Palash Speaks

Jyoti Basu Dumped By CPIM Once Again!
Palash Biswas

Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
Email: alashchandrabiswas@gmail.com">palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com

SEZ land acquisition creates tension
Times of India, India - 8 hours ago
KANPUR: Seeking to soothe frayed nerve over land acquisitions in Kanpur and Unnao for SEZ projects, Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation ...
Land acquisition for SEZ creates tension in Kanpur Hindu
Land acquisition for SEZ creates tension in Kanpur Economic Times

I have been consistantly writing that the solution to NandigramSingur stand off may be sought with Basu initiative. Once I wrote, had I been Mamta Bannerjee, I would have wanted basu to intervene. Basu intervened and CPIM rejected his peace initiative! Thus, Basu is dumped once again! It is rather very harsh to realise that a personality like Basu is under the thumb of his masters Buddha and Biman, two front men of the Politbureau who pulled his legs when the Nation wanted this man as the Prime Minister. In fact, not Basu, it is Pranab Mukherjee who happens to be the real patriarch of CPIM and the left front government of West Bengal. Thus, the marxists are dying to make the Kuleen Brahmin the next President of India dumping Basu! Jyoti Basu, who was Chief Minister of Bengal for a record 26 years, is once again playing the warrior, all primed to lead the Left's charge from the front.

Singh lets out nuke volley.Singur onus on govt, not front.: After several rounds of political initiatives, the ball is now in the government’s court with industries minister Nirupam Sen preparing a note on how to work out a compromise formula for Singur.This is also a CPM strategy to buy time because the party seems undecided on how to deal with Mamata Banerjee’s demand that land be returned to “unwilling farmers”. That is why CPM leaders gave no indication to allies at today’s front meeting on how they proposed to address the issue.Jyoti Basu had suggested that “unwilling farmers’’ whose plots had been taken for the Tata Motors project be provided land either in the project area or outside. But with Mamata ruling out the possibility of accepting alternative land outside the project site, Sen has a complicated job on hand.Allotting alternative plots opposite the project site to the farmers, too, could pose legal and commercial problems, as CPM secretariat member Benoy Konar had indicated .

What happens next?
Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee today ruled out the possibility of holding any talks with West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacherjee over the Singur issue!

Still I believe, had mamata been somewhat politically pragmatic, she could have suggested Basu as Presidential candidate! Since Left Front has isolated her so much so that she has no option but to remain ultra aggressive losing her bargain and positive implications of Basu initiative, she could have done some thing to expose the great divide in the Ruling Left! But Mamta lost the golden opportunity and it is definitely Advantage CPIM! The latest satnd off position is: If CPM dump Basu because of his compassionate attitude for the unwilling farmers of Singur, Mamata will also never attend further meeting. Mamata wont spend time on futile discussion! Mamata will be highly cautious for yet another all party meeting as all CPM wants to kill the time and take away all the lands to maintain normalcy of law and order situation so that investors will hover around Brand Buddha!

Why the meeting was arranged after all? Was it meant to isolate Mamata Bannerjee or CPIM leaders decided to expose the limitations of Basu to marginalise his supporters as well as the front partners? Handshake between veteran Indian communist Jyoti Basu and ''poor people's leader'' Mamata Banerjee - does Nandigram have a solution? Does the Left want a solution at all? Or it is just time killing ploy to dilute the Nandigram resistance?

They talked, they smiled, they admired each other - they are the greatest of rivals and fought all their life against each other.Could they take West Bengal to contemporary new India without sacrificing poor farmers?

Jyoti Basu and Mamata Banerjee came together in an unparalleled meeting to discuss Nandigram and Singur, raising the question whether this heralds an attempt to build a political consensus on industrialisation and land acquisition.The meeting at Basu’s home came through after the former chief minister phoned Mamata and asked whether they could meet. The Trinamul leader, having received the first call of her lifetime from Basu, readily agreed to reach Indira Bhavan at Salt Lake.

THe result is out already. Nothing but ZERO! There seemed to be some light at the end of the tunnel for farmers fighting against the forcible acquisition of their land for Tata Motor's car factory in Singur which sparked off a violent agitation against industrialisation. Whereis the light now? It is darkness all over once again! The West Bengal government admitted in the Calcutta High Court that nearly one third of the land acquired in Singur belonged to unwilling farmers who have refused to collect their cheques.Apparently Basu has advised Chief Minister Buddhadev Bhattacharya and CPM party boss Biman Bose to give in to some of Banerjee's demands to break the deadlock over industrialisation. What happened to Basu`s stance?

Nod given, KPT gets its act together for SEZ
Ahmedabad Newsline, India - 8 Jun 2007
Incidentally, the State’s biggest SEZ in size will come up close to the country’s first Free Trade Zone (now rechristened KSEZ) set up in 1965 and run by ...
Govt sticks to 5K hectare cap for SEZs Times of India

India's longest serving Chief Minister, Jyoti Basu served as the Chief Minister of West Bengal between 1977-2000.

Born on 8 July 1914, Basu is a Politburo member of the Communist Party of India (Marxist). He graduated from the Presidency College, before going to London to study law. Upon his return to India in 1940, he became involved with the Communist Party of India.

He was elected to the Bengal Legislative Assembly in 1946 and when the Communist Party of India split in 1964, Basu became a leader of the new Communist Party of India (Marxist).

He served as the Chief Minister of West Bengal between June 21, 1977 and November 6, 2000. He missed becoming India's Prime Minister in 1997.

He resigned from the post of Chief Minister in 2000 citing health reasons and was succeeded by Buddhadeb Bhattacharya.

He was re-elected to the CPI(M) politburo at its 18th session held in Delhi in 2005.

Jyoti Basu
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jyoti_Basu
Jyoti Basu

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chief Minister of West Bengal
In office
1977-200
Preceded by Siddhartha Shankar Ray
Succeeded by Buddhadev Bhattacharya

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Born 8 July 1914
Calcutta, West Bengal
Political party Communist Party of India (Marxist)
Residence Kolkata
Religion Atheist
Website www.cpim.org
As of January 27, 2007
Source: [1]

Jyoti Basu (Bengali: ?????? ???) (born July 8, 1914) is a Communist politician from West Bengal, India. Basu is a Politburo member of the Communist Party of India (Marxist), and, as the Chief Minister of West Bengal from 1977-2000, was India's longest-serving Chief Minister.

A political journey with Jyoti Basu

By Marcus Dam

KOLKATA, MARCH 30. "A political journey with Jyoti Basu lasting more than six decades," is how filmmaker Goutam Ghose describes his latest documentary — one on the nonagenarian Marxist leader and former West Bengal Chief Minister that is to be screened for the first time to a private audience here tomorrow.

``I can see the occasion as a very special and emotional experience for Jyoti Babu who will be there at the theatre in person, along with some of his old friends and, of course, party colleagues," he told The Hindu in an exclusive interview today.
http://www.hindu.com/2005/03/31/stories/2005033103721300.htm

Though Home Minister Shivraj Patil has emerged as a clear front runner, the government still has some convincing to do with the Left as well as some of their allies.UPA may have the numbers but faced with an opponent like Bhairon Singh Shekhawat, it may not be an easy task. Hence the effort to arrive at a consensus candidate.Out of the 11 lakh votes, UPA has a majority if it's a straight fight between them and the NDA.But political equations are now being reworked. Parties like the AIADMK, SP, TDP and the AGP are now willing to support Shekawat if he contests as an independent candidate.

Left is trying its best to make Pranab Mukherjee the Next President!
Why?
Why does Buddhadev meets Pranab in Delhi while Kolkata Left Front is engaged in Killing the Two Giant Birds with a single stroke?

NDTV.com Reprocessing absolutely necessary for India: Pranab
Zee News, India - 5 hours ago
New Delhi,June10: Sending a tough message to the Untied States on the civilian nuclear deal with India, External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee on Sunday ...
Reprocessing absolutely necessary for India: Pranab Zee News
Nuke deal: Pranab adopts tough stand NDTV.com
Reprocessing absolutely necessary for India: Pranab NewKerala.com

Bhutanese refugees passage through India will cause problems: Pranab
DailyIndia.com, FL - 2 hours ago
Kolkata, June 10: External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee has said that the demand by the Bhutanese refugees in Nepal for passage through Indian ...
Buddha seeks Pranab help for talks between Bhutan and Nepal Kolkata Newsline
Pranab-Buddhadev discussion on Indo-Nepal border Zee News
India says Bhutanese refugee stalemate is 'international problem' Nepalnews.com

We will not negotiate with the chief minister who was responsible for the killing of farmers at Nandigram," Banerjee told

"I readily accepted an invitation from former chief minister Jyoti Basu for discussing issues out of my respect to him as a politician. He had also the wisdom to understand the essence of the problem and had agreed with me that the land of the unwilling farmers for the Tata Motor's project should be returned," she said.

"It is now clear that the CPI(M)'s top leaders are not prepared to listen to the views of Basu. Since they are not respecting a leader of his stature, how can we expect that views of the Opposition on Singur and Nandigram issues would be respected by the government?" she asked.

See the CPIM reporting in People`s democracy:
Trinamul Congress Chief Meets Jyoti Basu Over Nandigram

B Prasant

TRINAMUL Congress chieftain Mamata Banerjee met senior CPI(M) leader Jyoti Basu at his residence at Salt Lake during the evening of May 4. They had a discussion for around 45 minutes over the peace process at Nandigram. Mamata Banerjee brought up the issue of Singur as well.

Jyoti Basu gave a patient hearing and agreed that peace should be restored to Nandigram and that the peace process through dialogue and discussion should continue apace.

In coming out to face the media, Mamata Banerjee did a volte face of sorts. She spoke of the need for peace, thanked Basu for his patient hearing, but would have words only for ‘her’ people who were allegedly at the receiving end at Nandigram.

She would not mention the brutal killing of 15 villagers till date for their having stood opposed to the anarchic tactics of the save agriculture committee; she would gloss over the horrible plight of the close to five thousand people living in refugee camps, she would not speak about the rapes and murders committed on women for bracingly standing up to the brigandage of the Trinamul Congress and its lackeys; she would not speak about roads and bridges that remained destroyed, she would not know much to say on life being ground to a halt in two Gram Panchayats by her lumpen cadre at Nandigram, she also would maintain a tight-lipped stance over the continuing violence indulged in by her outfit and its sidekicks at Nandigram and surrounding areas, even as she waxed eloquent over ‘wiping tears away from eyes of the affected.’. Interestingly, her press briefing did not mention the word ‘genocide’ even once.

Jyoti Basu later reiterated that the peace process through discussions would continue until peace was restored at Nandigram.
http://pd.cpim.org/2007/0610/06102007_nandigram.htm

Left won't leave Govt in red: Pranab
CNN-IBN, India - 12 hours ago
NO U-TURN FOR LEFT: Pranab clears air on why Left is miffed with UPA governance. The Congress has been increasingly under fire from the Left. ...
Government will last five years with Left support: Mukherjee Monsters and Critics.com
Government Will Last Five Years With Left Support: Mukherjee NEWSPost India
Government will last five years with Left support: Mukherjee India eNews.com
all 6 news articles »

Sahara Samay Talks on with allies: Pranab
Hindu, India - 17 hours ago
External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee on Saturday night told reporters after West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee had called on him that ...
Cong begins preparations for Prez polls Business Standard
all 18 news articles »

The Satesman Kolkata reports:
After being coaxed by his party to sit for talks with Miss Mamata Banerjee, Mr Jyoti Basu was virtually dumped by the CPI-M today under pressure from the chief minister and industry minister who are not willing to spare any land given to the Tatas for the small-car project. Not left with much of a choice, the smaller partners in the Left Front followed Big Brother.
CPI-M sources said that a section of the party leadership is unhappy with the former chief minister for letting Miss Banerjee bargain for land for Singur farmers during a discussion that was supposed to concentrate only on Nandigram.
Moreover, the chief minister’s loyalists do not want to offer land as compensation to farmers over and above the financial package because setting a precedent may jeopardise similar projects in future. Mr Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee and Mr Nirupam Sen explained their stand before the CPI-M secretariat yesterday. Convinced that there was no land that could be offered to Singur farmers, Mr Basu insisted on some package that may pacify Miss Banerjee, even if temporarily.
“The Left Front today welcomed the talks Mr Basu had with Miss Mamata Banerjee. But only the government can take decisions on Singur. This does not come under the parameters of the Left Front,” CPI-M state secretary and Left Front chairman Mr Biman Bose said after the crucial Front meeting at Alimuddin Street this morning. Mr Basu, who hasn’t missed any important meeting over the past weeks despite his failing health, was conspicuous by his absence. “Jyotibabu came for the secretariat meeting yesterday. He has not been well since,” Mr Bose explained. Mr Sen skipped the meeting too.
“Mr Basu has already advised the government to talk to the aggrieved parties in Singur and take necessary steps. The Left Front does not run the government at Writers’ Buildings. It can start a campaign but cannot issue government orders. Only the government can do that,” Mr Bose said.
Asked whether the party’s senior most leader will talk to Miss Banerjee in future if talks between the government and the Trinamul do not work out, Mr Bose said: “This was not discussed by the Left Front today as it was not on the agenda.
“But he can talk to her if he wants to. He initiated talks with the Opposition because that would have opened new avenues. He was supposed to convene the all-party meeting as well but he fell sick. Forward Bloc secretary Mr Ashok Ghosh had to take over.”
Mr Bose had no reply when asked whether the former chief minister had been told to give up his efforts at a rapprochement. “I don’t have an answer,” he said.

India will launch its first dedicated military satellite in August to give the country the capability to monitor missile launches in its neighbourhood.

The dedicated military reconnaissance satellite, CARTOSAT 2A, will be launched on a Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle rocket by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) in the first week of August, an official said.

CARTOSAT 2A will boast of spatial resolution and will be loaded with cameras that can supply advanced imagery. It will cater to military and intelligence specifications than any existing Indian satellite.

The launch of the satellite will fulfill a long- standing demand from the armed forces for a dedicated reconnaissance spacecraft.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has said there were some 'difficulties' in signing the 123 pact with the US to pave the way for civil nuclear commerce but added that some 'tough negotiations' should see the deal through.

'It will take some time,' the prime minister told journalists on board his special aircraft Air India One during his return from the G8 Outreach Summit in Heiligendamm Saturday, after meeting with US President George W. Bush on the margins.

'I think some tough negotiations will be required before we see the light at the end of the tunnel,' he said, but also added that the atmospherics of his talks with Bush were positive.

'He has very a positive feeling towards India. I think he feels certain sense of ownership of the nuclear deal. Therefore, I am quite, I think, satisfied with my meeting,' the prime minister said.

'There are some difficulties but I think both of us expressed determination to overcome them. The president is quite appreciative of our concerns. Beyond that I wouldn't want to say more than that.'

The prime minister said that there were several ideas being exchanged by the two sides, hinting at India's proposal to set up a dedicated facility to safeguard spent nuclear fuel that can come under the scrutiny of an external agency.

'All we are interested in is the substance of the 123 agreement should confirm with what I have told the people of India and what I have told parliament,' he said, adding because of that attack from opposition did not bother him.

The prime minister said at a a parallel level, National Security Advisor M.K. Narayanan also met with his US counterpart Stephen Hadley at the same venue, seeking to remove the irritants holding up the path-breaking agreement.

'Nuclear energy happens to be a clean energy. If we get access to international cooperation and international technology, I think that will only enhance our development objectives.'

He also said the primary effort was to end India's nuclear isolation and at the same time preserve integrity of the country's strategic programme and find new pathways for cooperation fore nuclear energy.

The deal has been elusive since India is demanding the right to be given prior approval for reprocessing spent atomic fuel to run its fast-breeder programme, which Washington is not yet ready to accede to, saying the issue will arise at a much later date.

New Delhi is hoping the new proposal on safeguards is able to break the impasse.

Officials said India also wants to preserve its strategic autonomy and is unwilling to go beyond a voluntary moratorium on nuclear testing, while the US wants to terminate the agreement should India conduct a nuclear test.

Rupee rally may dent mango exports
NDTV.com - 6 hours ago
PTI An appreciating rupee could eat into the earnings from mango exports this year, which is expected to fall by about Rs 10 crore, although the government expects a seven per cent rise in volumes over 2006.
WTO advises India to cut complex schemes for exporters Zee News
Rising rupee to hit EXPORTS: Fieo The Statesman
Financial Express - Business Standard - Economic Times
all 9 news articles »

Zee News
Bharti Teletech eyes 30% marketshare in free-to-air set top boxes
Zee News - 4 hours ago
New Delhi, June 10: Sunil Mittal-led Bharti Teletech today said it is targeting to double sales of its free-to-air set-top boxes (ST in terms of volumes to consolidate its market share to 30% by the end of this fiscal year.
Bharti Wal-Mart set to debut next year Business Standard
Retail venture may begin by ’08 Financial Express
The Statesman - Monsters and Critics.com - NewKerala.com - Livemint
all 25 news articles »

Zee News
New funds add Rs 3500 cr to MF's kitty in May
Economic Times - 6 hours ago
PTI [ SUNDAY, JUNE 10, 2007 01:45:26 PM] NEW DELHI: As the mutual fund industry's wealth crossed the Rs 4 trillion mark in May, the contribution from new offerings jumped 30 per cent over the previous month's figures to touch Rs 15473 crore.
MFs corner Rs 1 trn assets in 9 months Business Standard
AMFI demands tax break for MF investing abroad Moneycontrol.com

An upbeat Prime Minister questioned the “patriotic” credentials of politicians opposing the nuclear deal with the US and indicated that the two nations are well on their way to the resolution of its trickiest aspects.While Indiayesterday failed again to bring Bofors accused Ottavio Quattrocchi to stand trial in the country after an Argentine court turned down the plea to extradite him in the 20-year-old case. ... Speaking on board the special flight returning home from the G8 summit in Germany, Manmohan Singh also challenged the BJP to a contest on the presidential polls. As the “governing” alliance, he said, the UPA has the right to propose its own nominee for President, just as the NDA had done with A.P.J. Abdul Kalam five years ago — and the Congress had accepted.But it was on the nuclear deal that the Prime Minister was most direct. Clearly, Singh had been stung by criticism that he was willing to barter away India’s nuclear sovereignty.

“Any patriotic Indian, if he or she had the reins of running this country, would welcome the deal,” he said. Then, swinging a side swipe at the BJP’s leaders rumoured to have attempted a similar deal with the US when in power, the Prime Minister added: “You should judge politicians not when they are in the Opposition but when they are in power.’’

The atmospherics as well as the content of his 10-minute meeting with US President George W. Bush yesterday in Heiligendamm had been very good, he said. “The President appreciated our concerns. He is very positive about India. He feels a certain ownership about the nuclear deal. I am satisfied with the meeting.”Then he went on to bluntly express his own ownership of the deal: “It will end India’s nuclear isolation. It will preserve the integrity of our strategic programme. It will open up new paths.”Negotiators are to resume technical-level discussions and both sides now hope they will be able to wrap up the deal when US secretary of state Condoleezza Rice comes to India in end-July or early August.But Singh also pointed to the tough negotiations that still need to be done “before there is light at the end of the tunnel”.

Sources said the Singh-Bush talks as well as those between national security adviser M.K. Narayanan and his US counterpart Steve Hadley had gone off so well the US was signaling its intention to compromise on the two key counts of concern to India — reprocessing rights of spent fuel and immunity for the strategic fuel reserve.

The Prime Minister admitted as much. “Bush took copious notes of what I told him,” he said.

At yesterday’s meeting, front allies didn’t want to take responsibility for the Singur talks, leaving it to Bose. However, they went through a report on the discussions Basu had with Mamata at his residence and welcomed the initiative.

“The Left Front won’t be able to work out the Singur land return details through discussions. The Singur issue is not on the front’s agenda. It is for the government to decide whether land can be returned. The front can campaign but can’t issue orders like the government,” front chairman Biman Bose said.He added that land return wasn’t discussed at the meeting, which was attended by chief minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee.

CPM sources said Sen would have several options to work on. One of them relates to the 290 acres reserved for ancillary units. The land is apparently with the West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation, which has been examining proposals from 70 units. Another 50 acres of vested land are with the government but are not part of the project area.The industries minister will also have to deal with the tricky issue of “unwilling farmers”. Mamata had claimed that several farmers had not collected compensation as they did not want to part with their land. But the government argued that many of them did not take the cheques because of legal complications over property rights or as they didn’t have valid land deeds.

“Basu has told the chief minister the government will have to give some concessions to Mamata or else there won’t be any progress in talks. Buddhababu is looking into that aspect and Nirupam is working out the details. Since nothing has been finalised, the ball is in the government’s court,” a senior front leader said.

According to Bose, Mamata could always discuss the Singur issue with the government and the chief minister, too, was willing to hold talks with her.

First trickle of a homecoming
- 18 pro-CPM families back in Nandigram after five months
IMRAN AHMED SIDDIQUI
http://www.telegraphindia.com

CPM supporters on Tekhali bridge on the way back to their homes in Gokulnagar on Saturday. Picture by Pradip Sanyal
Nandigram, June 9: As Manindranath Das stood before his house at Simulkundu, its doors and windows ripped off, the asbestos roof shattered and everything inside looted, the CPM supporter’s eyes brimmed with tears of joy.

“I am ready to start life all over again. I can’t believe I have returned home after five months,” the 45-year-old marriage registrar said.

Nandigram’s bumpy road to peace became a two-way street today with the return of the first batch of 18 families out of the 3,600 CPM supporters driven out since January.

On Thursday, 35 refugee families from the other side of the divide — supporters of the Bhoomi Uchchhed Pratirodh Committee — had crossed the Tekhali bridge with police escort to their homes in Left-dominated Khejuri.

A few pro-CPM families, too, had set out from their camps but the committee wouldn’t let them enter its pockets if the police accompanied them. Last evening, the committee relented.

“We persuaded the local people to let the refugees back in the interests of peace,” said committee leader Abu Taher.

Some may have braved the journey without escort: while the police said 18 families with 88 members had returned home to Simulkundu, Gokulnagar and Ranichowk, district CPM secretary Ashok Guria claimed the number was 24.

The number of those yet to return is still 3,500 from the CPM’s side and another 500 from the Opposition’s.

Of the CPM refugees, only 1,200 are staying at the three camps in Bhangabera, Sherkhanchowk and Baharganj while the rest are scattered at relatives’ homes outside Nandigram.

Das plans to get three of them back soon. “I shall put a polythene sheet on the roof tomorrow and bring back my wife and two daughters who are staying with my in-laws in Khejuri.”

“The homecomings happened only because of the initiative taken by the local leaders,” a senior police officer said. “They met at the Nandigram police station eight days ago. Then they exchanged lists of refugees through us.”

But the political battle continued in Calcutta. The Trinamul Congress, which is leading the Opposition in Nandigram, held an hour-long chakka jam from 5 pm on the issue of forcible land acquisition anywhere in the state. The protest disrupted traffic in parts of Moulali, Entally, CIT Road, Hazra, Brabourne Road and Tollygunge.

Some of those who returned were cagey. “I am happy but I don’t know how long I shall be able to stay. There is so much uncertainty,” said 50-year-old Narain Debnath at Gokulnagar.

Debasish Boral, additional superintendent of police, Haldia, said there was no reason to worry. “Pickets have been posted in these villages and patrolling intensified.”

But late at night, Guria alleged that bombs were being burst on the Tekhali bridge and at Ranichowk, where four families returned today. “They are trying to scare these families,” he said.

Das had a pleasanter welcome. His neighbour Lakshmi Rani Samanta, whose family supports the Pratirodh Committee, was waiting for him.

“Kemon aachhen? Shob thik hoye jaabe, chinta korben na (How are you? Everything will be all right, don’t worry),” she said as Das gripped her hands and began sobbing.

Multiplex checks in
OUR CORRESPONDENT
Bhubaneswar, June 9: Multiplex culture is set to creep in to the state.

Private parties are mulling to set up two of them in Cuttack, while Orissa Film Development Corporation (OFDC) is toying with the idea of starting a multi-screening cinema near the capital.

Talking to mediapers- ons on the occasion of announcing a new facility — a digital recording studio — on Kalinga Studio premises leased out to Prasad Labs, the OFDC chairman, Sitakant Mishra, said the initiative to set up multiplexes has been taken by private parties in Cuttack.

OFDC is willing to extend its assistance to such ventures, he said.

“We have asked the government to provide land near the state capital for this purpose. Once the land is available, we may set up a multiplex in a joint venture,” he said.

The film development corporation has extended financial help for setting up 267 cinemas in the state and has sanctioned subsidy to 283 films. It has also helped in production of 415 Oriya films so far.

Detailing the facilities at the new digital studio set up by Prasad Labs, Mishra said it would have high- end facilities like dubbing, editing, mixing and hi-definition digital recording.

Earlier, producers from the state had to go out of the state to avail the facilities.

OFDC, the state’s vehicle to promote film production, is in deep financial crisis over the past few years. It is yet to get back Rs 3 crore from film producers, which it provided as long-term and soft loans.

“Currently the government has stopped all grants to us and has advised us to manage with our own resources,” Mishra said.

“Producers owe us more than Rs 3 crore. For recovery, 108 certificate cases have been filed. Of these, only 29 have been closed,” said the film development corporation’s deputy general manager.

Money, money, money
The remarkable upturn in India’s growth has been powered by consumer demand. And the bulk of the spending action is — not in big metros — but in small towns, says Seetha

HEY BIG SPENDER: A Chanel showroom in Delhi caters to the super rich (top) and shoppers rack up volumes at a clothes store in Calcutta
Delhi-based radio jockey Ginnie Mahajan catches up with her friends over a meal twice a week, each of them running up a bill of around Rs 1,000 every time. There’s another Rs 4,000-Rs 5,000 a month spent on clothes, shoes and accessories and impulse shopping at malls.

Rekha Sharma, a Mumbai-based copywriter, plans to spend at least Rs 10,000-15,000 a month until the end of the year doing up her new house. That’s apart from the Rs 10,000 she and her boyfriend set aside on eating out, entertainment and shopping for clothes and lifestyle items. And then there are the few thousand rupees she spends on books and music, things she “simply can’t have enough of”.

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1070610/asp/7days/story_7902113.asp

Not enough votes to make Taj a 'wonder'
Times of India - 7 Jun 2007
NEW DELHI: And you thought the Taj Mahal would be a shoo-in. With just 30 days left for the new seven wonders of the world to be decided, the marvel in marble is still struggling to make the cut.
Acropolis leads New Wonder poll Melbourne Herald Sun
Taj is 10th on new Wonders’ list Daily News & Analysis

Pl See the follwing items on:http://www.dnaindia.com/dnainner,catid-2.html

RJD rules out cross voting in UPA in presidential polls
RJD on Sunday said it was dead against the ideology of BJP and would fully support any candidate of the ruling coalition for the top job.
Four killed in Chandigarh market collapse
Four persons were killed and about 200 trapped when the concrete roof of a shed collapsed on them at a vegetable market here on Sunday evening.
Only centrist democracy suits India: Sonia
'My journey from the placid backwaters of a contented domestic life to the maelstrom of public life has not been an easy one.'
India's first military satellite
India will launch its first dedicated military satellite in August to give the country the capability to monitor missile launches in its neighbourhood.
Rajasthan BJP suspends two Gujjar MLAs
The decision to suspend MLAs Attar Singh Bhadana an

Green Death Zones Of Tea

Palash Biswas

Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
Email: alashchandrabiswas@gmail.com">palashchandrabiswas@gmail.com

Closed tea gardens spell doom for Bengal's tea labourers. A court inquiry in India has found 700 former tea workers have died from diseases linked to malnutrition over the past year.The deaths resulted from a combination of starvation, malnutrition, general debility and diseases among workers in the abandoned tea gardens in North Bengal.Investigations by the Supreme Court found poor production and low yields led to the closure of 16 tea gardens in a remote part of West Bengal state.Many workers lost their jobs and were left with no income to survive.

Experts say the deaths have stood out in a unionised sector like tea, where workers were given electricity, water, food as part of their emoluments.While millions of Indians live in poverty, jobs in unionised sectors like tea are normally prized for the stability they offer workers.

India, the world's largest producer of tea, has had state regulations to protect formal workers for decades and unions are strong.But in this case, union protection appears to have collapsed.More than 15,000 workers in West Bengal have been struggling to survive without any alternative means of livelihood and depending on rats, wild plants and flowers for food.
"It was appalling to find how the world's largest tea producer treats its workers," Talwar, who is due to submit her report to the Supreme Court, said in Kolkata.

In many tea plantations in West Bengal, employers did not pay wages owed to workers following the shutdown, Talwar and tea workers' associations said.

A spokesman for the Tea Board, the umbrella organisation for tea companies, said an internal report on the situation had been sent to the government, but said the board could make no further comment because the matter was pending in courts.

The government wants the plantations to reopen.

At least 150 people have died of malnutrition in West Bengal in the past year after the closure of scores of tea plantations in what investigators say is a unique case of social breakdown in a heavily unionised sector.Hundreds more are starving.Ailing tea gardens have created a large and unemployed workforce. The government, however, denied that workers are dying of hunger in these gardens. On the other hand, The Tea Board is planning to tie up with the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) for mapping the tea gardens for better monitoring of the industry and its natural resources.

Referring to reports in the media of plantation workers and their family members dying of malnutrition, District Magistrate of Jalpaiguri R Ranjit said, “These are old reports. There have been 571 deaths in the last 15 months and the total population of the 14 closed tea gardens is 75,000. This is a death rate of 6.4 per 1000 people. The rate for West Bengal as a state, on the other hand, is 8 per 1000.” The DM said regular camps are being organized in the district for health check-ups and mid-day meals are also being provided.

India's tea industry has been suffering since 1999, with growers now fetching much lower prices for tea leaves, while production costs have been soaring. Tea Association of India says overseas competition has contribruted to the problem.Tea industry sources said the efforts might not bear much fruit as tea gardens need to increase production and cut down on cost of employment, which is not possible. How long can the NREGA sustain such a big workforce, they wonder. “We need to look at the scope of diversification in tea gardens, and try to introduce new crops, keeping 51 per cent of the land under tea cultivation. However, that is not possible as land ceiling laws in the state will not permit more than 5 per cent of land to be used for such purposes,” said an industry expert. Director of Tea Development (DTD), Tea Board of India, G Boriah, was optimistic about the government’s plans. “Sincere entrepreneurs can avail subsidies and financial benefits provided by the government and banks and run the gardens profitably,” he said.

It is claimed taht Tea Board approaches close to re-opening four gardens in July. The Tea Board is in an advanced stage of re-opening four more gardens in West Bengal for which talks were currently on with intending owners and bankers, its chairman Basudeb Banerjee said. Banerjee told reporters that regular meetings were being held and one had been slated for Monday. "We hope to re-open four more tea gardens in July," he said.

Out of the 33 closed tea gardens across the country, 14 were located in West Bengal.

The first closed tea garden to re-open was Surendranagar Tea Estate on May 17.

Asked by which time Tea Board would be able to re-open all the closed tea gardens in the state, Banerjee said it was not possible to give a date since there were a few court cases involved in some of the gardens.

"But we are trying our best," Banerjee.

Total area under hectarage in the 14 gardens was 6500, involving 12,000 families.

Banerjee said that close co-operation from the West Bengal government was also required for re-opening of the closed gardens.

Meanwhile, the centre was in the process of preparing a relief package for re-opening of the closed gardens.

While the package had been finalised by the Commerce Ministry, it was awaiting approval of the Cabinet, Banerjee said.

The package would include rescheduling of loans by banks, sanction of working capital and interest subsidy, issue of fresh terms loans and waiver of tea board dues and penalties.

As per rough calculation, the banks would have to make a sacrifice of Rs 80 crore over the next five years, while the burden on the government would be Rs 58 crore during the same period.

Tea board had also made conditional that new owners of closed tea gardens would have to make significant investments in modernisation.

Ageing of bushes was one of the main reasons for gardens Closing.

"The Government may portray the deaths their way," said Anuradha Talwar, a Supreme Court adviser, who compiled a report about the deaths.

"But the fact remains that workers have starved to death, and many are waiting to die," she said.

Many were suffering from tuberculosis and night blindness.

India, the world's largest producer and consumer of tea, has strong regulations to protect workers' rights and powerful unions often guarantee free electricity, water and food as part of their salary packages.

But unions say that estate owners did not pay wages and other arrears owed following the shutdown.

They are now fighting for compensation.

Organisations representing the tea producers say they plan to reopen the estates under a cooperative plan.

Hundreds of former tea workers are being forced to travel across the border to Bhutan to work in the tiny nation's growing stone crushing and mineral factories.

Most earn less than $2 a day in the factories.

Those who stayed back -- starving and weak, are being forced to forage for food in nearby forests to keep themselves and their children alive.

Surviving on bitter gourd fruit for weeks, Molly Kajur, 30, can barely get up to feed her three starving children.

"It tastes bad and very bitter," she said, barely able to speak.

"But this is the only way to keep me and my children alive."

Sources said that monitoring had become critical for the regulatory body, especially in view of the massive re-plantation exercise that is being taken up. It involves activity over 2.12 lakh hectares out of the 5.26 lakh hectares under tea cultivation in Assam, Dooars and Darjeeling in West Bengal, and Kerala and Tamil Nadu in the south. A small quantity of a speciality tea is also grown in the Kangra Valley in Himachal Pradesh. Initial meetings on the project entitled Tea Area Development and Management, using remote sensing and geographical indication systems (GIS), have already been held with the faculty of IIT Kharagpur, which runs the regional remote sensing centre (RRSC). A core group, which would be formed after a final round of meeting with ISRO, would work out the modalities and the finer points, sources said. The project would involve the participation of officials of the Tea Board, the Tea Research Association, the industry and the RRSC. The project will be funded under the 11th Five-Year Plan, which commenced in April 2007. The mapping, to be done through the GIS, will generate garden-wise data on the actual extent of area under tea cultivation and also their location. It will also throw up data on the extent of area available either for new plantation or for alternative cropping. The profile of the resident population will also be known and village resource centres are planned to be set up accordingly. Water resources, rivers around a garden and their drainage systems will also be known.

The exercise is expected to establish a connectivity with each garden to gather information about the physical progress made under the various development schemes of the Board.

AT least 700 Indian tea workers have died from diseases linked with malnutrition over the past year after the closure of tea estates left them with no income.And hundreds more are still starving, a court inquiry has found. Two years ago, poor production and low yields led to the closure of 16 tea estates in Jalpaiguri, a remote part of West Bengal, leaving plantation workers with no income. Investigations by the Supreme Court and tea workers' associations found this had directly led to the deaths and had left hundreds more unable to feed themselves. But the Government says the deaths are unrelated to starvation. In a bid to share the problems of workers at sick and closed tea gardens, the state government has decided to bring them under the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA). Earlier, this Act was not applicable to a tea garden since it did not come under panchayats.

DEATH ZONE
Poverty and hunger can never cause deaths in Left-ruled Bengal. It is not easy to decide which one is more shocking — the unending deaths of workers and their family members in Jalpaiguri’s closed tea gardens or the state government’s shameless attempt to pass them off as ‘natural’ deaths. The poor and the hungry would naturally die if no succour is provided to them. It is also natural that they would suffer from malnutrition and diseases before they actually die. It is thus both absurd and revolting that the government sees nothing unnatural in the deaths. The official line reflects the cynical politics that surrounds such deaths in India. When farmers in other parts of the country are driven to death by debt or hunger, the Leftists are the most vocal of politicians about those ‘starvation deaths’. On their own turf, it is a different story — not even the poorest can starve to death. The danger in this approach is that it seeks to underplay the government’s failure to prevent these deaths. Worse still, such a callous government would do little to improve things at Jalpaiguri’s death zone.

Yet, only recently the government almost pleaded guilty over the deaths in north Bengal’s tea gardens. The picture that the governor, Gopalkrishna Gandhi, painted of the conditions there during a visit to a tea garden also led him to make a loud and strong condemnation of the State’s inaction. The number of deaths — 571 in 15 months — makes a cruel mockery of the promises that the finance minister, Asim Dasgupta, had made to the tea-workers sometime back. The most shocking aspect of the tragedy is the government’s blatant attempt to gloss over its failures. The government and political parties seem to know of just one use of the poor tea-garden workers, the majority of whom belong to tribal communities. They serve only as vote-banks.

However, short-term welfare measures may not be the answer to a problem that is essentially economic. For far too long, tea gardens have been run, not as business ventures, but almost as social security programmes. The techniques of production are outdated at most of the gardens. The owners have invested little towards modern production or managerial methods. To make matters worse, the industry has been burdened with social responsibilities that should have been with the government. True, the Centre and the state government have recently been forced to take note of the alarming situation at the tea gardens. The Union minister of state for commerce, Jairam Ramesh, has provided some ideas for reviving Bengal’s tea industry. But it is time New Delhi and Calcutta realized that the industry could no longer be run the way the British planters ran it. Hunger and deaths will continue to stalk the tea gardens until the industry reforms itself.
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1070608/asp/opinion/story_7891152.asp

Promises made, only to be broken

Three months after Asim Dasgupta went around some of the ailing Dooars tea gardens and rolled out promises aplenty, it is time for a progress report.The finance minister had sanctioned Rs 16 crore to the district administration on April 3. With the funds for the quarter ending June came the promise of doctors for every tea estate, a slew of financial schemes and alternative means of livelihood.

“Health staff attached to the gardens before they closed down will also be recalled to ensure better healthcare,” the minister said.

But even after 571 deaths, the picture remains the same.

“Only two doctors responded to our ad and agreed to work on contract,” said Banamali Roy, the sabhadhipati of Jalpaiguri zilla parishad. “We have appointed them to Kalchini and Bharnobari gardens.”

Even a second ad failed to attract doctors to the hunger death zone. “Not only that, no health worker who had served in the gardens earlier, turned up,” said Bhusan Chakraborty, the chief medical officer of health, Jalpaiguri.

Many workers of the closed estates had not taken Dasgupta seriously. “We never expected it to happen. There was a mobile van earlier that used to carry patients. For the past two-three months, that service, too, has been discontinued,” said Gopal Das of Sikarpur and Bhandapur Tea Estate.

But there were many oth- ers, like Biplab Sarkar of Bharnobari, who pinned their hopes on the minister’s promi- ses. Sarkar said a health sub- centre has come up in his garden. “But there are usually no medicines there.”

Sania Bhumij, a leader of the Citu-affiliated Cha Bagan Mazdoor Union at Raipur Tea Estate, said the mobile medical team is more frequent now. “But we still don’t have an ambulance in our garden to carry patients to Jalpaiguri, 10 km away.”

Some of Dasgupta’s other promises include agriculture or multi-cropping on 2,200 acres of unused land in the estates. “We had sent a proposal to start cultivation of pulses, black gram, corn and paddy on 800 acres,” said Sarthak Burma, the north Bengal additional director of agriculture. “It hasn’t been sanctioned.”

Distribution of foodgrain and monetary relief has started, though. Labour officials monitoring the Financial Assistance to Workers of Locked- out Industries Scheme said all 13 gardens have been included in the list.

The district administration has completed a housewise survey that was part of the study to find the number of deaths in the gardens.

Bengal’s death harvest
AVIJIT SINHA

Siliguri, June 5: At least one person dies every day in Jalpaiguri’s closed tea gardens where workers have been battling poverty and hopelessness for the past five years.The state government has for the first time admitted the humanitarian crisis, overshadowed by the Singur-Nandigram land wars and West Midnapore starvation scandals.

But the government refuses to admit either starvation or “malnutrition” — the euphemism it uses in West Midnapore — in the gardens where, unofficial reports say, at least 3,000 have died since the 2002 closure spree.

A survey in April across the 14 closed gardens (Surendranagar has reopened since then) found that 571 people had died in the 15 months ending March 31 this year. Of them, 409 were below 60, the national average life span.

But the chief medical officer of health (Jalpaiguri), Bhusan Chakraborty, steered clear of the word “malnutrition”. He cited a host of reasons for the deaths: over 250 had died of heart diseases and stroke, and scores of others from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, cirrhosis of liver, hepatitis, TB, high fever, meningitis, malaria, cancer and septicaemia.

But doctors said many of these can be brought on by starvation or aggravated to the point where they can lead to death.

“Malnutrition lowers immunity; the body loses its efficiency in fighting infections. Studies have revealed that malnutrition is a big factor in TB,” said Dr Milan Chhetri of Apollo Gleneagles Hospital, Calcutta.

Some of the findings left Sharmishtha Biswas, coordinator of Uttaron, a workers’ facilitation centre at Birpara that analysed the figures, “astounded”.

The dead include 46 under-10 children — three every month. “Some 465 people — 80 per cent of the total — died at home and only 106 in hospitals and health centres or on the way to hospitals,” one of the analysts said.

Workers said they couldn’t afford the long journey to hospitals and the ambulance service was non-functional. Only three of Kanthalguri’s 53 went to hospitals. At Bhornabari, all 79 died in their homes.

Anuradha Talwar, adviser to the food commissioner of the Supreme Court, has received a copy of the survey results. She said from Calcutta she would take it up with the Centre and the state.

During a visit to one of the closed gardens, Ramjhora, in March this year, governor Gopalkrishna Gandhi was appalled at the poverty and squalor he saw. Gandhi had told junior PWD minister Manohar Tirkey he just had to look at the sick children to find proof of malnutrition.

Some 17,000 labourers are jobless in the 13 gardens. The closures began in 1998 with a slump in tea prices. Some gardens reopened but in 2002, about 30 shut down again. In 2003, reports of starvation deaths started coming in.

Key role for tea women

An international workers’ forum has suggested a more active role for women leaders to end the problems in the closed tea estates of the Dooars.Representatives of IUF met trade union leaders from the brew belt in Calcutta last week to discuss the situation in the closed gardens. The Geneva-based International Union of Food, Agriculture, Hotel, Restaurant, Catering, Tobacco, Plantation and Allied Workers’ Associations works to unite food, farm and hotel workers worldwide.

“We want to take a fresh approach to try and end the workers’ problems. This includes empowerment of women who form more than 80 per cent of the total workforce,” Sujata Gothoskar, the agriculture and plantation coordinator of IUF in India, said over phone from Mumbai.

Describing women as “more sensitive” than men, Gothoskar said: “If they are made leaders or office bearers in trade unions, they will be more effective in organising movements on issues affecting their daily lives, like workload, occupational safety, malnutrition, drinking water supply and medical facilities.”

Su Long Ley, the international coordinator of agriculture and plantation at IUF, and Jasper Goss, the information officer for IUF in the Asia-Pacific region, were present at the meeting in Calcutta.

“We also discussed the need to raise the issue at international platforms like the ILO,” Gothoskar said.

Chitta Dey, the convener of the Coordination Committee of Tea Plantation Workers who attended the meeting, made a strong case for the formation of workers’ cooperatives to restart the closed gardens.

In December 2003, Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor Samiti, an IUF-affiliate, and the international union had conducted a survey on health, food, drinking water and living quarters of workers in the tea gardens of north Bengal and found the situation alarming.

Anuradha Talwar, a member of the samiti and an adviser to the food commissioners of the Supreme Court, had submitted the report to the apex legal body, which asked the Bengal government to respond within 10 days and take appropriate action.

In response, the state government intensified the promotion of welfare schemes and provision of medical facilities in the gardens and included every workers’ family in the BPL category.

Gothoskar said another survey might be conducted to find out the current situation in the Dooars gardens.

"We are working on a plan to reopen the gardens by getting the employees to form a cooperative," Jairam Ramesh, junior commerce minister said from New Delhi.

"I have heard about reports of starvation deaths in tea gardens of West Bengal, but right now our focus is to find a solution to reopen the gardens," Ramesh said on Wednesday.

Medical reports and death certificates of many dead workers show severe malnutrition and anaemia, Talwar said.

"I will drink water, but I am not sure what I will feed my three children," Talwar quoted Phulmani Kharia, a 25-year-old woman in Varnavari, 660 km north of Kolkata as saying.

Cabinet nod likely for revival of tea gardens

KOLKATA: Cabinet nod for a revival package for the 33 tea gardens closed in Kerala, West Bengal and Assam is likely within 45 days, Union Minister of State for Commerce Jairam Ramesh said here on Friday.

Addressing journalists after a meeting of stakeholders in these tea gardens in West Bengal, the Minister said that 11 of the gardens would be reopened in Kerala by May 27, while in West Bengal the process would be kicked off with the reopening of one by May 17, followed by two more by June 29. About 3,806 employees were employed in these gardens. He was hopeful of reopening another two by July. A total of 35,000 workers and over a lakh people were affected by the closure of these gardens. Of the 33 gardens, 17 are in Kerala, 14 in West Bengal and two in Assam. The Minister said that while low productivity levels were among the prime reasons behind the closures, more important was the issue of owners' insensitivity.

The first such garden, Bonacard in Kerala, owned by Mahabir Plantations, reopened on April 6, 2007 following rounds of consultations with the stakeholders initiated by Mr. Ramesh. The gardens to be reopened in Kerala include nine owned by Ram Bahadur Thakur and two more owned by Peermade Tea Company.

Referring to the relief package now being examined by the Government, Mr. Ramesh said the total financial implication, spread over five years, was Rs. 58 crore for the Centre and Rs. 80 crores for the banking system. The package included rescheduling of loans, fresh term loans at subsidised interest, wavier of Tea Board's dues and penalties of the Employees Provident Fund Organisation.

Situation of Tea Garden workers in Bengal

Fact - Finding Report of Centre for Education and Communication (CEC), New Delhi and United Trades Union Congress

Pipli Mahali, 34, was a permanent worker in Mujnai TE living with her husband Mani Mahali and a two and a half year-old son. However, she found it difficult to manage the household after the crisis in the tea estate began. Her husband was suffering from tuberculosis but, as the hospital was not equipped with any medicine, he died a slow death in early 2002. When the employers abandoned the tea estate in November, 2002, there was no foodstuff available in the estate at all. Hence, Pipli was forced to feed her son whatever fruits and vegetables were available in the nearby jungles. Unable to digest these wild fruits, her son succumbed to blood dysentery in November, 2002. Pipli now lives alone in a house and has sold off all her belongings in order to survive. She is suffering from tuberculosis and very few people visit her at home. She is helplessly awaiting her death.

Based on many such reports on deaths, starvation, wage cuts, fall in tea prices and closure of tea plantations in West Bengal, Centre for Education and Communication (CEC), New Delhi and United Trades Union Congress took the initiative in organising a Fact Finding Team to visit tea plantations in those states for an on the spot investigation.

Key Observations made in the Fact Finding Report from Kerala and Tamil Nadu

The Fact Finding Report Stress that there is a serious crisis in the tea industry of West Bengal. The major manifestations of the crisis are:

Closures and abandonment of the tea estates by the management

In the Dooars region of West Bengal, there are more than 19 tea plantations, which have been closed or abandoned by the owners. These tea estates include Rahimabad, Kathalguri, Ramjhora, Dheklapara, Mujnai, Srinathpur, Pathorjhara, Carron, Chamurchi, Dima, Kalchini, Raimatang, Peshok, Vettakver, Looksan, Sepoydhoorah, Shimulabari, Samsing and Putang. The senior managers have deserted these plantations. The closures have affected nearly 30,000 workers along with their families in these plantations.

Deaths due to Starvation and Drinking Contaminated Water

The tea plantations of the Dooars region have witnessed an abnormal numbers of deaths. More than 240 people have died in only four plantations between March 2002 to February 2003 in the Terai and Dooars regions. These tea plantations are Ramjhara T.E., Kathalguri T.E., Dheklapara T.E. and Mujnai T.E., where most of the workers are dying due to blood dysentery, liver cirrhosis, anaemia and cardio respiratory failure. An analysis of the death registers revealed that the death rates significantly increased after the closure of the tea plantations. The children and the aged constitute the largest number of the dead but many young workers were also dying. The number of female deaths in the age group of 16-35 is higher than the males because of a large number of deaths during childbirth.

Non-Availability of Food and Starving Workers

In West Bengal the management provides concessional foodstuff as part of the workers wages. However, after the closure or abandoning of the tea plantations, there was absolutely no food available for the workers. Some workers survived by selling their household items and by crushing stones, but many of them are starving and consequently suffering from acute malnutrition. The condition of the aged, women children and the ailing is the worst. In order to survive, some of the workers consumed any food that was available and cheap, resulting in chronic under nourishment or food poisoning and slow death.

Complete Absence of Drinking Water

As the electricity supply to the closed or abandoned tea estates has been disconnected, drinking water, which was supplied by the management to the worker households from common water tanks, has been completely stopped. Most of the workers fetched drinking water from the streams in the hilly areas of Bhutan. These streams are polluted because of the presence of dolomite - waste from the cement factories in Bhutan. The same source of water is also being used by the workers to cremate their dead. A sample of water that was being consumed by the workers in Kathalguri T.E. was sent by the Fact Finding Team to Quality Laboratory, New Delhi, (approved by the Department of Epidemiology, Government of India). The report found the water highly contaminated and unfit for drinking.

Non-Functional Estate Hospitals

In almost all the closed or abandoned tea plantations, the estate hospitals have closed down after the doctors left the estates. A few hospitals, which are still run by the compounders, have no medicines. There are no ambulances available to take the seriously ill or injured workers for advanced medical care to the city hospitals. Most of the people who were dying in these tea plantations could have been saved if the estate hospitals were functioning normally. There are many cases of women workers dying during childbirth. There is hardly any medicine left at the estate hospital and the inexperienced nurses are attending complicated delivery cases using kerosene lamps as the electricity connections have been cut off. In some plantations, there are ambulances, but are stationary, as there is no fuel available.

The Women Workers Suffer Most

The permanent workers in the tea plantations of West Bengal are mostly women, because they usually do most of the plucking work. As the main wage earners, women workers are under tremendous pressure. They are restricted by a lack of skills from joining other income earning activities, an absence of alternate employment opportunities and unfavourable conditions for migrating long distances in search of alternate opportunities of work. The Fact Finding Team came across many households where only the woman worker was staying at the tea plantations. They could not leave the security of the line room, which was allotted, to them and where they had been staying for generations. Many women workers had died due to pregnancy related complications. Some fortunate women had been shifted to the city hospital in a lorry when the workers pooled in money to help them out, but such cases were rare.

Condition of the Children

Most of the children in the tea plantations of the Dooars and Terai regions stopped going to school. Instead they were cooking food and carrying it for their parents who were crushing stones in the dry riverbeds. The Fact Finding Team also witnessed many children crushing stones along side their parents to augment the family income.

Non-Payment of Wages

The wages of the tea plantation workers of West Bengal are the lowest in the organised sector. The workers barely manage to survive with the paltry daily wages of Rs. 49.25 in West Bengal, which is lower than Rs. 65.88 in Assam (The tea garden workers in Assam and West Bengal receive concessional foodstuff as part of their wages) and much lower than the tea workers’ daily wages in Kerala, Rs. 76.17 and Rs. 72.62 in Tamil Nadu. These low wages prevail in spite of the fact that labour productivity in West Bengal is one of the highest in the country and so is the land yield and overall price of tea. However, due to the closure of the tea plantations, the workers have been deprived of even the low wages they were receiving. The Fact Finding Team found on their to visit the tea plantations, that the period for which workers had not received their wages in the above-mentioned 19 plantations varied between three to 10 months. In Mujnai T.E., workers had not received wages from April 24, 2002. Similarly, in Ramjhora T.E. workers had not been paid wages from August 10, 2002 and workers have not received their wages in Dheklapara T.E. from August 21, 2002 and in Kathalguri T.E. from July 22, 2002. It was reported that in the same region there were more than 15 other tea estates, which had not closed down, but were not paying regular wages or other benefits to the workers. The workers were surviving in West Bengal by crushing stones deposited in the dry riverbeds despite the fact that the total family earning of a worker through crushing stones was between Rs. 15 to 20 per day. Moreover, the stone crushing work was not available throughout the week.

Mounting Provident Fund and Gratuity Dues

All the 19 tea estates mentioned above had not deposited provident fund contributions for months now. They had also not paid gratuity to many workers. Anjuman Tea Company, which owns Mujnai T.E., owes Rs.55,46,498 as Employees Provident Fund (EPF) dues for February, 2002 to October, 2002 and Rs.15,01,829 for non-payment of gratuity from March, 2002. Similarly, in Ramjhora T.E. the company’s provident fund dues had gone up to Rs. 68,30,667 and it also owed Rs.13,85,147 in terms of gratuity. There are more than 15 tea plantations, which were still functioning but had defaulted in depositing the workers’ provident fund contributions.

Growing Unemployment in the Tea Estates

Thousands of workers were rendered jobless because of the closure of the tea estates. In some of the functional tea plantations, the managements proposed reduced days of work and not employing temporary workers.
The major factors behind the Crisis
* The Report stress that there is evidence of cartelisation in the tea auctions due to dominance of big corporations in the tea trade. The Report by International management consultant, A.F. Ferguson & Co about tea auctions on behalf of the Tea Board of India in 2002 severely criticised the existing rules.
* It has been also stressed that the average tea prices in the retail market is around Rs. 140/- per Kg while in the auctions it is less than Rs. 48 per kg. The report points out that the increasing clout of traders in tea business is a factor leadi