Unfortunately enough facts are not available concerning Malkangiri and Dantewara. But simple logic may put forward the level of danger ahead. The catchment areas have to be submerged and the damage have to be extensive as we have seen in cases of Tehri Dam, Rihand Dam, Bhakhra Nangal dam, Narmada dam and Sardar Sarovar. We know the destined calamity but we may not project it to our people, this the basic problem of any mass movement. And the misinformation campaign overlaps our concern and endevours. Anti Polavaram Dam Agitation is centred around Khammam and east Godavari districts of Andhra only despite the fact that the project woud cause extensive damage to resettled Bengali refugees, Dalits and tribals in Chhattishgargh and Orissa. The Dandakaranya Project touches the borders of Maharashtra ,too. Thus, the role of respective state governments are not transparent anyway. This is a violation of RTI act. Medha patkar is quite a vetern in mass mobilastion against anti people River and water management. She has neglected the Orisssa and Chhattishgargh factors. More over link Krishna Godavri project implications are not highlighted properly. Which may have adverse impact on other southern states also. I believe, the activists involved have greater tasks ahead. It needs proper homework to resist the State Power and Brahminical Set up. I am afaid, the anti Polavarm dam agitation lacks momentum on these points. Immediate task should be surveys to point out the submergence are a village to village in Dantewara and Malkangiri. Public hearing should be arranged in every effected village. I believe that it is going a big agitation. Perhaps bigger than Narmada bachao Andolan! Palash Bharath to me Dear Palashda & friends Met Shridamda and Ujawalda. Discussed the issue of Polavaram damn displacement from different dimensions of the problem that adivasis and dalits are going to suffer from displacement and post displacement that is going to be a disaster in Eastern Ghats The sheet of reservoir on the bed of displacement of more than three hundred villages in three states of Dandakaranya is a problem with several implications Social and political unrest as a consequence of displacement and ecological destruction in the region is going to be manifold Problem in Orissa is not just 13 settlements with around 3000 aces of land at +150 ft RL. And it is not a question of mere consultation of AP government with neighbouring states It is a problem much higher in magnitude of implications due to direct displacement and also indirect implications. Real magnitude of displacement in Orissa and Chattisgarh is not known yet known. It will be much higher like in Andhra Pradesh where the government revised its displacement figures from 250 villages to 276 (officially admitted) after the field studies have pointed out that AP Govt data is all baseless fiction Similarly it will go up from 13 to many villages in Orissa also Besides, the whole issue is currently debated at +150 ft RL. While there is also problem of +175 ft for which the AP government has agreed to give compensation for frequent damages due to floods and backwater effect. thus the number of villages affected by displacement and backwaters is going to be high. and that is totally ignored currently the problem of displaced adivasis and vulnerable communities in tens of thousands moving helterskelter will being havoc in the entire region adjoining the submerged villages. they do not see the boundaries of forests or the states. so called unaffected villages in the proximity of the submerged villages will pay heavily because of this. it will be social, political and ecological disaster. Bengali settlements in Orissa will face the fallout, so is the the region up to Sukma in Dantewada of Chattisgarh and Bhadrachalam town and surrounding areas of Polavaram and Devipatnam mandals in Andhra Pradesh. threatened villages are not accepting the government rehabilitation. even if the government succeeds in forcibly evicting them or luring them with compensations the villagers are finally going to live further up in the hills by axing the forest. already the threatened villagers have put up their village name boards to 'reserve' a patch of the forest. newspapers have reported of the earmarking villagers have done in the neighbouring forest region. one needs to realise these aspects of the problem and also press for action in the light if this reality. not just the official data of 13 settlements in Motu block Shridamda plans to visit Malkangiri shortly will keep you informed of the progress bharath See these references: References http://www.iimcal.ac.in/programs/FPM/DataFile.asp?FileID=6 India: Peaceful Demonstrators Against the Narmada Dam Project Arrested, Beaten, and Intimidated by Police.?? The Sierra Club: Human Rights Campaigns.? 1999. ?Medha Patkar.?? The Goldman Environmental Prize.? 1992. Narmada River page.? International Rivers Network.? 1996-2000. Roy, Arundhati.? The Cost of Living.? New York: Random House, Inc.? 1999. ?The Sardar Sarovar: A Brief Introduction.?? Friends of the River Narmada.? 2000. Shruti Mukthyar.? ?Alternatives.?? Friends of the River Narmada.? U of Wisconsin-Madison: Institute for Environmental Studies.? 2000.? Large dams power India`s growth story Sapna Dogra Singh / New Delhi July 25, 2007 http://www.business-standard.com/economy/storypage.php?leftnm=3&subLeft=1&chklogin=N&autono=292202&tab=r Despite the controversies surrounding large dams, the government is betting on a host of such mega projects to meet the country?s power generation needs. As part of the strategy, it is working on what will be the biggest dam in the country ? the 3,000-Mw Debang multi-purpose project on the Debang river in Arunachal Pradesh. Multipurpose dams serve two purposes ? power and irrigation. The Debang project will benefit the entire North-East and the eastern regions. ?The detailed project report has been prepared and is awaiting techno-economic clearance by the Central Electricity Authority,? said an official of the authority. Being developed by the Arunachal Pradesh government and the National Hydro Power Corporation (NHPC), the project is likely to be commissioned in the Twelfth Five-Year Plan (2012-17). The displacement of people due to the project was ?marginal? and so it was unlikely to face much opposition, said officials working on the project. Power planners say dams have been good for the country. An example is the Bhakra Nangal dam, which irrigates Rajasthan, Haryana and Punjab, and provided water for the Green Revolution. A multi-purpose project on the Satluj river, this 1,326-Mw dam will soon add a capacity of 90 Mw. According to an official of the Bhakra Beas Management Board, the dam produced 440 million units of electricity in June to meet the demand for paddy crop. During non-monsoon months, the production is 275-300 million units. Last year (April 2006-March 2007), the production was 5,382 million units. In Maharashtra, the Koyna dam, which has the country?s first underground power house, supplies water to western Maharashtra and power to the neighbouring areas. Completed in 1963, the 1,920-Mw project is one of the largest civil engineering projects commissioned after India?s independence. The Koyna electricity project is run by the Maharashtra State Electricity Board. Most generators are located in excavated caves a kilometre deep inside the surrounding hills. The 1,000-Mw Tehri dam in Uttarakhand became fully operational this year. By 2011, another 1,000 Mw will be added. Simultaneously, many other dams are being upgraded. The Srisailam dam in Andhra Pradesh, for instance, will soon add another 900 Mw to its capacity of 770 Mw. The six river basins in the country have the potential to generate 150,000 Mw. However, so far, only 34,000 Mw has been tapped. The power ministry plans to add 16,553 Mw by 2012. According to an official of the Central Electricity Authority, the contracts for 16,000 Mw have been awarded. The government plans to add 30,000 Mw hydro capacity during the Twelfth Plan, 31,000 Mw during the Thirteenth Plan and 38,000 Mw during the Fourteenth Plan. More big projects like Debang might come up, said the official. By 2012, the country will see three new projects of 1,000 Mw and above. These are the Karcham Wantoo project (1,000 Mw) in Himachal Pradesh, the Tehri pump storage scheme of 1,000 Mw and the 2,000-Mw plant at Subansiri in Arunachal Pradesh. DEVELOPMENT-INDIA: Poor Pay Social Costs of Big Dams Without Gain, says Global Report By Meena Menon http://www.ips.org/socialforum/0122/devindia.htm MUMBAI, India, Oct 12 (IPS)- The hundreds of big dams built by India in the past half century have boosted national food and industrial production, but at a cost paid by the poorest, says a new study backed by both supporters and critics of multi-purpose river schemes. The survey was sponsored by the World Commission on Dams (WCD), which has been set up by governments, aid agencies, non-governmental organisations and anti-dam movements from across the world, to review the gains and losses from the world's 45,000 large dams. The India study is one of several country studies, which are helping prepare the WCD global report to be released in November. The India report, made available to IPS, has advised India to build big dams only if the benefits can be spread evenly among the people. The WCD is funded by industry, governments and aid agencies. It has held nine public hearings on six continents and listened to experiences of 120 people from 68 countries, regarding 1,000 dams. Although the Indian government did not permit a WCD hearing in the country two years ago, it subsequently became a member of the global forum. ''Large dams...must only be implemented if they also serve the cause of equitable distribution of resources, wealth and opportunities,'' says the India country report prepared by a team of Indian experts. According to the study, India's big dams have played an important role in increasing farm productivity, power generation and industrial water supply. However, they also had negative social and environmental effects, specially the eviction of a sizeable part of India's population from its ancestral home. India has more than 4,000 large dams of over 15 metres height as defined by the International Commission on Large Dams. Nearly two-thirds of the people displaced by multi-purpose river valley projects, are either tribals or members of the socially oppressed 'scheduled castes', who have the lowest incomes among the country's poor. These groups had to bear a disproportionate share of the social costs of big dams, considering that tribals and scheduled castes make just one-fourth of the Indian population, the report notes. The big dams have been specially harsh on indigenous people, who are less than a tenth of India's population, but made up nearly half of those displaced by the projects. ''There seems no justification for the imposition of costs on millions of innocent tribals and other rural people, who lose even the little they have in order to benefit those who already have more than them,'' says the report. The irrigation benefits of big dams are reaped by farmers and others in the command areas and the costs are borne by ''society at large, the taxpayers and the project affected people,'' it adds. The report estimates that on average, each big dam in the country has submerged nearly 5,000 hectares of forest. In the last 20 years, big dams are estimated to have swallowed up some 9.1 million hectares of India's forests. The study notes with concern that most of these schemes were not required to internalise the costs of preventing or minimising their harmful impact. It expresses greater worry over the Indian government's inability to enforce compliance with project conditions. Moreover, the process of environmental impact assessment (EIA) of big dams was subjected to political and administrative pressures, it says. ''Pressure is brought upon the professional project consultants to prepare EIAs in a manner such that the project is cleared,'' it says. India is estimated to have spent about 919 billion rupees (20 billion U.S. dollars) in the past 50 years on irrigation schemes. Most of these were linked to dams. However, India's big irrigation schemes have run up heavy financial losses, with annual operational losses of more than 30 billion rupees (680 million dollars) in 1993-94, the study estimates. The report also expresses worry that the safety aspect of big dams has been generally neglected by planners. ''In dam after dam, it has been observed that the required attention is not being paid to this very serious aspect of dam appraisal,'' it points out. Environmental clearance for big dams was made compulsory by the government 22 years ago, and ''that also more as a matter of policy than a statutory requirement.'' It became a statutory requirement only six years ago. More than 2,500 of the large Indian dams were begun before the year 1978. ''Consequently, for these 2500 plus large dams, no assessment was required to be done of their social and environmental costs or viability nor was there any attempt to prevent or minimise most of the adverse impacts,'' says the study. (END/IPS/ap-dv-en/mm/mu/00) September 18, 2003: Arundhati Roy discusses India's dams with host Mishal Husain. http://www.pbs.org/wnet/wideangle/shows/dammed/transcript.html Mishal Husain: Arundhati Roy, welcome to WIDE ANGLE. Arundhati Roy: Thank you. Mishal Husain: Now you've come to be very much identified with the issues that we've seen in the film. Why was it that you chose to get involved? Arundhati Roy: Because I think that the story of the Narmada Valley is the story of modern India -- and not just modern India, but the story of the powerful against the powerless and the whole world, really. And it isn't a story that works itself into the conventional divisions of the left and the right and the working class and the bourgeoisie and so on. It's a story that somehow is so complex that it involves the river, the ecology, the caste system in India, the class system, too. [It?] sort of a peg, or a keyhole, to use to open a very big lock, you know? I thought this was that story. And in 1999, when the Supreme Court lifted its stay on the construction of the dam after six and a half years, that decision was what pushed me into the valley. Because suddenly it appeared that this fight that we thought had been won -- the Bank had been pushed out, [which was] unprecedented in the history of the bank, and the six year stay given by the Supreme Court seemed to point in the direction of a victory -- and, suddenly, it was all reversed. Mishal Husain: The history of dams in India is a very long one. I mean, this is a well-established way that India's pursued development. Arundhati Roy: Absolutely. Dams are the temples of secular India and almost worshipped. I keep saying they are huge, wet cement flags that wave in our minds. They're the symbol of nationalism to many. And if there were an Olympics in dams, India would have a bronze. It's the third largest dam builder in the world; and perhaps the most committed because we have built 3,300 dams in the 50 years after independence. And today another 650 [are] under construction. Forty percent of all the big dams being built in the world are being built in India. And so there's this, until recently, unshaken faith in these completely obsolete things. But hopefully, the faith has been shaken a little. I don't know. Mishal Husain: But they've been a source of pride for successive Indian governments-- a symbol of achievement? Arundhati Roy: Well, certainly it started off that way. I think it would be unfair to say that in the late '40s and '50s, when Nehru was the champion of big dams, that it was a cynical enterprise because they really believed that these were going to be the solution to the famines and hunger in India. But the point is that 50 years down the line, they have proved otherwise. We have 3,300 big dams, but the drought prone and flood prone areas in the country have actually increased. And from being a dream, they've become a very cynical corrupt enterprise; a way of letting governments lay their hands on huge sums of money; a way of centralizing resources; a way of snatching rivers away from the poor and giving them to the rich. And so in a sense they've become monuments to corruption. Mishal Husain: But, obviously, there have been benefits because successive governments don't build over 3,000 dams unless at least some of the benefits are tangible. Arundhati Roy: You can argue that about anything. Colonialism didn't have benefits. Surely, it did. The issue is not that they don't have benefits. The issue is: who does it benefit and how sustainable are those benefits? And you see when a dam is built, forgetting about the issue of displacement, even ecologically, it takes many years for the destruction to set in. So in a place like Punjab, which was the cradle of the Green Revolution and really the heart, the rice bowl of India, today all those lands are getting waterlogged, salinized. They don't know what to do with the salt water. And that destruction, once it sets in, can't be reversed. Mishal Husain: Let's just talk for a moment about the area that we saw in the film, the Narmada Valley, an area you now know quite well. Describe to us what it's like from your perspective. Arundhati Roy: You mean aesthetically? Well, I guess, if you go soon after the monsoon, it's beautiful. It's like Scotland... misty and green and lush and idyllic in some way. And in the plains, perhaps the richest soil in Asia, where every kind of crop can grow. And so when you're there, you keep thinking the ideal had all been flooded, and you keep thinking of all that under water: all that life, all that culture, uninterrupted civilizations from, I don't know, the Paleolithic Age or something. All those temples, everything just gone, and for what? The argument is always posited as though you can either have irrigation and electricity because of dams or you can go back to the Stone Age, whereas that isn't what the NBA is saying. [They are] simply saying that there are better, more efficient, more sustainable ways of irrigation and producing electricity than these big dams. Mishal Husain: But what would you say to the argument that everyone has to start somewhere and the government is trying to do something pro-actively to meet these really pressing needs that India has? I mean, water is such a precious resource and India's demand for it is going to double in the next 20 years or so. Arundhati Roy: Precisely. And that's why the dams are the wrong thing. Just take the case of the Sardar Sarovar Dam. You know, of course it's been projected as the solution to the problem of Gujarat drought regions of Kutch and Sarashtra. If you actually look at the government's own plans, it's going to irrigate 1.6 percent of Kutch's agricultural land and 9 percent of Sarastra. The rest of it is going to already water rich areas where the big farmers grow sugar and so on. And what it has done over the years? This huge project? It has soaked up almost Gujarat's entire irrigation budget. And with that amount of money, using more local water harvesting schemes, you could have brought water to every single drought prone village in Gujarat. Mishal Husain: Do you think exactly the same potential benefits could have been met in other ways? Arundhati Roy: Not exactly the same. Ten times more. And the question is never asked about why are those areas drought prone? Why are they becoming increasingly more drought prone? Because of this completely random exploitation of ground water or because of the destruction of the mangrove forest as an ingress of salt water from the sea. There's no question asked about why environmentally destructive projects have been allowed to proceed. And you take the case of Gujarat. I think it has the second largest number of big dams in India, and still it's drought prone. Mishal Husain: Why then would the Indian government spend all of this money? After all, India is bearing the entire cost of this huge project alone after international donors pulled out. Why would it spend all this money if the benefits are as questionable as you say they are? Arundhati Roy: Because for one, a potential dam is more important politically than an actual dam. So when the Sardar Sarovar is coming up, in the election campaigns in Gujarat --of course until this Hindu fundamentalism became the chief issue -- the benefits of this dam are trumpeted. It's complete propaganda. But they?e told, it can serve you breakfast in bed, it will solve your daughter's wedding. The campaign makes it sound like some magical thing. Eventually when the dam is built, as the Bargi Dam was built, the benefits are never what they say they are. So a lot of it has to do with propaganda and people's unquestioning belief in big dams, which have never been questioned before. Why are they so terrified of the argument? They don't let it be made. The World Commission of Dams was threatened with arrest when it was going into Gujarat because they don't want to question it. They don't want to say maybe there's a different way of doing it. Mishal Husain: But these are tried and tested. I mean, for instance, the United States is water sufficient largely because of some dams over the years. The Hoover Dam is the most notable example. I mean, these are tried and tested ways that countries have become sufficient in water. This particular project might be flawed, but are you against the principle of dams, per se? Arundhati Roy: Yes, I am, actually, after much thought. And in America, if you ask Bruce Babbitt, they're blowing up big dams. They're decommissioning them. In California, there are huge problems because of dams. I'm against big dams, per se, because I think that they are economically unfeasible. They're ecologically unsustainable. And they're hugely undemocratic. And even if you look at America and look at India, they're two very different kinds of countries, you know? Of course when they built big dams in America, they dunked the American Indian into reservoirs. In India, you're talking about a kind of model of development that has displaced between 35 and 50 million people. On what basis can it be justified? We?e been talking about what big dams have done for India. In fact, there's not a single study done by the government that says that big dams are the reason that India is now food self-sufficient. Mishal Husain: No, but the government and-- there are other analyses that have been produced -- is that this particular dam will displace about 250,000 people. Now obviously that's a huge number, but the potential benefits will reach 40 million. Somewhere that arithmetic also works. Arundhati Roy: It doesn't, does it? I mean, isn't that a flawed argument when, firstly, the number of people it's going to displace is 400,000 because there's a very clever way in which they decide who is officially counted as project affected and who is not. And then if you posit the fact that it's going to benefit 40 million, first of all, if you read the essay I've written, you'll see how arbitrary that figure has been arrived at --A. B -- who are those 40 million people? It's absolutely untrue that this is going to be the case. But secondly, the assumption is that either you displace these 400,000 people and you bring water to 40 million or nothing. But what we're saying is that there are more sustainable ways of bringing water to those 40 million people. Mishal Husain: How would you do it? How would you meet India's water needs? Arundhati Roy: If you go to Gujarat today, you'll see that in Gujarat, there are villages who now know that this rhetoric about the Sardar Sarovar and Narmada water's coming is simply untrue. And you see the fantastic ways in which local water harvesting schemes have really been producing two and three crops a year in areas which we've been told are drought prone. page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 continue to next page Large Dams In India -- Temples Or Burial Grounds? By Angana Chatterji and Robert Jensen 22 September, 2004 Zmag How do we measure progress? How are lives improved by progress? Who benefits from -- and who suffers the consequences of -- progress? These are central questions today as nation-states and corporations pursue what are typically called "development" projects. One of the most controversial of these in recent years is a series of more than 3,000 dams in India?s Narmada River Valley. Government officials say these dams and an extensive irrigation system will bring electricity and water to areas of the country suffering from drought, and the technocrats insist that it will work. But other voices challenge this rhetoric of technological triumph, most notably the Narmada Bachao Andolan (Save the Narmada Movement). Arguing that the government exaggerates the benefits and underestimates the costs, this nonviolent people?s movement since the mid-1980s has focused attention on the human suffering and environmental damage that comes with "big dams." These dams flood vast areas and displace hundreds of thousands, mostly peasants and adivasi (tribal) people, while promises of relocation and resources usually prove to be illusory. Just one of the dams, Sardar Sarovar, could uproot as many as a half-million people. In August 2004, Angana Chatterji was one of three members of an independent commission who went to the Narmada, visiting villages and listening to more than 1,400 people at hearings. The commission investigated violations in resettlement and rehabilitation policies connected to the Narmada Sagar, one of the Narmada dams. Chatterji, N.C. Saxena (a member of the Indian government?s National Advisory Council and former secretary of the Planning Commission of India), and Harsh Mander (former director of ActionAid India) will submit their report this fall to the National Advisory Council, headed by Congress Party leader Sonia Gandhi. Chatterji, a Calcutta-born anthropology professor at the California Institute of Integral Studies in San Francisco, described the situation in the Narmada Valley as desperate and cited one villager?s statement to sum up the sense of despair: "There is no future here; we are living out our days, focused on survival. The Narmada gave us life; they have turned her against us." Despite the setbacks, Chatterji not only continues but intensifies her advocacy work through her association with the Narmada Bachao Andolan and groups such as the U.S.-based International Rivers Network (http://www.irn.org/), for which she is a board member. Chatterji is passionate and sharp-tongued, with an ability to bring the complex issues into clear, and sometimes painful, focus. In a play on an often-quoted comment of India?s first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, Chatterji began our conversation by saying, "Dams are not the temples of India. They are her burial grounds." In an interview in September, she explained why the Narmada struggle remains crucial. http://www.countercurrents.org/en-jensen220904.htm India?s Greatest Planned Environmental Disaster: The Narmada Valley Dam Projects http://www.umich.edu/~snre492/Jones/narmada.html The Narmada Valley Development Project is the single largest river development scheme in India.? It is one of the largest hydroelectric projects in the world and will displace approximately 1.5 million people from their land in three states (Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Madhya Pradesh).? The environmental costs of such a project, which involves the construction of more than 3,000 large and small dams, are immense.? The project will devastate human lives and biodiversity by inundating thousands of acres of forests and agricultural land.? ?The State? (India) wants to build these dams on the Narmada River in the name of National Development.? But ?How can you measure progress if you don?t know what it costs and who has paid for it?? (Roy 16).? Each monsoon season thousands of people are told by the Indian government that they will have to be relocated as their ancestral lands are flooded out.? ?The people whose lives were going to be devastated were neither informed nor consulted nor heard? (Roy 26).? A disproportionate number of those being displaced are tribal people: Adivasis and Dalits. Damming the Narmada River will degrade the fertile agricultural soils due to continuous irrigation (rather the seasonal irrigation which is dependent on the monsoon), and salinization, making the soil toxic to many plant species.? The largest of the dams under construction is the Sardar Sarovar, which, if completed, will flood more than 37,000 hectares of forest and agricultural land, displacing more than half a million people and destroying some of India?s most fertile land. The thing about multipurpose dams like the Sardar S
  • Left parties Have Failed to Defend Tribals and Refugees Facing Polavarm Submergence!

    Left parties Have Failed to Defend Tribals and Refugees Facing Polavarm Submergence!

    Would the Intellegentsia Kolkata, Mahashweta Devi and Sanhati Udyog clear their satnd ?
    Would Mamta Bannerjee speak out to defend the partition Victim dalit Refugees?

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Would the Intellegentsia Kolkata, Mahashweta Devi and Sanhati Udyog clear their satnd on Polavaram dam?
    I am waiting!
    Police lathicharge on protestors in Khammam district of Andhra Pradesh has left eight people dead and several others injured on Saturday.The incident took place when police opened fire on protestors who were demanding land reforms in the district.The bloodshed could prove costly for YS Rajasekhara Reddy's government in the state.However,Chief Minister Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy announced a judicial probe into the police firing on communist parties' agitation seeking land for the poor.
    Since May, Left parties have led the landless poor to forcibly occupy vacant lands all over the state. It culminated in a hunger-strike this week and Saturday's protest bandh in the state.
    But the Left parties have failed to defend Tribals and Refugees facing Polavarm Submergence! The protest turned violent in Modugonda village in Khammam district where police opened fire to quell a stone pelting group in which six activists were killed and several others injured. coincidentally, Anti Polavarm agitation has got its epicentre in Khammam itself. But left does not care for the declining dalits and tribals. they want only political milage and want a better image after Nandigram singur episode. Nothing else!

    Meanwhile, UPA Chairperson Sonia Gandhi has asked Chief Minister YSR Reddy for a report on the police firing.
    The CM has transferred the district police chief and suspended the additional SP. A judicial probe has also been ordered into the incident.
    ''The police were overpowered and pushed around. Without provocation, they (protestors) pelted stones at the police,'' Reddy said.
    Dear Palash Babu,
    I have tried to understand the suject mentioned above.
    It is seen that the polavaram-vijaywara canal project
    is going to uproot 250 villages and about 2 lakhs of
    people will become shelterless. I am very much worried
    and feel agony that about twenty thousand kutcha
    houses fall within the zone and it is a fact that the
    owner of those houses are the people of dalit and
    tribal communities. It needs agitative protest from
    all corner all over India to safeguard their
    displacement. Sharing your thought and endeavour to be
    beside the Dandakaranya (Malkangiri in Orissa and
    Bastar in Chattishgarh)refugees particularly the
    namasudras who will become refugee once again.
    -----Manohar Mouli Biswas
    General Secretary, Bangla Dalit Sahitya Sanstha
    Manohar Biswas
    651 V.I.P nagar.
    Gouranga Palli.
    Kolkata 700100
    Tel # : (033) 23451294
    Cellular : +919433390044
    thanks!
    Manohar Babu!
    We want a initiative right from you.
    Mamata slams CPI(M) government over Nandigram
    Bolpur: Trinamool Congress supremo Mamata Banerjee today came down heavily on the Left Front government over the Nandigram issue.Addressing a rally at Nannur near here, Ms Banerjee alleged that appropriate punishment had not been meted out to the responsible for the Nandigram massacre.
    '' The Left Front government is giving false assurances to the poor farmers that they would be given employment in the Tata factory. All the claims of the government about making West Bengal an industrialised and prosperous state are hollow, '' Ms Banerjee said.
    She stated that the farmers would not be able to get justice unless the CPI(M) was ousted from power.
    Well, Mamata Bannerjee also habitual to quote Dandakarny Refugees and Marichjhanpi Genocide! Would she speak out to defend the partition Victim dalit Refugees?

    Maoist bandh hits life in Malkangiri, PTI reports.
    Normal life was affected in some interior areas of Malkangiri district following a bandh call by the CPI(Maoist) in protest against alleged police repression on people, corruption and in memory of 'martyrs' killed in encounters with the police.
    Mind you, Motu Tehsil has to be submerged by Polavaram and the bandh had its maximum impact in the Motu tehsil where traffic had come to a standstill and shops and business establishments closed, reports from the interiors said. The large weekly market held at Kalimela on Thursdays also had thin attendance. It was also heavily raining in the area, the reports said.
    CPM, BUPC men clash in Nandigram
    Statesman News Service
    HALDIA, July 27: Fighting broke out in Nandigram along the Talpati canal this afternoon when CPI-M cadres and supporters of Bhumi Uched Pratirodh Committee opened fire and hurled bombs at each other. BUPC members alleged that CPI-M cadres attacked them from the other side of the canal when they were marching in a rally to the Tekhali bridge. However, nobody was injured. The protesters, too, reportedly responded with bricks and bombs. The violence was primarily concentrated in Gokulnagar, Maheshpur and Parulbari. Women protesters have threatened to gherao Nandigram police station on Wednesday.
    Meanwhile, the state government resumed peace process in Nandigram today. “The chief minister informed us that peace process will resume from today. All parties will be part of it. We are concerned about Nandigram. It can’t be allowed to remain a no man’s land forever”, former chief minister Mr Jyoti Basu said today in Kolkata. n SNS

    Intellegentsia Bengal is posing as great sympathiser of the Peasants Uprising in Singur and Nandigram. But except Mr Sunanda Sanyal none of them was seen present during No SEZ National convention. Rashida B and Bhopal gas Tragedy victims, Arundhati ray, Medha Patekar and NBA along with mass organisations countrywide and delegates from abroad participated in this convention held on 2nd and 3rd June, 2007. Muslims and dalits participated in this convention on large scale. Afraid of Dalit Muslim United Insurrection, two arch rivals of West Bengal Geopolitics and both representing the brahminical Ruling Class met next day!
    Would Mahashweta Devi who has written on Marichjhanpi Genocide so many times in her regular colum stand united those very Dandakaranya Refugees, the victims of Partitition Haolocaust as well as state sponsered Violence in Marichjhanpi who face another displacement and have to be evicted for Polavaram Dam?
    I am waiting for her writeup. I appreciate her and support all the causes she fights for. But I am disappointed when I she that she reluctantly refuses to write or say anything for Dalit Refugees. I know, she does not believe in Caste and rather believes in Class struggle! This is also a classical game of Brahmin dominated Marxist Ideologues and politicians in India!
    I would like to see what stand the Sanhati Udyog takes, too!
    Mind you, Polavaram Dam Project has to submerge Malkan Giri in Orissa and Dantewara in Chhattishgargh. Both the governments have opposed the project. Orissa Chief minister naveen Patnike, despite his drive for urbanisation and Industrialisation and Eviction Bengali speaking resettled refugees Drive, has come out openly to defend Malkangiri perhaps because not only Bengali Refugee colonies but tribal villages also have to be wiped out if the project goes on.
    Medha Patkar has centred her agitation basically in Andhra. Malkangiri and Dantewara people along Sharbari river do not know about submergence destiny! This is perhaps RTI effect. Orissa Government or Chhattishgargh Governments have not circulated any information. Thus, there is virtually no agitation in Malkangiri or Dantewara. No survey or public hearing is reported. would Medha Patkar go there?
    We know Mahashweta Devi`s lifelong fight for civil and human rights of Indian tribals. A whole tribe named Koya has to be wiped out. Tribal and refugee population of three Indian states face immediate danger to their life, liberty and livlihood. Benagli Refugees have to suffer most as they have no political support. Kolakta Media has not published a single report. I am sending daily updates. They have their own hifi Network. But they are not interested.

    What about the Marxists who have launched an agitation in Andhra already, but has failed to make an issue of Polavarm Project! Is it necessary to stay away from any agitation against so called development, to defend the inhuman acts of WB Government. Perhaps may be. Technically, they should come forward as Mr Naveen Patnaik also opposes the project. So does Mr Raman singh!
    CPM General Secretary Prakash Karat on Saturday condemned the police firing in Khammam district and said the party would stage dharnas all over the country in protest against it and press the Andhra Pradesh government to accede to their demand on land for the landless.
    "I strongly condemn the police firing and attitude of the Andhra Pradesh government," Karat told reporters here.
    Karat said when Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y S R Reddy met him in Delhi a month ago, he had suggested resolving of the issue pertaining to demand for land for the landless through negotiations with local left leaders.
    Instead, the Andhra Pradesh government has resorted to "police repression", he alleged. Casualties in the police firing is "highly unfortunate" and it`s regrettable that the situation has come to such a pass, he said.
    The shutdown threw normal life out of gear in Guntur, which witnessed peaceful protests.
    On the Chennai-Kolkata National Highway 5, vehicular traffic was obstructed for over an hour near Kakani village, a suburb of Guntur city.
    Traffic was allowed to move after 12 noon, Sub Inspector S Ravi said.
    Educational institutions, shops and financial institutions like banks remained closed in view of the shutdown.
    However, attendance in government offices was normal.
    SUCI demands fresh lists of abandoned CPI(M) activists in Nandigram
    Kolkata: The Socialist Unity Centre of India (SUCI) today demanded a fresh list of CPI (M) supporters, who lost their homes after the March 14 incident in Nandigram.
    The CPI(M) had claimed that thousands of their party activists were still homeless since the masscare that took place at Nandigram.
    However, SUCI state secretary Provash Ghosh told mediapersons that the CPI (M)'s claim was baseless.
    ''The ruling party should release a fresh list of their marooned party workers at Nandigram mentioning the camps they were taking shelter at,'' he said.
    He said, after the Haldia Municipality poll's victory, the CPI(M) 'miscreants' had started fresh violence in Nandigram.
    Veteran marxist leader Jyoti Basu yesterday said the efforts were on to resume peace talks in the troubled area but peace could not be resumed in the area if appropriate punishment were not given to those responsible for the Nandigram carnage.
    Haldia in pocket, the CPM would now be tough with the Opposition in nearby Nandigram, Jyoti Basu said today.
    “Efforts to restore normality in Nandigram had been suspended because of the municipal election. The process will be renewed from today,” the CPM patriarch said a day after the Trinamul Congress spurned Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee’s talks offer yet again.
    “Nandigram can’t be allowed to run as a liberated zone for long. We have won the Haldia poll, even in the areas close to Nandigram, after so many incidents in the zone,’’ Basu said after the weekly meeting of the CPM state secretariat at the party headquarters.
    He lashed out at the Opposition parties for their “opportunist alliance” in Haldia.
    Tension prevails ahead of "martyr day" , a Hindustan times Report:

    Tension prevails in the jungle areas of Gadchiroli, Chandrapur and Gondia districts, bordering Chhattisgarh, Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh over the week-long bandh call given by the banned naxalites outfit, CPI (Maoist) to commemorate its "martyr day", beginning from July 28.
    According to reports reaching Nagpur on Saturday, the naxalites have given the call ostensibly to commemorate the 35th death anniversary of their founder, Charu Majumder, who died in police custody in Kolkata on July 28, 1972. The state police are taking adequate precautions in view of the bandh and sounded a high alert in the naxalites-prone border districts.
    The Maoist rebels are determined to bring these districts, particularly the interior areas, to a complete standstill during the period. They are distributed pamphlets and leaflets in this regard and appealed to villagers to ensure its success. The police recovered 23 kg explosive from two different places. The naxalites had planted explosives with a view to trigger explosions and blow up vehicles and create terror in the area.
    The anti-naxalite squad in Gadchiroli was on way to patrolling Korchi area to thwart any attempt to disrupt peace when they discovered explosive plated on Bori route with the intention of blowing up passing vehicles. The police also recovered two detonators from the spot. Similarly, the patrolling party recovered 9 kg explosives near Jafrabad Hills in the district.
    Talking to Hindustan Times, the additional director general of police (ADGP), anti-naxal cell, Pankaj Gupta asserted that the police were also determined to scuttle any naxalite design. “A massive police bandobast has been made in all the affected districts. Moreover, police patrolling in all the sensitive areas have also been spruced up in view of possible violence,” Gupta further informed.
    Operation Munnar not wound up: Kerala CM

    Thiruvananthapuram: Refuting reports that the campaign against land encroachment at Munnar was wound up, Kerala Chief Minister V S Achuthanandan on Saturday said the operation at the hill station would continue till the area was freed from land-grabbers.
    "The Munnar campaign has only been suspended due to inclement weather following torrential rains and land-slips. It would be resumed in another two weeks when the weather becomes conducive for that," he said.
    The impression created by the media that the Munnar operations had been called off even prompted the Supreme Court to remark that it would be 'unfortunate' if the government had left it half-way, he said.
    Defending the removal of a sign board put up by Tatas in the area, he said the board was taken away as it stood on public land. After that the company itself had taken it away.
    The head of the task-force carrying out the Munnar eviction drive was now under treatment. In a fortnight the same team would be back in operation or a new team would be assigned, he said.
    The goal of the campaign was to save Munnar's ecosystem and natural beauty to make it a leading tourist spot. Also, part of the reclaimed land would be distributed to the landless, he said.
    On the dispute over Mullapperiyar dam with Tamil Nadu, Achuthanandan said Kerala was firm on building a new dam in place of the 110-year-old structure which posed a threat to 3.5 million people living downstream.
    Construction of the new dam was estimated to cost Rs 300 crore. A lion's portion of this amount would be met by the exchequer and the rest raised from the people, he said.
    Achuthanandan expressed strong resentment at the Railways' plans to inaugurate the Salem Division in September.
    This was against the assurance given by Railway Minister Lalu Prasad that any final decision would be taken only after consultations with Chief Ministers of Tamil Nadu and Kerala.
    The Centre's unilateral decision would mean that the Railway minister was going back on his assurance under pressure from Minister of State for Railways, R Velu, he said.
    Achuthanandan said a massive sanitation campaign would be launched across the state to tackle serious health threat posed by piling up of wastes.
    He said he would take personal initiative with regard to the drive which would be carried out with the participation of local bodies and all sections of people.
    The Legacy of the plight of Hindus in Bangladesh - Part-IX
    Thu, 2007-07-26 02:31
    By Rabindranath Trivedi - for Asian Tribune from Dhaka
    Part-IX: Genocide In Bangladesh By Pakistani army 1971
    Dakah, 26 July, (Asiantribune.com): Bangladesh was created after the India-Pakistan War of 1971, a conflict—elaborated in this report—that was preceded by the massacre of an estimated two million East Pakistani citizens and the ethnic cleansing of 10 million (mainly Hindus), who fled to India from that country. In the summary of his report dated November 1, 1971, US Senator Edward Kennedy (D - Massachusetts) wrote:
    Field reports to the U.S. Government, countless eye-witness journalistic accounts, reports of International agencies such as World Bank and additional information available to the subcommittee document the reign of terror which grips East Bengal (East Pakistan). Hardest hit have been members of the Hindu community who have been robbed of their lands and shops, systematically slaughtered, and in some places, painted with yellow patches marked ‘H’. All of this has been officially sanctioned, ordered and implemented under martial law from Islamabad.”
    "They (Hindus) come out of East Pakistan in endless columns, along trails stained with tears and blood. They are dressed in rags, robbed of everything they owned, the women raped, the children gaunt from hunger. They have been on the move for up to a month, hiding from Pakistani soldiers by day, slogging through flooded rice paddies at night. A vengeful army pursues them to the very border of India. Rifle and machine gun fire crackles.
    The bedraggled columns scatter for cover. But soon they are moving again, streaming into India. Sobbing violently, a middle-aged man says, “The soldiers took my two nephews. They kicked them with their boots, ducked them in an open sewer, then machine-gunned them. After that, they took 50 to 60 young men of our village into a field and killed them whit bayonets”.
    A woman who was shot in the leg clutches her daughter and says, “ We were just about to cross the border when they started shooting at us. I don’t know what happened to my husband”. A ten-year old boy, who lost an eye when an army patrol threw a grenade at him as he was ending cattle in a field, says, “ Can anyone tell me what happened to my parents ?”Since late last March in 1971, when the Pakistani army launched this genocidal attack on the defenseless population of East Pakistan, more than eight million people have been driven from their native land. Millions more will surely follow. Moreover, the refugees have put grave strains on India, pushing India and West Pakistan to the brink of a war that could involve the two arch rivals of the communist world, the Soviet Union and China, The Readers' Digest wrote in November 1971
    . ..While the horrors of the refugees are bad enough, something even more ghastly is going on inside East Pakistan, also known as East Bengal, Reader Digest added: An American missionary in Dacca grits his teeth and says, “ It’s murder - mass murder”. The military junta that Pakistan has tried to cover up the atrocities, and maintains that East Bengal has largely returned to normal. But one of the authors of this article, who spent two weeks there last August, found evidence to the country on every hand. Touring three districts of East Bengal by car, he found not a single village or town that had not suffered at the hands of the troops. Many towns were half-empty, homes and shops looted and burned, people either dead, driven into exile or hiding in the country side. Perhaps a third of Dacca’s population is gone; its economy is crippled and its people are so terrified that no one ventures outdoors at night. Not far from Dacca, a missionary said, “The soldiers killed 249 people in our village. Fortunately for the wounded, high-powered bullets tear right through them, so the doctors didn’t have to probe.” A farmer in a refugee camp along the Indian side of the border said, “The headmaster of our school was sitting on the veranda of his home, grading examination papers, when the soldiers dragged him out into the road and cut his throat.” Said another refugee, “The soldiers forced the doctor in our village to dig his own grave; then they shot him.” A doctor in a border hospital pointed to a woman who had been raped repeatedly by the troops in the presence of her four children after the soldiers had killed her husband
    “On the afternoon of March 25, Yahya, having broken off the talks with Mujib, returned to West Pakistan. At 11 O’ clock that evening, Tikka Khan was unleashed.Suddenly, all of Dacca rocked with explosions. Troops opened fire with artillery on the city; tanks rumbled throughout he streets, gunning down anything that moved. The dormitories of the university, a stronghold of Bengali nationalism, were riddled by machine-gun fire. The invading soldiers went on a rampage in the old city, a particular political stronghold of Mujib, breaking down doors, dragging people into the street and shooting them. Shops were looted and burned. the barracks of the pro-Mujib Bengali police were gutted by tank cannon. Troops burst into a telephone exchange and killed 40 persons on duty.Special West Pakistani army squads had lists of people-professors, doctors, businessmen and other community leaders - whom they dragged off to army headquarters. Most have never been seen again. Although Mujib’s followers urged him to go into hiding, Mujib refused. Tikka’s troops took him off to imprisonment and an uncertain fate in West Pakistan.With Dacca in ruins, Tikka sent his troops into the countryside, and in each town the ghastly pattern was repeated. Anyone associated with the Awami League was killed. Young men, Muslim and Hindu alike, were rounded up and murdered. In almost everytown, refugees report, women were raped.
    …The Indian government is making every effort to care for these piteous people, but the influx is so staggering that new miseries await them there. For instance, in one of more than a thousand squalid refugee camps in India, 150,000 people live in straw hovels surrounded by mud and filth. There are few latrines. and the stench is such that people cover their faces with cloth.
    Because of the vast numbers, refugees have to wait in line for as long as ten hours for their food rations - ¾ pound of rice a day per adult, plus some lentils, vegetables when available, and a little salt and cooking oil.The children suffer the most. Many are beginning to look like the starving children of Biafra, their ribs protruding, their stomachs distended. Almost all suffer from malnutrition or dysentery. Life-giving milk and other protein foods are available in some of the camps, but the rush is so great that many children never get any. A doctor at a border hospital says, “the children die so quickly that we don’t have time to treat them.” [ *Article by David Reed and John E. Frazer, Readers’ Digest, November, 1971. ] "
    The birth of Bangladesh in 1971 was a unique phenomenon- it was the first nation state to emerge after waging a successful liberation war against a post colonial state. The nine-month-long liberation war in Bangladesh drew world attention because of the genocide committed by Pakistan which resulted in the killings of approximately three million people and raping of nearly a quarter million girls and women. Ten million Bengalis reportedly took refuge in India to avoid the massacre of the Pakistan army and thirty million people were displaced within the country(Loshak,1971; Marcarenhas, 1971; Payne, 1973 ;Ayoob and Subramanyan, 1972; O’Donnell, 1984,Rounaq,2005,p.65)
    Eye Witness Accounts
    On the night of 25-26 March on the orders of General Yahya and the Pakistani ruling clique the Pak forces armed with mortars, cannons and recoilless guns attacked the citizen in their sleep.
    In an attempt to drown in blood and silence in terror the upsurge of Bengali Nationalism, the military junta of Yahya Khan unleashed the most barbaric war of extermination against the entire people of Bangladesh. In the wake of this war the occupation Pakistani Army indulged in an unparalleled orgy of wanton loot, rape, murder and destruction. It is these gruesome happenings which have been characterized by U Thant, the Secretary General of the United Nations, as “one of the most tragic episodes in human history” and as “ a very terrible blot in the page of human history.”
    Loren Jenkins of Newsweek, New York, was in Dhaka on March 25-26 and here is what he reported: “When the army decided to strike, it attacked without warning. Houses were machine-gunned at random. It was a blatant exercise in terror and vengeance, there can never be any excess for the sort of fire-power we saw and directed against unarmed civilians. There can be no excuse for the mescals burning of the shanty homes of some of the most impoverished people.” (April 12, 1971).
    On March 25, 1971, the Pakistan army launched Operation Searchlight to 'eliminate' the Awami League and its supporters in East Pakistan. The goal was to 'crush' the will of the Bengalis. The killing began shortly after 10 pm. In the first 48 hours the orgy of killing had ravaged Dhaka city.
    The Hindu population of Dhaka took the brunt of the slaughter. Dhaka University was targeted and Hindu students were gunned down. Mujib was arrested shortly after declaring Bangladesh independent. The rest of the Awami League leadership went into hiding and those that survived eventually fled to India. The genocide had just begun.
    On February 22, 1971 the generals in West Pakistan took a decision to crush the Awami League and its supporters. It was recognised from the first that a campaign of genocide would be necessary to eradicate the threat: 'Kill three million of them,' said President Yahya Khan at the February conference, 'and the rest will eat out of our hands.' (Robert Payne, Massacre [1972], page 50.)
    On March 25 the genocide was launched. The university in Dhaka was attacked and students exterminated in their hundreds. Death squads roamed the streets of Dhaka, killing some 7,000 people in a single night. It was only the beginning. Within a week, half the population of Dhaka had fled, and at least 30,000 people had been killed. Chittagong, too, had lost half its population.
    All over East Pakistan people were taking flight, and it was estimated that in April some 30 million people were wandering helplessly across East Pakistan to escape the grasp of the military. (Payne, Massacre, page 48.) Ten million refugees fled to India, overwhelming that country's resources and spurring the eventual Indian military intervention. (The population of Bangladesh/East Pakistan at the outbreak of the genocide was about 75 million.)
    But the will of the Bengali people was not broken on the night of March 25, 1971. On the contrary, while Dhaka burned, so did the illusion of a united Pakistan.
    Yahya Khan and the Pakistan army planned their genocide well. Yahya Khan aimed to crush the Bengali spirit once and for all. Before the crackdown all foreign journalists were expelled from East Pakistan. Only a handful managed to evade the Pakistani army.
    One of them was Simon Dring. On March 30, 1971 he filed a chilling report of the massacre that took place in Dhaka on the night of March 25. Dring reported that in 24 hours of killing, the Pakistan army slaughtered as many as 7,000 people in Dhaka and up to 15,000 people in all of Bangladesh.
    The Pakistan army employed tanks, artillery, mortars, bazookas and machine guns against the unarmed population of Dhaka. Their targets were students, local police, intellectuals, political leaders, Awami League supporters, Hindus and ordinary citizens. They carried out their ruthless killing spree with military precision.
    Dring described the attack on Dhaka University as follows:
    'Led by American-supplied M-24 World War II tanks, one column of troops sped to Dacca University shortly after midnight. Troops took over the British Council library and used it as a fire base from which to shell nearby dormitory areas.
    'Caught completely by surprise, some 200 students were killed in Iqbal Hall, headquarters of the militantly antigovernment students' union, I was told. Two days later, bodies were still smoldering in burnt-out rooms, others were scattered outside, more floated in a nearby lake, an art student lay sprawled across his easel.
    'Army patrols also razed nearby market area. Two days later, when it was possible to get out and see all this, some of the market's stall-owners were still lying as though asleep, their blankets pulled up over their shoulders.'
    The 'old town' quarter of Dhaka city was singled out for destruction by the Pakistanis because of strong Awami League support there and because there were many Hindu residents in the area. Here is how Simon Dring described the attacks on unarmed civilians:
    'The lead unit was followed by soldiers carrying cans of gasoline. Those who tried to escape were shot. Those who stayed were burnt alive. About 700 men, women and children died there that day between noon and 2 pm, I was told.
    'In the Hindu area of the old town, the soldiers reportedly made the people come out of their houses and shot them in groups. The area, too, was eventually razed.
    'The troops stayed on in force in the old city until about 11 pm on the night of Friday, March 26, driving around with local Bengali informers. The soldiers would fire a flare and the informer would point out the houses of Awami League supporters. The house would then be destroyed -- either with direct fire from tanks or recoilless rifles or with a can of gasoline, witnesses said.'
    After having massacred 15,000 unarmed civilians in a single day, the Pakistani soldiers bragged about their invincibility to Simon Dring:
    '"These bugger men," said one Punjabi lieutenant, "could not kill us if they tried."
    '"Things are much better now," said another officer. "Nobody can speak out or come out. If they do we will kill them -- they have spoken enough -- they are traitors, and we are not. We are fighting in the name of God and a united Pakistan."' In the name of God and a united Pakistan, genocide had just begun.
    Don Coggin, correspondent of Time, New York, reporting from Dacca wrote: “Before long, howitzer, tank, artillery and rocket blasts rocked half a dozen scattered sections of Dacca. Tracers arched over the darkened city. The staccato clatter of automatic weapons were punctuated with grenade explosions and tall columns of black smoke towered over the city. In the night came the occasional cry of ‘Joi Bangla’ (victory to Bengal) followed by a burst of machine gun fire” (Time, New York, April 5,1971).
    Saturday Review, edited by Norman Cousins, reported : “A machine gun was installed on the roof of the terminal building at Sadarghat, the dock area of old Dacca. On March 26, all civilians within range were fired upon. After the massacre, the bodies were dragged into buses, some were burned. Some were dumped into the Buriganga river, adjacent to the terminal,” (Saturday Review, May 22,1971).
    Quoting reports from British citizens who were evacuated from Dacca a few days after the start of the military operations, Guardian, London, April 5 wrote.
    Another British eyewitness account described how troops in Dacca shot nine professors, their families, and 21 students in one of the University resident buildings. Similar attacks were alleged to have taken place in three halls. At Tanti Bazar, troops surrounded the area and set fire to the bamboo and thatched houses in an area of a quarter of square mile where thousands lived. Women and children who attempted to flee were machine-gunned and bayoneted.
    “Two small Hindu villages on the infield of the Dhaka horse-racing tract (near the central district) were surrounded by the army and every man, woman and child was massacred. Three days later, a heap of bodies, three feet high, remained where they fell when they were machine-gunned.”
    Sanders, an Englishman, is an eye-witness to the ghastly rape of the Bengali girl students at the Rokeya Hall of the Dacca University. In an impassioned letter to the editor of the Blitz, Bombay (April 11), Sanders wrote: “April 2, 1971. It was around 5 p.m. when about 350 to 400 Pakistani troops attacked the hall. They entered all the rooms lodging the girls and dragged them out, tearing off their clothing one by one. The girls were pinned down to the floor, face upwards, leg mercilessly pulled apart and fully stretched then finally the brutal act of ramming. It was at this juncture that 50 brave girls jumped to their death from the hall

  • Most Needed is a Passport to Reach the Village!

    Most Needed is a Passport to Reach the Village!
    No one imagined disintegration of USSR even during first Gulf War!
    Deepening Strategic Partnership with India : Bush
    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com

    The question that remains is: how much of what happened to the USSR was going to happen anyway, and how much resulted from the efforts of President Reagan and hisadministration? Was it just coincidence that the closing years of the Soviet empire mirrored those of the most anti-Communist President in U.S. history? The purpose of this paper is to inquire as m to the specificity of President Reagan's plan to bring about the downfall of the Soviet Union and
    to discover if his policies constituted a new form of containment. This Study is germane to a complete understanding of the United State's part in the decline and fall of the Soviet Union and to the larger issues surrounding the appropriate application of national power to "contain" another nation's growth. I have chosen recent works by former U.S. government and administration officials, and journalists for my research. These sources represent the continuum of opinion that places President Reagan, on one end, as the mastermind behind the demise of the USSR and, on the other, as an ill-informed, passive by-stander. I have chosen these particular works in order to highlight current disagreements on President Reagan's rightful place and to offer a synthesis of
    these views. Additionally, I have supplemented these sources with interviews from Johnn enczowski, Peter Rodman and Angelo Codevilla -- all mid-level insiders during the Reagan years. Their perspectives, generally unbridled by concerns about attribution, assisted greatly in penetrating much of the myth about President Reagan and his administration.
    My line of inquiry will begin with an overview of U.S. containment policies (1947-- 1981) highlighting differences in President Reagan's approach to containing the Soviet Union. I will then offer case Studies of the top five external events leading to the disintegration of the Soviet Union: the insurgencies in Angola, Afghanistan and Central America; the Solidarity movement in Poland; and the Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI) to see if they reveal a coordinated anti-USSR effort. I will then address the effects of these activities inside the Soviet Union and finish with my Ronald Reagan And The Fall Of The Soviet Union: Plot Or Serendipity
    http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/1995/BMH.htm
    As Reagan emerged as the God for the Western Capitalism and Imperialism to annihilate the Communist World, Bush is emergeing with similar images. Unfortunately, now we don`t refer USSR or Europe. It is India and Asia respectively. Indo US Nuclear Deal has opoend all military avenues for US strike power to disintegrate Asia and essentially India!
    The US has announced it has taken the unprecedented step of agreeing to the creation of a civil nuclear enrichment facility in India even though India is not a signatory to the international nuclear non-proliferation treaty. The deal, which has taken almost two years to finalise after it was announced by Manmohan Singh and George W.Bush in Washington, is likely to face tough questions from the US Congress, which now has to approve it.
    In a statement on Friday President Bush said that the deal marked an important step in “deepening our strategic partnership with India – a vital world leader”.

    My usndergraduate son reacted sharply watching News Updates on TV channels and opined that India is not safe! They are going to break it as they succeeded to break soviet Union.
    I rplied, ` I may not visit my anchestral village somewhere in Narail district (Jassore) and I am afaraid they won`t allow you to visit my village in Uttarakhand!
    When I shifted from Bareilly, just one hour from my village, my father was living and he was pained. He objected. It was 1991. Soviet union was no more. I told him that if Soviet Union may be diluted, the turmoils within tyhecountry are enough indication for our fate. We are deprived of our identity and it is better that I should shift myself to West Bengal. my father disagreed and hoped that India is somewhat a different polity and despite the experience of partition holocaust we have to survive as Indian Nation!
    No one imagined disintegration of USSR even during first Gulf War!
    Well, I may not repeat the same words at present as it is quite transparent that disintegration is the agenda of zionist hindu US post modern Manusmriti Galaxy order and there happens no resistance at all.

    The nationalities question in the Soviet Union was long an esoteric topic that Western specialists saw little purpose in studying. The Soviet authorities claimed to have resolved the national question, and Westerners who did not have a special interest in one or another region tended not to challenge that thesis. The collapse of the Soviet Union brought new interest, but not all the results of this suddenly refocused attention have been very satisfying. The book at hand, fortunately, is one of the better ones.
    We have not even addressed the Nationality questions despit AFPSA experiences in Kashmir and entire North East, Khalistan Movement , Assam Movement, Gorkhaland movement and the latest one, Kamtapuri movement! Rather we seek military solutions! RAW is assisted by MOSAD! US presence is felt in our internal affairs since Indira days very well! Now, we have opend all doors and windows of terrorism and foreign interference!
    Indian enslaved Masses are no better than detached, entertaining WWF audiance. The power game is another enterment for the people and the informations are nothing better than packed Entermaent or showbiz!
    Well, sometime during 2001 or 2002, I am not sure, I wrote a paoem titled `Passport’ which was published in SHAKSTKAAR”, a reputed hindi monthly published from Bhopal, MP. I haven`t got the issue as I am not able to accomodate all published writeups in my rented room!
    I wrote:
    SABSE JAROOREE HAI PASSPORT
    GAON TAK PAHUNCHNE KE LIYE
    MOST NEEDED IS A PSSPORT
    TO REACH ONE`S OWN VILLAGE
    They published some of my poems on globalisation and information technology.Bengali poet sukana bhattachary once wrote that there should not be any place for poetry in a country of Hunger. I am writing hard prose nowadays!
    The United States sees India as a key strategic partner and as a potential balance against China`s potential dominance of Asia, and is prepared to equip India for the role. Already one of the world`s biggest customers for arms, spending over $10 billion in the last three years, India is now planning to buy 126 multi-role combat jets. The US F-16 and F/A-18 Super Hornet are seen as the main contenders in a deal that could be worth another $10 billion. A new study by India`s Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry, 'Private Sector Participation in Defense,' suggests that India`s imports of military hard and software should reach $30 billion by 2012.
    This is the strategic context for the nuclear deal, which ends the isolation from the nuclear community that was imposed on India when it staged its first nuclear tests in 1998, and will allow India to import nuclear fuels and technology under the terms of the Non-Proliferation Treaty. This will be important for India`s civilian nuclear power program, but its main impact is symbolic in asserting the new closeness of the U.S. strategic partnership.
    My son is an engaged boy with his video games and virtual world and he is nowhere concerned with the day today world. But I am happy that he is worried of National unity and integration. But he and generation Next may not help it all as everything seems predestined in accordance with the great Karam theory. Our national leadership, political parties and intelleigentsia is least concerned for the future of Nation India until they lose the power game. No body cared for the outcome and suffring of the corores of Indians after Partition as our leaders were engaged in power transfer in favour and best interests of the ruling Brahminical Class.
    It is a striking coincidence that the Indian and U.S. governments should have announced the successful conclusion of their long-stalled nuclear cooperation deal in the same week that India established its first overseas military base.
    India`s new base, an electronic listening post and radar station on the island of Madagascar, is perfectly situated to monitor the international waterways around South Africa and the Indian Ocean with its oil tanker routes to Asia. India has also leased an atoll from Mauritius on which a similar facility is to be built. Its navy has secured berthing rights in Oman, and signed an agreement last year to patrol the Mozambique coast. In 2003, the Indian navy provided seaward protection for the African Union summit at Mozambique.
    The Indian Ocean is increasingly under Indian management, led by a fast-growing navy that is buying advanced French-made Scorpene 'stealth' submarines and has just acquired its first ever U.S. warship, the former USS Trenton, a large amphibious transport and landing ship, along with U.S. UH-3H helicopters. Three months ago, India completed a $1.1 billion deal with the United States for Hercules military transport.

    Nicholas Burns, the US undersecretary of state, who led the often difficult negotiations with his Indian counterparts, said it removed the “fundamental roadblock” in the way of a full global partnership between the world’s largest democracy and its richest.
    Mr Burns denied the deal would act as an incentive for other countries to develop nuclear weapons outside the NPT. He said that Iran was “inside the NPT but cheating” whereas India was outside the NPT but had a good record of non-proliferation. “This agreement sends a message to outlaw regimes such as Iran that if you behave responsibly you will not be penalised,” said Mr Burns.
    India denied that the agreement, which non-proliferation hawks say will free up indigenous Indian fissile material for use in the country’s atomic weapons programme, would contribute to an arms race in south Asia, destabilise the balance of power in the region and potentially prompt a copycat deal between Pakistan and China.
    According to Indian negotiators, the agreement makes no explicit reference to the US Hyde Act, which allows the US to demand the return of all fuel and technology supplied under the deal in the event that India tests a nuclear weapon.
    Shiv Shankar Menon, the Indian foreign secretary, said: “This is an agreement between two governments. It meets the concerns of the two governments. It’s not for us to interpret their laws, nor for them to interpret ours.” Mr Narayanan added: “We dealt with the administration and we believe they know how far they can go.”
    However, Mr Burns yesterday said the deal left untouched Washington’s rights under the law, which was passed by an overwhelming majority in both houses of Congress last December.
    Mr Burns said he hoped the International Atomic Energy Agency and the 45-member nuclear suppliers group, whose agreement is essential for the deal to become operational, would approve it within “several months”.
    The Indian nuclear establishment, represented in the negotiations by Anil Kakodkar, chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission, has set aside its earlier reservations that the deal would compromise New Delhi’s strategic weapons programme. Mr Kakodkar said: “I don’t think there’s any reason for people to be concerned on that front.”

    Nuclear security and the Green Revolution
    During the 1971 War, the US had sent its Seventh Fleet to the Bay of Bengal as a warning to India keep away from East Pakistan as a pretext to launch a wider attack against West Pakistan, especially over the disputed territory of Kashmir. This move had further alienated India from the First World, and Prime Minister Gandhi now accelerated a previously cautious new direction in national security and foreign policy. India and the USSR had earlier signed the Treaty of Friendship and Mutual Cooperation, the resulting political and military support contributing substantially to India's victory in the 1971 war.
    But Gandhi now accelerated the national nuclear program, as it was felt that the nuclear threat from the People's Republic of China and the intrusive interest of the two major superpowers were not conducive to India's stability and security. She also invited the new Pakistani President Zulfikar Ali Bhutto to Shimla for a week-long summit. After the near-failure of the talks, the two heads of state eventually signed the Shimla Agreement, which bound the two countries to resolve the Kashmir dispute by negotiations and peaceful means. It was Gandhi's stubbornness which made even the visiting Pakistani Prime Minister sign the accord according to India's terms in which Zulfikar Bhutto had to write the last few terms in the agreement in his own handwriting.[citation needed]
    Indira Gandhi was criticized by some for not making the Line of Control a permanent border while a few critics even believed that Pakistan-administered Kashmir should have been extracted from Pakistan, whose 93,000 prisoners of war were under Indian control. But the agreement did remove immediate United Nations and third party interference, and greatly reduced the likelihood of Pakistan launching a major attack in the near future. By not demanding total capitulation on a sensitive issue from Bhutto, she had allowed Pakistan to stabilize and normalize. Trade relations were also normalized, though much contact remained frozen for years.
    In 1974, India successfully conducted an underground nuclear test, unofficially code named as smiling Buddha, near the desert village of Pokhran in Rajasthan. Describing the test as for peaceful purposes, India nevertheless became the world's youngest nuclear power.
    Main article: Green Revolution
    Special agricultural innovation programs and extra government support launched in the 1960s that had finally resulted in India's chronic food shortages were gradually being transformed into surplus production of wheat, rice, cotton and milk. The country became a food exporter, and diversified its commercial crop production as well, in what has become known as the Green Revolution. At the same time, the White Revolution was an expansion in milk production which helped to combat malnutrition, especially amidst young children. 'Food security', as the programme was called, was another source of support for Mrs. Gandhi in the years leading up to 1975. [1]
    Established in the early 1960s, the Green Revolution was the unofficial name given to the Intense Agricultural District Programme (IADP) which sought to insure abundant, inexpensive grain for urban dwellers upon whose support Gandhi -- as indeed all Indian politicians -- heavily depended. [5] The program was based on four premises: 1) New varieties of seed(s), 2) Acceptance of the necessity of the chemicalization of Indian agriculture, i.e. fertilizers, pesticides, weed killers, etc., 3) A commintment to national and internatonal cooperative research to develope new and improved existing seed varieties, 4) The concept of developing a scientific, agriculturial institutions in the form of land grant colleges. [6]. Lasting about ten years, the program was ultimately to bring about a tripling of wheat production, a lower but still impressive increase of rice; while there was little to no increase (depending on area, and adjusted for population growth) of such cereals as millet, gram and coarse grain, though these did, in fact, retain a relatively stable yield. Yet by the mid 1970's the IADP and its "Green Revolution" had collapsed in all but name due to bad administration, human greed, and heavy-handed politics among all parties on both state and national levels.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indira_Gandhi
    The deal has been stalled over some of the terms imposed by the U.S. Congress under the Hyde Act, which sought to impose certain restrictions on India. The first was to hold the deal hostage, allowing it to be suspended if India staged more nuclear tests. The second was to bring some, but not all, of India`s nuclear rectors under the intensive inspection regime of the NPT and the International Atomic Energy Agency.
    The most authoritative opposition to the deal has come from Peter Iyengar, former chairman of India`s Atomic Energy Commission, who listed his concerns in an exclusive United Press International interview at his home in New Delhi with this reporter in February this year.
    'As currently drafted, the agreement would force us to stop re-processing nuclear fuel, something we have been doing for thirty years,' Iyengar said. 'It would terminate our strategic program (India`s nuclear weapons program) by exposing us to sanctions if we conducted nuclear tests. And it puts impossible barriers in our path to ongoing and future research, including our well-developed programs for fast-breeder reactors and to use thorium rather than uranium as a nuclear fuel,' he added.
    'By saying that India shall not re-process fuel and not develop the fast-breeder reactors, this deal undermines our ability to produce energy in the future when uranium runs out,' Dr Iyengar went on. 'This is a question of national sovereignty, of India`s right and ability to decide such things for ourselves.'
    The Hyde Act was designed to be watertight, but somehow the Bush administration has managed to accommodate India`s concerns. This was done, to widespread surprise last week, when Vice President Dick Cheney took personal charge of the talks in Washington with India`s National Security adviser M.K. Narayanan, Foreign Secretary Shiv Shankar Menon and Anil Kakodkar, secretary of India`s Department of Atomic Energy
    Menon was packed and about to check out from his hotel when Cheney intervened and brought Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice into the final phase of talks, which opened with Cheney saying, 'This deal must be done.' The White House national security adviser Steven Hadley was also brought into the talks to fine tune the text of a document called 'The 123 agreement' that spells out the details of the deal.
    The precise terms have not yet been made public, and the final document is a frozen text, which means that it can now only be voted up or down, and not amended further. According to U.S. sources, it is based on Cheney`s traditionally robust view of the president`s prerogative over foreign policy and strategic issues, and allows George W. Bush or future presidents to give India a form of waiver under the terms of the Hyde Act when supreme U.S. national interests are deemed to be at stake.
    The Democratic-controlled Congress may have doubts about this, but potential presidential candidates may see its usefulness. The increasingly conservative U.S. Supreme Court, with two new Bush-appointed justices, is likely to sympathize with Cheney`s view of the presidential prerogative.
    The deal has been strongly backed by the wealthy and influential Indian community in the United States. Sanjay Puri, chairman of the U.S.-India Political Action Committee commented: 'The United States and India have achieved what everyone thought was impossible when President George W. Bush and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh announced their plan for a civil nuclear agreement in July 2005. Exactly two years later, the two nations have not only reached an agreement, but created a lifelong partnership between two nations that are committed to democratic principles and the idea of energy independence.'
    This also seals the presence on the world stage of India`s emergence as a regional superpower in Asia, while becoming a close U.S. ally and a major economic and technological force. Next month, India will launch its first dedicated military reconnaissance satellite, CARTOSAT 2A, on one of its own launch vehicles. Two more advanced imaging satellites with Israeli synthetic aperture radars are to be launched next year for all-weather monitoring of Asian airspace, including China
    It may also not be a coincidence that these developments come as China is upgrading its ballistic missile facility at central-north Delingha, where launch pads for older Dong Feng-4 intercontinental ballistic missiles are being modernized for new DF-21 medium-range missiles. A report this month by the Nuclear Information Project for the Federation of American Scientists concluded that the DF-21s 'would be able to hold at risk all of northern India, including New Delhi.'
    End of the Soviet Union
    The August 1991 coup, designed to halt the weakening of the centralized USSR, ironically hastened the Union's dissolution. Declarations of independence by the constituent republics, the abolition of all-Union institutions and the transfer of their assets to the republics, and increasing international acceptance of these developments sapped what little strength there had been in the Union. While Gorbachev tried desperately to find a formula to halt the centrifugal process, his former political allies, reading the signs, abandoned him one after the other. And yet, there was no inevitability about the decision to replace the Soviet Union with a Commonwealth of Independent States. That decision, adopted by the leaders of Russia, Ukraine, and Belorussia, seems to have been made hastily if not whimsically.
    On August 23, 1991 Boris Eltsin, as President of the RSFSR, decreed the suspension of the Russian Communist Party on the grounds that it had lent its support to the coup attempt and had otherwise violated Soviet and Russian laws. Gorbachev, who upon returning to Moscow after the coup had tried to absolve the party of any blame and announced his intention of continuing his efforts to reform the party, was left with little choice but to resign as General Secretary of the entire (All-Union) party, which he did two days later. Seeking to counter the further erosion of central authority, Gorbachev persuaded a majority in the Congress of People's Deputies in early September to dissolve that body in favor of a State Council which would consist of republic leaders and Gorbachev and act in a temporary capacity until a new bicameral legislature could be elected. Aside from approving independence for the three Baltic republics, the State Council accomplished nothing and was largely ignored by republic governments. Eltsin, swelled with new powers granted by the Russian parliament, meanwhile accelerated the transfer of central institutions to Russian authority.
    December turned out to be the month in which the fatal blows to the Soviet Union were delivered. On December 1, voters in Ukraine overwhelmingly approved a referendum on independence and by a smaller margin elected Leonid Kravchuk, a former Communist Party boss turned nationalist, as their first president. A week later, at a hunting lodge in Belovezhskaia Pushcha, not far from the Belorussian capital of Minsk, Eltsin, Kravchuk and the Belorussian leader, Stanislav Shushkevich, signed a declaration terminating the Soviet Union and replacing it with the Commonwealth of Independent States. Gorbachev, who had not been consulted or informed beforehand, publicly responded by declaring his "amazement" and urging republic parliaments to discuss the draft Treaty on the Union of Sovereign States on which he had worked tirelessly over the previous months. On December 21, the presidents of all the other republics with the exception of Georgia (already embroiled in civil war) and the three Baltic states, declared their willingness to enter the Commonwealth. Finally, on December 25, Gorbachev announced his acceptance of the dissolution of the Soviet Union and his resignation as its president.

    In Lenin's party-state, the nationalities question was supposed to occupy only a minor role, a question of form in the constitutional structure that in turn had to carry Out the directions of the superior party structure. While critics now may point to failures in Soviet nationalities policy, they should remember that relatively few saw this as a significant question before the mid-1980s - least of all, most major Western Sovietologists. As late as January 1990, when Gorbachev made his vain pilgrimage to Lithuania, he and his entourage were still insisting that 'the national question is not the most important question in life'. As it turned out, this was a question of life and death for the Soviet Union.
    Gorbachev inherited a centralised party-state that faced serious economic problems. As Fowkes points out, he experimented with both party reform and political decentralisation, but through it all he wanted to keep his own position as the leader who maintained the integrity of the Soviet Union. When the going became rough, he tried to make his peace with the conservatives. He failed: the Soviet Union collapsed, and he lost his job.
    Please read:
    History of the Soviet Union (1985–1991)
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Soviet_Union_(1985-1991)
    The Causes and Consequences of the Collapse of the Soviet Union
    http://newarkwww.rutgers.edu/guides/glo-sov.html

    What were the causes of the disintegration of the Soviet Union as a socialist one party state?
    Firstly, it is important to highlight that the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 can be examined in two ways. It can be looked at in terms of the break-up of an empire; the reasons why the Soviet Union no longer exists as a federation of nations including Russia, the Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Armenia etc. Alternatively, it can be looked at in terms of reasons why the political system that governed the state collapsed. It is this latter perspective that will be examined in the course of this essay. While the former is no doubt an important question, it will only be considered to the extent that there is naturally a link between the government of a state and its component parts. Regional nationalism therefore shall only be examined in light of the effect...
    http://www.coursework.info/I_B_/History/What_were_the_causes_of_the_disintegration_of_the_Soviet_L10411.html
    Fall of the Soviet Union
    Back to Links

    In December of 1991, as the world watched in amazement, the Soviet Union disintegrated into fifteen separate countries. Its collapse was hailed by the west as a victory for freedom, a triumph of democracy over totalitarianism, and evidence of the superiority of capitalism over socialism. The United States rejoiced as its formidable enemy was brought to its knees, thereby ending the Cold War which had hovered over these two superpowers since the end of World War II. Indeed, the breakup of the Soviet Union transformed the entire world political situation, leading to a complete reformulation of political, economic and military alliances all over the globe.
    What led to this monumental historical event? In fact, the answer is a very complex one, and can only be arrived at with an understanding of the peculiar composition and history of the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union was built on approximately the same territory as the Russian Empire which it succeeded. After the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, the newly-formed government developed a philosophy of socialism with the eventual and gradual transition to Communism. The state which the Bolsheviks created was intended to overcome national differences, and rather to create one monolithic state based on a centralized economical and political system. This state, which was built on a Communist ideology, was eventually transformed into a totalitarian state, in which the Communist leadership had complete control over the country.
    http://www.coldwar.org/articles/90s/fall_of_the_soviet_union.asp
    What are the main factors responsible for the disintegration of the Soviet Union?
    First answer by anonymous. Last edit by 84.217.153.170. Question popularity: 146 [recommend question]
    Answer
    one very big factor was the economy or lack of one, the cold war was a full fledged war between the united states and russia, but rather than killing each other it was a war of weapons and development. we build a new rocket and they would try to build a better one to try to keep ahead, they send a man in orbit. we send one to the moon, they build a bigger bomber we build a faster one, etc.etc.etc.... this is a very expensive process on both sides, soon russia just could not keep up financialy any more. this was just one factor.

    Answer
    Russia fell primarily because the Great God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob caused it to fall. For more than 60 years Godless communism had enslaved and murdered people all over the globe and espoused that the state was God. It is humorous that He also used the false religion on Islam to break up the Soviet Union. Afganistan was the first chink in the mighty soviet armour. Then the other "stans" broke away. All those soviet vassel states with great numbers of muslems broke away and the communist lost control of their empire. Mainly God allowed thousands of Jews to return to return to Israel from Russia. The great red bully of the world was shaken to the core and split up when God decided that enough was enough!

    Answer
    The Soviet's command-economy was not able to compete with the free-market economy of the US and its allies. In almost every area of competition - excepting only nuclear armaments - the Soviet system fell behind. One example of this can be found in the production of Soviet steel. Around and after WWII, the Soviet system was behind the US in steel production. Since they used a command economy, this was a factor that had to be settled not via supply and demand but rather through the Soviet government's use of limited resources and time (e.g. currency and time). By the 1990s, Soviet steel production surpassed that of the US. Unfortunately for the Soviets, by this time there was a plethora of steel traded on the open markets. So while they did indeed begin to produce more steel than the US, it was more expensive for them to produce steel domestically than it was for the US to import it. This left the US with resources to spend on other "projects" - such as computer technology. This phenomenon was to repeat itself in a variety of other manners as well.
    http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_main_factors_responsible_for_the_disintegration_of_the_Soviet_Union
    One indicator that has been tabulated, if not quantified, to everyone's satisfaction is that of the Soviet economy. It is know, for example, that in the 60s and 70s Soviet productivity in steel and coal caught up with and even surpassed that of the United States. But declines already had commenced in labor productivity and the quality of machine tools, while advances in science and technology increasingly proved illusory.
    Nevertheless, economic reports drawn by Western experts basically found that the Soviet situation, while somewhat gloomy, was still redeemable. These half-way optimistic measurements were even seized upon by the Soviet leadership to buttress their own traditionally overly optimistic assessment. Consumer goods, meanwhile, increased in number during these years but the distribution system was so broken down that milk rarely got delivered before souring and, though Soviets produced more shoes than anyone else in the world, customers were forced to stand in line time and again to buy several pairs because the sizes were so askew that it was necessary to acquire many pairs to make a fit. Housing meanwhile was atrocious with couples required to wait years before qualifying for a small apartment; the wait for cars also dragged on interminable, and after one finally arrived, it was not unusual for it almost immediately to experience mechanical problems.
    Defense costs, furthermore, were eating up an inordinate portion of Soviet expenditures. Because of the difficulty in measuring the Soviet GNP it was not always clear what percentage was being spent to this end. Experts now claim the West routinely underestimated the numbers. It is now believed that in years just prior to 1991 as much as 30 percent of the economy went toward the defense sector putting an enormous burden on the average citizen in terms of delayed consumer satisfaction. Then there were the costs incurred by shoring up overseas adventures such as those in Africa, not to mention the drain of the war in Afghanistan and the expense involved in maintaining Castro's lifeline.
    But all of this is preliminary to asking and attempting to answer what clearly has becom

  • Weep, Mother India! Weep!

    Weep, Mother India! Weep!
    Blackest Day For Independent India, Indo- US Deal declared
    The post Cold War aggressiveness of American and British foreign policy now makes India a Real Colony
    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Deal silent on N-test; Govt says nation?s interests not mortgaged

    The agreement to operationalise the Indo-US civil nuclear deal is silent on any repercussions on New Delhi conducting an atomic test even as the government today made it clear that the country`s interests have not been mortgaged and the strategic programme remains unaffected.
    http://zeenews.com/index.asp
    The post Cold War aggressiveness of American and British foreign policy affecting Iraq, North Korea, and the southern former states of the Soviet Union has step-by-step unsettled Moscow. The straw that broke the camel’s back is undoubtedly the US decision to build a new radar facility on Polish and Czech soil, that although directed at putative Iranian rockets could easily be upgraded to be aimed at Russian ones. But it began with President Bill Clinton’s decision to expand Nato right up to the frontiers of the old Soviet Union.
    Dangers of return of the Cold War
    http://www.thestatesman.net/page.news.php?clid=4&theme=&usrsess=1&id=164042
    It is the Blackest Day for Independent India but has to be written in Golden letters in the history of Shinging Sensex India ruled by Brahminical comradors as they have been successful to make India a real Zionist Hindu Colony of US Post Modern Manusmriti Galaxy Order at last! The enslaved Indian People have no courage to face the US strike power omnipresnt with collabration of the colonial Indian statepower. Pakistan is feeling the heat and fire! We may not feel. Bangla nationality in Dhaka has also welcomed US supremacy there. This Indian subcontinent is a free military zone since today.
    A suicide bomber killed at least 11 people and injured about 45 others on Friday at a hotel near Islamabad's Lal Masjid, officials said, just hours after riot police clashed with hundreds of religious students at the newly reopened mosque. We don`t see any Red Alert whatever happen around! We have not learn anything from Iraq and Afgan experiences. Our memry does not have any archive on Vietnam, Latin america, Korea. We have forgotten all japanese crimes. Even we forgot the War of 1962 and now we do gang up agianst China with strategic grouping with US, Australia and japan!
    This is Indian foreign Policy. This is nonsense Sensense! This diplomacy!
    Weep, Mother India! Weep!
    What a Farce!
    India and United States today officially announced that they had completed negotiations on the bilateral text on civil nuclear co-operation, but opposition parties said doubts remained on the extent to which Indian strategic autonomy had been curtailed ...
    The United States and India have completed an agreement to share civilian nuclear fuel and technology, it was announced Friday, in a deal that would reverse three decades of American anti-proliferation policy if approved.While a step forward on what would be a major shift in U.S. policy, the accord must still clear several more steps, including international and U.S. congressional approval, before nuclear trade could begin.
    In a single-page joint statement, the countries provided no specific details, but hailed their work as a "historic milestone." The United States has portrayed the agreement as deepening ties with a democratic Asian power.Critics say the measure damages international nonproliferation efforts and could boost India's nuclear bomb stockpile by freeing up its domestic uranium for weapons. That, they fear, could spark a nuclear arms race in Asia.
    Friday's announcement came after more than a year of detailed, often frustrating technical talks.
    Whatever demon may be Bush or any American President he may not dare to go against US interests. Our so called National leadership along with so much hyped democratic institution and FDI fed gift sponsorship monger media damn care Indian National interests and the enslaved population. They have made a woman first citizen! They will have a Muslim as vice President and reservation and quota are enough to satisfy the bargaining previleged enslaved Cream! This casteology and absolute communalism happens to be the spirit of Indian nationality mortgaged in the Swiss bank accounts! Bush may have the Veto Power but he has to care for the Parliamentary debate and popularity graph. Our leaders have every avenue to bypass the Parliament and Judiciary! US citizens may boast of democratic transparency and civil as well as human rights. But we Indian citizens are identityless orphans roaming around and stripped of everything including life , liberty and livelihood.
    Minimum empowerment of individual citizen is absent till this date to defend citizenship. Thus, they sale out our freedom and sovereignity so smoothly and we fools sing Vande mataram! Mera Bharat Mahan!
    The Centre on Friday tried to hardsell the Indo-US civil nuclear agreement to the political setup in particular and the nation as a whole, saying it will open the way for bilateral cooperation between India and US.

    Briefing journalists on the nuclear deal, National Security Adviser MK Narayanan, however, admitted that the "deal is not the best, but is a very good one." In the same breath, he claimed that "India has retained its right to test."

    The government fielded the Chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission, Anil Kakodkar; Foreign Secretary Shiv Shankar Menon and National Security Adviser MK Narayanan at a briefing on the nuclear deal.

    Narayanan said the Indo-US bilateral agreement on nuclear deal fulfills the terms outlined by Prime Minister in Parliament on August 17.He said there was no reference in the agreement to the nuclear tests carried out by India in 1998. "It refers to only civil nuclear cooperation."

    Asked what he felt were the shortcomings of the agreement, Narayanan said India would have liked to get reprocessing and enrichment technologies.
    The Left allies and opposition NDA is "satisfied" with the civil nuclear deal concluded with the US, the government maintained today.
    "We have already met the Left and the members of the NDA. I think we have explained to them in great detail as to what it is," National Security Adviser M K Narayanan said when asked about the response of the two political alliances to the deal in the backdrop of their stated apprehensions.
    "The impression that we have got from the discussions is that they were particularly satisfied," claimed Narayanan who briefed the Left and opposition leaders when they met Prime Minister Manmohan Singh here over the last two days.
    To press the argument in this regard, he said Atomic Energy Commission Chairman Anil Kakodkar did most of the talking with the leaders of Left and NDA which carries "a lot of credibility and which will be carried across the board."
    "If nuclear community is on board, I think, that would make everybody happy," Narayanan said.
    Narayanan was addressing the joint press conference along with Kakodkar and Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon on the 123 agreement reached with the US last week.
    Kakodkar, who had earlier voiced doubts over certain elements of the deal particularly the reprocessing right, expressed happiness over the final text of the agreement.
    He said the final agreement reflects the understanding between the two countries reached on July 18, 2005 and March 2,2006.

    The Australian government has dropped charges against an Indian doctor arrested over foiled bomb plots in the UK over a lack of evidence.Meanwhile,
    Hundreds of religious students clashed with police and occupied Islamabad's Red Mosque during its reopening Friday, demanding the return of a pro-Taliban cleric two weeks after an army raid to oust Islamic militants ...On Friday, TADA court Judge Pramod D Kode said he would sentence Dutt on Tuesday, July 31. Last November the star was found guilty of possessing arms in the 1993 Mumbai blasts case.The Home Ministry is reportedly upset with super cop Kiran Bedi for her open tirade against the government. Sources in the Home Ministry have claimed that her comments violate service conduct rules.
    Three years after President Bush urged global rules to stop additional nations from making nuclear fuel, the White House will announce today that it is carving out an exception for India, in a last-ditch effort to seal a civilian nuclear deal between the countries.In general, advocates of a far-stronger relationship between India and the United States have favored the nuclear cooperation deal, and it passed through Congress fairly easily. But those arguing that the administration has not made good on its promises to clamp down on the trade in nuclear fuel argue that Mr. Bush could be setting a precedent that will undercut his nonproliferation initiative.
    Australia has said it would consider supplying uranium to India despite the country not being a signatory to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, provided it agreed to inspections by the UN atomic watchdog.
    The proposal, which has been strongly backed by Prime Minister John Howard, has put the Opposition leader Kevin Rudd at the loggerheads with the labor government, which had earlier argued that selling uranium to India would undermine the NPT.
    Foreign Minister Alexander Downer said Australia would consider supplying uranium to India even if it did not sign the NPT, provided it agreed to inspections by International Atomic Energy Agency.
    Federal Resources Minister Ian Macfarlane, meanwhile, said the government will seek further legal advice on whether it has the constitutional powers to override the states' bans on uranium mines in western Australia and Queensland, 'The Age' reported today.
    Downer said that while he would prefer the countries signed the International Non-Proliferation Treaty, "you have to face up to the facts".
    He said India had no record of exporting nuclear weapons technology to other countries and the export of uranium would help curb greenhouse emissions on the sub-continent.
    "India is the second biggest country in the world in population terms," Downer said, adding "Its economy is growing at nearly 9 per cent a year. It's going to be a massive consumer of energy and we want to deal with the issue of climate change."
    Downer said any uranium exported to India could be used only in civil nuclear facilities and Australia would never sell yellow cake for nuclear weapons or nuclear-powered military vessels.
    Just two months ago, Macfarlane had vowed Australia would not sell uranium to India unless it signed the NPT.
    Shadow Foreign Affairs Minister Robert McClelland said that the Federal Government's "unrestrained promotion of nuclear power was a cause for great concern."
    "Instead of - seeking approval for the export of Australian uranium to India, the Foreign Minister should - join labor in campaigning for wide-ranging reform of the non-proliferation treaty to encourage India to join," McClelland said.
    US lawmakers have warned Bush administration of “inconsistencies” in the 123 agreement after reports that Washington has agreed to allow India to reprocess spent nuclear fuel under the civilian nuclear deal with New Delhi.
    The warning came after the agreement between the USA and India was finalised in extended talks in Washington last week.
    In a letter to President George W Bush, as many as 23 Congressmen-led by Democratic lawmaker Mr Edward Markey expressed their concern that perhaps Washington may have “capitulated” to India’s demands on the agreement.
    The Congress passed the Hyde Act less than a year ago, settling minimum conditions that must be met for nuclear cooperation with India, as well as the non-negotiable restrictions on such cooperation, Mr Markey said.
    Stating that these conditions and restrictions were not optional or advisory, Mr Markey warned “If the 123 agreement has been intentionally negotiated to sidestep or bypass the law and the will of Congress, final approval for this deal will be jeopardised.” In the letter, the lawmakers stressed “the necessity of abiding by the legal boundaries set by Congress” for nuclear cooperation.
    “The Agreement for Nuclear Cooperation is subject to the approval of Congress, and any inconsistencies between the Agreement and the relevant US laws will call congressional approval deeply into doubt,” lawmakers told the White House.
    The scheduled announcement, described yesterday by senior American officials, ends more than a year of negotiations intended to keep an unusual arrangement between the countries from being defeated in New Delhi.Until the overall deal was approved by Congress last year, the United States was prohibited from selling civilian nuclear technology to India because it has refused to sign the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty.The legislation passed by Congress required the United States to cut off the supply of nuclear fuel to India.
    India's Parliament balked at the deal, with politicians there complaining that the restriction infringed on India's sovereignty because it cut off nuclear assistance to India if it tested a nuclear weapon, and because it prohibited India from using American fuel to help bolster its weapons arsenal.
    Under the arrangement that is to be announced by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, Mr. Bush has agreed to go beyond the terms of the deal that Congress approved, promising to help India build a nuclear fuel repository and find alternative sources of nuclear fuel in the event of an American cutoff, skirting some of the provisions of the law.
    In February 2004, President Bush, in a major speech outlining new nuclear policies to prevent proliferation, declared that “enrichment and reprocessing are not necessary for nations seeking to harness nuclear energy for peaceful purposes.” He won the cooperation of allies for a temporary suspension of new facilities to make fuel, but allies that include Canada and Australia have also expressed interest in uranium enrichment.
    The problem is a delicate one for the administration, because this month American officials are working at the United Nations Security Council to win approval of harsher economic sanctions against Iran for trying to enrich uranium. India is already a nuclear weapons state and has refused to sign the treaty; Iran, a signer of the treaty, does not yet have nuclear weapons.
    But in an interview Thursday, R. Nicholas Burns, the under secretary of state for political affairs, who negotiated the deal, said, “Iran in no way, shape or form would merit similar treatment because Iran is a nuclear outlaw state.”
    He noted that Iran hid its nuclear activities for many years from international inspectors, and that it still had not answered most of their questions about evidence that could suggest it was seeking weapons.
    Because India never signed the treaty, it too was considered a nuclear outlaw for decades. But Mr. Bush, eager to place relations with India on a new footing, waived many of the restrictions in order to sign the initial deal. It was heavily supported by Indian-Americans and American nuclear equipment companies, which see a huge potential market for their reactors and expertise.
    Representative Edward J. Markey, a Massachusetts Democrat who opposed the initial deal and said he would try to defeat the new arrangement, said Thursday, “If you make an exception for India, we will be preaching from a barstool to the rest of the world.”
    Though India would be prohibited from using the fuel it purchases from the United States for nuclear weapons, the ability to reprocess the fuel means India’s other supplies would be freed up to expand its arsenal.
    “It creates a double standard,” Mr. Markey said. “One set of rules for countries we like, another for countries we don’t.”
    Robert J. Einhorn, a scholar at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said that in “the first phase of negotiations with India, the administration made concessions that put the country on par with countries that have signed” the Nonproliferation Treaty. (Israel and Pakistan are the only other countries that have refused to sign it, and North Korea quit the treaty four years ago.)
    “Now we’ve gone beyond that, and given India something that we don’t give to Russia and China.”
    Mr. Burns said he disagreed because “this agreement is so very much in our national interest.”
    “It will further our nonproliferation efforts globally” by gradually bringing India into the nuclear fold, he said.
    Peace process in Nandigram to begin today: Basu

    Kolkata: The West Bengal government has decided to begin today the peace process in Nandigram, where 14 people were killed in violence four and half months back, veteran CPI(M) leader Jyoti Basu said.
    "The Chief Minister (Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee) has said that the peace process in Nandigram is beginning today," Basu said after the weekly CPI(M) state secretariat meeting here where Bhattacharjee was also present.
    The government was forced to shelve the chemical hub SEZ in Nandigram following stiff protests by villagers led by Trinamool Congress and Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind under the umbrella of Bhumi Ucched Pratirodh Committee.
    However, the area continued to be on boil prompting the Chief Minister to appeal to the opposition for talks on restoring peace in Nandigram.
    Bhattacharjee has also written to the Opposition parties on the chemical hub, which is now proposed to be set up in Haldia, as also the acquisition of agricultural land for industries.
    However, Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee has rejected the Chief Minister's overtures, saying their agitation would continue till the perpetrators of the March 14 'genocide' in Nandigram were brought to book.
    Basu, however, said that the government was not thinking of holding an all party meeting to arrive at a consensus on the proposed chemical hub in Haldia.
    "We are not thinking about it. We are thinking about Nandigram. An area cannot remain a free zone for long," said Basu, a former West Bengal Chief Minister.
    While slamming the opposition for forming an 'opportunistic alliance' in the recent Haldia civic polls, Basu said the Trinamool Congress was bereft of any principles and programmes.
    The Trinamool Congress-led grand alliance, which included the Congress and the Jamiat's political arm People's Democratic Conference, got seven seats in the Haldia municipal polls, as the Left Front retained the civic board retaining 19 of the 26 wards. While the TC got six, PDCI claimed one seat.
    The Opposition had drawn a blank in the previous elections of the Haldia municipality in 2002.
    "We were confident of winning the Haldia civic poll. But since the municipality is adjacent to Nandigram, we thought the opposition would get some seats," Basu said.
    "That way the victory is significant because despite the municipality being close to Nandigram, the opposition could not make inroads. The Trinamool, Congress and BJP had formed an opportunistic alliance," the nonagenarian leader said.
    Asked about the Trinamool rejecting the Chief Minister's offer for talks, Basu said "They (Trinamool Congress) do not have any principles and programmes. Still they have got votes.
    We have to go to those people who have voted for them".
    Stiff opposition to Tata`s titanium-di-oxide project in TN

    Chennai: After having a rough ride on its Singur small car project in West Bengal, the Tata Group is now facing stiff opposition in Tamil Nadu to the Rs 2,500-crore titanium-di-oxide project proposed to be set up in southern districts of Tirunelveli and Tuticorin.
    Expressing apprehension that the corporate giant's venture would displace them from their native land and deprive them of their livelihood, local villagers, mostly belonging to the dominant Nadar community in the south, have resolved to oppose the project tooth and nail.
    The issue is set to snowball into a major controversy, similar to the Nandigram row, with some political parties, apparently eyeing the Nadar votebank, also "taking up the cause."
    PMK founder S Ramadoss, a ruling DMK ally who is trying to get a foothold in south Tamil Nadu, has also reportedly expressed support to the agitating groups.
    A Viyanarasu, who has formed a struggle committee called Federation for Tamil Land Protection, told a news agency that about 40,000 families would be displaced as the Tata company is planning to set up the plant on 12,000 acres of land.
    "The government is talking about employment and economic growth. But take the cases of Koodangulam nuclear plant and Neyveli Lignite Corporation. Jobs and rehabilitation were promised when those projects were implemented but most of the displaced families were left in the lurch. What is the guarantee that a private company will honour its word,?" he asked.
    Though Tata Steel originally inked a pact with the previous AIADMK government in 2002, the project did not take off due to undisclosed reasons.
    Buoyant global economic outlook has prompted the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to revise upward India`s Gross Domestic Production (GDP) growth rate by 0.6 per cent to 9 per cent for 2007. Major upward revision has been made for emerging markets with growth projection for China, India and Russia being raised substantially, IMF said in its update on the World Economic Outlook (WEO) on Wednesday. IMF had revised India`s GDP forecast to 9 per cent over the projection made in April this year. The WEO update has also revised the growth forecast for 2008 by 0.6 per cent to 8.4 per cent.
    The Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister, headed by former Reserve Bank Governor C Rangarajan, had on July 16 pegged the country`s economic growth rate at 9 per cent in 2007-08.
    The RBI, however, in its annual policy statement had projected a growth rate of 8.5 per cent.
    India has recorded a GDP growth rate of 9.4 per cent during 2006-07.
    IMF has also revised the forecast for world economic growth to 5.2 per cent, up by 0.3 per cent from the projection made in April.
    The growth rate for china, however, has been revised by 1.2 per cent to 11.2 per cent and for Russia by 0.6 per cent to 7 per cent.
    Vyapar Rojgar Bachao Andolan, a consortium of traders, hawkers, farmers, trade unions, cooperatives and consumer organisations, will organise country-wide protests to oppose the entry of big corporate houses and global retailers into the Indian retail sector.
    "The entry of big corporate and retail giants had put the livelihood of more than 40 million people at risk," India FDI Watch Director Dharmendra Kumar told reporters here.
    The consortium, in association with the other similar organisation, is going to observe August 1-8 as the awareness week and would held demonstrations, dharnas and protest march in all district headquarters on August 8. It will hold a protest march and rallies on August 9 in all metro cities.
    "On August 9, which is also the 65th anniversary of the Quit India Movement, we along with other trade unions would organise huge protests in all metropolitan cities," he said.
    It will also submit a memorandum to chief ministers of various states and to the prime minister.
    It also plans to present a charter of demands to the prime minister, demanding strict law to ban all corporations in retail, formulation of national policy on retail trade and small manufacturing industries, implement the national policy on urban street vendors, and the repeal of APMC model act.
    The consortium also claimed that it has the support of large number of trade organisations and labour unions across the country.
    Secy: Posco will stay even if it misses out on Khandadhar
    NEW DELHI: A NEW twist to the country’s biggest FDI project, Orissa state government has said that Pohang Steel Company will stay in the state even if it does not get the Khandadhar mines. State officials, however, indicated that the chances of that happening were rare.
    Mittal to build steel plants in both Jharkhand, Orissa
    Indian Express

    News Today

    “It is not necessary that every company should have its own captive mines. Posco has plants across the world and nowhere does it have captive mines,” said Orissa government Industries Department commissioner cum secretary Ashok Dalwai. “Posco never came to Orissa just for iron ore but for a host of other reasons.”
    While the Korean steel giant refused to give a straight answer on this, according to the MoU signed between the government and the company in June 2005, the state government had agreed to grant prospecting licences and captive mining leases for 600 million tonnes to Posco.
    For the first phase of the project, the government had recommended Khandadhar mines in Keonjhar district which reportedly have reserves of 200 million tonnes. The centre, however, had returned the application citing need for giving a hearing to other applicants.
    Almost 251 applications have been received for the mines and 45 have already been rejected.
    “We don’t expect a situation where we will not get the mines,” said a senior Posco official. “Principally, it has already been decided to give the mine to Posco. It is just a matter of completing the procedures and hearing the other applicants out. We expect to get the lease in the next two months.”
    Meanwhile, the state government has denied that the mine is owned by Kudremukh Iron Ore Company and said that it was a virgin mine. Khandadhar would provide ore for Posco’s first phase of production of 4 million tonnes by 2010.
    To sort out the issue of land acquisition, Posco has roped in the Xavier Institute of Management to prepare a master plan for relief and rehabilitation. “Private land acquisition has not been a problem and it is part of the government land that has been encroached upon. Once the master plan is ready, displacement will begin,” Dalwai said.
    Out of the 4,004 acres earmarked for the company in Jagatsinghpur area, 3,566 acres belongs to the government while the remaining 436 acres is private land. “We are trying to work out some kind of a settlement with the people who would be displaced. We will follow the norms that are laid down in the relief and rehabilitation policy of the state including planned resettlement of the houses and providing jobs to one member of each family in the company,” the Posco official said.
    Almost 3,093 acres of the government land is classified as forest land and would require compulsory forestation for the same area in some other part of the state. The company is meeting the Forest Advisory Committee next month.
    Where is nation's biggest FDI project headed?
    • Posco expected to start construction by December 2007. Company hopes to get mining leases and land in the next three months.
    • Master plan for relief and rehabilitation of encroachers on government land being prepared by Xavier Institute of Management.
    • Encroachers may be offered alternate land or money.
    • Hearing of 251 applications on Khandadhar mines in the process; 45 applications already rejected.
    • The 12 million tonne plant will come up in three phases of 4 million tonnes each. First phase to be completed by 2010.

    ACC extends deadline for Hasina, Zia to submit asset info

    Dhaka: The Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) has extended by seven days the deadline for submitting wealth statement of detained former Bangladesh Prime Minister and Awami League chief Sheikh Hasina after her archrival Khaleda Zia of BNP was granted similar extension.
    "The former Prime Minister (Hasina) has sent to us a petition through the jail authorities seeking extra time for seven more working days," ACC secretary Mokhlesur Rahman was quoted as saying in media yesterday.
    The anti-graft body served notices on the two former Prime Ministers of Bangladesh last week, demanding their wealth statements within seven working days. The two leaders, however, sought an extension of the deadlines.
    Zia received the notice at her Dhaka cantonment residence while Hasina got it through jail authorities at her makeshift prison at the Parliament complex.
    ACC officials said the leaders were given extra time to furnish their asset information in accordance with the Anti-Corruption Commission rules 2007.

    Haneef Released
    Indian doctor Mohamed Haneef, who has been cleared of charges of supporting a terrorist organisation, has been conditionally freed from custody, requiring him to report to the immigration department by phone everyday and in person every week.
    Immigration Minister Kevin Andrews said he has made a residential determination, meaning that rather than being detained in immigration custody, Haneef will be released into residential detention.
    Earlier in the day, prosecutors withdrew the case against the 27-year-old Haneef, arrested on July 2 and later charged with "recklessly" supporting a terrorist group, at a Brisbane Magistrates` court hearing following a review.
    Andrews said while he had not reinstated Haneef`s visa, the Gold Coast-based doctor would not be moved to a detention centre.
    The Immigration Minister said he is seeking advice on whether to reverse his decision to revoke Haeef`s visa, but in the meantime he is free to live at home.
    "That means that he has to reside at an agreed place, it means he`s free to actually move about in the community," he said.
    Under the conditions of his release, Haneef would be required to report to Immigration Department by telephone either every day or every few days, and once a week report in person, Andrews said.
    Haneef would be free to move about in the community. "Residential detention means the place in which he is residing is that unit. That means that he has to reside at an agreed place, he`s free to actually move about in the community, but as a matter of legal principle he is still formally... in detention".
    Andrews said he would seek further advice from the Commonwealth Solicitor General about whether he would need to reverse his decision to cancel Haneef`s visa.
    "My duty is to uphold the Immigration Legislation. I will continue to regard this with the utmost seriousness,` he said.
    "This does go to the whole question of national interest and national security," he said.
    "The decision I`ve made can be looked at by the Solicitor General", he added.
    Andrews said the police investigation would continue. "The DPP made a decision today, the charge was withdrawn. As a matter of prudence, as a matter of caution, I am seeking that advice," he said.
    Pranab in Thiphu
    External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee arrived here on Friday on a three-day official visit during which India and Bhutan are expected to sign an agreement on implementation of a 1095-megawatt hydro-power project.
    The minister was received by Bhutanese Information Minister Leki Dorji on his arrival and was given a traditional white scarf.
    He flew in by a chartered flight of Druk Air, a royal Bhutanese airline, which landed one hour behind the schedule due to bad whether.
    During his visit, the two countries are expected to sign a landmark agreement on implementation of a 1095-megawatt hydro-power project. The run-of-the-river project is estimated to cost around Rs 3,514 crore.
    Cooperation in Hydel power sector is one of the key elements in Indo-Bhutanese ties which will get a further boost during Mukherjee`s visit as part of stepped up bilateral exchanges in the recent months.
    Burns on Kashmir
    Offering to “influence quietly” India and Pakistan on the Kashmir issue, the USA has noted that there has been “good” progress to resolve their bilateral differences but the two countries need to “go a lot farther” to consummate this process. US undersecretary of state for political affairs Mr Nicholas Burns said there had been progress in bilateral ties.

  • Losing Heart as No One stands United with Dandkaranya refugees

    Losing Heart as No One stands United with Dandkaranya refugees
    Should we not learn something from Mr Gauranga Sarkar?

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Mr Shridam Biswas or Mr Ujjwal Biswas could not call me. Neither they cared to give any follow back from Orissa. Meanwhile I requested dalit Sahitya sanstha and West Bengal refugee and dalit leaders to take a stance inthis connection. I did my best to infrom dalit and refugee leaders countrywide about evrything relating Polavaram Dam. Only Mr Bharat Bhushan kept me informed about updates. thanks Mr Bhushan!

    Mr Gaurang Sarkar, a vetern Dalit and Refugee leader, a rtd. IRS, based in Bally, Howra edits and publishes Adhikar Patrika and Bengali which is well circulated among Bengali dalits and refugees countrywide. I talked to him . He is an octogenerian intellectual and ia enthusiastic enough to initiate immediate mass mobilisation. He informed to teke up the matter in his Patrika. Not only this , he is activating all his contacts accross the country. Should we not learn something from Mr Gauranga Sarkar?
    Mind you, Not only MarichjahapGenocide or Nandigram and Singur Repression, all activities of Ruling Brahminical class as they got hold on WestBbengal after power transfer amidst partition haolocaust, reveal class conflict within Bangla Nationality which roots in its history. The ruling class is more than successful to oust the Dalit Refugees continuously crossing the border out of Bangla Geopolitics. They annihilated the Dalit Base. The Bengali Dalit and refugee masses are much more enslaved and tamed as they could not sue the responsible Indian leadership and british Imperialists for partition holocaust. They were meek eye witness of genocides Naxalbari, Marichjhapi to Nandigram!They could not raise their voice aginst inhuman Brahminical system. First they supported the Congress on Dole and now they are the most loyal votebank of Marxist Brahminical Communalism represented by the scientific rigging machinery of CPIM. They dare not revolt against the Marxist Gestapo!It has also to be remembered that the comrades can be quite ruthless if they set their minds on something. The Marichjhanpi incident in the Sunderbans in the 70s (mentioned in Amitav Ghosh's The Hungry Tide) is a case in point. The hard-hearted manner in which the Left Front government evicted the East Bengali refugees from there and sent them back to Dandakaranya in what is now Chhattisgarh underlined the same official and political determination now in evidence in Singur.

    Yet, at one time, when the leftists were not in power in West Bengal, they used to favour the settlement of the refugees in the Sunderbans. But their views changed after assuming office; just as it has now on industrialization. So, the Left slogan today is not 'land to the tiller', but land to the Tatas.

    Echooes of the rcent Past may not touch them. They lost the heart to have enouh sympathy for the kith and kin exiled elsewhere. Media and literature help them as no news , no information is ever available about dalit refugees` plight outside Bengal.
    I am habitual in writing or speaking as I belong to the exiled lot which is deprived of everything including Identity and Mother language!
    Petitions are available in the records of the All-India Congress Committee. The refugees asked for jobs, housing, money and to be rehabilitated together with their own kind. The petitions show that people fleetingly held great hopes of the Indian State. Such hopes were not in evidence among the refugees decades later. Hopes of a paternalistic benevolence soon evaporated, leaving a popular disillusionment with the State.

    On August 15, 1950, a refugee organisation even celebrated "Anti- Independence day" at Hazra Park in Calcutta. The government, on the other hand, remained cruel and self-congratulatory.Dalit satyagrahis in Utter Pradesh marching to the Legislative Assembly in the middle of 1946 carrying placards and raising slogans saying: "Down with British Imperialism", "Down with Congress", and "Scrap the Poona Pact". Elsewhere, Dalit activists burnt khadi clothes and Gandhi caps. The leaders of the Scheduled Castes Federation interacted regularly with the leaders of the Muslim League. The Scheduled Castes Federation of UP, which called the Pakistan demand anti- national in 1944, supported the Pakistan demand in 1946. Some Dalits requested that they be made part of Pakistan.
    In 1999, Human Rights Watch (New York) published a report on the Dalits (literally broken or oppressed people) of India, a population that now numbers about 160 million. Before the growth of a self-conscious Dalit movement a few decades ago, the terms most commonly used to designate this population were ‘Untouchable’ and “Harijan” (“Children of God,” a term used by Gandhi). Human Rights Watch found that the situation of Dalits was deplorable and called their condition “hidden apartheid.” Despite India’s very progressive laws, HRW found that Dalits do not enjoy the protections to which they are entitled.

    “If there are any people more oppressed than Dalits,” Rashidi notes, “I don’t want to see it. Nothing compares to that.” Ken Cooper, who was bureau chief for the Washington Post in New Delhi, notes that “as an African American I used to think American racism was the most stifling obsessive system of oppression in the world, with the exception of what was South African apartheid. After my stay in India, I am sure the caste system was and continues to be worse—it has religious sanction and has been ingrained for 3000 years.” Comparative oppression is not a useful exercise, since each society seems to conjure up its own form of barbarity. Nevertheless, both Rashidi and Cooper make the case quite forcefully that Dalit life is painfully hard.

    Little that HRW catalogued is new to either the Dalits or to the many agencies and political organizations who have been at work for social justice in India. As with social justice work elsewhere, there are many factors that prevent the emancipation of the Dalits. The main causes of atrocities against Dalits, the Indian government acknowledges, are “disputes and conflicts arising from land, wages, bonded labour and indebtedness.” Without widespread economic change, any movement for social justice will falter.

    The government looked on refugee relief as a matter of charity, while the refugees increasingly demanded such relief as a matter of right.Are these government documents better read as an example of straightforward class prejudice? Did the lower-level personnel of the State, who dealt with the refugees daily, share the attitudes of their superiors? Even if a few words were common, State and people spoke different languages from which the dialects (if not the dialectics) of modern West Bengal's politics evolved. The general sense of rights among the public was considerably strengthened by refugee struggles. This is a debatable matter in our society where (despite much talk couched in the language of rights) a sense of entitlement is still weak. Even today, it depends more on political power and social connections, than on notions of citizenship.

    Dandakaranya is the burning evidence that the suffering and struggle for life and livlihood for Dalit Bengali Refugees have to continue infinite!

    Dear Palash Chadra, Ujwal and Shridamda

    Find a report on the situation by a national fact finding committee comprising shri b d sharma, social scientists from delhi, hyderabad and khammam, lawyers among others

    Looking forward to meeting Ujawalda and Shriramda shortly

    FYI
    Bharath

    All India Fact-finding Report on Polavaram Dam Project

    Preliminary Report

    An all India Fact-finding team comprising Dr. BD Sharma, Former National Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Tribes, Dr. Jayashankar, former Vice-chancellor, Kakatiya University, Dr. I. Thirumali, Reader in History, Sri Venkateswara College, University of Delhi, G N Saibaba, Lecturer in English, University of Delhi, Shirish Medhi, Social Activist from Mumbai, Dr. Gopinath, Eminent Cardiologist, Andhra Pradesh, Rona Wilson, Research Scholar, Jawahar Lal Nehru University, Ajay Mishra, Reporter, Sunday Post (Hindi), Suresh Kumar, Advocate, Hyderabad, Ch. Prabhakar, Advocate, Hyderabad and Ravichandra, Teacher, AP Government Residential Schools. The team toured across 9 mandals in the districts of Khammam, East and West Godavari districts that are to be affected by the Polavaram Dam Project between 3 nd March and 6th March, 2007.

    The team spent 4 days in and around the site of the proposed Polavaram Dam touring extensively in all nine Dam-affected mandals. First the members arrived at Hyderabad on the 2 March, 2007. The team proceeded to Bhadrachalam on the following day and from there it divided into batches to conduct surveys on all the mandals. It had extensive discussions with the people of various villages and sarpanches. It also met the various organizations formed to fight against the question of displacement of lives and livelihoods. The team felt the need for further extensive studies in the affected areas at regular intervals taking into consideration the enormity of the situation with the threat of displacement of vast sections of the people.

    Our findings:

    1. Damning the people; damning the procedures; damning the law
    The work of digging of canals by the government of Andhra Pradesh started even before permission is accorded to construction of the Dam. The modus operandi of the government so far without any procedures and norms spending crores for digging the canals have forced one to believe that ultimately it is going to serve the interests of the contractor lobby.

    2. No Permission accorded so far from any government agency

    The land acquisition has begun even before it could be known whether the projects would get permission or not from the Central Water Commission, the Forest Department, the Environment Department, the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes and other relevant departments and agencies. No permission has been so far given by the Central Water Commission. In fact the Supreme Court had asked the state of Andhra Pradesh to comply with the directives of the Central Water Commission. Contrary to this the AP government has been filing contradictory statements with different government institutions from which it has to get the necessary and mandatory clearance.

    3. Gram Sabhas bypassed: Politics of manipulation and coercion

    The Government has not gone to the people in the Scheduled areas which are mostly the project affected area. They have not been consulted nor their due consent been taken before proceeding with the acquisition of land for the construction of the dam. The entire area that will submerge when the dam gets finally constructed comes under provision of the 5 th schedule of the constitution. In most of the villages the mandatory Gram Sabha meetings did not take place to discuss and deliberate on the issue of Polavaram. Wherever it has happened it was facilitated under the shadow of heavy police deployment with a battery of government officials threatening the villagers with dire consequences. The Gram Sabhas of these areas are the supreme decision making bodies. Without the consent of these bodies any other notification of any government institution—including the aforementioned bodies—stands null and void.

    When in Maredubaka village in Kukunoor Mandal, people passed resolutions against Polavaram dam and the R & R package offered by the government those resolutions were ignored, suppressed and manipulated. Some Mandal Praja Parishads (MPP) also have passed resolutions against the construction of the dam but time and again over the last one year the officials have not accepted or recorded the written resolutions sent by the MPPs as told by Kantepale Raju, Sarpanch of Maredubaka and also by the sarpanch of Amaravaram of Kukkunoor mandal.

    The District Collector is not supposed to sit in the Gram Sabha. But in Paidipakka village in Polavaram mandal the district collector Mr. Luv Aggarwal sat in the Gram Sabha along with the RDO, BDO, MRO, PO and others and a huge posse of armed police force at the background. There he told the people that the government can't pay more than 1.3 lakhs and the villagers had no other option but to leave. This village has a sizeable section of the non-tribals and since they don't have any legal entitlement they are the main targets of coercion. Once they budge the tribals can follow.

    Secretly tribals are called individually to the RDO offices and are threatened to sign the papers. They are told that they have to inevitably move out and that is no way out for them. Those villagers who are refusing to budge have been targeted by striking off their ration cards, cutting of the power supply to the villages and also demolishing their roads.

    It is evident that the government of Andhra Pradesh has been keen to hide facts—from the people of the affected areas in particular and the society at large—than the things that they have so far revealed about the various facets of the project. It is intriguing that why the government is operating under complete secrecy when it claims that the project is the answer to all the water and power problems faced by the state.

    5. R & R Package: Old tales of Divide and Rule, Secrecy and Mystery

    The compensation package offered by the government varied from village to village, tribal to non-tribal and last but not the least, the nature of the land holdings. It has more loopholes than concrete proposals on paper. In many cases it operates by word of mouth than through any documented intervention. It is the good old strategy of divide and rule by manipulating on the vulnerability of the targeted population.

    The people of the project affected area, whether tribal or non-tribal are unaware of the rehabilitation package which is touted by the AP government as one of the best packages ever made in the world! Yet no sarpanch of the affected villages could give us a copy of the R&R package spoke volumes of the secrecy and mystery behind the politics of R & R. It should be noted that since 1947 not a single R & R package of any major displacement has been fulfilled by the government.

    Some of the absentee landlords in the area who are non-tribals will definitely get a good compensation many times higher than what the government has so far offered to the common tribal masses. One glaring example is that of Mr. Totakura Venkattappaiah who owns 500 acres of fertile land at Amaravaram village in Kukkunoor mandal. He and his family lives in Hyderabad. Most of this land from the 500 acres belongs to the Koya tribals. The so-called compensation will come in the name of the tribals who have been living as agricultural labourers but the money will go to the coffers of the absentee landlord!

    The government also has used different tactics to lure the people in favour of rehabilitation by giving them packages which are at best illusory. For instance, in Kondukota village which comprises of 50 percent Koyas and 50 percent Malas (SC) there has been neither official notification nor survey. Yet the officials have approached the people with various packages. They have offered them to hold land at the project affected area ( i.e. their present place of stay) as well as the newly promised location of rehabilitation! The local MLA took the Empowering Committee appointed by the Supreme Court to only those places where the people have ostensibly supported the projects.

    6. Compensation amounts released in two villages: Administration's fraud and People's anguish

    In two villages Vinjaram (Kukkunoor mandal) and Rudramakota (Boorgampadu mandal) the first acts of acquisition of land for project took place. The compensation was released to the acquired cultivated and fertile lands. The team came across a big group of people at Rudramakota, Velerupadu mandal, sitting in the local temple and settling the dispute that has surfaced after the cheques were encashed and the actual money was being distributed. The size of the amount was decided by the village elders. Thus Kanthi Reddi Punnamma, a 65 year old woman got 58000 rupees. This was in return of the 2 acres of fertile land that was relinquished permanently for the dam. She and her family lived off this fertile land for many generations. For her 2 acres Punnamma was given 230000 rupees. At the end of the day Punnamma was left with a meager 58000 after dividing the amount with her sons and another major stake holder the local Cooperative Bank which had the lion's share: a good 50 percent of the total amount! This 50 percent covers the agricultural loans which were actually struck off by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh last year! The officials (MRO, MDO, Collector) promised the villagers that the amount of the loans would not be deducted from the compensation amount. This was one of the main agreements between the villagers and the government before they agreed for the compensation to part with their land. But once the compensation was awarded, all the banks queued up with their knives to demand their pound of flesh. Only the landlords who had the land under false names had the last laugh. The villagers reported with anguish how the land records were manipulated and outsiders got the benefits.

    7. Deceit and domination of the people of Telengana

    Yet another act of deceit and domination over the people of Telengana. More than 80 percent of the water of Godavari flows through Telengana. Significantly, the mammoth project has little to offer when it comes to water/power sharing to the already drought prone region that Telengana is. It is natural for the people of Telengana to suspect the unwarranted haste shown by the Andhra Pradesh government to push through the project flouting all norms and procedures before the formation of the Telengana State. They strongly believe that the formation of the Telengana state would be an impediment to the Polavaram project and hence against the interest of the Andhra Pradesh government.

    8. Protests prevented through repression and coercion

    The people who have protested against the construction have been threatened by the officials belonging to the office of the collector, the RDO, BDO, MRO, PO etc. The people who sat on Dharna from the Chegondipally village in Polavaram mandal have been charged of treason. Mr. Sonam Raju of the same village had to spend three months in the Rajamundry prison and warrant has been issued against five of his fellow villagers for allegedly burning the huts at the construction site of the spill way. Another Mr. Bangu Anil Kumar of Kondu Kota village was also arrested and released after 17 days for opposing the project.

    9. Polavaram: Another 'Modern Temple' of Colossal Waste

    The Polavaram project with its projected costs and benefits is a colossal waste of public money. It would destroy the rich flora and fauna of the forests of the Eastern Ghats on either side of the river Godavari in the catchment areas of the dam. It will uproot the lives and livelihoods of some of the oldest tribal communities—the Koyas and Konda Reddys—who are the inhabitants of these regions. Even according to the official estimates 236000 people living in 276 villages would be displaced by the dam in Andhra Pradesh (including a few of them in Chhattisgarh and Orissa). About 50 percent as per government statistics belong to the scheduled tribes and 15 percent to the scheduled castes.

    All the 9 mandals that will submerge come under the scheduled areas. In fact the Polavaram project displaces the largest number of people—more than 2 lakh tribals among them—as well as some of richest of biodiversity in the world. Tribals cannot live in non-forest areas. They will lose their constitutionally guaranteed rights under the scheduled area, if they are rehabilitated. They will lose their traditional strength and culture outside their natural habitat. They are aware of this and they steadfastly refuse to move away from their villages and forests.

    The ownership of land and forest produce is not fixed in these areas. Traditional sharing methods are more persistent. No R & R package will do justice to the tribal communities here.
    It is amazing and at the same time unfortunate and disappointing to note that the media and the civil society have written very little about this! It is unequivocally the largest displacement and destruction of natural flora and fauna in Post-47 India.

    As recommendations what flow out evidently from the initial findings are that:
    The government of Andhra Pradesh should immediately come out with a White Paper on all issues related to the Polavaram Dam Project. All construction work including that of canals should be stopped forthwith till a proper review is made after a discussion on the White Paper by the people of the affected areas, civil society and experts of peoples' organizations.
    The President of India through the Governor of Andhra Pradesh should seek a report on the impact of the project on the tribals in the area as per the 5th Schedule of the Constitution of India. Such a report should be made by experts who have worked on the issues of the tribals including various laws related with the 5th Schedule. Till the Presidential review is done all construction work related to the dam should be suspended.
    The Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy package announced by the Andhra Pradesh government and the ground realities of the use of force and coercion by the local administration on the people in all the 9 mandals should be enquired into by an independent committee comprising of experts who have knowledge on the various aspects of tribal life and livelihood.
    The central government should initiate immediately a process to study the alternative plans for utilizing the waters in Godavari as well as other rivers and tributaries in Andhra Pradhesh made by expert committees and peoples' organizations.
    A judicious and acceptable plan to redistribute the waters in the river Godavari among the Andhra, Telengana and Rayalaseema regions.
    An all India Fact-finding team:
    1. Dr. BD Sharma, Former National Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Tribes
    2. Dr. Jayashankar, former Vice-chancellor, Kakatiya University, Warangal, Andhra Pradesh
    3. Dr. I. Thirumali, Reader in History, University of Delhi
    4. G N Saibaba, Lecturer in English, University of Delhi
    5. Dr Medhi, Social Activist from Mumbai
    6. Dr. Gopinath, Eminent Cardiologist, Khammam, Andhra Pradesh
    7. Rona Wilson, Research Scholar, Jawahar Lal Nehru University, New Delhi
    8. Ajay Mishra, Reporter, Sunday Post (Hindi), New Delhi
    9. Suresh Kumar, Advocate, Hyderabad
    10.Ch. Prabhakar, Advocate, Hyderabad
    11.Ravichandra, Teacher, AP Government Residential School, Hyderabad

    That this is not an isolated observation is testified to by a report on practices of untouchability published a few years ago in a well-known Calcutta weekly (Gupta 1977: 48-50). The report vividly brought home the persistence of caste discrimination in rural West Bengal, Debu Mukhi, a hanri by caste, of Rohini village in Jhargram sub-division of Midnapur district mentioned that inspite of the much publicized literacy campaign in the district their children were kept segregated in school. He said, ‘Teachers tell our children to bring their own asaans (small mats) and they are asked to sit separately in class.’

    But spatial segregation in school or residential segregation in the village is not the only discriminations they face, as Gupta learned from the doms and hanris (two scheduled castes) of Rohini. For many years after Independence, they had to wear bells around their neck whenever they ventured outside their locality (para) to forewarn the upper castes of their approach! Though these practices have waned others persist. The doms and hanris are not allowed inside the homes of the upper castes and if they stray inside then the premises have to be washed and plastered afresh with cow dung. Their touch is still considered polluting and for the brahmin, baidyas and kayasthas, a purificatory bath is mandatory on contact with them.

    The scheduled castes are not allowed to draw water from wells and tubewells belonging to the upper castes. They are only allowed to use the public tubewells sunk by the government. Though they play the dhak (drum) during the Durga Puja or other festivals, they are denied the right to enter temples or offer prayers. At ceremonial feasts they are treated like scavengers and offered the leftovers in soiled leaf plates. As Jaladhar Patar of the same village puts it, ‘We and the dogs eat together after everyone else has eaten.’ And when the dogs have to be shooed away, the upper castes call out ‘shoo hanri’!

    Upper castes in the village do not admit to the persistence of untouchability but concede after persistent enquiry that isolated instances may have occurred. They maintain that it is the filth and squalor of the lower caste lifestyle that sets them apart. The stigma attached to status is deftly displaced upon questions of hygiene.

    Last year another instance of caste discrimination came to light from another place. In Pursurah village of Hooghly district, a scheduled caste school teacher’s wife was fined Rs 8,000 because she entered the local Kali temple to offer prayers after bathing in the temple pond. Subhama Sheet was singled out for her misdemeanor by the village elders for her caste status. The fine imposed was necessary to perform the purificatory rituals (Biswas 2001: 22).

    More than five decades after Independence, with nearly two and half of them under Left Front governance, caste discrimination has not disappeared. Yet caste discrimination is not a major public issue in West Bengal. Embedded in the customary practices of the civic community it persists unobtrusively. Caste is not the principal conduit of political power and contestation in the state. Transgression of caste norms invites social sanctions but not violent retribution. Caste based pogroms and massacres are not frequent. A quick review of the historical reasons as to the absence of caste as the means of exclusion will reveal the historically constituted nature of discrimination.

    There are certain particularities to the caste structure in West Bengal. The upper castes: brahmin, kayastha and baidyas, who as a result of the Permanent Settlement (1793) came to control most of the land, functioned largely as absentee landlords. Land was a productive asset that yielded substantial rent. But they were neither directly engaged in supervising agricultural production nor increasing productivity. As residents of urban areas in Calcutta or the district towns, these upper caste landlords became detached from agricultural pursuits.

    These castes had the opportunity to acquire English education in urban educational institutions and develop a stranglehold on jobs and professions (Mitra 1995: 20). The high correlation between literacy and engagement in higher professions is clearly manifest from Table 1. The head start of the upper castes in education enabled them to monopolize jobs and professions, so much that the upper caste bhadraloks have since exercised undisputed authority in the public realm. As Mitra (1995: 21) put it, ‘Indeed, so absolute is the ascendancy of the top castes in Bengal that the subordinate castes take their subordinate status almost as a divine dispensation.’

    In the rural areas, during British rule, the dominant peasant middle castes were too dispersed and disparate to pose a challenge to bhadralok hegemony. The 1931 Census enumeration of castes in the West Bengal districts reveals that middle caste groups were localized in particular districts or contiguous areas but were not distributed over a wide area. The rajbangshis (later to be classified as scheduled caste) were preponderant in the North Bengal districts of Dinajpur, Jalpaiguri, Darjeeling and Cooch Behar. In Cooch Behar they comprised 53.56% of the population, while in Jalpaiguri they were 33.68% and in Dinajpur they formed 20.53%. Dependent on rainfed agriculture, these districts were the least developed. Other than plantations and orchards, there was little sign of industrial development. For the rajbangshis, opportunities of higher education were limited in the region and Calcutta was too far and inaccessible.

    The mahishyas were prominent in the south-western districts of Midnapore (31.56%), Howrah (24.92%), Hooghly (15.92%) and 24 Parganas (12.14%), and present in Nadia (6.49%) and Murshidabad (5.48%). The kurmimahatos were largely confined to Manbhum (17.84%) from which has been carved the present district of Purulia, while the aguris/ugra kshatriyas, another dominant peasant middle caste, were only to be found in Burdwan district.

    A section from these castes who became proprietary tenants and succeeded in educating their children, engaged in social reform of their castes. In the 1920s when the non-cooperation movement of Gandhi found a resonance in the rural areas of South-West Bengal, it was these middle castes like mahishyas who formed the bulwark of the movements. Engagement with the Congress party gave a boost to the reformist stirrings among these castes. But none of the middle castes had a statewide presence to exercise social dominance. Their localized presence, lack of English education and professional advancement left them far behind the upper caste bhadraloks (Chatterjee 1982).

    The challenge to bhadralok hegemony that the emergent Muslim middle class posed in the 1940s was dissolved with the partition of Bengal, as the landowning Muslim peasantry left for Pakistan. Chatterjee (1982:101) has noted how even though the Muslim landowning peasantry was akin to the dominant peasant middle castes of other parts of India in their behaviour, their challenge to the bhadraloks acquired the stigma of communalism.

    In his own words, ‘Muslim conversion has a great deal to do with the rather unique caste structure in Bengal, because a very substantial bulk of the peasantry who would otherwise have formed the large middle caste, became Muslim. In many respects, both before and after partition the Muslim landowning peasantry in both halves of Bengal have behaved much like the dominant peasant middle castes in other parts of India, but because of religious "communalism" this has taken completely different ideological and organizational forms in undivided and later divided Bengal, especially in terms of the hold of the substantial landed peasantry over the Muslim small and landless in eastern Bengal’ (Chatterjee 1982:101).

    Like the intermediate caste dominant peasants, the scheduled castes were also too dispersed and fragmented to pose any challenge to the upper caste bhadralok. In the wake of partition, the most organized among them, the namasudras who were mostly to be found in the East Bengal districts, migrated to West Bengal in large numbers. Many of them settled in the border districts of Nadia and 24 Parganas but later migrants who sought refuge after 1964 were resettled in Andaman Islands and Dandakaranya in Madhya Pradesh.

    The 1940s were turbulent times in Bengal. Large scale political mobilizations and strikes tested British governance sorely. But the large scale mobilization of the sharecroppers in both North and South Bengal known as the Tebhaga movement by the Bengal Provincial Kisan Sabha left an enduring legacy. The Tebhaga struggles began in the North Bengal districts a couple of years before Independence and continued especially in the South Bengal districts after 1947. The struggle for two-thirds share of the produce by the sharecroppers set in place the discourse of class for agrarian struggles. It was able to displace any vestiges of the caste discourse for peasant struggle.

    http://72.14.235.104/search?q=cache:3kaiImDiA1cJ:www.india-seminar.com/2001/508/508%2520anjan%2520ghosh.htm+Dalit+Refugee+movement+in+Bengal&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=18&gl=in

    This was the impact of collective leadership and peoples movement where tribals took leadership and faced the Government and RTZ in a non violent struggle. I try to visualize the mining situation of Kendujhar and what is going to happen in 10 to 15 years. I take leaders (men and women) to Badamapara area, where Tata has already completed mining. They see the real situation after mining. The natural streams have dried, forests are destroyed, tribal people have left their native l

  • International Conspiracy, Latest Logic of Repression by Marxist Gestapo Mechanism!

    International Conspiracy, Latest Logic of Repression by Marxist Gestapo Mechanism!
    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Buddhadeb Now sees International conspiracy! What for? Is it a Marxist government at all? Does this government undermine US interests or it has decided to overthrow the Zionist Brahminical system? Who is opposing his brand of capitalist Development?
    Mrs Indiran gandhi was most quoted to warn of international conspiracies whenever she faced any challange within!
    Mind you, this is the latest logic of repression by Marxist Gestapo Mechanism!
    International conspiracy to destabilse India, says Buddhadeb while India's ruling Congress party looked set to lose power in the tiny western tourist state of Goa on Thursday after a group of legislators withdrew their support to the coalition. Expressing concern at terrorist activities in West Bengal like last year's blast at a railway station in Jalpaiguri that killed eight people, Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee today said this was part of an international conspiracy to destablise India from within. Buddhadev Bhattacharjee today admitted that his Left Front government was not free from corruption and his `do-it-now` slogan given a year ago could not overnight bring transparency in the administration.
    A total of 40 people were killed in political clashes in West Bengal last year, Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee told the assembly today.
    The 40 included 24 CPI-M activists, three members each of the Trinamool Congress and congress and 10 from parties like the Gorkha National Liberational Front and Jharkhand Party, he said while replying to a question.
    A total of 3,998 arrests were made in connection with the clashes and 19 cases were registered, he said.
    West Bengal`s opposition Trinamool Congress today rejected Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacherjee`s apology and appeal to lift its boycott of the assembly shortly after he expressed regret for his alleged derogatory remarks about the leader of the opposition.The political heat over farmland acquisition issue, sought to be cooled down during the recent parleys between Marxist veteran Jyoti Basu and Trinamool chief Mamata Banerjee, is still raging in West Bengal with the latter's decision to boycott the chief minister for his alleged derogatory remarks in the Assembly recently.
    The Basu-Mamata talks, which generated hope of an early restoration of peace in trouble-torn Singur and Nandigram as also ensuring normal relations between the government and the opposition, received a setback nearly a month after over the Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya's comments against the opposition leader in the state Assembly.
    The Trinamool Congress' decision to boycott all House proceedings where the Chief Minister will be present, has come at a time when the state Assembly is on its extended budget session and that is likely to continue till end of this month.
    The chances of rapprochement between the ruling Left Front and the main opposition Trinamool Congress over the controversial farmland acquisition issue had brightened after the former Chief Minister's diplomacy. The exercise however, received the jolt with the Chief Minister's comments on opposition leader Partha Chatterjee.
    During his reply to Home (police) department's budget speech last week, the Chief Minister made a remark against Chatterjee, questioning his power and liberty to speak in his own party without fear.
    It was a matter of concern that explosives used to trigger the blast at Belakoba Railway Station were brought from outside and local people were involved in the attack, he told the assembly in reply to a question.
    Terrorists were active along the Western and the Eastern borders. "If we look at Pakistan and Afganistan, we can see what shape terrorism is taking on the subcontinent," he said.
    Asked whether the US had a hand in this conspiracy, Bhattacharjee replied that the US had a role wherever terrorist activities were taking place across the world.
    "I cannot say specifically whether the US has a hand here, but there is no doubt that they play some role in the subcontinent," he said in reply to a supplementary question.
    Bhattacharjee said the state government was working in tandem with the Centre to combat terrorist activities. The danger remained despite stepped up vigil, he said.
    Noting that information was regularly exchanged among intelligence agencies of the state, the Centre, the Army and BSF, he said in some cases, arrests were made on the basis of information provided by the central agencies.
    Bhattacharjee, who also holds the home portfolio, admitted there were some weakness in the state intelligence agencies.
    Replying to a question on the Kamtapur Liberation Organisation (KLO), he said after the operation by Bhutan's army against rebels sheltering in the kingdom, KLO activities had stopped for some time and the militants took shelter in a neighbouring country.
    The KLO was now trying to re-group in Cooch Behar, Jalpaiguri and Siliguri in North Bengal, where vigil had been stepped up. The KLO problem would persist because of the Ulfa in Assam, he said.
    Claiming that the KLO and other groups did not have the people's support, he said the state government had initiated a process to bring KLO militants back to the mainstream and around 150 of them had returned. But other groups like the Kamtapur People's Party were coordinating among themselves.
    To another question, he said the state government would provide compensation of Rs 50,000 to families of the eight persons killed in the blast at Belakoba Railway Station. But this was getting delayed due to a complicated procedure, he said.
    Asked whether the state had sought more security forces from the Centre, Bhattacharjee said: "We have asked for more forces keeping in mind the situation in Jammu and Kashmir and the Western border."

    Undersecretary of State Nicholas Burns said on Wednesday that a just-completed nuclear deal with India complies with U.S. law, but some experts doubted that, and lawmakers said the agreement could face a rough road in the U.S. Congress.
    \
    Congressional sources and other experts told Reuters the agreement reached last week appears to go a long way toward meeting the demands of India's nuclear establishment, giving New Delhi rights only accorded to key U.S. allies Japan and the European Union.
    "The administration is going to call this a success even though from policy and legal perspectives, there are major problems," said one congressional source, who spoke anonymously because he learned details of the deal on a confidential basis.
    The pact, approved by India's cabinet on Wednesday, would allow India access to U.S. nuclear fuel and equipment for the first time in 30 years, even though New Delhi refused to join non-proliferation pacts and tested nuclear weapons.
    "We're very satisfied because we know the agreement is well within the bounds of the Hyde Act," Burns told reporters after testifying before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.
    The Hyde Act, approved by Congress in December, created a unique exception to U.S. export law to allow nuclear cooperation with India. The just-completed agreement, called a 123 agreement after a section of the U.S. Atomic Energy Act, spells out technical details for that nuclear cooperation.
    Communist Buddha of West Bengal confesses corruption but does any one know how much they have milked from expatriate Indians (NRIs)
    Media Release
    Jul. 26, 2007

    Countless money has been stolen by the West Bengal communists from expatraite Indians who tried to set up industries in West Bangal but did not understand only bribes work with these communists.
    These communists are in bed with Indian oligarchs like Tata, Birla, Ambanis who feed them well with money. These communists will do anything to get hold of money. They preach laziness in west Bengal. The approach to the expatriate Indian is simple - you have it, I do noy. So your's is mine.
    When it comes to Indian oligarchs, the comminists are straightened top to the bottom. Thge oligarchs treat these communists as street dogs. They throw a some crores of Rupees (million of dollars) and ask them to secure the oligrachs'' interests at the cost of common people and poor farmers.
    The communists are now in bed with Intalian born Sonia Gandhi's congress party too. That has happened because Indian oligrachs want that to happen.
    http://www.indiadaily.com/editorial/17692.asp
    CIA, ISI had plan for militancy in Punjab: Ex-RAW official

    The US had an "interest" in Punjab militancy and hatched a "covert action plan" in collusion with Pakistan`s ISI in 1971 to encourage a separatist movement in the border state, says a new book by a former top Indian intelligence officer. The American "interest" in Punjab militancy lasted for a little more than a decade through the seventies and eighties after the covert plan was initiated by the Richard Nixon administration, says the book.
    http://www.zeenews.com/znnew/index.asp
    Disinvestment white paper in next session, no change in policy

    New Del: The much-delayed status report on disinvestment process during the previous NDA government will be tabled in parliament in the coming monsoon session.
    The white paper on disinvestment since 1999, which has been in the making since the UPA regime took over, would finally be tabled after sustained pressure of the parliamentary standing committee on finance.
    "Standing committee on finance has been repeatedly insisting on the government to place a white paper in Parliament on disinvestment. It is nothing but a chronological development of the entire scenario of disinvestment since 1999. It does not mean we are changing policy," Information and Broadcasting Minister Priyaranjan Dasmunsi told newsmen after the Cabinet meeting that cleared the paper.
    He said the national common minimum programme has made it abundantly clear that UPA coalition shall not encourage nor implement and support any strategic sale and that policy stands as it was.
    After the document is placed in Parliament, there can be a debate on it. The Parliament is meeting for monsoon session between August 10 and September 14.
    Since 1999, government has given up the controlling stake in 12 central public sector companies apart from selling hotel properties owned by India Tourism Development Corporation and Air India's subsidiary Hotel Corporation of India.
    The government has raised more than Rs 10,350 crore since NDA government took office from strategic sales.
    Special Economic Zone
    A Special Economic Zone (SEZ) is a geographical region that has economic laws that are more liberal than a country's typical economic laws. The category 'SEZ' covers a broad range of more specific zone types, including Free Trade Zones (FTZ), Export Processing Zones (EPZ), Free Zones (FZ), Industrial Estates (IE), Free Ports, Urban Enterprise Zones and others. Usually the goal of an SEZ structure is to increase foreign investment. One of the earliest and the most famous Special Economic Zones were founded by the government of the People's Republic of China under Deng Xiaoping in the early 1980s. The most successful Special Economic Zone in China, Shenzhen, has developed from a small village into a city with a population over 10 million within 20 years. Following the Chinese examples, Special Economic Zones have been established in several countries, including Brazil, Pakistan, India, Iran, Jordan, Poland, Kazakhstan, the Philippines,Russia, and Ukraine. North Korea has also attempted this to a degree, but failed. Currently, Puno, Peru has been slated to become a "Zona Ecomomica" by its president Alan Garcia. A single SEZ can contain multiple 'specific' zones within its boundaries. The two most prominent examples of this layered approach are Subic Bay in the Philippines and the Aqaba Special Economic Zone in Jordan.
    According to World Bank estimates, as of 2007 there are more than 3,000 projects taking place in SEZs in 120 countries worldwide.
    SEZs have been implemented using a variety of institutional structures across the world ranging from fully public (government operator, government developer, government regulator) to 'fully' private (private operator, private developer, public regulator). In many cases, public sector operators and developers act as quasi-government agencies in that they have a pseudo-corporate institutional structure and have budgetary autonomy. SEZs are often developed under a Public-Private-Partnership arrangement, in which the public sector provides some level of support (provision of off-site infrastructure, equity investment, soft loans, bond issues, etc) to enable a private sector developer to obtain a reasonable rate of return on the project (typically 10-20% depending on risk levels).
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEZ

    Development and Technology
    ( The Statesman, June 29, 2007)
    http://www.thestatesman.net/page.news.php?clid=4&theme=&usrsess=1&id=161080
    We can modernise our agriculture through innovations in cooperation with our research organisations. And technology should disturb the environment and the ecosystem the least, suggests MANAS JOARDAR
    Incidents of brutal atrocity in Singur and Nandigram are quite fresh in our memory. In context of the present agitation against land acquisition and industrialisation drive here, it is worthwhile to recollect the plight of the English workers in Britain during the early years of industrial revolution. A large pool of displaced farmers and farm workers was forced to leave villages and joined factories as industrial workers. They were an extremely exploited lot. The Saddler Committee, constituted on the issue, made the round of a horrible working condition of the workers.
    China with an enviable GDP growth record after implementing quite a few industrialisation projects under the SEZ scheme with tax and labour rules favouring the industrialists, has been facing agitation in recent times by millions of displaced farmers and jobless factory workers. Environmental pollution is exceedingly high. Of the twenty most polluted cities of the world, sixteen are in China. With labour-scarce modern technology, benefit of industrialisation is being enjoyed by the privileged section only. Inequality is rapidly growing there. Gini Index has jumped from 35 in 1990 to 45 in 2003. For America, the figures are 35 in 1970 and 41 in 2003.
    Policy formulators of our country, overzealous to imitate the China way, seem to have rubbished the darker side of the SEZ experience of China. A top politician of UP reportedly received a new plane as return gift from a leading industrialist who (courtesy - the politician) was offered one thousand hectares of agricultural land under the SEZ scheme.
    In the post-industrial revolution ages, spectacular advancement of science took place in the Western world. This led to new technological innovations that sought to make people’s life more comfortable. Industries readily took them up to produce consumer goods. Overthrowing all religious barriers upon gluttony and greed, people of the West jumped upon raising their standard of living. Added to colonial exploitation, industrial development helped them accumulate more wealth.
    Rabindranath Tagore, during his pretty long tour of some western countries in the 1920s, was overwhelmed by their scientific achievements, but at the same time their insatiable greed pained him utterly.
    Apart from various branches of science and technology, tremendous progress has been made in developing destructive war weapons too, by trading which the industrialised countries are getting richer and richer. Ironically, the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council – a body to ensure global peace – are five prominent weapon traders too. They export over three-fourths of all conventional weapons.
    As a fall-out of industrialisation and urbanisation, forests and wetlands are being destroyed. Stock of fossil fuel and other minerals is getting exhausted. The level of underground water is steadily going down. The ozone layer at the stratosphere is getting depleted, making way for almost uninterrupted entry of harmful ultraviolet rays from the sun. Tropical rainforest, once considered as the lungs of the planet, generating over 20 per cent of oxygen, is being rapidly destroyed by the wood and paper-pulp traders of the West. Air and water are being heavily polluted.
    Following a series of events the world over, it is now almost conclusively established that global warming caused by greenhouse gases (GHG), comprising about 77 per cent of carbon dioxide, is not a myth. In an article published a few years back in the British journal Nature, it was estimated that over one million species of plants and animals, one-fourth of all life in the world, would be extinct within 2050 due to man-made climate change.
    During a recent sitting in Bangkok, the Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reported that emission of GHG has gone up by 70 per cent between 1970 and 2004. Carbon dioxide has increased by 80 per cent. Increase of GHG during the period was maximum in the power generation sector – about 145 per cent, next was vehicular emission – 120 per cent, followed by industrial emission – 65 per cent.
    Through globalisation, policies are being so formulated as to help the rich countries pile up wealth for lifting their hedonistic life-style without caring for the other world where more than 2.5 billion people live in extreme poverty. More than 10 million children die each year before attaining the age of five. Around one billion people lack access to safe water and some 1.75 million die each year due to cholera, dysentery and other diarrhoeal diseases The richest 10 per cent own 85 per cent of the global assets, and the bottom half only 1 per cent. The inequality between the rich and the poor is on the rise in countries where 80 per cent of the global population lives. The IPCC recommended downsizing of lifestyle. The richer section can cut down on use of natural resources and reduce pollution substantially.
    In 2005, Nelson Mandela observed: “Massive poverty and obscene inequality are such terrible scourges of our times – times in which the world boasts of breathtaking advances in science, technology, industry and wealth accumulation – that they have to rank alongside slavery and apartheid as social evils.” The liberalisation policy under the structural adjustment programme of the World Bank, has been depriving the Indian farmers. During the past 12/13 years, over 1,50,000 of them have committed suicide.
    In formulating development strategy for our country, we must keep in mind that the western model may not work here. Our historical tradition and geographical location are different. We can modernise, as we have done through the ages, our agriculture through innovations in cooperation with our research organisations. We must put stress on development of the underprivileged section. The technology should disturb the environment and the ecosystem the least. We should aim at a sustainable development paradigm.
    Much water and electricity can be saved by avoiding wastage and by using more efficient appliances. Dependence on fossil fuel has to be reduced. We must say “No” to nuclear power. Pollution control measures need to be strictly monitored.
    With huge solar and wind energy available here, we should fully utilise them. Small hydropower is another source of clean energy which can be generated with natural falls, run-of-river and back water. Quite a few such installations are working successfully. Biofuels derived from agricultural residues and the seeds of neem, jatropha, ratanjyot and some other trees may play an important role in the transport sector. Such efforts have already started through self-help groups in Puducherry and Dehradun with technical know-how from the IIT, Delhi.
    About five lakh women and children die each year due to diseases related to smoke emitted during cooking. Dr Karve has devised a bio-gas plant that needs only vegetable residues, waste food, green leaves, etc. It requires only 1 kg of feedstock against 40 kg of cow-dung. The digestion process is also quick – 48 hours instead of 40 days. More than seven hundred such units have already been installed in Maharashtra.
    Sulabh Public Toilet founded by Dr Pathak in 1970, has been quite a successful sanitation device. It has been further modified to make it more suitable for rural areas. The Centrally sponsored Rural Sanitation Programme, supported by UNICEF, is another low-cost project providing proper sanitation facility.
    Besides all this, micro-irrigation, rain water harvesting and, hopefully, many more small innovations shall work wonders through community participation, if, of course, political will is not lacking.
    (The author, a former member of the Senate and Syndicate, is a retired teacher of Applied Physics, Calcutta University)
    India was one of the first in Asia to recognize the effectiveness of the Export Processing Zone (EPZ) model in promoting exports, with Asia’s first EPZ set up in Kandla in 1965. With a view to overcome the shortcomings experienced on account of the multiplicity of controls and clearances; absence of world-class infrastructure, and an unstable fiscal regime and with a view to attract larger foreign investments in India, the Special Economic Zones (SEZs) Policy was announced in April 2000.
    This policy intended to make SEZs an engine for economic growth supported by quality infrastructure complemented by an attractive fiscal package, both at the Centre and the State level, with the minimum possible regulations. SEZs in India functioned from 1.11.2000 to 09.02.2006 under the provisions of the Foreign Trade Policy and fiscal incentives were made effective through the provisions of relevant statutes.
    To instill confidence in investors and signal the Government’s commitment to a stable SEZ policy regime and with a view to impart stability to the SEZ regime thereby generating greater economic activity and employment through the establishment of SEZs, a comprehensive draft SEZ Bill prepared after extensive discussions with the stakeholders. A number of meetings were held in various parts of the country both by the Minister for Commerce and Industry as well as senior officials for this purpose. The Special Economic Zones Act, 2005, was passed by Parliament in May, 2005 which received Presidential assent on the 23rd of June, 2005. The draft SEZ Rules were widely discussed and put on the website of the Department of Commerce offering suggestions/comments. Around 800 suggestions were received on the draft rules. After extensive consultations, the SEZ Act, 2005, supported by SEZ Rules, came into effect on 10th February, 2006, providing for drastic simplification of procedures and for single window clearance on matters relating to central as well as state governments. The main objectives of the SEZ Act are:
    (a) generation of additional economic activity
    (b) promotion of exports of goods and services;
    (c) promotion of investment from domestic and foreign sources;
    (d) creation of employment opportunities;
    (e) development of infrastructure facilities;
    It is expected that this will trigger a large flow of foreign and domestic investment in SEZs, in infrastructure and productive capacity, leading to generation of additional economic activity and creation of employment opportunities.
    The SEZ Act 2005 envisages key role for the State Governments in Export Promotion and creation of related infrastructure. A Single Window SEZ approval mechanism has been provided through a 19 member inter-ministerial SEZ Board of Approval (BoA). The applications duly recommended by the respective State Governments/UT Administration are considered by this BoA periodically. All decisions of the Board of approvals are with consensus.
    The SEZ Rules provide for different minimum land requirement for different class of SEZs. Every SEZ is divided into a processing area where alone the SEZ units would come up and the non-processing area where the supporting infrastructure is to be created.
    The SEZ Rules provide for :
    Simplified procedures for development, operation, and maintenance of the Special Economic Zones and for setting up units and conducting business in SEZs;
    Single window clearance for setting up of an SEZ;
    Single window clearance for setting up a unit in a Special Economic Zone;
    Single Window clearance on matters relating to Central as well as State Governments;
    Simplified compliance procedures and documentation with an emphasis on self certification
    Approval mechanism and Administrative set up of SEZs
    Approval mechanism
    The developer submits the proposal for establishment of SEZ to the concerned State Government. The State Government has to forward the proposal with its recommendation within 45 days from the date of receipt of such proposal to the Board of Approval. The applicant also has the option to submit the proposal directly to the Board of Approval.
    The Board of Approval has been constituted by the Central Government in exercise of the powers conferred under the SEZ Act. All the decisions are taken in the Board of Approval by consensus. The Board of Approval has 19 Members. Its constitution is as follows:
    (1)
    Secretary, Department of Commerce
    Chairman

    (2)
    Member, CBEC
    Member

    (3)
    Member, IT, CBDT
    Member

    (4)
    Joint Secretary (Banking Division), Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance

    (5)
    Joint Secretary (SEZ), Department of Commerce
    Member

    (6)
    Joint Secretary, DIPP
    Member

    (7)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Science and Technology
    Member

    (8)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Small Scale Industries and Agro and Rural Industries
    Member

    (9)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs
    Member

    (10)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Defence
    Member

    (11)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Environment and Forests
    Member

    (12)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Law and Justice
    Member

    (13)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs
    Member

    (14)
    Joint Secretary, Ministry of Urban Development
    Member

    (15)
    A nominee of the State Government concerned
    Member

    (16)
    Director General of Foreign Trade or his nominee
    Member

    (17)
    Development Commissioner concerned
    Member

    (18)
    A professor in the Indian Institute of Management or the Indian Institute of Foreign Trade
    Member

    (19)
    Director or Deputy Sectary, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Department of Commerce
    Member Secretary
    Administrative set up
    The functioning of the SEZs is governed by a three tier administrative set up. The Board of Approval is the apex body and is headed by the Secretary, Department of Commerce. The Approval Committee at the Zone level deals with approval of units in the SEZs and other related issues. Each Zone is headed by a Development Commissioner, who is ex-officio chairperson of the Approval Committee.
    Once an SEZ has been approved by the Board of Approval and Central Government has notified the area of the SEZ, units are allowed to be set up in the SEZ. All the proposals for setting up of units in the SEZ are approved at the Zone level by the Approval Committee consisting of Development Commissioner, Customs Authorities and representatives of State Government. All post approval clearances including grant of importer-exporter code number, change in the name of the company or implementing agency, broad banding diversification, etc. are given at the Zone level by the Development Commissioner. The performance of the SEZ units are periodically monitored by the Approval Committee and units are liable for penal action under the provision of Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, in case of violation of the conditions of the approval.
    Incentives and facilities offered to the SEZs
    The incentives and facilities offered to the units in SEZs for attracting investments into the SEZs, including foreign investment include:-
    Duty free import/domestic procurement of goods for development, operation and maintenance of SEZ units
    100% Income Tax exemption on export income for SEZ units under Section 10AA of the Income Tax Act for first 5 years, 50% for next 5 years thereafter and 50% of the ploughed back export profit for next 5 years.
    Exemption from minimum alternate tax under section 115JB of the Income Tax Act.
    External commercial borrowing by SEZ units upto US $ 500 million in a year without any maturity restriction through recognized banking channels.
    Exemption from Central Sales Tax.
    Exemption from Service Tax.
    Single window clearance for Central and State level approvals.
    Exemption from State sales tax and other levies as extended by the respective State Governments.
    The major incentives and facilities available to SEZ developers include:-
    Exemption from customs/excise duties for development of SEZs for authorized operations approved by the BOA.
    Income Tax exemption on export income for a block of 10 years in 15 years under Section 80-IAB of the Income Tax Act.
    Exemption from minimum alternate tax under Section 115 JB of the Income Tax Act.
    Exemption from dividend distribution tax under Section 115O of the Income Tax Act.
    Exemption from Central Sales Tax (CST).
    Exemption from Service Tax (Section 7, 26 and Second Schedule of the SEZ Act).
    SEZ Approval Status
    Consequent upon the SEZ Rules coming into effect w.e.f. 10th February, 2006, fifteen meetings of the Board of Approvals have since been held. During these meetings, formal approval has been granted to 341 SEZ proposals and in-principle approval has been granted to 171 SEZ proposals. Out of the formal approvals, 130 SEZs have been notified.
    Land requirements for approved Special Economic Zones:
    The total land requirement for the 341 formal approvals granted till date is approximately 44268 hectares out of which about 87 approvals are for State Industrial Development Corporations/State Government Ventures which account for over 21169 hectares. In these cases, the land already available with the State Governments or SIDCs or with private companies has been utilized for setting up SEZ. The land for the 130 notified SEZs where operations have since commenced involved is approximately 17663 hectares only.
    Out of the total land area of 2973190 sq km in India, total agricultural land is of the order of 1620388 sq km (54.5%). It is interesting to note that out of this total land area, the land in possession of the 130 SEZs notified amounts to approximately 177 sq km only. The 341 formal approvals granted also works out to only around 443 sq km.
    SEZs- leading to the growth of labour intensive manufacturing industry:
    Out of the 341 formal approvals given till date, over 120 approvals are for sector specific and multi product SEZs for manufacture of Textiles & Apparels, Leather Footwear, Automobile components, Engineering etc.. which would involve labour intensive manufacturing. The employment projected in the 130 SEZs notified so far is over 17,43,530 additional jobs. SEZs are thus going to lead to creation of employment for large number of unemployed rural youth. Nokia and Flextronics electronics hardware SEZs in Sriperumbudur are already providing employment to 3800 and 2069 persons, majority of which are women. Hyderabad Gems SEZ for Jewellery manufacturing in Hyderabad has already employed 1200 girls majority of whom are from landless families, after providing training to them. They have a projected direct employment for about 30,000 persons. Apache SEZ being set up in Andhra Pradesh will employ 20, 000 persons to manufacture 10,00,000 pairs of shoes every month. Current employment in Apache SEZ is 2500 persons. Brandix Apparels, a Sri Lankan FDI project would provide employment to 60,000 workers over a period of 3 years. Even in the services sector, 12.5 million sq meters space is expected in the IT/ITES SEZs which as per the NASSCOM standards translates into 12.5 lakh jobs. It is, therefore, expected that establishment of SEZs would lead to fast growth of labour intensive manufacturing and services in the country.
    Benefits derived from SEZs
    Benefit derived from SEZs is evident from the investment, employment, exports and infrastructural developments additionally generated. Investment of the order of Rs.100,000 crores i

  • Santhals and the Muslims are the Victims of Forced displacement in Assam

    Santhals and the Muslims are the Victims of Forced displacement in Assam

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    PACT IN INDIA ASSURES SOME, INFLAMES OTHERS
    By STEVEN R. WEISMAN, SPECIAL TO THE NEW YORK TIMES
    Last August Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi triumphantly announced a settlement in a bitter ethnic dispute that had cost thousands of lives in the northeastern state of Assam. But now the carrying out of that accord is creating new bitterness and fears of violence in this remote region of India. What had been hailed as a victory for national unity has instead produced sharp new antagonisms between Hindus and Moslems. The focus for the renewed friction is a state election scheduled for Dec. 16.
    December 4, 1985

    PEACE FRAGILE IN ASSAM A YEAR AFTER CARNAGE
    By SANJOY HAZARIKA, SPECIAL TO THE NEW YORK TIMES
    A perilous calm prevails in this northeast Indian state of Assam, one year after thousands of people were killed in riots. The fighting turned the fertile valley of rice fields into a vast, bloody religious and ethnic battleground. It is widely believed that at least 5,000 died. Some officials argue that the toll was higher, perhaps as high as 8,000. The Assam government says its figure is 3,000 dead. Hindus fought Moslems, the native Hindu Assamese battled aboriginal tribespeople and Bengali-sp...
    February 26, 1984
    The Santhals and the Muslims are the victims of forced displacement in Assam's Bodo areas.They are already the breeding ground for armed rebellion but now militant outfits in and outside the state are exploring options of recruitment from amongst these groups.For eleven long years the Santhals have been refugees in their own land. Life in the camps, which are home to at least two lakh Santhals, has always been and still remains harsh.
    Systematic ethnic cleansing in an erstwhile insurgent and now resurgent Bodoland has ensured that the Adivasis lost their land and livelihood forever.
    Assam refugees seek rehabilitation
    Mind you, In the cacophony of jingoistic nationalism against the Bangladeshi infiltrators many Bengali Hindu refugees that had migrated to India during the 1947 Partition are being targeted for lack proper documentation and face the specter of deportation to the place they had left some sixty years ago.
    The Citizenship Amendment Bill passed by the Parliament in 2004 has further weakened the case of the Bengali Partition refugees to acquire the citizenship rights. The bill clearly states that under no circumstance the Bengali refugees can get citizenship rights in India and even their children would be treated as illegal migrants. Joya Chatterjee examines the place of the Bengali refugees in the postpartition politics of India. Initially sidelined, neglected, and denied privileges, unlike the Punjabi refugees of West Pakistan, over time the Bengali refugees learned to organize and demand their rights. Chatterjee argues that the refugee experience led to awareness and a language of rights for all citizens articulated in the voice of the politicized Bengalis. 3
    Dovetailing her essay is Ramnarayan Rawat's analysis of Dalit politics in the partition years and their demand for recognition and rights as a minority group, which they failed to achieve. As the author argues, Dalit politics reveals the true face of Indian democracy as no more than a majoritarian tyranny.
    The Ambedkrites calls this a conspiracy of the upper caste Hindus to punish the followers of the B.R Ambedkar who mostly came from Kholna, Jassor, Barisal, Dhaka and Faridpur region from where Jogendranath Mandal had got Ambedkar elected to the Constituent Assembly. Since these Bengali refugees belonged to the low caste they were deliberately settled in undeveloped locations and the state governments instead of rehabilitating, discriminated them due to the yawning language divide.
    The Citizenship Amendment Bill passed by the Parliament in 2004 has further weakened the case of the Bengali Partition refugees to acquire the citizenship rights. The bill clearly states that under no circumstance the Bengali refugees can get citizenship rights in India and even their children would be treated as illegal migrants.
    The Ambedkrites calls this a conspiracy of the upper caste Hindus to punish the followers of the B.R Ambedkar who mostly came from Kholna, Jassor, Barisal, Dhaka and Faridpur region from where Jogendranath Mandal had got Ambedkar elected to the Constituent Assembly. Since these Bengali refugees belonged to the low caste they were deliberately settled in undeveloped locations and the state governments instead of rehabilitating, discriminated them due to the yawning language divide.
    The Bengali Refugees: A Surfeit of Woe
    Unbalanced Exchange. While India has temporarily accepted the refugees and is doing its best to help them, the government of Indira Gandhi sees only economic and political disaster in the massive influx of impoverished peoples. The refugee problem has chronically troubled India since the August 1947 partition of the subcontinent into India and Pakistan. In northern India there was a fairly balanced exchange, with 6,000,000 Moslems fleeing to Pakistan and 6,500,000 Hindus and Sikhs entering India. But since partition, 4,300,000 Hindus from East Pakistan have fled to India, for the most part into West Bengal. There has been no comparable flight of Moslems. This imbalance has created the social, political and economic problems that have plagued the state and turned its capital, Calcutta, into a sinkhole of human misery.
    The cost of feeding and attempting to house the refugees is currently $1,330,000 a day—an expense that Mrs. Gandhi's government can ill afford if it is going to fulfill the campaign promise of garibi hatao (eradicate poverty) made last March. The food required by the refugees is rapidly depleting existing food stockpiles, and threatens to create a famine for the Indians themselves. The refugees are also taking work away from the Indians; in West Bengal, refugee peasants are hiring out as agricultural labor for a quarter of the wages local labor is paid.
    No Room. Faced with these problems, the Indian government calls the refugees "evacuees" or "escapees" and hopes for their return to their homeland. "Being a poor country ourselves," Mrs. Gandhi told refugees at a camp in eastern India, "we cannot afford to keep you here forever, even if we wished to do so." Their return to their homeland is not likely in the foreseeable future, with the pogrom under way in East Pakistan and the probability of a protracted guerrilla war there. Moreover, because of the war and the exodus, the planting of crops in East Pakistan was at a disastrously low level before the rains began. Famine is almost certain to strike, and when it does, millions more will pack their modest belongings and seek refuge in a country that has no room for them.

    http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,905183-3,00.html
    http://www.internal-displacement.org/idmc/website/countries.nsf/(httpEnvelopes)/446DBB731DBFEEB5802570B8005A71A5?OpenDocument
    AROUND THE WORLD; Assam Said to Plan To Deport Bangladeshis
    REUTERS
    The man elected the next Chief Minister of the state of Assam in northeastern India said today that his party planned to expel thousands of immigrants who came here illegally from neighboring Bangladesh. ''We want them to be deported immediately after their detection,'' the politician, Prafulla Mahanta, leader of the Assam People's Front, said in in an interview. The party defeated the Congress Party, led by Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, in elections on Monday.
    December 21, 1985 World News
    MORE ON IMMIGRATION AND REFUGEES AND: DEPORTATION, MAHANTA, PRAFULLA, INDIA, BANGLADESH
    Government concern over Bangla refugees
    4 Dec 2001, 2316 hrs IST,TNN

    new delhi: home minister l k advani on tuesday said that the influx of refugees from bangladesh following prime minister khaleda zia’s return to power had caused serious concern. responding to a calling attention motion moved by p r das munshi and adhir chowdhury (both congress) in the lok sabha, advani said the government had received reports about atrocities on minorities by supporters of the ruling bangladesh national party and jamaat-e-islami. ‘‘such incidents were in particular noticed during the durga puja festival when cases of physical assault on members of the minority community, damage to temples and puja pandals, disruption of festivities and vandalising of idols were reported,’’ he said. advani said such incidents had ‘‘bred a sense of insecurity amongst the minority community in that country.’’ he said brajesh mishra, principal secretary to the prime minister, had taken up the matter with begum zia on his visit to dhaka on 26-27 november. he, however, urged the members to keep in mind that the attitude of the eastern neighbour towards india was much different from that of pakistan. das munshi pointed out that secular elements in bangladesh had protested the harassment of minorities and cited the example noted bangladeshi intellectual sahrar kabir who had been arrested for his denunciation of communal incidents.
    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/323266003.cms
    Title: Crisis of Hindu Bengalis
    Author: Abhijit Bhattacharyya
    Publication: The Daily Pioneer
    Date: Nov 13, 2001
    URL: http://www.dailypioneer.com/secon3.asp?cat=\opd2&d=OPED
    The ruling Bangladesh Nationalist Party's call for imposition of Jaziya on the Hindu Bengalis (as reported in the Bangla daily, Sangbad) typifies the phrase: "History repeats itself." What was a hypothesis yesterday, however, is a reality today as Hindu Bengalis in Bangladesh are facing the grim prospect of forced conversion, inevitable death or inevitable (and ignominious) migration to India. The gravity of the situation can be gauged from the fact that even the normally indifferent regional language press of India's West Bengal - which is not known to be supportive of or sympathetic to the plight of the minorities in Bangladesh - is narrating the graphic details of the plight of Hindu refugees from Bangladesh at the various rural points and the suburbs of Calcutta.
    Narrating his transformation from garment exporter to pauper, Harishchandra Das of Dhaka says he has "lost a bank balance of Rs 30 lakh" and suffers "a forced occupation by Bangladeshi Muslims of his 30 bigha land". The only silver lining for Mr Das is that his "wife and children are intact (sic)" and their penury is compensated by the open society of India.
    The new victim of Begum Zia's anti-Hindu actions appears to be the prosperous urban Hindu Bengali of Bangladesh. Mr Das is a living example of this. In fact, the other two characteristics of the Bangladeshi Muslims were evident even during Partition and post-partition days, when Hindu women and Hindu land (property) were targeted. The tradition continues, notwithstanding a few incident-free interregnums.
    http://www.fisiusa.org/fisi_News_items/Bangla_news/bangla021.htm
    Bangaldeshi refugees flooding state: Academician
    Author: Times News Network
    Publication: The Times of India
    Date: January 30, 2003
    An estimated 60,000 people have entered India from Bangladesh after the last general elections in that country in October 2001.
    This was revealed by Asiatic Society president Amalendu De, an expert on Bangladesh affairs, in Kolkata on Wednesday. Talking to TNN on the occasion of the presentation of a research paper on the problems of refugees at the institute, De said these Bangladeshis had scattered in West Bengal and other states.
    And, unlike the refugees who had entered after the Partition, the Centre as well as the state government were indifferent to the plight of the new entrants.
    According to information from across the border, there is real danger of 'Talibanisation of Islam' in Bangladesh. And, it is feared that unless a secular leadership is developed there, communal forces are likely to gain ground in neigbouring West Bengal, harping on the plight of the minorities across the border. De called for a study on property laws in the two countries.
    Bangla refugees flooding state He said there was nothing discriminatory in the property laws in India but in Bangladesh properties of minorities could be taken away rather easily. For example, if one brother of a family in Bangladesh left for India, his property could be attached as enemy property.
    Transfer of properties was the prime reason why many people belonging to the minority community had left Bangladesh, De said.
    Editorial published in ULFA organ Freedom says:
    Problems are result of 59 years of colonial rule
    Recently masses of Geleki, border area of Asom and Nagaland became victims of Naga aggression.Armed Nagas carried out attack against the residents of Geleki, Sibsagar killing two men and destroyingteagardens along with houses. Supporters of Greater Nagaland demanded oil city Nagira to bewithin their territory which is followed by attack on people with volleys of gunfire for continuous oneweek. Simultaneous attack was also carried out upon the people of Sadiya by Arunachali people.During the same period, most surprisingly Mizoram govt sent intruders to Asom to harass the peopleresiding in Asom – Mizoram border.
    Obviously these attacks occurred under the same network. The area of land of Asom, which is carrying struggle against the Colonial rule for the last 28 years is 78,529 square kilometers. This is a conspiracy to occupy lands of Asom in the name of aggression by other states so as to diminish the area to such an extent that the national liberation movement becomes irrelevant. Already Nagas established
    four municipal boards, schools, hospitals and churches upon the land of Asom.
    This is a national crisis. Attack on Merapani, Chungajan of 1984 could not be obliterated from the
    memory of people of border areas. The misery of the penury – stricken backward sections of Boro
    and Kochari people under the Naga invasion became the vital cause for Boro agitation later on. The
    total area of greater Nagalim was 1.26 lakh hectares during their dialogue with India govt on 2001.

    In the post-World War II period refugee problem emerged out to be one of the biggest problems before the international community. India has also experienced it at a large scale. Factors such as rise of religious nationalism, ethnicisation of politics, state terrorism, anarchic majoritarianism and above all state’s refusal to conform to norms set by the international refugee regime, rendered the refugees stateless and subjects for inhuman treatment. On the other hand, historical forces like religious, linguistic or ethnic nationalism and regional economic disparity continue to generate refugees in the eastern and north-eastern regions of India. Faced with unfriendly state, both in the country of origin and the country of adoption, the refugees struggle to find the ways and means for a healthy living, and wherever possible they make efforts to put up an organised movement for their ‘human rights’.
    In 2001, the BJP government in Uttaranchal had denied domicile certificates to the Bengali Hindu refugees settled in the state since early fifties. Some moneylenders turned land mafia even grabbed their land with the help of police and officials. After demonstrations by some social organization, the state government reluctantly started investigation and made some arrests and dismissed few officials.
    This was not an isolated incident against the Bengali refugees who were victims of the division of Bengal in 1947. In 2004, twenty-one such persons were deported from Navrangpur district in Orissa. The BJD-BJP combine government also served deportation notices to more than fifteen hundred people in Kendrapara district of the state. A strong protest by the Utkal Bagiya Surakshya Committee forced the Patniak government to keep its order in abeyance.
    The same story moves to Maharashtra where recently in Arsha Tehseel of Bhandara district fifty-two Bengali refugees were arrested but later released with a fine and personal bond to submit all documents relating to the citizenship rights. All district collectors in Maharashtra have been instructed to collect the data of the Bengali refugees residing in the state. The collectors in turn have issued a circular that all such persons to submit their citizenship documents within a month, failing which they would be liable for deportation. This has created anxiety among number of Bengali refugees that had settled in Bhandara, Chandrapur and Gadchirauli districts of Maharastra since fifties.
    The 1955 Indian Citizens Act clearly states that all those who migrated to India in wake of country’s partition are entitled for citizenship and their children would become natural citizens of the country. This raises the question why such persons have been denied the citizenship rights in the country?
    In order to understand this problem one has to look at the pattern of the settlement of the Partition refugees in India. The majority of the refugees that had come from West Pakistan were either Punjabis or Sindhis. Most of them belonged to the Hindu upper caste and were given money and land at low rate and were settled in the big cities of India. They were the one who were the prime beneficiaries of evacuee property left in India by the Muslims migrating to Pakistan. Such people today hold the lions share in the development of the country and are enjoying the benefits of the ‘Shining India’.

    ''Everytime people come and ask us and I say the same thing over and over again. Our condition is deplorable. Ten days of the month we get ration and that's just rice. Since 1996 this problem has been going on,'' said Kisku, Secretary, Relief Camp.
    ''We've done everything, no one has listened. Now it's better to die than go on living like this. We had two groups which were fighting for our rights - Cobra and Birsa.
    ''The government has appeased them and brought them into ceasefire. They were promised tribal status but that's also not fulfilled. The situation is such that there maybe another riot,'' Kisku added.
    It was in these refugee camps that insurgent groups fighting for Adivasi rights were born.
    At the moment these groups are on ceasefire but NDTV was told that some negotiations were on with armed Adivasi groups in Jharkhand.
    With a 70 lakh Adivasi population in Assam, the potential for militant groups to recruit is enormous.
    Potential rebels
    The ULFA has already started recruiting from Upper Assam's Adivasi tea garden community.
    ''We had sought help from them, but they said it's your own state problem we won't be able to help you, we cant join your fight but we can give you ideas,'' said Kisku.
    ''The way the government policies are, without picking up arms, without violence, you can't achieve what you want, even your basic rights,'' he added.
    And once recruitment takes place, children will be a step away from picking up the gun.
    There are at least 50,000 children under 15. With no support systems they are the worst off.
    Many have died of hunger, of which no records exist. The ones who do survive are forced into labour.
    The government of Assam had recently assured that anganwadis sanctioned in 2005 will be operational by June 30 this year. But there are no such centres in the vicinity of the camps.
    Hunger, homelessness and uncertainty have led to chronic depression. For traffickers too, this is fertile ground for luring young girls with promises of jobs.
    Moni has just been rescued from a Delhi household in Karol Bagh. She was taken by a middleman two years ago. She isn't alone, many others have disappeared.
    ''This has happened here. They are given the temptation of Delhi and money and all the girls who've gone have never returned,'' informs Kisku.
    ''We found out that Ekka Placement services take them. They don't give us the addresses or make the guardians speak to their children,'' he added.
    Ethnic riots
    In Bongaigaon dist, thousands of displaced Muslims - mostly of Bengali origin - are also waiting to be shifted from the refugee camps.
    Forced to live in refugee camps in the first wave of ethnic riots in 1993 with the Bodos at least 20,000 refugees still remain. During monsoons, the place is flooded. Health, sanitation, education or food were never delivered.
    These people have completed the archetypal 14 years in exile, meanwhile they've lost their land and hope. Even these people get nothing from the government but they are the survivors.
    Both men and women work outside the camps. The only help they get is from Muslim organisations.
    ''Till we get rehabilitated we will keep waiting, we will agitate. We have pinned our hopes on our minority leaders. It is they who help us out,'' said Tanser Ali, Muslim Relief Camp, Hepasara Bongaigaon.
    ''We don't get any help from the official agencies - no ration, no water, no education, no electricity, no healthcare, but we all work as daily wagers,'' he said.
    The condition in these Adivasi and Muslim relief camps is deplorable.
    The Supreme Court's Special Commissioner, who visited the camp, has said ''it is completely unacceptable that citizens of the country are living in conditions of destitution with chronic denial of their rights to food and livelihood.''
    Three months have been given for the state government to fulfill their commitment. But the deadline is not a guarantee for the government to act.
    For camp residents, there is little hope.
    Bangla Hindu influx has Northeast India on edge
    Dhaka’s disclaimer and New Delhi’s tacit approval thwart a resolution of the status of Hindus in Bangladesh

    In the weeks following the 1 October 2001 general elections, Bangladesh witnessed an outburst of systematic attacks on the minority Hindu community across the country, in addition to attacks on activists of the freshly ousted Awami League.
    By 8 October 2001, at least 30 people had been killed and more than 1,000 others injured. Their houses were torched, ransacked and in many cases seized, women were raped, and temples were desecrated.
    The Hindu-dominated areas in Barisal, Bhola, Pirojpur, Satkhira, Jessore, Khulna, Kushtia, Jhenidah, Bagerhat, Feni, Tangail, Noakhali, Natore, Bogra, Sirajganj, Munshiganj, Narayanganj, Narsingdi, Brahmanbaria, Gazipur and Chittagong were the worst hit.
    Many Hindu families have reportedly fled their homes and sought refuge in areas considered ‘safe.’ The Bangladesh Observer reported that at least 10,000 people of the minority community from Barisal district had left their homes following attacks by activists of the fundamentalist Jamaat-i-Islami party and had taken shelter in neighbouring Gopalganj district, the electorate of the former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. Many others fled to the Indian states of Tripura and West Bengal.
    In one incident on 4 October 2001 at Panchaboti in Narayanganj district, activists of the newly-elected Bangladesh National Party attacked the house of schoolteacher Dilip Mondol. They assaulted Mondol's 60-year-old father and four-month-old daughter. They also attacked and attempted to strip the teacher's two sisters and their mother when they came to the father’s defence.
    Dhaka, in a permanent state of denial regarding any influx of minorities into India, took a regrettable approach to the violence. Ministers in the newly sworn-in government characteristically dismissed reports of the attacks as “exaggerated” and “politically motivated.”
    The Government's sensitivity to any scrutiny of its treatment of minorities is indicated by the detention of Shahriar Kabir, an independent documentary filmmaker, under the Special Powers Act, 1974. Kabir, who was returning from Calcutta after investigating the condition of Bangladeshi refugees in India, was detained for being “in possession of documents which can endanger the stability of the country.”

    Kabir told the BBC that his group, the South Asian Coalition Against Fundamentalism, had collected evidence from the victims who had fled the country, and would publish its findings soon.
    Despite a demonstration in Dhaka to demand Kabir's release as well as appeals from rights groups, the journalist was kept in detention and later charged with sedition. He was released after a month in custody on six-month ad-interim bail.
    Meanwhile, on 27 November 2001 the High Court, in response to a petition filed by a rights organisation, ordered the Government to investigate the incidents and submit a report by 15 January 2002. It issued notice to the government as to why it had not taken action against those responsible for the attacks on minorities. Earlier, on 24 November 2001, the Court had ordered the Government to explain why it had not taken steps to halt post-election attacks and harassment of minorities.
    The attacks on Hindu minorities drew the attention of the Indian Government led by the Bharatiya Janata Party. Another right-wing ally of the BJP, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, sought New Delhi's intervention.
    The Indian Prime Minister's Principal Secretary and National Security Advisor Mr Brajesh Mishra subsequently visited Dhaka reportedly to convey India's concern over the attacks on minorities, in addition to general parleys on security issues. The subject was also raised in the Indian Parliament.
    Attacks on Hindus in Bangladesh however are not a new phenomenon. The community has suffered discrimination and harassment since the 1947 Partition of India. In 1965, following the Indo-Pakistan war, the then Pakistan Government introduced the Enemy Property (Custody and Registration) Order II of 1965. The Defence of Pakistan Rules identified the minority Hindus in what was then East Pakistan as enemies and dispossessed them of their properties.
    After independence from Pakistan, the President of Bangladesh, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman in his Order No. 29 of 1972 changed the nomenclature from Enemy Properties Act (EPA) to ‘Vested Property Act’ (VPA). The repression of minorities however did not end - this, in spite of the fact that Bangladesh's liberation war was antithetical to the 1947 Partition that took place on religious lines. Linguistic and cultural similarities also do not seem to have induced efforts to ensure equal treatment of the country's Hindu minority.
    Rather, Clause 2 of the Order stated, “Nothing contained in this Order shall be called in question in any court.” In fact, one of the reasons for Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's continuation of the VPA was the forcible takeover of Hindu-owned lands by Awami League leaders during the Pakistani regime, and opposition to the repeal of the EPA.
    The consequences of the continuation of the VPA have been devastating. The Association for Land Reform and Development (ALRD), a Dhaka-based NGO, estimates that a total of 10,48,390 Hindu households have been affected by the Vested Properties Act, and estimates that 1.05 million acres of land have been dispossessed. About 30 percent of the Hindu households (including those that are categorised as missing households) or 10 out of every 34 Hindu households are victims of the VPA/EPA.
    These estimates, although based on various plausible assumptions, should be considered as sufficiently indicative of the problem.
    The Hindu minority has suffered under Governments of both the Awami League and the Bangladesh National Party (see box). Because of the atrocities, hundreds of thousands of Hindus have fled from Bangladesh and have taken shelter in neighbouring States of India. According to ALRD, “the implementation of Enemy Property Act\Vested Property Act has accelerated the process of mass out-migration of Hindu population from mid 1960s onward. The estimated size of such out-migration (the missing Hindu population) during 1964-1991 was 5.3 million, or 538 persons each day since 1964, with as high as 703 persons per day during 1964-1971. If the above estimates are close to reality, then it would not be an exaggeration to conclude that the Enemy/Vested Property Acts acted as an effective tool for the extermination of Hindu minorities.”
    The influx of the Hindu minorities due to the repression of the Muslim majority in Bangladesh and migration of Muslims in search of lebensraum has been equally devastating for the indigenous peoples in North East India. As a result of the exodus of Hindus in 1947 to escape the communal riots in then East Pakistan and subsequent illegal migration, indigenous Tripuris in the Indian state of Tripura have been reduced from being 70 percent of the population in 1947 to 27 percent today.
    The insurgency movements in the Indian state of Tripura are directly related to the uncontrolled illegal migration into Tripura, the marginalisation of the indigenous Tripuris and the unwillingness of New Delhi and Agartala to take cognisance of the problem.
    The insurgency led by the United Liberation Front of Assam (ULFA) is also rooted in anti-foreigner agitation in Assam. Though, because of the religious affinity the focus has generally been on migration by Muslims, there is no denying that most Hindus migrate to India permanently due to the insecurity and repression they face in Bangladesh. New Delhi's silence and tacit approval of Hindu fundamentalist organisations in India have encouraged Hindus to migrate to India, and have forestalled the seeking of a permanent resolution of the status of millions of Hindus in Bangladesh.
    Moreover, the reaction of both New Delhi and Hindu fundamentalist organisations to the atrocities on other minorities in Bangladesh has been contemptible. When thousands of Chakma and other tribal minorities from the Chittagong Hill Tracts of Bangladesh sought shelter in India in the mid-1980s, New Delhi made the camp conditions in Tripura insufferable to force them to return to their homeland.
    Whenever tribal refugees facing massacres sought refuge in India, they were repatriated. Many refugees tried to enter Tripura from the Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT) of Bangladesh following large-scale communal violence on 25 June 2001 in which more than 200 houses were gutted. However, within 24 hours, the Border Security Force personnel on the Indian side had repatriated 34 Marma families after a flag meeting with the Bangladesh Rifles. The refugees were not even given temporary shelter.
    New Delhi needs to take a pragmatic approach to this problem. While illegal immigration threatening the demographic composition of the North East has to be dealt with, New Delhi cannot overlook the unabated influx of Hindu minorities that also directly contributes to the insurgency problems in the North Eastern region. It is also obliged to provide refuge to those fleeing atrocities at home.
    At the same time, it should take comprehensive measures to identify the Hindus who fled Bangladesh since 1971 after the signing of the Indira-Mujib Accord and take up the issue of their return with safety and dignity with the Government of Bangladesh. New Delhi must demonstrate its political resolve to take up their plight with Dhaka and find a solution within the framework of international law.
    Most migrants can provide evidence that can withstand judicial scrutiny to prove their Bangladeshi citizenship and ownership of lands in Bangladesh. Unless, such measures are taken, episodic reactions such as visits by the National Security Advisor are meaningless.
    Nor can the issue be resolved by opening the floodgates to millions of Bangladeshi Hindus. The large influx and the connivance of the local administration in Tripura and West Bengal, coupled with New Delhi's tacit approval to the clandestine integration of the Hindus, is only contributing to insurgency in the North East.
    It is time New Delhi woke up and addressed the root causes of its own problems.
    http://www.hrdc.net/sahrdc/hrfquarterly/Jan_march_2002/bangla_hindu.htm

    Indo-Bangladeshi relations
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    (Redirected from India-Bangladesh relations)
    Jump to: navigation, search
    During the partition of India after independence in 1947, the Bengal region was divided into two territories: East Bengal (present-day Bangladesh) and West Bengal. East Bengal was made a part of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan due its overwhelmingly large Muslim population (then more than 85%). In 1955, the government of Pakistan changed its name from East Bengal to East Pakistan.
    However confrontations between East and West Pakistan started soon after. In 1948, Jinnah declared that only Urdu would be the official l

  • Suicidal Detachment Would Lead to Greter Tragedies Like Polavaram

    Why Don`t You Ring Me?
    Suicidal Detachment Would Lead to Greter Tragedies Like Polavaram
    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Were my late father Pulin Babu living today, he certainly would have reached Malkangiri and would have visited adjoining all Chhattishgargh and Andhra areas which have to be submerged in Polavaram Dam. He could do any damn thing to save his people! He met all the prime ministers from Pdt. Jawahar Lal Nehru to Atal Bihari Vajpayee during his life time and voiced the Dalit Bengali Refugeees scattered countrywide. Unfortunately, I may not do that. He invested his property for Dalit Refugee movements. He encounterd statesponsered violence and repression accross the border not only as a refugee leader but also as a peasant leader in Uttarakhand. I have no property to invest as I only inherit the lifelong struggle from him. I have to work as a professional for my biotic sustenance! I face sever crunch for time, space and money. But I may not be detached from the plight of my people simply because I bear the destined legacy of my dead father.
    Every month my wife Savita complains of heavy Telephone and Internet Bills pending and crunch for money to run the home. But I am not able till this date to discontinue my adventure with the destiny of the enslaved eighty five percent masses of this country and beyond.
    In my home district, Udhamsingh Nagar, in the district town more than three hundred officials belonging to Bengali dalit refugees live together in different posh colonies. They organised under UP- Uttarakhand Bengali Employees` association. They have no financial crunch. They financed and mobilised the Bengali Refugees resistance aginst denial of citizenship by then BJP government led by Nityanand swami. At that time , everone happened to be in close touch with me. Now no one cares to ring me up or giving any followup. But whenever they face a serious crisis , they never forget to get me involved immediately.
    This is the trend amongst SC ST Tribal Minority communities suffering from lack of social interaction and communication gap altogether!
    I never get a regular feedback from anywhere. I have to write. I have to ring them. Well, I called on every refugee and sc Leader and intellectual in Bengal and Orrissa. Only today, my wife warned me of phone and Net billing. She complained , no one rings you or recalls you why you are so involved!
    In Salt Lake , Kolkata a host of intellectuals and IAS officers, engineers, scientist, professors, doctors cave in within an Arena of Post Modern Brahminical Consumer arena. Only I name a few of them, Dr Upen Biswas, former joint Director of CBI and a leader Bengali Namoshudras, IAS officer rtd. Income Tax commissioner Mr Amar Biswas, a poet and backbone of Bangla dalit Sahity sanstha, Mr Kumud Biswas, another Rtd. IAS officer. My wife`s MaUSA, MY uNCLE iN Law, IAS Sudhir Kumar Biswas, former chairman of UP employees Selection Board reside in Lake Town. None of these gentleman is anyhow concerned with the problems of the community. They encashed Ambedkar and dalit origin to get the job thanks to quota and reservation. They have been very very successful by profession. They have enough money, time and space to invest for the community. Many of them may turn up as whole timer. But non of them is ready to expose themselves belonging to Dalit Community.
    That is how, no national Dalit movement is possible despite individual attempts like that of VT Rajshekhar!
    My Father was a whole timer and he invested his life for the community. Why others are so detached?
    This suicidal detachment would result in greater tragedies as our people have faced during Partition Halocaust, during Marichjhapi Genocide and Have to face in Polavaram Submergence in Malkangiri!
    Pl read Ambedkar`s Life and works once again! If you believe in other ideologies, plese go through the theories and history once again!
    B. R. Ambedkar
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._R._Ambedkar

    The Polavaram reservoir submerges an area of 63,691 ha comprising of 60,063 ha in Andhra Pradesh, 2,398 ha in Chattisgarh and 1,230 ha in Orissa. Out of the total submergence area, the area under cultivation is about 30,650 ha and the forest area 3,705 ha. The reservoir submergence will affect 250 villages and a total population of about 1.45 lakhs in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Chattisgarh and Orissa.
    http://nwda.gov.in/index3.asp?sublink2id=12
    SHRI ARJUN SETHI: My actual problem or concern arises only when the implementation of a project by a State affects the interests of other States. As I have stated, I would like to be very brief in my intervention.
    As far as Godavari Water Dispute Tribunal is concerned, the hon. Minister has already stated that it has recommended for FRL/MWL 150 ft project. The hon. Minister has not said anything and has stuck to the award given by the Godavari Water Dispute Tribunal. It is now reported that the concerned States had held inte-state meeting in the year 1997. The Government of Andhra Pradesh has intimated that the water level may go up to FRL/MWL 182 feet due to back water effect, by adopting design of 36 lakh cusec, and as a result seven villages and 1026 hectares of territory in Orissa are likely to be affected.
    We have no problem if they adhere to 150 ft. FRL/MWL because that has been agreed to by the concerned State. It is now reported that they have intimated in a meeting that they are going to have FRL/MWL 182 feet, as a result a number of villages, especially in Malkana district of Orissa, are going to be affected. As you know, Sir, especially in those areas a large number of adivasis live and their homes will be submerged due to this.
    The State Government of Orissa has a number of times written to them and they should not go up to 182 feet FRL/MWL. A number of times, meetings have been held under the aegis of Central Water Commission also. So far as I remember, three times, that is in the year 1997, 2000 and 2001, the CWC held meetings to resolve the issue. In every meeting both the CWC and the State Government of Orissa have requested the concerned State of Andhra pradesh to give details of back water effect. Both the CWC as well as the Government of Orissa wanted to have a detailed study report as well as back water profile up to FRL/MWL 182 feet for examination[R13] .
    The State Government of Andhra Pradesh has not given the details. As a result of this, the particular issue is still pending before the CWC. I would like to know from the hon. Minister whether the State Government of Andhra Pradesh is having this particular project at the FR level 150 feet or they have increased it to 182 feet.
    Secondly, I have asked a number of questions in this particular Session itself regarding the details of this project. Today also in his statement he has not given any details as to whether the particular State Government is going for 182 feet FR level. I would like to have the details. Similarly, I would like to know from the hon. Minister whether the Government has any information now in this regard. In response to an unstarred question on this subject, he avoided giving the answer. The State Government of Andhra Pradesh has not reported the status of construction of Indira Sagar or Polavaram Project. This is the answer given by the hon. Minister to the House.
    Another thing which I would like to bring before the House is that the hon. Minister has stated in his statement that the environment clearance has already been given. You will be surprised to know the time taken to give the environment clearance. The report was submitted to the Ministry on Environment and Forest on 10.10.2005 and the clearance was given on 25.10.2005. Within 15 days, the environment clearance was given. I am surprised how the environment impact of having this particular project can be studied in 15 days only, whereas a number of such other projects are lying for months and years together. For those projects, they have not been given the environment clearance.
    PART II PROCEEDINGS OTHER THAN QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS (XIV LOK SABHA)
    http://164.100.24.208/debate14/debtext.asp?slno=5759&ser=&smode=
    Red Listed plants threatened by Polavaram Dam- ANTHRA Sanyasi Rao et al.pdf
    394K View as HTML Download
    Polavaram Dam makes Godavari Nadhi an item for consumption Sunday, Jun 24
    http://mbbhushan.wordpress.com/2007/06/24/polavaram-dam-makes-godavari-nadhi-an-item-for-consumption/
    Bachawat Award is outdated and makes the Polavaram project hazardous
    According to the Central Empowered Committee appointed by the Supreme Court to examine the implications of the Polavaram project proposed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh strong objections were raised by Orissa and Chattisgarh state Governments and several individuals against the project and they wanted it to be revised.
    Agreement were entered into in 1978 by the 3 states of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa regarding an FRL/MWL of +150ft on the condition that the back water curve due to the project during floods should not exceed +150ft above mean sea level. Ultimately the agreement was revised on 2-4-1980 and it was accepted by the tribunal on 3-4-1980 and the Government of India accepted this agreement.
    Polavaram Dam is controversial and is opposed by varied sections in Andhra Pradesh and elsewhere in the country. The claims of Andhra Pradesh government are questioned and the manner in which it has carried out the works has raised serious doubts about the importance it gives to any national norms and transparency in a project that would have irreversible implications to ecology and people.
    It threatens to displace a Koya tribe that’s no less than cultural genocide.
    Displacement underestimated and scope for social justice displaced
    http://mbbhushan.wordpress.com/2006/10/10/polavaram-dam-need-for-national-debate/
    AP government mentions of 299 villages (276 in AP, 7 in Orissa & 16 in Chattisgarh) displacing a total population of 1,95,357. Villages forming part of the scheduled area are 297 villages. Eexcept 2 villages in East Godavari of AP all other villages threatened of submergence are in the Scheduled Areas of Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Orissa. The data of AP government is old and many villages have not been included in the submergible villages. The data provided by the AP is contested by activists and scholars. Studies of M Bharath Bhushan & R Murali, CESS, among others have found AP govt has underestimated and underplayed the the losses.
    About 3,30,000 people with Scheduled Tribes constituting around 60% are likely to be affected with the contemplated backwaters level of + 183 feet. It is estimated that about 400 villages will be affected. Massive displacement of adivasis is bound to have irreversible ecological losses with uphill migration of the adivasis and deforestation in the Eastern Ghats. Ecology of Orissa, Chattisgarh and AP is threatened of the uphill migration by displaced tribals. Media reported of the tribal villages already identifying pockets in forest as alternative sites.
    It is in sensitive area and displacement of adivasi in large numbers is bound to make the situation volatile in “dandakaranya”.
    Ecological concerns Wildlife and biodiversity concerns of Eastern Ghats are beyond state boundaries. There are approximately 10 tigers in the Papikonda sanctuary and about 5 tigers in the affected area as there is abundant water even during the summer. This is the richest forest area in AP in terms of biodiversity and is mostly moist deciduous forest. This forest forms a contiguous forest corridor with the forests in Orissa and Chattisgarh
    Flood disaster is underestimated
    Much against the AP government’s submission to the GWDT that severe floods of 25 lakh cusecs occurs once in 48 years, it is seen such floods occur within twenty years with such floods occurring in 1986 and 2006! Flood water level (Back water level) at Badrachalam has reached at RL 172 this year with a flood discharge of 20 to 23 lakh cusecs without any Dam. If the proposed Dam is constructed with the height off wall about 84 ft. above the River Bed Level at Polavaram obstructing the Flow would, create heading of the levels which may reach more than +200 ft., at Badrachalam and same may be at Konta of Chattisgarh and Motu of Orissa. Owing to which the submergence of Forest, private land, and villages adversely affected and people displaced would be far above the estimates of the AP government.
    Central agencies failing to ensure norms
    The Government of A P has commenced the Head Works and the Canal Works before the Site Clearance that was granted on 19-09-2005 and Environment Clearances were obtained on 25-10-2005. Public Hearing was conducted on 10-10-2005 and within 8 days, the A.P. Pollution Control Board has given “No Objection Certificate” on 18-10-2005. The very next day i.e. on 19-10-2005 the Expert Committee of MOE&F has granted Environmental Clearance. It was approved by the MOE&F on 25-10-2005, after the construction of the Project commenced in the Month of March, 2005.
    As per the norms the Government is required to hold the Public Hearings in all the areas of submergence due to construction of the Project. But the Public Hearing were not held in the submergence areas of Chhattisgarh and Orissa till date and as on today the Pollution Control Boards of those two states have not given “No Objection Certificate”.
    CM takes dam issue to Centre
    Statesman News Service
    BHUBANESWAR, July 12: Union environment and forest minister Mr A Raja has reportedly assured chief minister Mr Naveen Patnaik that he would ask the Andhra Pradesh government to redraw its Polavaram project proposal to meet the stipulations set by the High Court.

    Official sources here said Mr Patnaik had met Mr Raja in New Delhi today and expressed concern over the environmental clearance accorded to the Polavaram project. The project will adversely affect 6,000 tribals of Malkangiri district in the state, he said.

    The chief minister pointed out that over 100 hectares of forest land in Orissa will be submerged if the AP project was implemented. He also informed the Central minister that the Orissa High Court had directed the AP government to reformulate the project in such a manner that there is no submergence in Orissa.

    Mr Patnaik also requested Mr Raja to clear the proposals submitted by the state government for regularisation of eligible pre-1980 forest encroachments. The state government had submitted proposals in respect of 17 districts, of which clearance has been received for regulararisation of encroachments made prior to 1972 in nine districts.

    The chief minister requested Mr Raja to clear the balance proposals, in respect of the nine districts, viz, Jharsuguda, Sambalpur, Khurda, Nayagarh, Rayagada, Boudh, Kalahandi, Koraput and Kandhamal (ie, up to the cut off year of 1980) and also to clear all the proposals in respect of the remaining districts viz, Baragarh, Cuttack, Deogarh, Dhenkanal, Gajapati, Jajpur, Nuapada and Sonepur.

    Later the CM met the Union minister of mines, Mr Sis Ram Ola and apprised him of the investments taking place in the mineral-based industry sector in the state. The chief minister, emphasising the value addition principle for allocation of mines on preferential basis, sought the support in providing such raw material linkage to the mineral-based industry.
    Mr Ola stated that some of these issues have been addressed in the Hoda Committee Report, which will be duly considered by his ministry.

    The contentious issue of divestment of Nalco also figured in the discussions and the Central minister reportedly told Mr Patnaik that the proposal for disinvestment in Nalco has been clearly withdrawn. Mr Ola stated that some of these issues have been addressed in the Hoda Committee Report, which will be duly considered by his Ministry.
    http://www.thestatesman.net/page.news.php?clid=9&theme=&usrsess=1&id=123032
    POLAVARAM DAM kills Lakhs of People in Godavari Delta -5
    http://profshivajirao.googlepages.com/polavaramdam-5

    The opponents are arguing that on the basis of the latest spillway design criteria used for dams in other countries the Central Water Commission is also following their own standards as presented in the above tables. They argued that the normal rule of thumb is to design the spillway for a peak flood that is 1.5 to 2 times more than the previously recorded flood and this thumb rule is not followed in the case of Polavaram. The opponents argued that the peak flood discharge recorded in 1970 and 1966 varied from 20 to 22 lakhs cusecs and on this basis the engineers of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa advised their Chief Ministers to incorporate in the agreement of 2-4-1980 , 36 lakhs cusecs as the peak flood discharge recorded in August 1986 in Godavari was 35 lakhs cusecs and hence the peak flood for spillway design of Polavaram project must be fixed at about 54 lakhs cusecs. It is reported in the News papers that on the advise of the A.P.State Government has recently revised the spillway design flood to about 48 lakhs cusecs. Consequently the revised peak floods is increased by about 30 to 33% of the previous figure of 36lakhs cusecs for which the 3 states of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa have entered into an agreement on 2-4-1980 as accepted by the Bachawat Tribunal. In view of this enormous increase in Probable Maximum Flood being used for spillway design, the whole nature of the project has completely changed and all the previous estimates made for back water curve, number of villages likely to be submerged and extent of Forest lands under inundation and the population to be resettled and the costs of rehabilitation have to be completely enhanced on a substantial scale with the result that the cost of the project will abnormally exceed as compared with the benefits will be conferred by the project and hence the costs far exceed the benefits and make the feasibility of the project unacceptable even from the point of view of Economy. The opponents argued that although the dam break analysis has been done by one of the wings of the Union Ministry of Water Resources namely, the National Institute of Hydrology at Roorkee, their work as presented in the Environmental Impact Assessment report is drastically reduced upto a length of about 30km downstream of the Polavaram dam upto Rajahmundry. But the catastrophic damage due to an inevitable collapse of the dam due to bombing by terrorists, earthquakes, construction and foundation failures or human failures or collapse of dams in the upstream side of Polavaram will result in inundation of dozens of cities and thousands of villages covering a population of about 45 lakhs in most fertile deltas of East Godavari and West Godavari districts. If a risk analysis is made the A.P.State Government will come to understand how difficult and almost impossible it will be to plan for an effective disaster management plan to protect the lives of billions of animal and human population and save the most valuable crops, industries and human habitations of inestimable value. Since the state Government is refused to take the responsibility to prepare these crucial reports they can never arrive at a meaningful cost benefit ratio and consequently they can not think of alternate project proposals which can be implemented to attain the same economic goals of agriculture developments by supplying the Godavari water for drinking water and agricultural needs of millions of farmers and farm labourers in the drought prone regions of Rayalaseema and Telangana besides stabilizing the existing irrigation systems of Godavari, Krishna and Pennar deltas. Hence the opponents of the Polavaram dam are demanding for a fresh appraisal of the Polavaram project to utilize the enormous quantity of river waters wastefully joining the Bay of Bengal for diversion to all the regions of Andhra Pradesh including North coastal Andhra, Telangana and Rayalaseema. If the present engineers and officials of the state Government are found to be non-cooperative with the state Government to chalk out new projects in place of the Polavaram project for optimal utilization of Godavari waters the independent engineering experts and the intellectuals of the state will come forward to help the state Government for this purpose.
    Large numbers of people show their opposition against the Polavaram Dam.

    RAIPUR, India (AWW) - A mammoth dam and river inter-linking project in eastern India has sharply raised environmental concerns and propelled neighbouring states into a bitter dispute over the costs and benefits of water. The case highlights the kind of future battles that will increasingly be fought over water, one of the world's most precious resources.
    The dam and river inter-linking project, called Polavaram project, straddles the eastern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh (AP). The AP government is promoting the project over objections from its neighbours Orissa and Chhattisgarh states that decry the project's adverse impact on local communities.
    At the heart of the squabble lies significant environmental and human rights concerns. Project critics say, construction of the dam is already inducing tribal villagers, called Adivasi, to flee to higher ground to escape inundation, taking with them a particularly unsound farming practice called 'podu'. This practice entails burning up a patch of forest, farming it for 2-3 crop cycles, and moving on in search of another pristine patch for the same purpose, scarring the earth and destroying forest cover.
    BIG PROJECT...
    Concerns have begun to grow in recent months as the AP government pursues construction of the mammoth US 3-3.5 billion dollar project. First envisaged by the British in 1941, the Polavaram project aims to construct a dam on the mighty Godavari river and divert large quantities of water 174 kilometres through a link canal to the Krishna river. The dam is expected to produce 960 megawatts of power and irrigate 291,000 hectares of land in 15 of AP's 23 districts, according to a study done by India's Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF). The total land requirement for the project is 46,060 hectares. Authorities claim that the project will also provide drinking water to 2.5 million people in 540 villages on the project's route.
    ...BIGGER CONCERNS
    Clearly, a massive undertaking such as this is bound to raise just as massive controversies. The project's critics claim that human and environmental costs make the project too expensive to construct.
    Environmentalists are particularly concerned about the adverse effects of the project. A study by the MoEF estimated that a combined total of nearly 200,000 people would be affected by Polavaram in AP, Orissa and Chhattisgarh states. Studies carried out by Independent groups, such as a 1996 report by Godavari Krishna Vijaywada Link (GKVL) and National Council for Applied Economic Research (NCAER), found that the project would submerge an area of 63,691 hectares, mostly in AP but also in the nearby two states. Half the estimated inundated land will be agricultural, and about five percent will be forests.
    With numbers like these, the controversy is hardly likely to go away. Already, there have been reports that the local Adivasis have been moving uphill, axing more forests for farmland and homesteads. Tribals who remain in their traditional villages have put up notices to discourage AP government officials from visiting. One such notice states: "This is our village and we do not allow any body from the Government."
    P. Shivaramkrishna of Shakti, an organization fighting for the rights of the tribal, said, “The government should give a second thought on decreasing the height of the dam to minimize the sub-mergence level.” He added, “Besides, an alternate model could be find out for safeguarding the lives of the Lakh people coming under the sub-mergence zone.”
    Most recently, the major irrigation minister P. Lakshmaiah has informed that the state government has decided to retail the dam height at 150 feet as per the recommendations of the nine-member committee of experts headed by Preetam Singh, former Chairman of the Central Water Commission (CWC), which was mandated to study the issue of submersion of land under the project.
    Non-governmental organizations have found that uphill migration of the Adivasis has contributed to deforestation. A 1994 study by NGOs had estimated that 153,000 acres of forest cover would likely lost due to such uphill migration. Even that rate is now considered conservative. M. Bharath Bhushan, one of the authors of the 1994 study who is associated with of Aranyika, a network of NGOs from the three states affected by Polavaram, says," the rate of deforestation observed in October 2005 indicates that earlier estimates are far small and do not show the real danger."
    CONTROVERSY CONTINUES
    The Polavaram project has been controversial since the very beginning. Decades after the British mooted the idea, the federal government's Central Water Commission (CWC) granted hydrological clearance to the project in 1982. But opposition from activists stalled the project for years. In 2005, the AP government took up the matter seriously and declared its intention to complete the project in five years.
    But it has not been smooth-sailing. Public protests and litigation brought the project to a standstill as the AP High Court stayed work till the MoEF granted environmental clearance to the project. That clearance was contingent upon public hearings in the affected areas. Accordingly, a series of such public hearings were conducted by the state, ultimately helping it win clearance from the MoEF in October 2005.
    But critics charge that not only will the project threaten indigenous tribes, but the October 10, 2005 public hearings too were conducted haphazardly. They point out that the MoEF clearance was granted in haste after the AP government conducted such hearings in only five places - Khammam, West Godavari, East Godavari, Visakhapatnam and Krishna districts. None were held in neighbouring affected states of Orissa and Chhattisgarh.
    According to Bharath Bhushan, tribal communities that are hardly literate were not provided the executive summaries of the project in their local language before the hearings. Nor were they allowed to raise their voices during the hearings. Besides, he adds, they were not aware about the rehabilitation packages being offered.
    "How can the project get environmental clearance when the views of tribal villagers who are going to be affected were not taken into consideration and when no proper public hearing was held?" asks Medha Patkar of the National Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM) which had presented a joint memorandum to the AP chief secretary, demanding that construction of the Polavaram dam be stopped.
    NEIGHBOURING STATES ALARMED
    Manish Kunjan, former state lawmaker from Chhattisgarh's Bastar district was equally enraged over the MoEF clearance without consent from his state. "The project will submerge at least 30 villages in our state and we are not going to let that happen," he declares.
    The Chhattisgarh state government has asked AP state government to review the project, making it clear that it would not allow inundation in its territory because the benefits accrued to it is so minimal.
    Meanwhile, Orissa state's chief minister Navin Patnaik also wrote a letter to his counterpart in AP, objecting to the latter's decision to go ahead with the project without consulting Orissa. He has sought a review of the entire issue and sent a similar letter to the Central Water Commission expressing his displeasure at clearances given without his state's approval.
    But the protests have fallen on deaf ears, and it is easy to see why. India is a huge country with pockets of prosperity amid grinding poverty. So is the case with water. While parts of the country have abundant water, others remain dry for long spells. For politicians and technocrats, the obvious answer lies in technology, especially those that can bend nature to the will of "development experts" in government departments. Tellingly, politicians are loathe to oppose a project that is touted to have such wide benefits. A meeting of all political parties in January this year also gave its tacit approval to the project, though the Communist Party of India (Marxist) asked the state government to reduce the size of the dam to minimize submersion.
    R Ajayan, convener of Plachmeda Solidarity Committee commented, “It is very unfortunate that all the political parties are in favour of the dam. Though the communist parties speak about safeguarding people’s interest, in this case they are also supporting the government.”
    Ajayan also said that under the Panchyati Raj Act, It was the Gram Sabha that has got the power to decided what should be done. “But in this case,” he said, “the Gram Sabhas have been completely sidelined.”
    PROJECT SUPPORTERS SEE BENEFITS
    Project supporters say, the river inter-linking is crucial for irrigation. They point out that long distance inter-basin transfer of water from surplus basins to deficit areas has been mooted for a long time. A National Perspective Plan (NPP) formulated in 1980 by the federal government and CWC identified a number of inter-basin water transfer links to connect both peninsular and Himalayan rivers across the country. The inter-linking of Mahanadi, Godavari, Krishna, Pennar and Cauvery rivers is one of the four parts of the Peninsular Rivers Development Component of the NPP.
    OTHERS SEE HIGH COSTS
    However, the benefits of Polavaram have been hyped out of proportion, claim critics. They point to a 2005 survey by GKVL and National Water Development Agency (NWDA), the project would displace at least 250 villages affecting around 20,000 houses. Other studies have put the number of likely-to-be-displaced villages at more than 300, predominantly tribal villages. (ENDS/AWW/RM/SP)
    ‘No’ to dam

    We are disappointed with your coverage of the resistance to Polavaram dam. People’s resistance to such large projects is necessarily complex and subtle. While the article ‘Get out’ (Down To Earth, November 30, 2005) makes a passing reference to the protests against the dam by Adivasi communities in Khammam, West Godavari and East Godavari, the coverage in the December 31, 2005 issue of dte, is a complete misrepresentation of the movement against the dam.
    By saying that the Andhra Pradesh government has finally bowed to pressure from families to come up with a modified rehabilitation package for the project-affected families, thereby implying that this has fulfilled peoples demand, is a far cry from reality. Their demand is not for a better rehabilitation package but a strong “No” to the dam. The following points illustrate the vibrancy and strength of the movement:
    l Strong grassroots mobilisation by youth groups in Khammam district has forced the Communist Party of India (Marxist) to reconsider its ambivalent position on the dam. Local leaders of the party are now completely opposed to the dam while state and national level leaders continue to play around with demands like height reduction and complete rehabilitation
    • People’s committees in Khammam, East and West Godavari districts are raising larger questions about the purpose of the dam and its relationship to the growth corridors along the coast where massive domestic and foreign investments in industrial and tourism infrastructure are being made at the expense of fishing communities.
    The Polavaram dam cannot be understood outside its geohistoric specificity. While Narmada Bachao Andolan raised many important issues, resistance to Polavaram is moving ahead very creatively and attempting to articulate a new sets of questions.
    Anantha Krishna and Sagari R Ramdas
    sagari.ramdas.gmail.com
    Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar
    April 14, 1891 – December 6, 1956
    Bhimrao "Babasaheb" Ambedkar.
    Alternate name: Baba Saheb
    Place of birth: Mhow, Central Provinces, India
    Place of death: Delhi,India
    Movement: Dalit Buddhist movement
    Major organizations: Independent Labour Party,Scheduled Castes Federation,Republican Party of India
    Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar (Marathi: ????????? ?????? ????? ???????) (April 14, 1891 — December 6, 1956) was a Buddhist

  • Pratibha In, Kiran Out!

    Pratibha In, Kiran Out!
    Indian Ocean Becomes Most Dangerous Zone as Strategic Grouping with US lead is Final

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    Ruling Brahminical comradors are never worried of India as a nation or the Indian People. They made a Woman the President and ditched anothre well established woman Kiran Bedi at the same time. All the three parliamentary factions are backing a Muslim for Vice Presiden candidate. It is more than clear that the Ruling comradors are playing the Vote Bank Card and are never committed to the issues relating to the Eighty Five percent Enslaved population of Dalits, BC, OBC, tribals and minorities, the indeginous people including the cent percent population of woman. They could not pass the woman`s representaion bill as yet to maintain caste equation intact and now they are credited with making a woman President. It is much more serious that the cabinet chose this historic date to endorse Indo US Deal, finalising strategic regrouping and making Indian Ocean the most dangerous Zone!
    Pratibha takes over as India's 13th Prez.Pratibha Patil created history by becoming the country's first woman President while Kiran Bedi, who lost the race for the job of Delhi's police commissioner, on Wednesday blamed Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for picking "someone junior" to her for the coveted post.On the other hand, today only, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh achieved a difficult task when all his senior colleagues put their weight behind his dream of getting the Indo-US civil nuclear co-operation going. The finalised text of the 123 agreement will be revealed on the floor of Parliament on August 10. The Cabinet Committee on Security and the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs have both approved the text of the 123 agreement which will eventually be signed by India and the US.
    For the past decade, U.S. leaders have been privately considering China as a rival. Publicly China is the United States' great trading partner, even though the trade relationship between the two is a bit skewed. Ever since China emerged from the shadows as an economic and military powerhouse, U.S. policymakers have been concerned about its rapid rise in military expenditures and its economic influence in the neighborhood. Hence the United States, after careful consideration, came up with a policy to balance China's growing power by developing an equally powerful nation in India. The latter in itself is an economic powerhouse, but is held back by lack of funds. It is also surrounded by unfriendly neighbors -- China in the north and Pakistan in the west. Unfortunately, the Iraq War derailed the U.S. agenda in Asia for some time.

    Since the end of the Cold War and the disintegration of the erstwhile Soviet Union, American naval doctrine has undergone a dramatic transformation. The focus on a global threat during the Cold War years has shifted to one of regional challenges and opportunities. Consequently, the doctrine of open-ocean war-fighting at sea, against erstwhile Soviet naval and nuclear forces, is increasingly changing to one of power projection and the employment of naval forces from the sea, in order to influence events in the littoral regions of the world. Moreover, the “littoral” continues to be defined vaguely as “areas adjacent to the oceans and seas within direct control of, and vulnerable to, the striking power of sea-based forces,” although it is understood to extend to more than a thousand miles inland. 4 This strategic concept has been further expanded to encompass the employment of naval expeditionary forces and joint operation missions.
    In a departure from its earlier position, the government will soon amend rules to allow units in Special Economic Zones to use old machinery and still qualify for tax concessions. Earlier the government had prohibited use of second hand machinery in SEZs to prevent migration of units from domestic tariff area to the tax free zones. The issue is currently being looked at by the revenue department for fine-tuning the guidelines for transfer of old machinery to SEZs. The rules have been changed on request mainly from technology companies who wanted to shift some used machinery from their operations outside India.
    The companies who have made such a request, include Cisco and Honeywell, and the old machinery that they want to bring in constitutes a small percentage of their overall investments in the SEZs, the official said.
    Meanwhile, in a seminar on policies and issues pertaining to SEZs, Additional Secretary in the Department of Commerce R Gopalan said SEZs investments in excess of Rs 2,59,000 crore would be made in the zones by 2009 and 1.7 million additional jobs would be created. On the recent suggestions by Defence ministries to closely monitor employment of foreign nationals in SEZs, Gopalan said employment would be subject to Indian laws for foreign nationals.
    It is expected that China's manufacturing advantage will be nullified within 20 years, with the emergence of other manufacturing hubs elsewhere in Asia and Latin America. India's advantage as a technologically proficient nation will remain. The Chinese know about this Indian advantage and are working hard to counter it by teaching English in schools. But they miss the point. India's English advantage dates back 200 years to 1820; the Chinese cannot gain that advantage in 15 years. Hence, if the United States has positioned India as a knowledge center of the world, it is with good reason.
    India's economy was growing below its potential as a large number of poor people were not participating in the growth process, Finance Minister P Chidambaram said on Sunday.
    "I am proud that we have achieved an average growth rate of 8.6 per cent during the past three years. At the same time, I am acutely aware that our economy is growing at a rate below its true potential," Chidambaram said at the convocation ceremony of the Indian Institute of Management.
    "There are many reasons, but the most important appears to be that nearly one-half of the people of the country do not fully participate in the growth process due to lack of education, skills, jobs, capital or opportunity," he said.
    "They are poor, not only in terms of income poverty but also in terms of many human development indicators." Chidambaram noted that India could emulate some smaller and poorer countries in its neighbourhood that have surged forward.
    "Some of them have wiped out abject poverty, for instance Malaysia and Thailand," he said.
    Some have become middle-income countries like South Korea while others like Sri Lanka have achieved remarkable progress in literacy, life expectancy and other human development indicators, he said.
    Chidambaram said India, after independence, failed to encourage the creation of wealth. "Wealth creation, especially through private enterprise, was viewed with suspicion and sometimes even contempt," he remarked.
    India’s American Dreams
    M K Bhadrakumar
    THE United Progressive Alliance government is getting perilously close to bequeathing a foreign policy legacy for the country. It also becomes, inevitably, a sad legacy of the ageing Congress Party in its declining years.
    Clearly, the UPA government is diligently following up on a task that the previous NDA government had left incomplete – making India and the United States ‘natural allies’ in the 21st century. The UPA government’s decision to chariot India into the so-called quadripartite format – comprising the United States, Japan and Australia – is a turning point in the Indian foreign policy. India is thereby stepping out to fill a gap in the USA’s Asian strategy. The format has no political rationale except that of ‘ganging up’ against China. We know it, even if we won’t admit it, and the Asian region knows it, even if it doesn’t want to speak about it.
    From the viewpoint of the neo-conservative ideology that guides the present US administration’s policies, Delhi’s induction into the US strategic orbit is highly desirable. India is an important neighbour to China. Unlike Australia, which is quintessentially an Anglo-Saxon outpost in Asia’s seamless Pacific borderlands, or Japan, which still bears the cross for its appalling crimes in Asia during World War II, India has a benign presence in much of Asia – culturally and politically.
    Arguably, any US policy of containment of China (or Russia) will be ineffectual without India playing a supportive role. As the setting up of the Indian airbase in Ayni in Tajikistan testifies, India can be a ‘proxy’ power for Washington in regions in Asia that militate against direct American military presence. India, which has a miniscule economic presence in Central Asia, and has lost out on accessing the region’s energy reserves, has virtually nothing to defend in the Pamir Mountains. It is farcical to pretend that Delhi aspires to influence the anarchic events in Afghanistan from the Pamir side, either. Yet Delhi is incrementally beefing up its “base” in Ayni.
    Certainly, Washington views with satisfaction that India is demonstrating grit to make its strategic presence felt in a sensitive region, which borders China’s nuclear test sites in Xinjiang. In Central Asia, US geopolitical intentions are in serious disrepute. Thus, the entire thrust of Washington’s “Great Central Asia” policy is on encouraging India to be a rival player to China and Russia.
    http://pd.cpim.org/2007/0722/07222007_bhadrakumrar.htm

    CNN-IBN EXCLUSIVE

    Spy story: Rajiv Gandhi hushed up Bofors probe
    By Sumon K Chakrabarti for CNN-IBN

    A new book written by former deputy chief of RAW, B Raman, has revealed explosive details about the controversial Bofors arms deal, implicating former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi in an attempted cover-up to hide the truth behind the infamous contract. Here are some exclusive details from the stormy book, The Kaoboys of R&AW, which will be released next week. [0838 hrs IST]
    http://www.ibnlive.com/news/index.html
    A fatal US design

    By Shireen M Mazari
    For some it may seem surprising to find that even as the Pakistani state ups the military ante against terrorists in the country, and the nation suffers an increase in targeted suicide attacks, the US also ups the ante in terms of accusations against the Pakistani state and histrionics relating to Osama bin Laden's purported presence in Pakistan. However, for many of us who feel the US has a particular design for Pakistan, the present US vitriol relating to Pakistan and terrorism is not unexpected at all. In any event, the point-counter point statements of the US threatening to take military action in Pakistani territory and Pakistan absolutely rejecting such action is more of a charade because the US and NATO have been violating Pakistani sovereignty since they began military operations in Afghanistan post-9/11. In fact, it is precisely this sort of adventurism on the part of these forces that makes the Pakistani state's own fight against terrorism more difficult because accusations of acting on US behest immediately begin to flow by opportunist political forces. No matter that our own state and nation are threatened directly by these extremist terrorists who are also playing the US game of polarising our state and society.
    http://www.thenews.com.pk/daily_detail.asp?id=65635

    Implications for the Indian Navy
    Clearly, the two major trends in US naval policy in the Indian Ocean—the ability to exercise military power against littoral states deep inland from the sea, as well as the capability to successfully maintain forward deployed forces—have major implications for the Indian Navy. Not only could increased and enhanced American firepower from the sea be employed against Indian targets deep inland, but the overall level of American naval and military forces in the Indian Ocean is not expected to change substantially. Moreover, the perceived shifts or reductions in US force levels in the area would be more than compensated by the growing technological gap vis-à-vis the Indian Navy.
    India’s policy towards US naval forces in the Indian Ocean, meanwhile, remains exceedingly complex. On the one hand, its military dominance in the area is not perceived as a welcome assurance of a sustained political and military commitment to the security of the region (as envisaged by some states of the western and eastern littoral of the Indian Ocean), but as a major source of concern, both politically and militarily. This is due primarily to the uneasiness in dealing with a powerful state whose policies and actions in the past have invariably assisted, and contributed to, the intransigence of India’s hostile neighbour, Pakistan, as well as the intrusion of the USN in the Bay of Bengal during the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War.
    In terms of the latter, a carrier task force of the Seventh Fleet (then deployed off South Vietnam) set off for the Bay of Bengal at the height of the Indo-Pakistani War on December 10, 1971. Task Force 74 comprised the nuclear-armed carrier USS Enterprise, the amphibious assault carrier USS Tripoli, four destroyers, three guided-missile escorts, and a nuclear-powered attack submarine. On December 15, a day before the surrender of East Pakistan, the task force entered the Bay of Bengal, at a distance of some 1,760 km from Dhaka. Although the objective of this naval deployment appeared to be an attempt to assist Pakistan, the nature and extent of this assistance remained unclear. Not only did the Task Force arrive in the Indian Ocean virtually at the conclusion of the war, but it did not appear to threaten Indian security. In this sense, it represented an “expression” form of gunboat diplomacy. The Indian Navy, however, decided determinedly to ignore the American naval intrusion in the Bay of Bengal, and instead concentrate on its missions against Pakistan. The deployment of the American Task Force, therefore, did not have any effect on the outcome of the war. 33
    On the other hand, in recognition of the ground realities of the post-Cold War world, in which the erstwhile Soviet Union had disintegrated leaving the US as the sole superpower (albeit in a global system evolving from bipolarity to multipolarity, via the present state of unipolar dominance), India attempted to improve defence relations with the US. In addition, there was a tacit acceptance of the fact that the defence of the Sea Lines of Communication (SLOC) by the US Navy in the Persian Gulf also enabled the flow of oil supplies to India through the Straits of Hormuz, especially at a time when the country is increasingly becoming dependent on energy supplies from West Asia for its own security. 34
    Although the then Commander-in-Chief of the US Pacific Command, Admiral David Jeremiah, proposed the conduct of joint exercises between the two Navies as early as September 1989, it was only in the aftermath of the US Kickleighter proposals of 1991 that the formation of an Indo-US naval steering committee took place, with its first meeting held in New Delhi in March 1992. Since then, the Indian Navy has carried out four joint bilateral naval exercises with the US Navy, in 1992, 1995, 1996, and 1997 (“Malabar I–IV”). These bilateral exercises have been the largest conducted by the Indian Navy, involving the participation of, at times, four surface warships, submarines, and MR/S aircraft on both sides for a period of four days. Moreover, in a mature trade-off, Malabar II in 1995, for instance, included the participation of P–3C MR/S aircraft on the American side (similar to those destined for the Pakistan Navy), and Kilo-class conventional submarines on the Indian side (similar to those deployed with the Iranian Navy). 35 In addition, joint bilateral naval/marine Special Forces exercises have taken place twice between the two countries, in September 1994 and October 1996. In the wake of India’s nuclear tests of May 1998, all defence and naval cooperation with the US has been halted, at least for the time being.
    In operational terms, the Indian Navy is clearly not expected to initiate warfare against American military and naval forces in the Indian Ocean, for prudent political and military reasons. Consequently, it is also not expected to challenge its dominance in the area, nor provoke it into military action. At the same time, however, the Indian Navy would need to possess the ability to raise the costs of American military and naval intervention against India, especially in terms of its “counter proliferation” strategy, which includes the possibility of launching military strikes against India in order to deny its nuclear capacity—weapons, delivery systems, and assorted infrastructure. Therefore, the development of even limited “sea denial” capabilities against US military forces at sea could assist an attempt to deter an attack of this nature in the first place.
    It is not surprising, therefore, that a recent (May 20, 1998) internal Indian Navy study, “Strategic Defence Review: The Maritime Dimension—A Naval Vision” states, “The Indian Navy must have sufficient maritime power not only to be able to defend and further India’s maritime interests, but also to deter a military maritime challenge posed by any littoral nation, or combination of littoral nations of the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), and also to be able to significantly raise the threshold of intervention or coercion by extra-regional powers.” 36
    http://www.ciaonet.org/olj/sa/sa_98ror01.html
    NTPC, ADB plan renewable power projects
    Business Standard - 23 Jul 2007
    National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) has signed a memorandum of understanding with Asian Development Bank (ADB) to establish a joint venture power generating company.
    Monica Bedi walks free after five years
    Hindustan Times - 52 minutes ago
    After spending five years behind bars in Portugal and India, Monica Bedi, the companion of gangster Abu Salem walked free on Wednesday.
    India s new President Pratibha Patil has favoured a sustained economic growth that should be socially inclusive and called for empowering women. Patil described herself as the Republic s first servant and said her sincere endeavour would be to live up to the high expectations of the people. On the other hand, strategic grouping with US in lead and making Indian Ocean a most dangerous zone ia finalised as Cabinet approved a bilateral agreement for civilian nuclear trade with the United States on Wednesday but the landmark deal still faces hurdles before it can be finalized, officials and analysts said. The deal aims to give India access to U.S. nuclear fuel and equipment for the first time in 30 years to help meet its soaring energy needs, even though it has stayed out of non-proliferation pacts and tested nuclear weapons.
    The bilateral pact now has to be approved by Congress, while India needs to get clearances from the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) of nations that govern global civilian nuclear trade and also conclude an agreement to place its civilian reactors under U.N. safeguards.
    The deal has been opposed by critics in both countries who say their governments are making too many compromises in their eagerness to seal it.
    India is nervous about the reception the pact will get in the Democrat-dominated U.S. Congress where support for President George W. Bush has diminished and several members have opposed concessions to New Delhi citing proliferation concerns, the Indian official said.
    New Delhi was also not yet sure about giant neighbor China's support at the NSG and feared Beijing could block progress as stronger India-U.S. ties are seen as an attempt to counter China's rise, he added.
    Congress approval would be easy if India is successful in getting NSG support and concludes a safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency, said Harsh V. Pant, who teaches defense studies at King's College, London.
    First agreed in principle two years ago, it is seen as a symbol of the new strategic relationship between the once-estranged democracies. The framework deal was approved by the U.S. Congress last December. But the two governments managed to agree on a bilateral pact needed to govern nuclear trade only last week, after several rounds of negotiations over New Delhi's objections to what it said were new conditions.
    They approved the agreement," Indian Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee told reporters, after a joint meeting of the cabinet committees on security and political affairs.
    "All concerns of India have been reflected and have been adequately addressed."
    Details of the bilateral pact have not been made public.
    "I think the Indian government, based on the discussions we had last week, is taking positive steps," State Department spokesman Sean McCormack told reporters in Washington.
    He said he expected the United States to announce more details of the agreement in the "next couple of days."
    An Indian official close to the negotiations said Washington had agreed to accommodate New Delhi's concerns and allow it to reprocess spent nuclear fuel at a dedicated plant India has proposed to set up.
    It had also agreed to a permanent supply of fuel to nuclear reactors. A complex process of consultations would be required before the U.S. administration could penalize India by ending nuclear trade if it conducts another nuclear test.
    "This is a very significant milestone, but it is not the end of the road," the official, who did not want to be named, told Reuters. "We are still keeping our fingers crossed."
    The Cabinet Committee on Security includes Defence Minister A K Antony, Home Minister Shivraj Patil, Finance Minister P Chidambaram, and External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee.The other crucial panel, the CCPA, includes Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee, Human Resource Development Minister Arjun Singh, Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar [Images], Railway Minister Laloo Prasad Yadav, Patil, Chidambaram, Antony and Surface Transport Minister T R Baalu.
    This in effect means that the UPA and its allies are supporting the 123 agreement; only the Left parties have not spelt their stance against the final agreement.It also means that, legally speaking, from the Indian side Prime Minister Singh doesn't have to worry as much as US President George Bush [Images] who will have to take the 123 agreement to Congress for ratification.
    Already, Left leaders Prakash Karat and Sitaram Yechury, and former NSA Brajesh Mishra have been briefed on the issue in the last two days. Importantly, the Left parties have chosen to remain quiet so far. Mishra, too, hasn't spoken against the deal after he got a personal briefing by the top authorities. He was also briefed by US Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs Nicholas Burns a few weeks back.
    However, the Congress party's core group has not been briefed so far by Singh. The core group, one of the most powerful informal groups, meets every weekend to keep harmony between the PMO and 10 Janpath, and includes Sonia Gandhi and Singh.
    It is expected that NSA M K Narayanan will brief the Congress core group and he will face Arjun Singh at the briefing. Last year, in one such briefing on the nuclear deal, Arjun Singh had posed a few difficult questions to Narayanan.
    According to Mukherjee, the prime minister is also expected to brief BJP leaders Atal Bihari Vajpayee, L K Advani and Jaswant Singh.
    Pratibha Patil was on Wednesday sworn in as the country's first woman President.She was administered the oath of office by Chief Justice of India K G Balakrishnan at a function in the Central Hall of Parliament House.
    The function was attended by a host of VVIPs, including outgoing President A P J Abdul Kalam, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, Lok Sabha Speaker Somnath Chatterjee, Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman K Rahman Khan, UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi, Union ministers, former prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Opposition leaders, governors, chief ministers and members of the diplomatic corps.
    A 21-gun salute was accorded to Patil after she was sworn-in as the country's 13th President. She solemnly affirmed by the oath, which she took in English.
    Furious at being overlooked for the post of Delhi Police Commissioner, Kiran Bedi, the country's first woman IPS officer, said she would fight the ''injustice'' of the appointment of Y S Dadwal who is two years junior to her.
    ''All options are open,'' she shot back when asked whether she was contemplating taking recourse to legal means.
    ''I am a person who has always stood up against injustice and I will continue to do so,'' said Bedi.
    'Unfair decision'
    The displeasure of Bedi, a 1972 batch IPS officer of the union territory cadre, came to the fore after the Union Home Ministry cleared the name of Dadwal, a 1974 batch IPS officer, for the post of Delhi Police Commissioner and sent it to Lt Governor Tejinder Khanna, who issued the order.
    The decision was termed by Bedi as ''not fair''.
    ''It is not that the decision is unfair to an individual. It is not fair to the system,'' said Bedi, currently posted as Director General of the Bureau for Police Research and Development.
    She did not rule out the possibility of proceeding on ''protest leave'' to make public her disappointment.
    The Magsaysay award winner, who has served with the United Nations and carried out reforms in Tihar Jail, pointed out that she was two years senior to Dadwal, now posted as Special Commissioner in Delhi Police.

    Pratibha Patil, who took oath as President on Wednesday, favours a sustained economic growth that is socially inclusive and has called for empowerment of women.
    "Our combined endeavour should be to ensure that the rate of economic growth is sustained and it is socially inclusive," she said in her address at the Central Hall of Parliament after she was administered the oath of office by Chief Justice of India K G Balakrishnan.
    She described herself as the Republic's first servant and said her sincere endeavour will be to live up to the high expectations of the people who chose to elect her as President.
    Noting that India stood at the threshold of a new era of progress and was moving at 'historically unprecedented' rates of growth, Pratibha said, "It should be our combined endeavour to sustain this growth and ensure that it is socially inclusive."
    She said it should be ensured that every section of the society, particularly the weak and the disadvantaged are equal partners as beneficiaries of the development process.
    "We must also ensure that every region of the country participates in and benefits from the process of economic growth," Pratibha said.
    The first woman President said empowerment of women was particularly important to her as she believed that it leads to the empowerment of the nation.
    "We must banish malnutrition, social evils, infant mortality and female foeticide," she said while expressing her full commitment to the protection of child rights.
    Asking the people to wage a relentless campaign against poverty, ignorance and disease for a better future of the children, she said, "We must show wisdom and foresight in protecting our planet and our children, for the good of all living species and future generations."
    Pratibha said she was committed to the cause of education and would like to see every person to be touched by the light of modern education.
    "We must ensure that science and technology serve our needs better, and help us develop a scientific temper that will unleash the full potential of our people, our farmers, our workers, our professionals and our entrepreneurs," she said.
    She said the people of the country desire better governance, faster development and a life of peace and security.

    B S Raghavan , distinguished writer and retired bureaucrat said, "In India the prime minister has all the freedom to enter into an agreement. Approval by the CCPA, the CCS or even Parliament is not required. It's to this government's credit that they are bringing the 123 agreement to Parliament and trying to take the people together, and they must do it so."
    The Constitutional provision was that the prime minister has the power to enter into any bilateral agreement, so "from the Indian side the deal is done."
    Raghavan said, "Only a no-confidence motion or any such parliamentary provision against the 123 agreement can stop Singh from signing the deal."

    As things stand in New Delhi, Dr Singh has to face not legal hurdles but only a political challenge, and that too is expected to be limited in nature if the text of the 123 agreement doesn't trigger a furore in the Opposition parties and the CPI-M.
    It is expected that his party and its allies will continue to stand by the prime minister as they have done today and that in August 2007, Indian Parliament will pass a resolution in favour of PM Singh's decision to enter into the nuclear agreement with the US. In effect it will take India to a new era of nuclear technology and nuclear power generation and rejuvenated Indo-US relationship.
    The shock absorbers
    Ramachandra Guha
    Email Author
    July 24, 2007

    We Indians are very insecure about our heroes. A scholar who retold, without endorsing them, some old stories about Shivaji’s parentage found his book banned and burnt. A writer who made some disparaging remarks about Rabindranath Tagore was censured by the West Bengal assembly. Another writer was roughed up after he wrote a (admittedly nasty) book about BR Ambedkar. And I am myself still coping with a barrage of hate mail that followed a piece I wrote six months ago on the RSS leader, MS Golwalkar, which merely reproduced his own (admittedly nasty) remarks about Muslims and other minorities.
    In 2007, we imagine our heroes to be flawless. I wonder if this was always so. Yudhishtra and Rama were both capable of deceit and deviant behaviour — and our ancestors were happy to be told so. Now, a Dalit will not abide the mildest criticism of Ambedkar, a Maharashtrian will demand total reverence for Shivaji, a Bengali will ask that you share his wide-eyed worship for Subhas Chandra Bose and, more recently, Sourav Ganguly. These prejudices are usually manifest at local or sectarian levels, but sometimes they inform the policies of the mighty Government of India too.
    Thus, when the BJP was in power, a historian who had written critically about Savarkar would be blacklisted from academic appointments. The pattern is reproduced under the present Congress regime — except that to be blacklisted now you need to have written critically about Indira Gandhi.
    Speaking as a writer, I find that there are only two Indians one can write honestly about without fear of retribution — Mohandas K Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru. God knows there is plenty to criticise in both cases. Gandhi was a bad father — as recent biographies of his sons Harilal and Manilal testify. Some would say that he was a worse husband. And he was a stern mentor, forcing his disciples to follow his own quirky ideas with regard to clothing, diet, and sexuality.
    The list could go on — and it must. Gandhi was manipulative in his dealings with the Congress, disregarding democratic procedure, most famously in his unseating of Subhas Chandra Bose from the party’s presidency in 1939. He made major political mistakes — as in the Khilafat movement, which gave a boost to the mullahs, and in the Quit India movement, which quite possibly made Partition inevitable.
    Nehru’s flaws were also substantial as well as consequential. He treated his wife even worse than Gandhi. He was a mostly absent father. To his colleagues in the national movement he could appear distant and aristocratic. But this snobbishness had political costs too. As a Brahmin and an anglicised Socialist, Nehru distrusted businessmen as a class and the United States of America as a country. These personal prejudices led, on the one hand, to a stifling of the Indian economy, and, on the other, to an unfortunate cooling of relations between the two great multi-ethnic democracies on earth.
    http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=e3df3dfa-9134-49dc-b5ae-4b9c2b36248b&&Headline=The+shock+absorbers

    Last week, India sparked fresh cries of outrage from human rights groups when a report surfaced saying that it plans to sell an unknown number of sophisticated Advanced Light Helicopters (ALH) to Burma (also known as Myanmar).
    According to a report by Amnesty International and other international organizations, the helicopters should be covered by the embargo be

  • Amartya Stands For Industry,Polavaram Shadow Over Refugees

    Amartya Stands For Industry,Polavaram Shadow Over Refugees

    Palash Biswas
    Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
    Email: palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com
    The Telegraph - Calcutta : FrontpageCalcutta, July 23: Amartya Sen’s reasoning has forced the Opposition to tweak ... We stand for government intervention in land acquisition for industry and ...
    www.telegraphindia.com/1070724/asp/frontpage/story_8098274.asp - 31k - 23 Jul 2007 -
    Case for and against mega dams
    G.S. GANESH PRASAD

    PERSPECTIVES ON POLAVARAM — A Major Irrigation Project on Godavari: Biksham Gujja, S. Ramakrishna, Vinod Goud, Sivaramakrishna — Editors; Academic Foundation, 4772-73/23 Bharat Ram Road (23, Ansari Road), Darya Ganj, New Delhi-1 10002. Rs. 795.
    The Polavaram dam (renamed as Indira Sagar) is one of the fast track projects taken up by the Government of Andhra Pradesh with a view to improving the irrigation facilities in the State. The project originally conceived in 1941 had been making a slow progress until recently. The State Government of late has initiated measures to hasten the implementation of this project which has already witnessed intervention of the judiciary on a number of issues related to rehabilitati on and submergence of forests. Political parties and civil society organisations have threatened agitation against the construction of this dam which according to them has severe environmental consequences and would affect a vast population.
    http://www.hindu.com/br/2007/07/24/stories/2007072450031400.htm

    Chemical Hub - Ek Nihshobdo Ghatok (A Silent Killer)
    From Platform publications, 45 Beniatola Lane, Kolkata 700009
    The government of West Bengal has decided to build a chemical hub in the aftermath of Nandigram - the only question right now is where. This article analyses the effects of such a plan. Topics covered include the experience of other countries with chemical industries ( Brazil’s Valley of Death, Japan - the Minamata Disease), the bloody histories of chemical corporations such as Dow, and the effect on the environment and public health.
    Click here to read article [Bengali, PDF, 23 pages] »
    http://sanhati.com/front-page/305/

    So called Nobel Lareate NRI Dr Amartya Sen stands for land aquisition reqired for Industrialisation and Urbanisation. Left Front is succesful to maintain its hold on Haldia against United Oppositoion! Left won the election with a slogan in favour of Buddha`s capitalist Development, Petrochemical Hub and SEZ drive. Laxman appears on TV screen sidelining the first Woman President Mrs Pratibha Patil, who incidentally assumed office today! Laxman Seth is being held for Nandigram disater in CPIM party circles and a powerful leader of Midnapur CPIM, the Keshpur Vetern Deepak sarkar has emphasised to control him for public good and party interest in his confidential report to the CPIM state secretary and Left Front Chairman Biman Bose. But Seth is projectd as a hero and saviour of Buddhadev in Bengali media, electronic as well as Print.
    Only yesterday I spoke to Malkan Giri Refugee Leader Shridam Biswas on phone and infotrmed him about submergence of Malkangiri refugee colonies in Polavaram Project. I also talked to Mr Ujjwal Biswas, another orrissa Refugee leader based in Bhuvneshwar. Neither of them knew a word about this. Late in the night I got Mr siddharth Bharve, the Bamcef laeder in Gwalior and informed him all about West Bengal, Orrissa, Chattisgarh and Andhra refugee afairs and Polavoram project. He assured me that returning Mumbai he would ensure that Bamcef as an organisation takes up the Burning Issues!
    I understand the limitation of Bengali Refugee leaders out of Bengal as no RTI helps them to know their destiny. Orrissa and Chhattisgargh governments are keeping murderous silence and preparing for Eviction Drive!
    What about Andhra?
    What about Wetst Bengal?
    What about rest of the country?
    Has Ms Mayawati, projected as the future prime minister of India, taken any stance in light of his casteology?
    What about all thos Ambedkarites boasting to overthrow the Brahminical System?
    At least, in West Bengal I could not get any response from any SC, ST and minorities?
    Ruling Left Front in West Bengal survived a high-pitched campaign by opposition's grand alliance to retain power today in Haldia Municipality, close to the trouble spot of Nandigram, the epicentre of campaign against land acquisition for industries in the state. The Front, which had made a clean sweep in the previous elections to the municipality in East Midnapore district five years back, won 19 of the 26 seats, but conceded seven to the Trinammol Congress-led 'Mahajot' (Grand Alliance) that included Congress and the BJP.
    The CPI(M) bagged 17 seats, while another Front partner CPI claimed two seats. For the Mahajot, Trinamool Congress candidates won half a dozen wards, while the PDCI clinched one, according to state election departnment sources here.
    In 2002, the ruling Front nominees had emerged victorious in each of the 25 wards, that constituted the muncipality then.
    It is clear now that Buddh`s train for Capitalist development has no chance to derail!
    So far SC and ST leaders as well as minority leaders in West Bengal, out of Nandigram and singur Arena have been detached despite the fact that Nandigram Singur uprising happens to be first breakthrough in the Brahminical Dominance in Bengali Politics, Society and Economy! It opens all the windows of National dalit movement. But Dalit orgs countrywide have failed even strating a positive intiative in this direction. The ST SC and minority enslaved population seems to be quite happy as the mobile votyebank for different Brahminical parties including Left as well as Right besides centrist Congress remains intact.
    Haldia Verdict portrays the filure very well as Mamta Bannerjee, a Brahmin remains the challanger against another Brahmin Buddhdev Bhattacharya. Rest of the polity consists of entertained masses of WWF audiance.
    Missing the Wood for the Trees - A paper on land acquisition, past and present
    By Abhijit Guha, courtesy Frontier
    In the wake of unprecedented massive peoples’ resistance against the acquisition of fertile agricultural land in West Bengal a discourse on land acquisition has emerged. There are many stakeholders in this discourse. The state government, the opposition, the smaller partners of the Left Front Government (LFG) and the civil society are the major players in this discourse. The issues, which are at stake, revolve round the location of industries, compensation and employment of the displaced persons and above all the relationship between agriculture and industrialisation in the state of West Bengal. While all these issues are hotly debated among the stakeholders amidst claims and counter-claims no one really seems to be serious or even knowledgeable about the nature and functioning of the colonial Land Acquisition Act of 1894 (LA Act) which is the legal instrument of acquiring land for private companies in India even after 59 years of Independence. Everybody is now busy with the Special Economic Zone Act and its various undemocratic and authoritarian characteristics but nobody demands or makes any concrete plan or suggestion to overhaul the LA Act which stipulates only monetary compensation at market rate, ignores the local self-government, shows no concern over communal property rights and the environment, gives supreme power to the government to acquire land for a ‘public purpose’ which remains undefined and makes no provision for resettlement and rehabilitation for the displaced persons. The government, the civil society leaders including the noted intellectuals, the opposition and the partners still remain surprisingly dumb on the pro-people changes that have to be worked out to transform the LA Act in line with the democratic and egalitarian spirit of the Indian Constitution as well as congruous with a sustainable future of the country. It is true that making of good law is not enough. There are many good laws in India! But making a good law by scrapping an old one is the first step towards social justice and it requires a strong political will which all the political parties of the country badly lack. The distant upshot of this situation is undoubtedly grave because the people of West Bengal who have now risen against the neoliberal agenda of globalization to protect their rights over natural resources and livelihood will ultimately fall victim of state repression and confusion in the absence of a long term goal of the heroic fight they have waged. Given the ensuing controversy it makes sense to make an anatomical dissection of the main culprit—the Land Acquisition Act enacted by colonial masters more than 122 years ago. After all, Indians can’t make changes in the system unless they know it properly.
    http://sanhati.com/front-page/317/
    Refugee and dalit leaders in Bengal have been busy to prove thir loyality to CPIM bargaining maximum personal milage! They forgot everything about Citizenship Amendment Act, Deletion of more than twenty lac Voters` names in West Bengal in only last years Assembelly Elections and other problems. They no more complain of Untouchability and pose themselves as more Brahminical then Brahmins. Tagore is quoted every where and nazrul persecuted. Tagore is sophisticated. Thus, sophisticated package for literature, music, culture and folk for global marketing is quite in vogue and entire Bengali Intelleigentsia is indulged in vulgar protitution.
    So called Nobel laureate Dr Amarty Sen represents well this sophisticated market oriented psyche of Bengali Intelligentsia who are not commited to any other ideology but to Post Modern Manusmriti of US Zionist Brahminical Neo Galaxy Order!
    I have been called several times by the people from Jangi Pur, Murshidabad, where multi purpose National Identity cards are distributed as a pilot project for nationwide campaign. I discussed the refugee leaders without getting any response.
    Meanwhile,The Supreme Court on Friday asked the Andhra Pradesh Government to furnish a scheme as to how it proposed to rehabilitate and provide relief to those to be affected by executing the Rs. 16,000-crore Polavaram project.
    In April, the apex court had permitted the authorities concerned to process the applications seeking various approvals for the execution of the project but said that they should not pass any final order on the applications.
    When the matter came up on Friday before a three-judge Bench comprising Chief Justice K.G. Balakrishnan, Justice Arijit Pasayat and Justice S.H. Kapadia, senior counsel K.K. Venugopal, appearing for the State pleaded for granting permission for execution of the project.
    On the other hand,CPI(M) today dubbed the Left Front's victory in the Haldia municipal election as "people's verdict for industrialisation" but sidestepped the question whether the process of setting up a chemical hub there would now be accelerated.
    "The result clearly indicates that people want industrialisation and jobs," CPI-M state secretary Biman Bose told reporters here. He, however, said it was quite natural that rural people would take time to realise the positive benefits that industrialisation brought to improve their quality of life.
    Moreover, the Opposition's slanderous campaign with communal overtones misled a section of the rural people which enabled them to secure seven seats, he said. Asked whether the victory would give fillip to the state government's move to set up a chemical hub at Haldia which was to have come up at Nandigram, Bose said it was entirely a government matter. "It is a hypothetical question and I cannot answer."
    The CPI(M) was on the defensive after the Opposition registered victory in the seven seats mostly in rural areas of Haldia riding on the wave of what the opposition called the "farmers' resentment against the Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee Government's policy of industrialisation by acquiring farmland".
    Vidya Bhushan Rawat
    Visit my blog at
    www.manukhsi.blogspot.com
    For information on the issues, movements and priorities of Scavenger community in India please log on to
    www.swachchakar.blogspot.com
    Contribute your article on freedom, humanism and human rights to
    www.manuski.com
    Maoist shadow looming over Polavaram project
    Friday July 20 2007 11:36 IST
    KHAMMAM: With the Naxal shadow looming large over Polavaram project, there is tension in most of the villages that are likely to face submersion when the project gets under way.
    The rehabilitation programmes of the government for the project ousters are also going on at a tardy pace thanks to the Maoist threats.
    There are reports that several farmers, who wanted to move out to other areas, have decided against it. The killing of pro- Polavaram Congress leader and Velerupadu mandal Congress president Mandava Rami Reddy last week at Banjaragudem village has only added to their fears.
    Following the killing, at least 10 grass roots level Congress leaders have resigned their party posts and have also decided not to make any pro-Polavaram project noises.
    The people of several affected villages in Kukkunur, Velerupadu and Burgampahad are re-thinking on accepting the rehabilitation package or not. Until the other day, these people were seen requesting the government to include these mandals in the rehabilitation package list.
    As many as 10,150 houses were surveyed in the 33 revenue mandals of Kakunuru mandal, 8140 houses in 39 revenue villages of Velerupadu mandal and 2,563 houses in nine villages in Burgampahad mandal and a notification for R&R package was issued on July 7.
    But now, these villagers are reluctant to talk to the officials. The Maoists had issued a diktat warning the people of dire consequences if they accept the R&R package.
    http://www.newindpress.com/NewsItems.asp?ID=IEA20070720011510&Page=A&Title=Southern+News+-+Andhra+Pradesh&Topic=0
    For Social action, land rights, right to food and hunger issues support Social Development Foundation at www.thesdf.org
    Amartya Sen
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amartya_Sen
    Amartya Kumar Sen CH (Hon) (Bengali: ??????? ????? ??? Ômorto Kumar Shen) (born 3 November 1933), is an Indian economist, philosopher, and a winner of the Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences (Nobel Prize for Economics) in 1998, for his work on famine, human development theory, welfare economics, the underlying mechanisms of poverty, and political liberalism.
    From 1998 to 2004 he was Master of Trinity College at Cambridge University, becoming the first Asian academic to head an Oxbridge college. Amartya Sen is interested in the debate over globalization. He has given lectures to senior executives of the World Bank and he is honorary president of Oxfam.
    Among his many contributions to development economics, Sen has produced work on gender inequality. He is currently the Lamont University Professor at Harvard University. Amartya Sen's books have been translated into more than thirty languages. He is a trustee of the Economists for Peace and Security.

    Did Amartya Sen get the Nobel?-India-The Times of IndiaDid Amartya Sen get the Nobel? 8 Oct 2004, 1440 hrs IST , IANS ... The city sessions court has admitted Subodh Chandra Roy's petition for hearing. ...
    timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/877917.cms - 40k - Cached - Similar pages
    The Conspiracy to Keep You Poor and StupidThe city sessions court has admitted Subodh Chandra Roy's petition for hearing. ... published in a Bengali translation of one of Sen's books on economics. ...
    www.poorandstupid.com/2004_10_03_chronArchive.asp - 87k - Cached - Similar pages

    ‘Prohibiting the use of agricultural land for industries is ultimately self-defeating’
    Nobel laureate Amartya Sen speaks to Sambit Saha of The Telegraph on land acquisition for industrialisation, one of the most important issues facing Bengal and large parts of the country.
    Q: What are your views on farmland acquisition for industry and the Singur-Nandigram controversy?
    Amartya Sen: That is a very complicated question and has many aspects. Let me separate them out.
    First of all, the need for industrial priority in West Bengal, which is a big long-term question and an extremely important issue.
    It is sometimes underestimated the extent to which Bengal has been de-industrialised. Bengal was one of the major industrial centres in the world, not only in India. In European writings, Bengal has again and again come up as being one of the most prosperous areas in the world as an industrial base. The kind of reputation that some parts of Italy gained later.
    It is often said that historically, Calcutta was founded 300 years ago by Job Charnock but it is also true that there was an urban settlement based on trade and industry, apart from agriculture, in this area. This we see not only from Indian records but also from the writings of Ptolemy and Pliny the Elder. The Europeans were aware of that.
    Very near from Calcutta, there were industrial areas of huge prosperity. There is also mention in the writings of Fa Hien who came here in 401 and spent 10 years. He went back by boat. He took the boat from Tamralipta, which is very close to Calcutta. Effectively, it was greater Calcutta. So this has been a trading and industrial area for a very long time.
    When Charnock came and the Battle of Plassey happened, there was not only English but the French, the Portuguese, the Spanish, the Flemish and the Danish merchants. They were all interested in the industrial products of this area. Under the British, there was de-industrialisation of classical industry but new industries came in the form, for example, of jute. But gradually that went off after Independence and there was further de-industrialisation.
    The policy of the Communist Party itself was not well thought-out. The industrial agitation may have given the workers a little bit more rights, but they lost many more rights by the industries withdrawing out of Calcutta.
    Jyotibabu was aware of the problem and Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee has tried to carry the understanding forward by trying to make it possible to have a big industrial base here. And it is extremely important.
    It is also very important to recognise that production of industrial goods was based on the banks of the Hooghly and the Ganges, which are fertile areas anyway. So to say that ‘this is fertile agriculture land and you should not have industry here’ not only goes against the policy of the West Bengal government but also against the 2,000-year history of Bengal.
    http://www.telegraphindia.com/1070723/asp/nation/story_8094453.asp
    Singur land gifted to Tatas’
    Our Legal Correspondent
    KOLKATA, July 24: The land in Singur acquired under the Land Acquisition Act has been gifted to Tatas by the West Bengal Government, said Mr Siddhartha Shankar Ray, resuming his argument in the Singur land acquisition case before a Division Bench of the Chief Justice, Mr SS Nijjar, and Mr Justice Pinaki Chandra Ghose of Calcutta High Court today. To substantiate his point Mr Ray cited a number of judgments of the House of Lords.
    Mr Ray, who appeared with Mr Kalyan Bandopadhyaya, submitted that the state government’s notification for acquisition of land did not disclose for whom the land was being acquired. There were contradictory statements in the government affidavit about allotment of acquired land.
    From that affidavit it was clear that the value of the land had been paid by the West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation which had gifted it to Tatas.
    This land acquisition, Mr Ray stated, was not for any public purpose but for the Tata company.
    In Haryana, Maruti company was producing 400,000 cars in a year but only 400 acres of land had been given to that company. Here in Singur in the case of Tatas there was no assessment of production of cars. It was also not disclosed how many persons would be given employment. No details about employment were given by the government. What socio-economic development would take place after the implementation of the Tata motor car project was also not mentioned anywhere in the state government’s
    affidavit.
    Hearing continues.
    http://www.thestatesman.net/page.news.php?clid=1&theme=&usrsess=1&id=163727
    West Bengal land acquisition Bill deferred

    KOLKATA: The tabling in the West Bengal Assembly of a bill, considered critical for the future of industrialisation, has been deferred.
    It seeks to amend the existing legislation on land availability to facilitate acquisition for purposes of industry, commerce and infrastructure development.
    The delay comes at a time when the Industries and Commerce Department expects the flow of investment to touch the Rs. 90,000-crore mark soon.
    Nearly eight months after the West Bengal Land Reforms [Amendment] Bill 2006 was first referred to an Assembly select committee, it was unanimously decided on Tuesday to extend the term of the panel till the next session of the House, following differences among the members over certain details.
    Members on the committee, representing different parties, have not been able to reach consensus on the Bill. The differences are not confined to the Opposition and exist among some constituents of the ruling Left Front.
    According to the proposed amendments, land acquired would have to be used for purposes of industry, commerce and infrastructure within three years, else the government could reclaim it.

    Amartya Sen
    The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 1998
    Autobiography
    I was born in a University campus and seem to have lived all my life in one campus or another. My family is from Dhaka - now the capital of Bangladesh. My ancestral home in Wari in "old Dhaka" is not far from the University campus in Ramna. My father Ashutosh Sen taught chemistry at Dhaka University. I was, however, born in Santiniketan, on the campus of Rabindranath Tagore's Visva-Bharati (both a school and a college), where my maternal grandfather (Kshiti Mohan Sen) used to teach Sanskrit as well as ancient and medieval Indian culture, and where my mother (Amita Sen), like me later, had been a student. After Santiniketan, I studied at Presidency College in Calcutta and then at Trinity College in Cambridge, and I have taught at universities in both these cities, and also at Delhi University, the London School of Economics, Oxford University, and Harvard University, and on a visiting basis, at M.I.T., Stanford, Berkeley, and Cornell. I have not had any serious non-academic job.
    http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economics/laureates/1998/sen-autobio.html
    Prof. Amartya Sen
    This page will automatically be redirected to Prof. Sen's latest Website in 5 seconds. If the URL does not change please click HERE.
    http://www.nd.edu/~kmukhopa/cal300/calcutta/amartya.htm
    Articles on Amartya SenOn the occasion of his winning of the 1998 Nobel Prize in Economics.
    www.nd.edu/~kmukhopa/cal300/sen/articles.htm - 9k - Cached - Similar pages
    Amartya Kumar Sen - Democracy as a Universal Value - Journal of ...Article by Sen in the Journal of Democracy 10:3, using ideas more fully developed in 'Democracy as Freedom'.
    muse.jhu.edu/demo/jod/10.3sen.html - 56k - Cached - Similar pages
    Kenneth Arrow on Amartya Sen's Poverty and FaminesThe title of Amartya Sen's book is more provocative than it may at first seem. Hunger is associated with poverty in that people who are not poor are not ...
    finance.sauder.ubc.ca/~bhatta/BookReview/arrow_on_sen's_poverty_and_famine.html - 20k - Cached - Similar pages
    Amazon.com: Development as Freedom: Books: Amartya SenAmazon.com: Development as Freedom: Books: Amartya Sen by Amartya Sen.
    www.amazon.com/Development-as-Freedom-Amartya-Sen/dp/0385720270 - 183k - 23 Jul
    Arrest of activist Saroj Mohanty: An Urgent Appeal
    July 17, 2007 - Message from Kashipur Solidarity Group
    Saroj Mohanty, poet and long-time activist with Prakrutik Sampad Surakhya Parishad (PSSP), which has over 15 years been opposing the entry of large bauxite mining companies in Kashipur, has been arrested. Saroj was picked up at a railway station in Rayagada District, on Saturday, 14 July. He is currently in judicial custody in Rayagada district jail.
    The charges against him are completely fabricated but serious. These charges include section 395 of the IPC (Dacoity), section 397 (Robbery or dacoity, with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt), and section 450 (House trespass with intention to commit offence that is punishable with imprisonment for life).
    http://sanhati.com/news/320/
    Stakeholder analysis wrt land as a resource in the SEZ strategy in Bengal - a paper
    By Dheeraj Singh, IIM Kolkata
    The State government recently acquired 997.11 acres of land, spread across the five mouzas within the Panchayat Samity of Singur, for the TATA’s small car factory project. This paper performs a stakeholder assessment and looks into the finer details of the entire deal. The idea is to find out the land distribution among the different stakeholders such as middle peasants, small farmers, and marginal farmers, and the distribution of the compensation amount as declared and promised by the state government of West Bengal, given the price of the per acre of land assessed and fixed again by the state agency. The actual distribution provides us the real, fact-based information which can then be used as a basis to make broad assessment and prescribe some policy level initiatives or alternatives.
    Click to read paper [PDF, 15 pages] »
    http://sanhati.com/front-page/319/
    CPI(M) lies about Tapasi Malik’s death - apologist Vijay Prasad disseminates untruths
    By Partho Sarathi Ray, Sanhati
    The brutal rape and murder of Tapasi Malik, the 18 year old girl who was a highly motivated member of the Save Farmland Committee spearheading the struggle against land acquisition in Singur, had sent shockwaves through the body politic of West Bengal last year. The Save Farmland Committee had accused the CPI(M) cadre who double as night-guards for the fenced off area of land, forcibly acquired for setting up Tata’s factory at Singur. The CBI had taken up the investigation due to strong protests against the incident. However, CPI(M) leaders and the police had tried to pass it off variously as suicide, result of a love affair etc. Most vociferous and prominent among these was Debu Malik, who appeared on several TV channels claiming to have seen Tapasi go towards the fenced off area with a can of kerosene in her hand. Soon, and sure enough, some intellectuals serving the CPI(M) took up the task of adding a new twist to the story.
    http://sanhati.com/front-page/307/
    Intel inside rural India
    Mathures Paul
    JAIPUR, July 24: Taking PC accessibility and education to rural India is Intel, which has signed a memorandum of understanding with Infrastructure Leasing and Financial Services Ltd, as part of the World Ahead Program, to address capacity building, ecosystem enabling and technology support to 100,000 ICT enabled Common Service Centres’ (CSC) with a reach over 650,000 villages, including a few in West Bengal.
    Intel will provide IL&FS ~ the national level service agency of the CSC project under the department of information technology, ministry of communications and information technology ~ education consultancy to identify ICT enabled programmes and assistance for integrated applications service delivery at CSC’s, besides offering advisory services for wireless implementation towards a rural broadband programme.
    “It’s imperative to give children and parents in rural areas IT training. Each Common Service Centre is run by an entrepreneur and Intel simply defines the infrastructure required and provides some of the content. The content provided will be in English and local language,” said John McClure, director-marketing, Intel South Asia.
    The technology input cost of each centre would be around Rs 20,000 but would vary with extra services that would be requested. Using CSCs people in rural areas will not only become computer literates but also have easy access to solutions to agricultural problems. The CSC network, Mr McClure said, is a natural extension of the model centre Intel had set up in Baramati in Maharashtra. The centres will be run, based on standards established by IL&FS, by private entrepreneurs.
    Mr McClure said through World Ahead Program, the company plans to extend access to PCs with high-speed Internet connection to millions and train one million teachers on the use of technology in classrooms. Intel expects to help more than 30 million students in India by 2008. “Spending money to teach teachers will not produce immediate effects. This is just a catalyst.”
    Also on Intel’s radar is healthcare. In November 2006 Dr Craig Barrett, chairman of Intel Corporation, and Mr Sharad Pawar inaugurated the first “digital” community health centre with tele-diagonistics ~ Aarogya Jaal in Rui Hospital. In the six months the total number of out patients visiting Rui has been 11,000. The success of the programme has made the Maharashtra government express interest to scale Aarogya Jaal programme across 15 community hospitals within the district of Pune.
    “‘Digital’ hospitals is an important initiative. Patients wear a wrist band with bar code for identification. Information about the patient can be given into the system easily and also via remote access. This way, patients’ records cannot be tampered with. Secondly, remote diagnosis is possible. You don’t have to take the patient to a big hospital, thus reducing treatment costs. Thirdly, as more hospitals go digital, there will be better utilization of resources. Finally, such techniques will help look after the elderly easily,” said Mr McClure.

    The other side of India's tech boom
    Monday July 23, 11:43 am ET
    By Daniel Pepper

    Far from the gleaming high-tech parks of Bangalore and Hyderabad, 25-year-old Mohammed Zayeed hunches over a raised concrete slab in the slums of New Delhi. With surgical precision he disassembles the backbone of India's booming IT industry for 12 hours a day: removing cream-colored plastic casings from old desktop computers, separating hard drives from circuitboards, and stripping PVC coating from copper wires. He tosses the detritus into towering piles destined for the next link in a long chain of recyclers.

    In New Delhi alone about 10,000 people, some young children, dismantle old computers and other equipment known as e-waste - searching for gold, copper, palladium, or anything else to turn into cash. The work can be hazardous. Recyclers expose themselves to toxic metals such as lead, mercury, and cadmium. "We know that it's harmful," says Zayeed, whose monthly income of $75 supports a wife and two children. "But we are poor, so anything that can be recycled is money for us."
    E-waste recycling is a booming business in India. A study by Toxics Link, an advocacy group in New Delhi, found that metals from 183 defunct computers could yield as much as $24,000. India currently produces 150,000 tons of e-waste a year and illegally imports at least that amount from the West, says the group's associate director, Satish Sinha. Currently India has only 22 computers for every 1,000 people, but that number is projected to increase to 120 in the next five years.
    http://biz.yahoo.com/hftn/070723/070907_100135848.html?.v=1
    President General Musharraf, the Pakistan Army, and the elite have a long history of bolstering Islamic right as a bulwark against the working class and of using various militias to further the country's and their own geo-political ambitions in Afghanistan and India, claims Keith Jones in an article fo